News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The German Model by Roritharr on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @07:57AM (#4349634)
Being german i find this very blandly written. Most of the German economists know and say that Germany is only at the top right now because it has profited so much from the Euro, especially on the cost of other EU countries.

I find this very shortsighted to attribute Germany's financial and economic situation to some underlying culture of perfection and expectation.

As much as i'd love to attribute our current success to these things, i think we should rather look at the very fortunate fiscal situation the EU positioned us in.

Re:The German Model by woodpanel on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @08:54AM (#4349816)
Most of the German economists know and say that Germany is only at the top right now because it has profited so much from the Euro

hmm must be a different Germany you live in ;-)

DER SPIEGEL from july 24th (http://www.spiegel.de/wirtschaft/soziales/euro-krise-oekonom...): 172 renown German economists published a joint appeal to stop the government from implementing the ESM. While in response only 17 renown european economists made their plea in favor of the governments pro-Euro policy.

Re:The German Model by sentenza on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @11:05AM (#4350396)
No, actually he is spot on. The European crisis is layered like an onion and if you peel away the outer layers like banking, sovereign debt and all the things we hear so much about in the press, then you will arrive at the core.

That core is a inner-European trade imbalance which makes the existence of the Euro blatantly unsustainable. If you look at the overall trade balance between the EU and the rest of the world, you will see that lately, imports have been about 20 % larger than exports.

Germany on the other hand is (and has been for years) an extreme exporter. Now if you add up the numbers, you will see that obviously there must be some very heavy importers within the EU. These importers are the countries that we all know and love from the news reports and the way through which they financed their extreme trade imbalances was through massive private debt (not public debt, that's an outer layer).

Here are some numbers on the trade balances (yeah, I know, it's wikipedia. But they present both figures in a readable manner and they list the sources.): http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Au%C3%9Fenhandelsstatistik#Entw...

Germany was only able to reach its position as such a massive exporter by

1. Being incredibly competitive to begin with 2. Artificially boosting competitiveness by 10+ years of nonexistent wage increases, (also crippling German domestic demand) 3. Having a majority of its most important trading partners locked inside the Euro, so that they couldn't mitigate their trade imbalance through inflation (better cash in your Lira fast...), thus boosting the net worth of German exports

And that number 3 is why this crisis is never going away. Yes, never.

All "they" can do is to repair parts of the outer onion shells, buying time. However, that inner core continues to exert a force towards destabilizing the European system. Every single fix to the trade imbalance problem, probably also all partial fixes, are politically infeasible.

You cannot have a continuous flow of money from one part of the European Economy towards the other without some sort of approximately equal flow of money in the other direction. What kind of flow? If we look at the United States as a group of States that is of roughly equal size and has about the same internal inequalities between states as the EU there emerges a list of transfers that are effective in couteracting trade imbalances:

Social security, Medicare, Common Bank Insurance, Military spending (wanna bet there are per capita more soldiers from Alabama than from Maryland?) and so on.

If this is what can fix this crisis, then I am all for it. However, it seems that I am part of a minority here in Europe. So collapse it is. Ein Ende mit Schrecken oder ein Schrecken ohne Ende.

Re:The German Model by woodpanel on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @12:30PM (#4350830)
Thank you for making your post so rich in information while at least giving me the information that you're not responding to anything I said right away.

No, actually he is spot on

No he is not. I'm not even arguing against the euro or ESM. The majority of german economists are.

Re:The German Model by sentenza on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @01:19PM (#4351071)
Ok. I'll admit that I got carried away and failed to actually respond to your 170 economists.

I'm a physicist and one thing that I have learned throughout the crisis is that macroeconomics is plagued by an inflated importance of "schools of thought". Current mainstream macroeconomists disagree on ridiculously many things that a layman would expect to be basic facts. In that regard, it is a huge problem that what you are referencing to is "the majority of German economists".

"The majority of German economists" belong to only one school of thought which has not really proven to be "the" school of thought.

