[1] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4494450/
If you're referring to technology/civilization-building capabilities, that is a different matter.
[0] https://www.quantamagazine.org/intelligence-evolved-at-least...
Humans have been just as smart as you and me, maybe even smarter according to cranial measurements, without inventing anything that significantly changed their way of life.
There could be loads of planets with prehistoric humans, having a fine time hunting with bows and picking fruit.
Curiosity as an evolutionary trait is quite an advantage, and I would think is necessary for intelligent omnivores. It's what helped us figure out what we could and couldn't eat, and taught us better techniques for living. Curiosity naturally leads to technological developments, I would argue.
Based on what evidence? We only know if it happening once, after a very long delay.
You want to figure things out or you're interested in seeing what happens when you fuck around with things.
So I think a technological progression is a natural progression for intelligent life.
Does that make sense? I feel like I'm not explaining myself well.
Humans are cultural learners, so this allowed cumulative cultural evolution from at least as far back as the transition from Olowan to Acheulean stone technologies with Homo erectus ~2-3 million years ago. By the time we get to Homo sapiens and Neanderthal this capacity for cultural learning seems much increased. Some paleoarchaeologists (e.g. Dietrich Stout) argue that technological development has been exponential as far back as H. erectus, just that the early stages of the exponential curve look flat for a long time.
Suppose say, that people only trust a small group. Extended family and lifelong friends, for instance. People get very violent as soon as they disagree on something, immediately wanting to settle disputes by force.
Nobody can strike a deal to do anything with anyone outside their group, and you certainly can't make agreements with a guy in Seattle to deliver things to London. You can't mine coal hoping to sell it to an as yet unknown person. There's no point in fishing more fish than you and your friends can eat.
What happens in this world? Well, I think people will still be intelligent. They'll still think about social situations, especially when it comes to mating. There will still be stories, and humor.
But we're not advancing tech, and we're not changing economically.
Why do I say it's a small tweak? Well, we've all met people who seem to not be able to work with anyone. It's not unlikely that out in the stars, there's some planet with people who have everything we have, but they can't get things to work.
This seems to be supported if you consider how long it took for humans to emerge and the fact that other fairly intelligent species exist alongside us but didn't follow the same path. If you suppose that technological development has a clear selection path then why isn't there any evidence of space fairing dinosaurs?
In any case, the seeming stagnation is part of what I meant by the early part of an exponential curve looking flat: broadly it might look like not much is happening, but there are small changes all the time.
Lack of evidence is also a problem when looking that far back: we have little concrete evidence of what these people were doing with wood, fibres, and other perishable materials.
Having said that, archaeologists used to talk about a "cultural revolution" that happened 20-30k years ago. (Maybe they still talk about it, I just haven't looked at the research recently). This was the period of the famous Lascaux cave paintings and what looks like an explosion of greater complexity in tool assemblages. So it's possible there was some rare cognitive leap at that time, or again it could be that we lack the evidence that would show the more gradual progression.
How could we possibly know this? The only case of "Dolphins" we know of, is on Earth, with the interference of humanity, and we're looking at Dolphins at a really small timescale.
Given N thousands of years without interference from other species, who can really confidently tell exactly how Dolphins would evolve?
Says land-living animal :)
Again, are you saying that you confidently can predict a hypothetical future where Dolphins, even given millions of years, would never invent the radio? I think it's unlikely too, but so are humans, so who knows what could happen.
I can't think of any plausible ways a water-bound species would be able to harness and use electricity either
I wonder if things would progress if they had the same level of communication that dolphins do.
Also, I don't think you're right that they could do this easily. Their hind limbs have almost completely vanished, their pelvis too, and they have no chance of moving on land. To have a chance they would need to redevelop those things which they've lost, and I don't think there's a particularly plausible path where each step helps their survival at that step. In contrast, their four-limbed land adapted ancestors could swim much better than dolphins can walk.
It's possible we are absolutely one-in-a-billion uniquely lucky - after all, someone has to be the first and the luckiest. But every year we find indications that our planet is completely typical.
If we are able to harvest the solar system resources it would take by then.
Trial run for the bigger “solar warming” event.
In 500 million years absolutely anything could happen (if we survive this century).
But it's certainly the mark of "the beginning of the end" for life on this planet - it's a major milestone that we (the species) do need to leave eventually if we want to continue.
Why does this one in-particular sound like they don't know what they are talking about? It would be just as accurate for me to say in the range of responses, yours kind of sounds like an anti-science bot. Typical of that type of thinking.
Your anti-science bot comment however, is very anti-science.
Of course, calling someone anti-anti-science. The new 'right'. Using science arguments against science. Yes. Your comment is typical, just spam fud. "look at this huge range, see, scientist don't know what they are doing"
[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Star_lifting [2] https://www.orionsarm.com/eg-article/4a48d58c84350
Even if all industrial activity stopped tomorrow there's now enough CO2 in the system to guarantee a succession of uncomfortable and expensive droughts, floods, storms, and wildfires for thousands of years.
If it doesn't they will become more and more extreme very quickly.
If ocean acidification and warming destroy the foodchain in the seas, collapse on land will happen very quickly.
No, probably very much more different than that, more like rolling back on industrialisation and globalisation. Closer to 500 years than 50, without the same hope of "progress" that we had back then.
> "mass extinction" already been happening for ages for many species.
Yeah, we all learned about dinosaurs when we were little kids, but if humanity collapses there's no guarantee of anything similar developing after us.
Why wouldn't there be any hope of progress? What is the force that would make this regression permanent? As I understand it, the whole problem with climate change is not the outcome of the climate but the speed of change being too high for plants and animals to adapt, either by migration or evolution.
Maybe once day, aliens will drop by and discover what remains of humanity. And stories will be told of how, when the time came, our species decided to bury its head in the sand and hope the problem would go away. Or maybe that we attempted to create god to come rescue us.
Life imitates art. We refused to listen to the scientists.
(warning, this is one of the most depressive pages on Wikipedia)
[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_the_far_future
The Sun will not become a red giant in 500 million years.
Now, in just .5B years Earth would likely become uninhabitable due to Sun becoming a red giant. In other words, on Earth life spent 90% of its total available time before sentience emerged. So on one side life is constrained simply by time, and on the other, sentience might not be necessary for organisms to thrive: crocodiles are doing just fine without one for hundreds of millions of years. To think of it, it is only needed for those who can't adapt to the environment without it, so humans really might be very special, indeed.