News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:It Is Time to Stop Teaching Frequentism to Non-Statistici... by NewsaHackO on Saturday May 24, 2025 @02:01PM (#44082744)
It’s weird how random people can submit non peer reviewed articles to preprint repos. Why not just use a blog site, medium or substack?
Re:It Is Time to Stop Teaching Frequentism to Non-Statistici... by jxjnskkzxxhx on Saturday May 24, 2025 @02:03PM (#44082765)
> Why not just use a blog site, medium or substack?

Because it looks more credible, obviously. In a sense it's cargo cult science: people observe this is the style of science, and so copy just the style; to a casual observer it appears to be science.

Re:It Is Time to Stop Teaching Frequentism to Non-Statistici... by nickpsecurity on Saturday May 24, 2025 @04:17PM (#44083546)
Professional science has been doing that a long time if one considers that many published works were never independently tested and replicated. If it's a scientist, and uses scientific descriptions, many just repeat it from there.
Re:It Is Time to Stop Teaching Frequentism to Non-Statistici... by jxjnskkzxxhx on Saturday May 24, 2025 @04:26PM (#44083598)
Overly reductionistic. At the same time a proper rebuttal isn't worth the time for someone who's clearly not looking to understand.
Re:It Is Time to Stop Teaching Frequentism to Non-Statistici... by NeutralCrane on Sunday May 25, 2025 @09:39AM (#44087761)
Publication in a journal is not a requirement for the scientific method. If anything, the insistence that something not published in a scientific journal is not science is, itself, cargo cult scientism.
Re:It Is Time to Stop Teaching Frequentism to Non-Statistici... by groceryheist on Saturday May 24, 2025 @02:20PM (#44082873)
Two reasons:

1. Preprint servers create DOIs, making works better citable.

2. Preprint servers are archives, ensuring works remain accessible.

My blog website won't outlive me for long. What happened to geocities could also happen to medium.

Re:It Is Time to Stop Teaching Frequentism to Non-Statistici... by SoftTalker on Saturday May 24, 2025 @02:34PM (#44082951)
Who would want to cite a random unreviewed preprint?
Re:It Is Time to Stop Teaching Frequentism to Non-Statistici... by mitthrowaway2 on Saturday May 24, 2025 @03:07PM (#44083136)
You don't get a free pass to not cite relevant prior literature just because it's in the form of an unreviewed preprint.

If you're writing a paper about a longstanding math problem and the solution gets published on 4chan, you still need to cite it.

Re:It Is Time to Stop Teaching Frequentism to Non-Statistici... by NooneAtAll3 on Saturday May 24, 2025 @03:32PM (#44083276)
tbf, you cite the paper that described and discussed said solution in the more appropriate form
Re:It Is Time to Stop Teaching Frequentism to Non-Statistici... by mousethatroared on Saturday May 24, 2025 @04:16PM (#44083533)
You cite the form you encountered and if you're any good of a researcher you will have encountered the original 4chan anon post, Borges' short story, or Chomsky's linguistic paper.
Re:It Is Time to Stop Teaching Frequentism to Non-Statistici... by hansvm on Sunday May 25, 2025 @08:11AM (#44087253)
In some fields, sure, cite the 4chan source, ideally with an archived link.

Pure math tends to be much more conservative in citations than other fields though, and even when writing a paper about a longstanding math problem you wouldn't necessarily bother to include existing solutions. You reference the things you actually used, and even then you assume some common background knowledge for your audience and don't reference every little undergrad topology theorem or whatever. The point is to be honest with the reader about what was helpful for this work in particular, both to properly attribute things you actually used and to make any searches based on your work more targeted and fruitful.

Re:It Is Time to Stop Teaching Frequentism to Non-Statistici... by bowsamic on Saturday May 24, 2025 @03:55PM (#44083424)
It happens way more than you expect. In my PhD I used to cite unreviewed preprints that were essential to my work but simply for whatever reason hadn’t been pushed to publication. More common for long review like papers
Re:It Is Time to Stop Teaching Frequentism to Non-Statistici... by amelius on Saturday May 24, 2025 @03:07PM (#44083139)
Maybe other pseudoscientists who agree with the ideas presented and want to create a parallel universe with alternative facts?
Re:It Is Time to Stop Teaching Frequentism to Non-Statistici... by mousethatroared on Saturday May 24, 2025 @04:40PM (#44083678)
And people who care more for gatekeeping will stick to academic echo chambers. The list of community driven medical discoveries encountering entrenched professional opposition is quite long.