For me personally, the most striking thing about this crisis is that what may ultimately break our neck (our as in we the informed public, having our destiny in our hands) is the existence of language barriers. Believe it or not, but the intellectual frame of reference that is taken by the German press and many German economists (and of course all of the politicians) is very different from that of most of the rest of the world. Several things that should urgently be debated in Germany are not debated, since _everyone just knows_ that they are wrong.

For instance, have you ever read an argument for higher inflation from a German economist (not Munchau) in an important German newspaper? Why not? Why is the hyperinflation of Weimar mentioned every now and then but no one publicly gives thought to why there were (and are) many countries that manage to live with inflation higher than 2% (the long term italian rate was around 4-5% throughout the eighties and nineties)?

Why is there no discussions of historical occurences of deflation and the problems/catastrophes they caused?

But let us add something more useful:

How should a non-economist judge if a text written by an economist is trustworthy?

Exclusion criteria:

* Claiming things without citing historical examples or adequatly discussing historical counterexamples. Believe it or not, most things out there have happened before.

* Inability to understand the frame of reference/underlying assumptions of the people whose opinion is _opposite_ to yours. If you think that "they" are all idiots, then you have not understood them or the problem.

* Not having a model. By model I mean that assertions of the type "When X happens, then Y should follow and Z should be impossible." or such are made.

Tldr: At this point there is no reason to just trust economists, no matter how great their number.

Re:The German Model by wazoox on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @11:55AM (#4350670)
> And that number 3 is why this crisis is never going away. Yes, never.

It'll go away when there is a huge financial and fiscal integration of the Eurozone (with a finance ministry, and large, integrated taxes). This, of course, looks right now like a pipe dream. But as the only way out, it may become true anyway.

Re:The German Model by Roritharr on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @09:30AM (#4349977)
The question whether or not to support the ESM is completely separate from the question where Germanys current success is coming from.

The 172 renowned economists are basically stating the obvious that covering for the spending sprees that our lending-power allowed the slow-economy EU countries will hurt the German economy.

To me the question if we should or shouldn't support the ESM is a moral one to which i don't have an answer. We benefited from the Euro the most and the very system that allowed our success is now asking who pays the bills. Tough question to answer.

Re:The German Model by cdavid on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @03:30AM (#4354384)
I don't think the number game is very interesting, but you have more than 17 european economists arguing for banking union (e.g. http://www.voxeu.org/article/manifesto-banking-union-economi...). That call from the 172 make a lot of noise because it went against the consensus, not because they are for the consensus.

One issue of the debate is that so much of it is covered with most moralistic arguments that are not very useful to solve the issue (Greece is bad, they must pay, Germany benefited from the Euro, they must pay, etc... the level is often that low). I think Germany's position is really hard: a breaking of the euro would be catastrophic for everyone, but particularly for Germany. OTOH, they will have to pay a big share of the damage, and long terms outlook for Germany are not good (bad demography in particular, see for example http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2011/11/how...).

Re:The German Model by Tichy on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @08:04AM (#4349649)
Do you have articles about this "benefiting from the Euro" thing? Being German myself, I still don't understand what they mean - and btw this seems mostly to be an accusation by the struggling European countries, not "most German economists"?

So how does it work - how do we profit from the Euro, on the cost of other EU countries?

Re:The German Model by HSO on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @08:33AM (#4349730)
It's a strawman. In every country, you will find sectors (and the associated people) who have a net gain from the EUR and some with a net loss. It doesn't really matter and would be impossible to figure out who benefits and loses more, both on the micro and the macro level.

I myself think about it in this (admittedly broad stroke) way:

1) The EUR is not just an economic project. It is a political instrument. That's why it exists, and that's what will determine its future. The economics is only a constraint (alas, now binding) not the objective.

2) No matter the history, a breakup now would be incredibly costly for everybody. Bob Rubin, US treasury secretary under Clinton, aptly described it as "Lehman times x". That's why a complete reversal is highly unlikely.

3) There is a solution: Peripheral states must accept a German-dominated external voice in their fiscal affairs; Germany must let the ECB monetize the debt. Neither of which is politically realistic.

4) In the absence of a conventional political solution, the continent "needs" a holy-shit-moment, something that will scare enough people sufficiently s.th. politicians can reach the costly compromise (3). So I expect one to happen.

