News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by rdtsc on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @02:43PM (#43485428)
> Lidden pleaded guilty to offences under Australia's nuclear non-proliferation act that carry a possible 10-year jail sentence.

The bureaucratic apparatus, especially dealing with law enforcement always concentrates people who enjoy punishing others. Is Australia particularly bad about it perhaps? It seems they get some kind of sadistic enjoyment out of it. It's scary that everyone in the chain here: judge Leonie Flannery, Australian Border Force officials, police, even his employer just had a grand 'ol time punishing this guy. Everyone could have stopped, realizing it's obvious what's happening, give him a warning have him turn in this sample.

And the best part for them, there is no repercussion for it. Everyone can turn around and publicly proclaim they just "did their job".

Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by randomNumber7 on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @03:05PM (#43485712)
> It seems they get some kind of sadistic enjoyment out of it.

> Everyone could have stopped, realizing it's obvious what's happening, give him a warning have him turn in this sample.

I think the sad truth is that they are probably ignorant enough to not even think about it.

Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by logicchains on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @02:49PM (#43485500)
>Is Australia particularly bad about it perhaps

I'm an Australian, and Australia is absolutely terrible in this regard. There's a saying: the problem with Australia isn't that it was founded by prisoners, it's that it was founded by prison guards. I've lived in quite a few countries and never found anywhere with as many smug and self-righteous people as back home. There used to be two kinds of Australia: the larrikin (fun loving, prankster) Australia, and the wowser (fun hating) Australia, but in recent years the wowsers have thoroughly won.

Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by Larrikin on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @03:00PM (#43485645)
Hopefully they make a come back
Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by alabastervlog on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @05:55PM (#43487852)
> larrikin

This has become a kind of stock character (or, at least, a stock archetype for characters) in Australian media, and can be seen in lots of e.g. Australian or heavily Australian-influenced films, often portrayed in a basically-positive, if imperfect, light. This sort of attitude toward life and behavior is on display among several characters in the Peter Weir film Gallipoli, for instance, including and especially Mel Gibson's. In that film, the wowser-est folks are mostly British, because national myth-making :-)

Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by mvdtnz on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @08:19PM (#43489068)
I lived in Australia for five years and this is exactly the reason I left. Everyone is a stickler, NIMBYs own the cities and the police are always out to get you. Australians have an undeserved reputation for being "laid back" but they are absolutely the opposite. Any chance for a new rule or regulation is embraced by the population.
Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by smelendez on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @08:31PM (#43489135)
A laidback reputation can be a sign of an entrenched elite with a lot of leisure time.

This is the case in a lot of the US South.

Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by hilbert42 on Thursday March 27, 2025 @06:44AM (#43492174)
"This is the case in a lot of the US South."

I understand your reasoning re US South but 'laid-back' in the Australian context refers more to a 'laxadaisical' or 'couldn't-care-less' attitude—or that's what it used to mean. Class doesn't much enter the picture. :-(

Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by smelendez on Friday March 28, 2025 @03:48AM (#43502659)
Every race and class in Australia expresses this attitude equally?
Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by kelseydh on Thursday March 27, 2025 @02:14AM (#43490802)
Funny enough I'm experiencing the opposite: I moved to Western Australia and find the police presence much lighter than Canada or America.

Traffic stops by police are virtually nonexistent because speed cameras already do the work of traffic enforcement for the police. Unlike North America, it is very rare to drive and actually see somebody pulled over by the police.

The cameras are strict through. Demerits double on holidays and no amount of fine payment can get out of a license suspension.

Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by hilbert42 on Thursday March 27, 2025 @06:26AM (#43492062)
"I've lived in quite a few countries and never found anywhere with as many smug and self-righteous people as back home."

This is pretty much my experience too although the UK would come close.

"…the larrikin (fun loving, prankster), …and the wowser (fun hating) …but in recent years the wowsers have thoroughly won."

Any Australian who's not aware of this hasn't been around long enough to notice it. Frankly it's horrible, I now feel as if I'm an alien and no longer belong here.

I've my own thoughts as to why this cultural shift has occurred in such a comparatively short time but there'd be little point me posting them here. I wonder if there's any proper research on this, if not then I'd suggest it'd be deemed politically incorrect/too hot to handle.

Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by caycep on Thursday March 27, 2025 @03:50PM (#43497406)
Is this basically the source of a lot of Rhys Dharby jokes?
Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by bell-cot on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @03:02PM (#43485662)
Never been there...but my impression (mostly from articles on British news web sites) is that Australia has long had a reputation for systematized legal sadism.
Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by grumpy-de-sre on Thursday March 27, 2025 @02:48AM (#43490991)
Particularly the Australian border security industrial complex.

Ostensibly a great idea to protect Australian agri-business (don't kind yourself it's not about the environment). But in practice hasn't been particularly effective in achieving its stated goals [1][2][3].

Extremely effective at bullying autistic kids interested in chemistry though. There's a lot of stories.

1. https://www.abc.net.au/news/2021-02-26/white-spot-prawn-dise...

2. https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/article/2024/sep/...

3. https://www.abc.net.au/news/2025-03-03/black-market-tobacco-...

Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by mrkeen on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @06:05PM (#43487963)
> Is Australia particularly bad about it perhaps?

We may need to gather more data. He's literally the first person to be sentenced for a law which has been on the books for decades. In the meantime: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_incarcera...

> Judge Leonie Flannery, Australian Border Force officials, police, even his employer just had a grand 'ol time punishing this guy.

Maybe? I'm gonna wait until after the sentence has been imposed to decide whether it's excessive or not.

Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by jayrot on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @06:45PM (#43488333)
The best is when they use flimsy arguments about needing to "make an example" or "discourage this behavior" or "create a deterrent", as if people in these situations are even aware they're doing anything wrong.
Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by potato3732842 on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @07:39PM (#43488796)
The message being sent is "even if we can't prove intent we still can completely ruin your life"
Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by motorest on Thursday March 27, 2025 @02:57AM (#43491036)
> The message being sent is "even if we can't prove intent we still can completely ruin your life"

The message is "you should not import or be in possession of elements subjected to nuclear proliferation restrictions".

For those arguing the guy is just massively dumb and naive, are you aware this depicts the character as even more dangerous to himself and society?

Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by HelloMcFly on Thursday March 27, 2025 @08:10AM (#43492762)
> For those arguing the guy is just massively dumb and naive, are you aware this depicts the character as even more dangerous to himself and society?

No, because he hasn't done anything actually dangerous to society, it's not like he bought anything that can be weaponized. Is he a danger to himself? Only insomuch as his actions have landed him in jail.

Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by ty6853 on Thursday March 27, 2025 @08:17AM (#43492809)
It's a problem because if every single Australian imported one of these samples and put them in a potluck they would achieve enough mass for one or two nuclear weapons. Then Australia would become a nuclear power and finally conquer their arch enemy, the annoying island sidekick of New Zealand.
Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by SpicyLemonZest on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @07:57PM (#43488922)
Awareness that you're doing something wrong is a spectrum. Obviously this guy wasn't intending to build a nuclear bomb, but I'm extremely skeptical that a science nerd could get to the point of building a periodic table collection without learning that plutonium is dangerous and heavily restricted. (The source article doesn't cover this, so just to make sure we're on the same page: plutonium is _not_ any more legal to export from the US than it is to import into Australia, and whoever sold it to this guy was almost surely breaking the law too.)
Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by AuryGlenz on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @09:16PM (#43489444)
I don’t think it’s crazy for someone to know that you can buy uranium and not realize the full difference between that and plutonium.
Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by zoky on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @09:53PM (#43489645)
I think somebody who doesn’t know the full difference between uranium and plutonium definitely shouldn’t be having any.
Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by mcny on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @10:29PM (#43489831)
They shouldn't have any but also shouldn't face jail.
Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by motorest on Thursday March 27, 2025 @03:00AM (#43491046)
> They shouldn't have any but also shouldn't face jail.

If they are in possession of it, yes they should.

Here's a refreshment of what harm these morons can cause ti society.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goi%C3%A2nia_accident

Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by Ukv on Thursday March 27, 2025 @09:16AM (#43493295)
From what others have posted, this sample was apparently 35 nanograms salvaged from a smoke detector - and was sold by the online store embedded within an acrylic cube labelled "plutonium" in addition to still being in the original casing from the smoke detector.

To me it seems like that's strictly less likely to cause a Goiânia incident than when it was just in an old smoke detector that could've potentially be thrown out without consideration.

Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by ty6853 on Thursday March 27, 2025 @09:28AM (#43493409)
>Four months before the theft, on May 4, 1987, Saura Taniguti, then director of Ipasgo, the institute of insurance for civil servants, used police force to prevent one of the owners of IGR, Carlos Figueiredo Bezerril, from removing the radioactive material that had been left behind.