Both models are fallible, which is why discernment is so important.

Re:It Is Time to Stop Teaching Frequentism to Non-Statistici... by jononor on Saturday May 24, 2025 @05:59PM (#44084052)
You can do that with reviewed papers too :)
Re:It Is Time to Stop Teaching Frequentism to Non-Statistici... by jononor on Saturday May 24, 2025 @05:58PM (#44084047)
Anyone who found something useful in it and are writing a new paper.

That something is unreviewed does not mean that it is bad or useless.

Re:It Is Time to Stop Teaching Frequentism to Non-Statistici... by lametti on Sunday May 25, 2025 @08:11AM (#44087252)
You should check out https://rogue-scholar.org/ - full-text archiving and DOIs for science blogs. I use it and it works great.
Re:It Is Time to Stop Teaching Frequentism to Non-Statistici... by billfruit on Saturday May 24, 2025 @02:05PM (#44082780)
Why the gatekeeping. Only what is said matters, not who says it.
Re:It Is Time to Stop Teaching Frequentism to Non-Statistici... by tsimionescu on Saturday May 24, 2025 @02:33PM (#44082947)
That's a cute fantasy, but it doesn't work beyond a tiny scale. Credentials are critical to help filter data - 8 billion people all publishing random info can't be listened to.
Re:It Is Time to Stop Teaching Frequentism to Non-Statistici... by SoftTalker on Saturday May 24, 2025 @02:34PM (#44082957)
> 8 billion people all publishing random info can't be listened to.

Yet it's what we train LLMs on.

Re:It Is Time to Stop Teaching Frequentism to Non-Statistici... by verbify on Saturday May 24, 2025 @03:43PM (#44083339)
There's a paper Textbooks are all you need - https://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11644

> We introduce phi-1, a new large language model for code, with significantly smaller size than competing models: phi-1 is a Transformer-based model with 1.3B parameters, trained for 4 days on 8 A100s, using a selection of ``textbook quality" data from the web (6B tokens) and synthetically generated textbooks and exercises with GPT-3.5 (1B tokens). Despite this small scale, phi-1 attains pass@1 accuracy 50.6% on HumanEval and 55.5% on MBPP. It also displays surprising emergent properties compared to phi-1-base, our model before our finetuning stage on a dataset of coding exercises, and phi-1-small, a smaller model with 350M parameters trained with the same pipeline as phi-1 that still achieves 45% on HumanEval

We train on the internet because, for example, I speak a fairly niche English dialect influenced by Hebrew, Yiddish and Aramaic, and there are no digitised textbooks or dictionaries that cover this language. I assume the base weights of models are still using high quality materials.