5) What journalists, economists, and whoever writes about the success of a country ex post does not matter, it's just noise. Think about what people wrote about Japan in the 80s, the "Asian tigers" in the 90s, the "Washington consensus", etc etc. Until just a few months ago, it was China's state-dominated model, now it's Germany's social-consensus-based turn. Or, to stay with Germany, remember the Economist cover about "the sick man of europe"? It's quite similar to the attribution bias when successful people write autobiographies (or have biographies written about themselves). People like "the illusion of control", and a nice story with a neat, understandable "explanation" with max three identifiable causes or "factors" that led to the observation supports it.

Personally, I think the best way to test your understanding of how the world works is to make predictions and bet on them, preferably money, less preferably your reputation or your ego. So yeah, this article is probably blah but I will read it anyway because it will probably make me feel good, having grown up in and thus having links to the successful system du jour ;-)

Re:The German Model by stfu on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @11:46AM (#4350612)
1) The EUR is not just an economic project. It is a political instrument. That's why it exists, and that's what will determine its future. The economics is only a constraint (alas, now binding) not the objective.

This can not be repeated often enough. All the gloom and doom commentators making break-up predictions are highly underestimating this aspect. EU behavior can not be explained by rational/economic factors based logic.

Re:The German Model by erichocean on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @09:18PM (#4353359)
People like "the illusion of control", and a nice story with a neat, understandable "explanation" with max three identifiable causes or "factors" that led to the observation supports it.

Hmm. Reminds of a comment I just read here on HN. Trying to put my finger on it... :)

Re:The German Model by phreeza on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @12:55PM (#4350943)
Great comment. Can you explain what 'Germany must let the ECB monetize the debt.' means exactly?
Re:The German Model by maigret on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @04:38PM (#4352161)
Flood the debt with inflation ;) That means the ECB buys the debt basically, but of course it creates the Euros out of nothing, so that creates more Euros for the same economical situation.

The reason behind that is that if the ECB buys the debt, it can keep the rates under a certain level, buying everything that's above with its - theoretically - unlimited buying power. Of course that has a few flaws. The Euro is then less valued, so that's a reason more for wanting even more return on bonds.

Re:The German Model by lispm on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @11:45AM (#4350599)
good comment
Re:The German Model by czr80 on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @08:33AM (#4349732)
1) Cheap currency: "For German companies, the sinking euro acts as a kind of crisis buffer. While it reduces demand for German products within the euro zone, these make up only around 40 percent of the country's exports. But for the rest of the world, a weak euro means cheaper German products, which means they're more competitive."

2) Cheap credit: "But recently even interest rates on German bonds with longer maturities have decreased significantly. The federal government is saving a bundle. The reason for the windfall? Amid the ongoing euro crisis, Germany is one of the few borrowers that are still regarded as a safe haven. Many investors would rather lend the government money at bargain-basement rates than risk losses."

3) Inability of other countries to (quickly) adjust given single currency constraints, leading to, for example: "As mass protests form in Spain due to high unemployment among young people, Germany is benefiting from an influx of new skilled professionals. An increasing number of southern Europeans looking for work are heading north to prosperous Germany."

http://www.spiegel.de/international/europe/profiting-from-pa...

Re:The German Model by Roritharr on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @08:17AM (#4349677)
A good article about it in german is here: http://www.handelsblatt.com/politik/international/vorteile-d...

the tl;dr:

Germany is and was always a strong export oriented nation with our main-markets being in the direct vicinity. Before the Euro many of those neighbors hadn't had the economic lending power to build up their infrastructure and buy german goods.

With the introduction of the Euro these countries could suddenly lend money on the international markets with the support of the german rating, and spend that borrowed money to a large degree in Germany. (Greece is still buying German tanks...)

tl;dr of the tl;dr:

Germany is rich because other countries bought our stuff with money they could lend because of the trust the Euro had because of Germany.

