News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IDF Soldiers Confess: Ordered to Shoot Unarmed Gazans at ... by spacecadet on Saturday June 28, 2025 @04:47AM (#44403204)
If we look at history, do the oppressed always become oppressors?
Re:IDF Soldiers Confess: Ordered to Shoot Unarmed Gazans at ... by perlgeek on Saturday June 28, 2025 @06:50AM (#44403738)
I'd say it's very hard for a powerful nation to not suppress somebody in the long run.

Just think of any powerful nation (or group of people, or whatever), and try to think of somebody they have oppressed, or are still oppressing. It's typically not hard to come up with examples.

Re:IDF Soldiers Confess: Ordered to Shoot Unarmed Gazans at ... by spacecadet on Saturday June 28, 2025 @09:25AM (#44404562)
Agreed. Its possible that the group survived their oppression and becomes powerful enough to oppress, they loose their identify, in the sense that their culture evolves, along the way. Resulting in oppression along some axis.
Re:IDF Soldiers Confess: Ordered to Shoot Unarmed Gazans at ... by meindnoch on Saturday June 28, 2025 @06:30AM (#44403655)
Mostly, yes.

Christians were persecuted by the Roman Empire, then became conquerors of the world.

Russians were oppressed by the Mongols, then became conquerors of Eurasia.

Communists were oppressed by Tsarists, then became ruthless oppressors themselves.

Protestants were oppressed in Europe, so they set sail to America and became oppressors of the natives.

Re:IDF Soldiers Confess: Ordered to Shoot Unarmed Gazans at ... by orbital-decay on Saturday June 28, 2025 @07:58AM (#44404035)
Not sure if I would lump all those up together, these examples are overly broad and have little in common. There's more than a thousand years and basically no causal link between Roman persecution of early Christians and Crusades, let alone European imperialism, especially if you take Ethiopian, Greek, Georgian, and Armenian Christians into account. Same for Russians and Mongols, there's a pretty large gap with a ton of events in between. And communists that became ruthless oppressors were already radicalized during the persecution, it was literally the radical wing of a militant faction of a huge umbrella party that included people that would have felt right at home in modern EU (e.g. Kollontai and her early activism).

The better explanation is simple and banal - power concentration makes people abuse it.

Re:IDF Soldiers Confess: Ordered to Shoot Unarmed Gazans at ... by spacecadet on Saturday June 28, 2025 @09:21AM (#44404531)
I wouldn't consider this "lumping the groups together", or that they must exist together in time... its likely a group may require many generations before they can "oppress" another group.

My list of examples is very similar to this one and the ven diagram here is "was oppressed became oppressor"... in most cases it appears that only if the oppressed are destroyed or I would argue in the case of America- controlled at the margins... then they don't circle back around to abuse their newly acquired power.

Re:IDF Soldiers Confess: Ordered to Shoot Unarmed Gazans at ... by int_19h on Sunday June 29, 2025 @07:19PM (#44417525)
> There's more than a thousand years and basically no causal link between Roman persecution of early Christians and Crusades

You don't need to go that far forward, though. It took Christians <400 years to promulgate the Edict of Thessalonica that made Christianity (and of a very particular kind at that!) to be the only legal religion. And one can argue that it's no coincidence that it happened pretty much as soon as they have gained the political upper hand in the Roman Empire.

> Same for Russians and Mongols, there's a pretty large gap with a ton of events in between

Not really. Muscovy was still paying tribute to the Golden Horde and recognizing their supreme authority under Ivan III. His grandson Ivan IV ("the Terrible") conquered the Tatar state, making its lands such as Kazan part of his empire, and sent an expedition to start the conquest of Siberia.

The inaccuracies here are not so much with timing, more so with lack of precision wrt the groups involved. In general, though, I think it's fair to say that, for most part of human history, the oppressed become the oppressors pretty much as soon as they are capable of it.

Re:IDF Soldiers Confess: Ordered to Shoot Unarmed Gazans at ... by orbital-decay on Sunday June 29, 2025 @10:45PM (#44418747)
I think that a lot of monotheistic religions, including Christianity, are generally intolerant to other branches and religions, especially when the faith is supposed to represent absolute truth, so it's probably unrelated to the history of persecution. And Muscovy wasn't the only land opressed by Mongols.