Re:It Is Time to Stop Teaching Frequentism to Non-Statistici... by birn559 on Saturday May 24, 2025 @02:55PM (#44083070)
Which are known to be unreliable beyond basic things that most people that have some relevant experience get right anyway.
Re:It Is Time to Stop Teaching Frequentism to Non-Statistici... by tsimionescu on Saturday May 24, 2025 @02:51PM (#44083047)
It's what we train LLMs on to make them learn language, a thing that all healthy adult human beings are experts on using. It's definitely not what we train LLMs on if we want them to do science.
Re:It Is Time to Stop Teaching Frequentism to Non-Statistici... by billfruit on Saturday May 24, 2025 @10:26PM (#44085091)
GitHub lets anyone upload code. It works perfectly fine.
Re:It Is Time to Stop Teaching Frequentism to Non-Statistici... by tsimionescu on Sunday May 25, 2025 @12:23AM (#44085503)
There's no problem in letting anyone upload. The problem is in claiming that we should give the same amount of attention to the work of anyone, that "only what is said matters". Just like we don't run random code off github, we have no reason to read random papers on arxiv. And, even on github, anyone using a project knows that "who is maintaining this project" is a major decision factor.
Re:It Is Time to Stop Teaching Frequentism to Non-Statistici... by billfruit on Sunday May 25, 2025 @01:20AM (#44085715)
My objection was to the concept of gatekeeping/barriers to entry for posting/uploading. Not that everything uploaded demands the same attention.
Re:It Is Time to Stop Teaching Frequentism to Non-Statistici... by tsimionescu on Sunday May 25, 2025 @10:26AM (#44088076)
Sure and you're right about that. But the thread was about not judging a paper on the basis of authorship - my quote was a direct quote from the post I replied to.
Re:It Is Time to Stop Teaching Frequentism to Non-Statistici... by NeutralCrane on Sunday May 25, 2025 @09:41AM (#44087772)
With all the issues surrounding modern science and the replication crisis, much of which stems from the current standard of journal publications, I would argue that your alternative doesn’t scale any better.
Re:It Is Time to Stop Teaching Frequentism to Non-Statistici... by BlarfMcFlarf on Saturday May 24, 2025 @02:21PM (#44082879)
Peer review specifically checks that what is being said passes scrutiny by experts in the field, so it is very much about what is being said.
Re:It Is Time to Stop Teaching Frequentism to Non-Statistici... by SJC_Hacker on Saturday May 24, 2025 @03:09PM (#44083141)
They why isn't it double blind ?
Re:It Is Time to Stop Teaching Frequentism to Non-Statistici... by mcswell on Saturday May 24, 2025 @03:56PM (#44083425)
I've reviewed computational linguistics papers in the past (I'm retired now, and the field is changing out from under me, so I don't do it any more). But all the reviews I did were double blind.
Re:It Is Time to Stop Teaching Frequentism to Non-Statistici... by BDPW on Saturday May 24, 2025 @03:21PM (#44083209)
Often reviewing is executed double blind for exactly this reason. This can be difficult in small fields where you can more-or-less guess who's working on what, but the intent is definitely there.
Re:It Is Time to Stop Teaching Frequentism to Non-Statistici... by birn559 on Saturday May 24, 2025 @02:59PM (#44083092)
If what is said has any merit can be very hard to judge beyond things that are well known.

In addition, peer reviews are anonymous for both sides (as far as possible).

Re:It Is Time to Stop Teaching Frequentism to Non-Statistici... by ujkiolp on Saturday May 24, 2025 @03:00PM (#44083099)
i would filter your dumb shit
Re:It Is Time to Stop Teaching Frequentism to Non-Statistici... by tomhow on Sunday May 25, 2025 @11:11PM (#44093629)
You can't comment like this on Hacker News, no matter what you're replying to.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:It Is Time to Stop Teaching Frequentism to Non-Statistici... by watwut on Saturday May 24, 2025 @03:47PM (#44083370)
Yeah, that is why 4chan became famous for being the source of trustworthy and valuable scientific research. /s
Re:It Is Time to Stop Teaching Frequentism to Non-Statistici... by billfruit on Saturday May 24, 2025 @10:42PM (#44085148)
GitHub works on a similar model, without any barrier of entry, and it works well.
Re:It Is Time to Stop Teaching Frequentism to Non-Statistici... by randomNumber7 on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:40AM (#44086039)
Science is in a strange state, but I don't think the current HN audience (of inexperienced ai script kids) is the crowd to have a valuable discussion about it.
Re:It Is Time to Stop Teaching Frequentism to Non-Statistici... by jxjnskkzxxhx on Saturday May 24, 2025 @04:28PM (#44083611)
> news.ycombinator.com/user?id=billfruit

> Why the gatekeeping. Only what is said matters, not who says it.

Tell me you zero media literacy without telling me you have zero media literacy.

Re:It Is Time to Stop Teaching Frequentism to Non-Statistici... by constantcrying on Saturday May 24, 2025 @04:37PM (#44083664)
>It’s weird how random people can submit non peer reviewed articles to preprint repos.

It is weird how people use a platform exactly how it is supposed to be used.

Re:It Is Time to Stop Teaching Frequentism to Non-Statistici... by T-A on Saturday May 24, 2025 @11:56PM (#44085402)
> It’s weird how random people can submit non peer reviewed articles to preprint repos.

Assuming that you are referring to the Arxiv, they can't:

https://info.arxiv.org/help/endorsement.html

Re:It Is Time to Stop Teaching Frequentism to Non-Statistici... by naveen99 on Sunday May 25, 2025 @07:42AM (#44087135)
I would start with github. Arxiv, show hn, twitter, TikTok , Super Bowl ad if you are going for max look at me, i am not wearing diapers effect.