Re:The German Model by bjourne on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @10:25AM (#4350203)
Does it really make sense to think about Germany as a separate entity from the rest of the Euro Zone? Economically, I think Germany is more like the center of a huge country with Spain and Greece being the poorer provinces... It is a very strange situation caused by too diverse countries having the same currency.
Re:The German Model by Tichy on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @10:31AM (#4350229)
Does that question even make sense? Does it make sense to even consider countries - after all, they are all just provinces in the world? Of course everything is connected. But Germans don't make the politics in Greece or Spain.
Re:The German Model by Tichy on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @08:22AM (#4349690)
OK I get that, but won't that backfire in a big way? It's happening right now, I guess... Still, I don't really think Germany can be blamed. Unless you think of the "weaker" countries as children who can't take responsibility for themselves. But why would Germany be smarter?

I think overall we are just lucky atm (or were lucky for a while...).

Re:The German Model by Roritharr on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @08:28AM (#4349707)
Thats why i said, the euro put Germany in a very fortunate situation. I can't imagine Ex-Chancellor Kohl expecting it to play out this way.

Its not that Germany is in any way smarter, Germany would probably have done the same, even if it were just on a governmental or banking level, as private lending is very conservative in Germany.

Re:The German Model by dan00 on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @09:37AM (#4350005)
"Still, I don't really think Germany can be blamed. Unless you think of the "weaker" countries as children who can't take responsibility for themselves."

Well, you can't directly blame Germany, that's right.

But someone had to lend all that money, and I don't believe, that no one could see the real financial situation in these countries.

So, what did the banks wrong, and why nobody looked after the banks?

Re:The German Model by Tichy on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @10:08AM (#4350132)
The banks are very well looked after, billions after billions of tax payer money are used to bail them out of their problems. I think for the banks just lending as much as they can makes perfect sense. They have no risk in this modern age.
Re:The German Model by rbehrends on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @08:21AM (#4349687)
Because Germany is an export-oriented economy with a huge trade surplus, primarily trading with other EU countries.

If the Euro didn't exist, the natural course of events would be for countries at the receiving end (who are running a trade deficit) to devalue their currencies. That would cut into German exports. But with a unified currency, devaluation to counter trade or current account imbalances is impossible.

Re:The German Model by Tichy on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @08:26AM (#4349703)
I have to admit, I never understood the point of devaluing your currency, except maybe for sneaking taxes by your citizens.

Say you want to buy a German car that costs 20000€, and your country uses Drachme, not Euro. How does devaluing Drachme help you afford the car? if you say "no, a Drachme is not worth 0.5 Euros anymore, it is only worth 0.05Euros", it only means you have to 10 times more Drachmes for the car than before?

Say you produce olives, and one pound of olives goes for 1 Eur. So you need to sell 20000 pounds of olives to afford the car. How does the valuation of Drachme enter into that?

Re:The German Model by czr80 on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @08:41AM (#4349763)
You don't buy a BMW. But:

1) You buy a local car because the foreign ones are all too expensive

2) BMW decides to build a plant in your country because it is so much cheaper.

Both of those things help grow your economy, growth leads to a stronger currency, and then you buy a nice new BMW.

Re:The German Model by Tichy on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @10:07AM (#4350126)
Why is it cheaper to build the factory in your country? Instead of paying with a devalued currency, you could simply pay less Euros? Same for buying local vs foreign cars - I just don't see how the currency makes a difference (or the possibility to devalue the currency).

Let's stick to olives: either you get x Euros for a pound of olives, or y Drachmes. In the end, if you want to buy a car, you have to exchange the Drachmes into Euros. You should get exactly x Euros for y Drachmes. Otherwise there would be an opportunity to get infinite olives for free. So it doesn't matter how much you devalue the Drachmes, you'll always get the same amount of Euros per pound of olives.

Re:The German Model by AkThhhpppt on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @10:28AM (#4350216)
If Drachmes are devalued, labour in Greece is cheaper than labour in Germany - workers get paid the same number of Drachmes as before devaluation, but they're paid less Euros.
Re:The German Model by Tichy on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @04:22PM (#4352062)
So it is mainly just cheating your citizens. I can't believe economists seriously put this forward as a problem. They should seek to educate the population, not defraud them.
Re:The German Model by AkThhhpppt on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @06:41AM (#4354855)
No, it's raising tariffs on imported goods by stealth.