>In general, though, I think it's fair to say that, for most part of human history, the oppressed become the oppressors pretty much as soon as they are capable of it.

Doesn't this also hold for non-oppressed that have the opportunity? Although I suppose it'd be hard to find any examples of non-oppressed groups. Pillaging or conquering neighbors was pretty much the norm throughout the history. Rus' was converted to Christianity in part to stop raids such as Siege of Constantinople of 860.

Re:IDF Soldiers Confess: Ordered to Shoot Unarmed Gazans at ... by wiseowise on Saturday June 28, 2025 @08:53AM (#44404365)
> Communists were oppressed by Tsarists, then became ruthless oppressors themselves.

Everyone was oppressed by Tsarists. Commies are ruthless oppressors by default.

Re:IDF Soldiers Confess: Ordered to Shoot Unarmed Gazans at ... by laurent_du on Saturday June 28, 2025 @10:46AM (#44405070)
Communists were absolutely not oppressed by Tsarists.
Re:IDF Soldiers Confess: Ordered to Shoot Unarmed Gazans at ... by poly2it on Saturday June 28, 2025 @06:11PM (#44408581)
Were protestants the oppressors of the native Americans? Many partook, for example the French.
Re:IDF Soldiers Confess: Ordered to Shoot Unarmed Gazans at ... by locallost on Saturday June 28, 2025 @07:15AM (#44403846)
I don't know if it's always the case, but it's true if given the opportunity. In the end all people are the same. Cultures may be different, but our lizard brains are the same. Us vs them, and dehumanizing others into something less than humans, whose suffering does not concern us.
Re:IDF Soldiers Confess: Ordered to Shoot Unarmed Gazans at ... by mikevm on Saturday June 28, 2025 @05:27AM (#44403359)
[flagged]
Re:IDF Soldiers Confess: Ordered to Shoot Unarmed Gazans at ... by dang on Saturday June 28, 2025 @05:29AM (#44403362)
No racial flamewar on HN, please. I realize this topic is fraught with it but that's no reason to jump straight in—it's a reason to do the opposite:

"Comments should get more thoughtful and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive."

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Edit: yikes—quite apart from the current topic, you've been breaking the site guidelines a lot with flamewar posts and personal attacks. We ban accounts that post like this:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43604429 (April 2025)

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43604394 (April 2025)

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43596070 (April 2025)

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43596065 (April 2025)

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43593235 (April 2025)

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43593219 (April 2025)

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43322414 (March 2025)

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43251495 (March 2025)

I'm not going to ban you right now because you've also posted good things, but if you want to keep participating in this community, it would be good to review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the rules from now on.

Edit: I did end up banning you: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44403629. We simply can't have people posting like that to HN.

Re:IDF Soldiers Confess: Ordered to Shoot Unarmed Gazans at ... by Dettorer on Saturday June 28, 2025 @05:55AM (#44403495)
Is this a new karma system where for each post that doesn't break the guidelines, you're allowed one that does?
Re:IDF Soldiers Confess: Ordered to Shoot Unarmed Gazans at ... by dang on Saturday June 28, 2025 @06:20AM (#44403602)
No, this is how HN moderation has worked for over a decade.
Re:IDF Soldiers Confess: Ordered to Shoot Unarmed Gazans at ... by Dettorer on Saturday June 28, 2025 @06:30AM (#44403657)
Wait, my message was obviously intended as a bit sarcastic (which isn't very smart, I'll admit). But are you actually saying that I'm now allowed two racist comments without risking a ban? (three, counting this guideline-abiding comment?)
Re:IDF Soldiers Confess: Ordered to Shoot Unarmed Gazans at ... by dang on Saturday June 28, 2025 @06:33AM (#44403670)
I'm not saying that, no.
Re:IDF Soldiers Confess: Ordered to Shoot Unarmed Gazans at ... by Dettorer on Saturday June 28, 2025 @06:39AM (#44403696)
Then I don't understand what you were saying by "this is how HN moderation has worked for over a decade", wasn't that a response to my previous comment that said exactly that?
Re:IDF Soldiers Confess: Ordered to Shoot Unarmed Gazans at ... by dang on Saturday June 28, 2025 @06:51AM (#44403745)
Oh, I see. Let me try to be clearer.

