News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IDF Soldiers Confess: Ordered to Shoot Unarmed Gazans at ... by Dettorer on Saturday June 28, 2025 @06:39AM (#44403696)
Then I don't understand what you were saying by "this is how HN moderation has worked for over a decade", wasn't that a response to my previous comment that said exactly that?
Re:IDF Soldiers Confess: Ordered to Shoot Unarmed Gazans at ... by dang on Saturday June 28, 2025 @06:51AM (#44403745)
Oh, I see. Let me try to be clearer.

It's not the case that "for each post that doesn't break the guidelines, you're allowed one that does", and that's not what I was doing. When I said HN moderation has worked the same way for over a decade, I didn't mean that the description you gave was accurate—it isn't. (Nor, I assume, did you mean it to be, since you were being sarcastic.)

I meant that what I was doing in the GP comment (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44403362) was standard practice. As you can see from https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que..., it goes back a long time.

We try to persuade users to follow the site guidelines, and tend to give warnings and make requests before banning accounts, especially if they are active participants who have been around for a while. We don't rush to banning such users; we try to explain the intended use of the site and convince them to honor it. Sometimes that works, sometimes it doesn't.

Re:IDF Soldiers Confess: Ordered to Shoot Unarmed Gazans at ... by Dettorer on Saturday June 28, 2025 @07:51AM (#44403998)
Thank you for clarifying and sorry about the sarcasm.

I am absolutely no one, but I'd like to highlight that this kind of policy is (indirectly) why I don't use HN. Tolerating intolerance to the extent you do (which isn't 100% but still a lot) allows people like the one you responded to originally to drive hackers like me, my loved ones, my colleagues and my students away, while attracting other hateful people, as they see that they are tolerated here. In a possibly too extreme comparison, this the same dynamic as the "nazi bar problem" (https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/Nazi_bar). I hope you know what kind of community these policies has made of HN.

[deleted]
Re:IDF Soldiers Confess: Ordered to Shoot Unarmed Gazans at ... by Dettorer on Saturday June 28, 2025 @08:48AM (#44404331)
I have trouble seeing it your way. The person you were originally responding to, and originally wanted to tolerate because they also did good posts, was saying blatantly racist things about "the arabs in palestine" and that they essentially deserved the war crimes they're suffering, or that they brought it on themselves or whatever. To me this sounds like pretty straightforward political and ideological hate.

But anyway, this is only one case and we should not base our thinking just on it. The problem is the policy (or the way it's systematically enforced) and its broader results. I don't know the details of how the moderation works here nor have I any statistics. I only know that I saw too much racism and hate towards whole groups of people because of their identity here in the past, and that when I occasionally stumble across a HN link, I usually can still see that hate being a lot more represented than in other spaces I frequent, and that the kind of policy you described to me has never worked at building diverse and interesting communities.

Re:IDF Soldiers Confess: Ordered to Shoot Unarmed Gazans at ... by tptacek on Sunday June 29, 2025 @09:37PM (#44418344)
What are some diverse and interesting communities you have experience with that work differently?
Re:IDF Soldiers Confess: Ordered to Shoot Unarmed Gazans at ... by seirl on Saturday June 28, 2025 @07:38AM (#44403932)
Why such an involved effort just to keep racists on the website?
Re:IDF Soldiers Confess: Ordered to Shoot Unarmed Gazans at ... by dang on Saturday June 28, 2025 @08:13AM (#44404121)
This feels like a 'have you stopped beating your wife yet' question. That's not really very motivating.