<em>The currency only matters at the border</em>, so if the thing or person under consideration doesn't cross the border, devaluation doesn't matter.

Re:The German Model by eli_gottlieb on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @09:17PM (#4353353)
Ah, but the thing is, Greeks then find it massively easier to get out of debt to the other Euro nations.

Inflation has been called "austerity done right".

Re:The German Model by Tichy on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @04:11AM (#4354480)
That is kind of a "milk maid" equation, as we call it in Germany. If the Greeks wouldn't have the Euro, perhaps nobody would have lent them money to begin with. So at least if you advocate countries having their own currencies, you should be aware of that aspect. It's not as if problems (debts) just evaporate with control over the currency. You would have other problems instead.
Re:The German Model by eli_gottlieb on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @12:18PM (#4356389)
Yes, but it's much better to have a problem you can actually solve by taking responsibility yourself, rather than a problem whose solution relies on someone else being nice to you against their own interest (Southern Europe being on the same currency as Germany).
Re:The German Model by Tichy on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @05:54PM (#4358286)
But maybe those states would have been bankrupt much sooner, not being able to borrow without the Euro. That is what I mean - no problem would have been solved by not being on the Euro.
Re:The German Model by eli_gottlieb on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @07:44PM (#4358707)
Ok, let's talk two scenarios. First one: real world. We know how this one turns out.

Second one: Greece was never allowed into the Euro and off the Drachma. So what happens? Well, the lack of productivity in the Greek economy means the drachma stays and goes continually down in relation to the Euro, which we'll presume is the dominant currency-zone Greece wants to import from. The result is that Greece is forced to take responsibility for its own behavior much earlier-on, and without damaging impact on anyone else. At some point, the Greeks, in this scenario, simply cannot import much anything from Northern Europe, but their land, labor and capital become very cheap for external investors. Then, if the Greeks are at all smart, they get exploited for a little while to make foreign capital spend itself improving their productivity, until they can either become self-sufficient or balance their trade via cheap exports.

As Greek productivity improves, the drachma becomes more expensive, allowing the Greeks to then import more on the strength of their own economy rather than by borrowing from someone else.

It's simply a known fact in economics that separate macroeconomic policies and environments demand separate currencies, or else you get a financial crisis of some sort.

Re:The German Model by Tobias42 on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @10:48AM (#4350323)
I think it is a psychological issue. If salaries get cut by 30% across the country, people go to the streets. If you devalue their currency, most people don't even realize it and just accept that the prices for certain imported goods went up.
Re:The German Model by Tichy on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @04:23PM (#4352071)
I can understand the psychological aspects, but I can't accept that economists see that as a serious issue. It is like "oh dear, we can not cheat our citizens anymore", like saying "governments need the ability to defraud the population". They should instead seek to educate the population.
Re:The German Model by rrreese on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @02:03AM (#4354182)
It's not just that, while devaluation alters import prices local prices like rent and service costs don't fluctuate. So a 30% devaluation doesn't make people 30% poorer.
Re:The German Model by Tichy on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @04:15AM (#4354489)
Of course it would: in your example, the landlords would be poorer because they would collect less rent. Likewise for service providers. Perhaps you could argue for public services, but for those the government could just lower the fees instead of devaluing the currency.

But thanks to your example I see it has more subtleties: it is also a question who to take the money from. Making landlords poorer might be an easy sell to the majority of the population - if the population would have any idea of what is going on, which I doubt.

Services might just go away if they make less money.

Re:The German Model by AkThhhpppt on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @06:45AM (#4354872)
No, landlords would NOT be poorer, they're taking in exactly the same as before devaluation. Devaluation directly effects ONLY imports (more expensive) and exports (cheaper): it effects the local economy only based on how much it depends on each.
Re:The German Model by Tichy on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @12:38PM (#4356522)
That is simply false. Think it through.
Re:The German Model by AkThhhpppt on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @02:14PM (#4357084)
I am being paid a number of arbitrary denominators of value per time period.