It's not the case that "for each post that doesn't break the guidelines, you're allowed one that does", and that's not what I was doing. When I said HN moderation has worked the same way for over a decade, I didn't mean that the description you gave was accurate—it isn't. (Nor, I assume, did you mean it to be, since you were being sarcastic.)

I meant that what I was doing in the GP comment (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44403362) was standard practice. As you can see from https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que..., it goes back a long time.

We try to persuade users to follow the site guidelines, and tend to give warnings and make requests before banning accounts, especially if they are active participants who have been around for a while. We don't rush to banning such users; we try to explain the intended use of the site and convince them to honor it. Sometimes that works, sometimes it doesn't.

Re:IDF Soldiers Confess: Ordered to Shoot Unarmed Gazans at ... by Dettorer on Saturday June 28, 2025 @07:51AM (#44403998)
Thank you for clarifying and sorry about the sarcasm.

I am absolutely no one, but I'd like to highlight that this kind of policy is (indirectly) why I don't use HN. Tolerating intolerance to the extent you do (which isn't 100% but still a lot) allows people like the one you responded to originally to drive hackers like me, my loved ones, my colleagues and my students away, while attracting other hateful people, as they see that they are tolerated here. In a possibly too extreme comparison, this the same dynamic as the "nazi bar problem" (https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/Nazi_bar). I hope you know what kind of community these policies has made of HN.

[deleted]
Re:IDF Soldiers Confess: Ordered to Shoot Unarmed Gazans at ... by Dettorer on Saturday June 28, 2025 @08:48AM (#44404331)
I have trouble seeing it your way. The person you were originally responding to, and originally wanted to tolerate because they also did good posts, was saying blatantly racist things about "the arabs in palestine" and that they essentially deserved the war crimes they're suffering, or that they brought it on themselves or whatever. To me this sounds like pretty straightforward political and ideological hate.

But anyway, this is only one case and we should not base our thinking just on it. The problem is the policy (or the way it's systematically enforced) and its broader results. I don't know the details of how the moderation works here nor have I any statistics. I only know that I saw too much racism and hate towards whole groups of people because of their identity here in the past, and that when I occasionally stumble across a HN link, I usually can still see that hate being a lot more represented than in other spaces I frequent, and that the kind of policy you described to me has never worked at building diverse and interesting communities.

Re:IDF Soldiers Confess: Ordered to Shoot Unarmed Gazans at ... by tptacek on Sunday June 29, 2025 @09:37PM (#44418344)
What are some diverse and interesting communities you have experience with that work differently?
Re:IDF Soldiers Confess: Ordered to Shoot Unarmed Gazans at ... by seirl on Saturday June 28, 2025 @07:38AM (#44403932)
Why such an involved effort just to keep racists on the website?
Re:IDF Soldiers Confess: Ordered to Shoot Unarmed Gazans at ... by dang on Saturday June 28, 2025 @08:13AM (#44404121)
This feels like a 'have you stopped beating your wife yet' question. That's not really very motivating.
Re:IDF Soldiers Confess: Ordered to Shoot Unarmed Gazans at ... by tfrutuoso on Saturday June 28, 2025 @05:38AM (#44403419)
We appreciate your biased comment, aimed at portraying Palestinians as terrorists and non-indigenous to the area, cherry-picking history as it suits your narrative. We're not interested, though. Thank you.
Re:IDF Soldiers Confess: Ordered to Shoot Unarmed Gazans at ... by bombcar on Saturday June 28, 2025 @08:32AM (#44404236)
No. Many times the oppressed simply cease to exist (by assimilation, assassination, or other means).

Neanderthals aren’t going to become oppressors.

Re:IDF Soldiers Confess: Ordered to Shoot Unarmed Gazans at ... by spacecadet on Saturday June 28, 2025 @09:17AM (#44404508)
Well yeah, I meant if they go on to survive and become significant enough to be considered oppressive...
Re:IDF Soldiers Confess: Ordered to Shoot Unarmed Gazans at ... by int_19h on Sunday June 29, 2025 @07:20PM (#44417530)
For a more recent example of a group that was basically exterminated wholesale because they refused to fight back as a matter of principle:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moriori