Re:We replaced passwords with something worse
by DougN7 on Wednesday August 06, 2025 @11:41PM
(#44820361)
It sounds good, unless granny needs to visit Google or Microsoft to get a new password after losing her phone. Then what??
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:We replaced passwords with something worse
by drozycki on Wednesday August 06, 2025 @11:51PM
(#44820407)
She follows same reset flow as before. Passkeys are identical in this respect to the passwords of yore.
Re:We replaced passwords with something worse
by politelemon on Thursday August 07, 2025 @01:56AM
(#44821081)
Then that's worse, it's now two authentication flows to remember. It's only made the situation more complicated.
Re:We replaced passwords with something worse
by cuu508 on Thursday August 07, 2025 @02:03AM
(#44821125)
If granny forgets her password, she looks it up on the last page of her notebook where it is written down. Granny cannot write down her passkey.
To avoid getting locked out you could add 2-3 passkeys from different providers to each account. And/or use a passkey provider that allows backups, and back up your keys. But I doubt many people will have the discipline to do either of that.
Re:We replaced passwords with something worse
by raphinou on Thursday August 07, 2025 @02:21AM
(#44821231)
Honest question: isn't that introducing some weaknesses, allowing the attacker to either reactivate password auth or add it's own passkey eh by tricking the user in accepting that change after receiving a mail with a link to accept that change?
That would make the passkey unbreakable, but leave other easier to exploit weaknesses.
Re:We replaced passwords with something worse
by izacus on Thursday August 07, 2025 @03:09AM
(#44821478)
No. You always need that flow.
Re:We replaced passwords with something worse
by jonplackett on Thursday August 07, 2025 @04:06AM
(#44821865)
The problem with passkeys is they’re very unfamiliar and it’s easier therefore for less experienced users to get confused or tricked.
Re:We replaced passwords with something worse
by rcxdude on Thursday August 07, 2025 @04:10AM
(#44821904)
Passkeys are more like 2FA, and many services disable password resets without 2FA if it's enabled.
Re:We replaced passwords with something worse
by account42 on Thursday August 07, 2025 @06:54AM
(#44822914)
Do you have any examples of such services? How do they handle the lost phone case? Tell people to go pound stand?
Re:We replaced passwords with something worse
by patrakov on Thursday August 07, 2025 @03:29AM
(#44821601)
The scary part is not about losing her phone. It's about having to keep the old, no-longer-secure Android phone alive just for passkeys after getting a shiny (and secure) new iPhone.
Re:We replaced passwords with something worse
by charcircuit on Thursday August 07, 2025 @05:35AM
(#44822454)
You can add the new phone as an additional passkey. I don't see how this would be scary.
Re:We replaced passwords with something worse
by j1elo on Thursday August 07, 2025 @05:53AM
(#44822557)
I have 531 logins for varied websites and services. Would you enjoy having to change 531 passkey devices? Me neither. But default login flows in all these sites prompt you to use your current device as passkey by default, so people who don't know better (i.e. a general "everybody") are being gently pushed to do so.
Re:We replaced passwords with something worse
by charcircuit on Thursday August 07, 2025 @06:25AM
(#44822745)
No, which is why there is the cross platform standard CXF which allows for cross platform sharing of passkeys. Apple has announced that support for this is shipping later this year with iOS 26. Google hasn't announced when they are shipping it yet.
Re:We replaced passwords with something worse
by elteto on Thursday August 07, 2025 @07:00AM
(#44822943)
So until then you have to do what parent said? Change each one individually when you switch devices? Thanks but no.
Re:We replaced passwords with something worse
by ewoodrich on Thursday August 07, 2025 @03:44PM
(#44829415)
I keep all my Passkeys in Bitwarden, it works fine across different devices and I use all major platforms regularly (iOS, Android, Windows, MacOS, ChromeOS). As a backup I've also added some extra duplicate Passkeys in the Chrome and iCloud password manager for the most important accounts in case I lose access to Bitwarden somehow.
Re:We replaced passwords with something worse
by yunwal on Thursday August 07, 2025 @07:56AM
(#44823323)
Would’ve been nice if the basic UX would have been figured out before passkeys were shoved down everyone’s throats
Re:We replaced passwords with something worse
by reginald78 on Thursday August 07, 2025 @08:24AM
(#44823548)
It just wasn't an important consideration, unlike the attestation anti-feature.
Re:We replaced passwords with something worse
by kbolino on Thursday August 07, 2025 @09:54AM
(#44824492)
AFAIK, there is no requirement for websites to support multiple passkeys nor, if they do, to support them in a sensible way. Some sites do this well, most don't.
Re:We replaced passwords with something worse
by hgomersall on Thursday August 07, 2025 @03:57AM
(#44821797)
The problem here is really with Google and Microsoft than anything else. It's not like this problem doesn't occur already for other reasons.