Government declares that the arbitrary denominators of value now buy half the number of a different arbitrary denominators of value they did previously.

Because I am a locovore Luddite (for the sake of the argument), everything I buy is made in the country, with materials produced in the country.

How does the devaluation effect me?

Re:The German Model by rbehrends on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @10:45AM (#4350309)
Devaluing your currency makes foreign products more expensive relative to yours and makes your products cheaper relative to foreign ones. That means that it is less attractive to export goods to your country and more attractive to import from your country.

That does not mean that devaluation is a sinecure; for example, if you heavily depend on imported goods, it will drive prices for those goods up. But it can help correct trade and current account imbalances.

Also, devaluation is, more often than not, something that happens simply due to trading and market pressure and not because of government action. If a country keeps having a trade surplus, then its currency will automatically appreciate, unless there are countervailing forces.

Re:The German Model by skurry on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @01:35PM (#4351165)
Let's say you're Greece and you're a trillion Drachmes in debt. You can't pay the interest anymore, your deficit is too high. Greece uses INFLATION, it's super effective! Prices double, but wages double also. Tax income doubles. What stays the same is the debt, and suddenly Greece can afford to pay its lenders. National crisis averted. Only the lenders are screwed, and those who had their savings in Drachmes. That's also the reason why it's very popular to have savings accounts in "hard" currency in these countries.

That's how it has been for decades, but now with the Euro that's not possible anymore, leading to the Euro crisis.

Re:The German Model by iSnow on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @10:38AM (#4350261)
>How does devaluing Drachme help you afford the car It doesn't. On the contrary, it helps you export your home made Pallas Athene car.

Suppose it costs you 25000 GRD to build that car and that's 12500 € at 1 € = 2 GRD. You can sell it internationally for 15000 € for a profit of 2500 €.

Now the GRD plunges to 1 € = 4 GRD. Your costs stay at 25000 GRD but that is now only 6250 €. You either can continue to sell internationally for 15000 € and earn an extra 6250 € profit or reduce the price and sell a lot more thereby also raking in more cash.

Since you probably have to procure parts from abroad, the extra profit will be a lot less, but still it helps you _sell_.

Who pays the bill? Of course the general population if it continues to buy imported goods, because the price of those goes up. If only a part of the gen pop switches to buying domestic goods - hey even better for the domestic producers. Apart from making more on the international market, they gain on the domestic market.

Re:The German Model by lolcraft on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @11:22AM (#4350488)
Nope, it's the opposite, in fact. You confuse devaluation with depreciation. What should really happen is that Germany's currency should devaluate (via inflation).

I think of it as this: GIPS have massive debts in "German"-Euros. They also have prices too high in "Gypsy"-Euros, which is equivalent to say that GIPS have also salaries too low in "German"-Euros. They just can't pay that debt, because Gypsy salaries are too low, the prices are proportionately too high, and the debts are also too big.

What you do is, you create inflation only in Germany. Now German Euros are valued less, so wages and revenues grow. Gipsy Euros are valued the same as they were, so prices stay the same, and wages and revenues stay the same.

Now, this means that Germans want to buy more cheap Gypsy stuff and services, so there's now a trade deficit for Germany, and a trade surplus for the Gypsies. Which means an increase in wages and revenues for the GIPS, which is allocated to paying German debt.

The result is that the Gypsies get German jobs and German capital, and the Germans get their debt paid. This debt is, of course, of less value now for the Germans, they have to pay more for everything German, and there's less jobs on Germany, so they are pissed off. The thing is, they still win on the long term, because now they can buy cheaper Gypsy stuff, like Spanish-built German-designed cars. They can concentrate on more capital-intensive production, to offset lost jobs. Also, at least, they got back some of their debt.

Re:The German Model by lispm on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @10:26AM (#4350204)
Germany had a huge trade surplus before.

To devalue a currency is not a solution - the opposite. It may look attractive, but its effects are bad over long term. It for example makes imports more expensive.

Re:The German Model by maigret on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @04:35PM (#4352133)
Huge trade surplus before? When? http://www.indexmundi.com/g/g.aspx?c=gm&v=85 and http://www.tradingeconomics.com/germany/balance-of-trade

It correlates too well with the introduction of the Euro to be just random.

The issue is exactly that the Euro constantly devalues the German output - thus not slowing its increase in a natural way.

Re:The German Model by cdavid on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @08:16AM (#4349675)
The general idea is that Germany, since 2000 or so, did what is essentially an internal devaluation, by freezing salaries. This only works because Germany was the only big economy within the Eurozone to follow this policy. Note that GDP increase was not especially high in Germany compared to other countries with a similar size within the Euro (e.g. France did better in the 1999-2011 period: http://fatasmihov.blogspot.co.uk/2011/12/internal-devaluatio...). This policy cannot possibly work if other countries follow it within the Euro zone.
Re:The German Model by Tichy on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @10:29AM (#4350220)
What does that have to do with the Euro? And why can such a policy not work if "other countries follow it within the Euro" zone?

Also I wasn't aware that the government determines the salaries here in Germany. You are aware that the cold war is over and capitalism won, even here in Germany? We don't have a communist/socialist regime that can simply set salaries. Although the government can of course affect salaries by raising taxes (less net salary for everyone).

Re:The German Model by cdavid on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @11:21AM (#4350482)
If everybody decreases their labour cost everything else being equal, then obviously you don't get a competitive advantage from it. You just made everyone poorer. See also http://seekerblog.com/2012/01/17/euro-crisis-german-unit-lab... for the same line of arguments. Germany essentially gained market shares at the expense of other eurozone countries (0-sum game) instead of actual increases in productivity (which is not a 0-sum game).

As far as pressure for decreasing labour cost, this is pretty much uncontroversial. I did not say that Germany had a gvt authority setting salaries, but various factors such a pressure from high unemployment in the early 2000, and lower-than-eurozone inflation helped it (see e.g. http://www.voxeu.org/article/how-restore-competitiveness-eu - even though that article argues something closer to the opposite of what I am arguing here).

Re:The German Model by jordanlev on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @10:39AM (#4350271)
I just read this article which explains it nicely (IMO): http://www.stratfor.com/weekly/financial-markets-politics-an...
Re:The German Model by hessenwolf on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @08:50AM (#4349802)
I agree.

My colleague who sits across from me finished uni when Italy was booming and Italy knew all the economic answers. I finished uni when Ireland was booming and Ireland knew all the economic answers.

Germany is booming, but most people don't know why. Ten years ago it was absolutely the sick man of Europe, and now here in Germany they the economic answers? Erm, ja, bestimmt.

Re:The German Model by JackFr on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @08:51AM (#4349804)
I would go one step farther and say it is poorly written. It is rambling, disorganized, and lacks both both narrative structure and thematic clarity. It offers no systematic analysis, and confounds anecdotal evidence with personal rembrances. It reads like a the runner-up entry in a write like Thomas Friedman competition (which is not a good thing.)
Re:The German Model by foobarian on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @09:36AM (#4350001)
I always wondered how much Germany benefited from the restrictions on keeping a standing army, and being (effectively) defended by the U.S. military. The chunk of budget spent on that surely must have been used more productively.
Re:The German Model by lispm on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @10:42AM (#4350284)
Which restriction do you think of? Germany had many hundred thousands of soldiers. A huge standing army. Lots of military equipment. We bought stuff from the US. Germany even paid the US for the presence in Germany. We even paid you for the first gulf war.

What Germany did though: once the cold war was over, we reduced our military. The threat was over.

Accordingly the US reduced its presence in Germany. The rest of the US presence here is working on keeping the US empire. For example the central command for africa is in Germany. Hospitals pick up the soldiers from Iraq and Afghanistan. Logistics...

Re:The German Model by morsch on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @09:54AM (#4350072)
I'm not sure there are any such restrictions anymore. Germany has a standing army of about 200k soldiers, down from 450k in 1990. The US still has about 50k troops in Germany, but I don't think they're defending us (or controlling us) as much as they're hanging around in an allied state closer to multiple conflict zones.
Re:The German Model by lispm on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @10:36AM (#4350256)
I thought that our economic success had something to do with working people who produce stuff which is in high demand worldwide: machines, tools, cars, trains, aircrafts, energy systems, chemicals, ...
Re:The German Model by morsch on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @11:04AM (#4350394)
That just means that "we" are selling stuff people would like to buy -- the supply side --, not that they are buying it from "us", or even buying it from anybody at all -- the demand side.

Being able to buy stuff requires money, and one way of getting money is borrowing it. The Euro resulted in incredibly low interest rates for all the EUR countries, making borrowing money very easy. Certain German entities were also very happy to lend out, having lots of spare money.

Having money is not enough, though, you need to have money in a stable currency. So far the Euro has been very stable. Many of the countries that have got the Euro got in by falsifying statistics, something that was widely known at the time.

Finally, Germany engineered it's economy into extreme efficiency. You can do that by being super smart, broadly speaking, and by being super cheap. I guess Germany did the former; it certainly did the latter and Germany's working force suffered for it: increased retirement age, increased VAT, stagnant net real wages, reduced benefits, reduced unemployment, etc.

The end result: We drove our economy with a focus on exporting stuff to countries which can't really afford it, buy pay us with money borrowed from us. If/when they default, we're left with a huge amount of worthless defaulted loans, a huge export oriented economy that suddenly has lost most of its customers and not enough internal demand to make up for it.

Re:The German Model by lispm on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @11:43AM (#4350588)
'reduced unemployment' is hardly suffering. The opposite was true: we had, and still have, a lot of people without employment perspective. The main goal of the policies was to drive unemployment down - especially in the new states.

> Many of the countries that have got the Euro got in by falsifying statistics

A few. Not 'many'.

You seem to go for the easy explanation. In the EU and the Eurozone countries are still responsible for their politics. Even their economic politics.

It's also not Germany which lend especially much money to our southern partners in the EU. Check out France, US, Britain, ... The speculators were most from areas and industries which were not especially 'German'. German banks were dumb enough to follow the lead of the investment banks and speculators.

Each country has to:

* reduce debt * keep an educated work force * invest money wisely * prevent bubbles

That Spain had a housing bubble is not Germany's fault. That Greece has incompetent economics and finance is also not Germany's fault. Our fault was to sell them submarines. But I bet the Nato partners were more than happy that Greece wanted them. That Ireland's economy collapsed was also not our fault.

If you are not aware the is a global economy competition. Germany wanted to keep Europe able to compete. Many others made themselves a nice time - brought their money to offshore tax havens, to Switzerland, speculated in London, speculated in the housing boom.

Its not really our fault that we have no housing bubble, our investment banks were stupid enough, but the damage could be contained, we reduced our budget deficit, ...

Instead of blaming Germany, you should look at the incompetent politicians of those countries who are not able to collect taxes, not able to control bubbles, not able to invest in the 'real' economy instead of virtual ones, who are not able to balance their budgets.

Germany made enough mistakes on their own. For example we sold infrastructure to foreign investors. We were told that this was so much better. Huge mistake.

Re:The German Model by lmm on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @12:59PM (#4350967)
It's a lot harder to prevent bubbles when you don't control your own interest rates. The ECB kept interest rates low to reduce German unemployment, at the cost of feeding housing bubbles in Spain and Ireland.
Re:The German Model by lispm on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @01:34PM (#4351157)
The ECB did not set interest rates to reduce German unemployment. That's not their task. The ECB's main task is to provide a stable currency.
Re:The German Model by morsch on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @03:25PM (#4351790)
None of my arguments/observation depends on who is responsible. I don't really care who is to blame, I think the notion is fairly ridiculous given the situation.
Re:The German Model by tylee78 on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @10:07AM (#4350127)
being German myself, I cannot agree more. I was sometimes wondering if the author of this article was in the same country that I left. But I have seen this tendency before: people who visited Germany in the 60s, 70s and 80s have a "mental picture" of Germany that only partially fits reality. The structural unemployment is still very high, the educational system is a mess, the tax rates and regulations are borderline insane.