The Goiania accident was caused by government imposition, stopping the owners from moving it from the abandoned clinic before it was looted. The government was the moron there, just as the government is the moron in this story. So a good example, but not in the way you thought, as it shows government intervention with nuclear materials leading to needless tragedy.

Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by greenavocado on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @08:47PM (#43489239)
The Royal Australian Air Force shut down airspace over an air force base to test fire a “high-powered” single-shot .50 caliber rifle. They are a parody of themselves.
Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by defrost on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @11:53PM (#43490243)
The RAAF didn't test fire, nor did they "shut down" the air space.

Politicians and the police staged an air field adjacent test firing for media that carried risks that caused restricted, and warning notices to be issued for the air space.

  A Department of Defence spokeswoman said the activity was supported by Defence.

  “For safety, Air Force used a notice to airmen and provided air traffic control for a period of time in the vicinity of the area,” she said.

  “At no time were RAAF Base Pearce’s flying operations impacted. The activity was coordinated between WA Police and Defence in accordance with standard procedures.”

  National Shooting Council vice president told News Corp the demonstration was an “orchestrated media event to create fear in the community ... they were clearly told it was too risky but they went ahead anyway”.

  “There was a very, very high risk of ricochets and therefore injury to members of the public, press and police attending because of the type of targets they were shooting at … they were very lucky to get away with it with no-one being injured, killed or worse for this little sh.t show,” he said.
~ https://thewest.com.au/politics/state-politics/raaf-base-pea...

^^ NOTICE: this is from two years past in 2023 .. The Western Australian newspaper website has wrapped this with a masthead with todays date (2025). If you search on the story there are several links from 2023 referencing this .. I cannot fathom why The West has done this to date other than it's a rag with a monopoly in a small state and they can't be arsed to do a good job here.

Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by ultrarunner on Thursday March 27, 2025 @12:43AM (#43490457)
As a pilot, if I see a notam "that caused restricted … notices to be issued"-- especially in a military context-- I would be very comfortable describing the affected airspace as "shut down". I'm probably missing something as your link to an apparently low quality story is also paywalled. Maybe they're referring to the fact that the military almost always exempts itself from its TFRs, so technically it wasn't completely "shut down", but by that definition no airspace is ever shut down.
Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by defrost on Thursday March 27, 2025 @01:31AM (#43490627)

  “At no time were RAAF Base Pearce’s flying operations impacted. 
I'm also a pilot .. that RAAF base is mostly low traffic and my reading of everything published is they scheduled the media event for dead time and didn't have to abort or turn anything about.

I'd go further and guess that had the base been required for anything (sudden emergancy landing, etc) the media event would have been shut down and pushed away.

None of which supports the hyperbolic aspects of the original GP claim above.

Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by HeatrayEnjoyer on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @11:38PM (#43490182)
>to test fire a “high-powered” single-shot .50 caliber rifle.

Maybe that's just the public explanation.

Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by motorest on Thursday March 27, 2025 @02:54AM (#43491025)
> (...) as if people in these situations are even aware they're doing anything wrong.

Does this excuse even fly? I mean, do you actually believe that a guy who is a self-described "science nerd" with enough interest in chemistry to sought to get a sample of each element of the periodic table would somehow skip any and all references on how the element is subjected to nuclear proliferation restrictions?

Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by GoblinSlayer on Thursday March 27, 2025 @04:04AM (#43491331)
>investigators were aware he had obtained this material and it was in a very small quantity.

It was a small quantity. For comparison Trinity had 6 kg of plutonium.

Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by lenkite on Thursday March 27, 2025 @03:04AM (#43491070)
Yes, it is possible. Have seen a few nerds who could solve Math Olympiad problems in a jiffy but had extreme trouble navigating government bureaucracy.
Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by motorest on Thursday March 27, 2025 @03:11AM (#43491108)
> Yes, it is possible.

Bullshit. You are hard pressed to find a reference to Plutonium without having references to nuclear proliferation. That excuse does not fly.

> (...) had extreme trouble navigating government bureaucracy.

Cut the crap. This is not a bureaucracy problem. This is a problem caused by a moron importing a substance subjected to international non-proliferarion agreements.

Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by arkh on Thursday March 27, 2025 @04:06AM (#43491340)
I remember doing some radiation absorption experiment with some radioactive material in chemistry class in high school. I would be surprised to get to jail for ordering some milligram of plutonium.
Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by lenkite on Thursday March 27, 2025 @03:28AM (#43491195)
You should blame the Australian border force officials for being the true morons not this young man. He went ahead and ordered plutonium from a US-based science website openly with his real name and residential address - he didn't hide anything.

The most surprising thing to me is that it was actually delivered. Seems you can really buy anything from the internet.

Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by knodi123 on Thursday March 27, 2025 @08:31AM (#43492905)
> The most surprising thing to me is that it was actually delivered. Seems you can really buy anything from the internet.

Not surprising to me. Unrefined nuclear material really isn't particularly rare, or dangerous. You could create more havoc and terror with pool cleaning chemicals. And it's legitimately valuable for all sorts of purposes, including education and research.

It's not like we're talking about a giant green glowing rock that will generate a mushroom cloud if you drop it on a hard floor.

Hell, I've bought stuff from these guys: https://unitednuclear.com/radiation-and-nuclear-c-2/

Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by piokoch on Thursday March 27, 2025 @10:39AM (#43494134)
I would say that "nuclear proliferation" is about not letting North Korea or Israel getting nuclear weapons [1], not chasing random guy who tried to purchase infinitesimal amount of plutonium.

[1] As we know, both efforts failed.

Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by caseyy on Thursday March 27, 2025 @08:16AM (#43492798)
Many industrial websites exist in chemistry, weapons, and radio equipment, which don't check buyers' credentials and sell items not allowed to the general public.

The most broadly visible case is web stores that sell e-bikes with power ratings that demand a moped license to those who don't have one. Or ones that sell e-scooters (PLEVs) in countries where they are illegal to use on roads, such as the United Kingdom.

Generally, people assume what's broadly and openly available is legal. Nothing educates them that this is not always true. They would be deterred if they knew there was a law book somewhere prohibiting the purchase. But they won't be any more deterred by a law book somewhere with this case law, or a news article they won't have read, now.

Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by potato3732842 on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @07:36PM (#43488772)
It does this because "the purpose of the system is what it does"

It ain't no different than the king's men occasionally cutting down a peasant that didn't remove his hat quickly enough when the king rode by. By screwing people on a whim the system sends a "don't cross me, I hold complete power" message which acts as a force multiplier (until it doesn't but Aus isn't there yet).

Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by intrasight on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @07:45PM (#43488844)
> Aus isn't there yet

Nor is Trump

Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by pjc50 on Thursday March 27, 2025 @06:24AM (#43492049)
No, Australia has a very rigid import control system for biosecurity purposes, because the country is currently free of various animal and plant diseases which are endemic in other countries. One infected piece of fruit could, they believe, destroy an industry.

If they fine someone $3k for a chicken sandwich, https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/fined-3300-for-chicken-sandwic... , what are they going to do with plutonium?

Arguably plutonium guy is being hit with the book precisely to remind everyone who wants to come to Australia that they take import control very, very seriously.

(as well as, you know, the xenophobia that gets involved in any discussion of borders)

Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by franga2000 on Thursday March 27, 2025 @06:46AM (#43492186)
A chickend sandwich is probably more dangerous to Australia than a tiny vial of plutonium. Not that I'm saying the 3k fine for what clearly seems like a mistake is reasonable, just that this is even more unreasonable.
Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by GistNoesis on Thursday March 27, 2025 @08:34AM (#43492936)
What's the recommended way to handle being in such a Kafkaesque situation?
Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by red-iron-pine on Thursday March 27, 2025 @09:02AM (#43493168)
you wrote a lot of words to mean "they want to send a message"

and that's what's happening to plutonium joe over there: a not so gentle reminder to the rest of the country not to import shit you shouldn't.

and often in cases like these they do a quite "good behavior" release a year later or something. sometimes, anyway.

Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by bawolff on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @07:42PM (#43488819)
I don't think he should go to jail, and it could have been handled better, but i still think laws against purchasing/importing dangerous substances are reasonable, and a fine is reasonable in such a circumstance.
Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by m463 on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @09:00PM (#43489334)
I seem to recall drug laws in mexico having carveouts to decriminalize small quantities to prevent abuse by law enforcement anywhere in the chain.

Also, speed limits in some states can't be enforced from 0 to 5mph over the limit.

Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by roenxi on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @11:47PM (#43490227)
The attitude of all boundaries being fuzzy is probably more harmful than anything else. You end up with a bunch of laws that aren't laws but just overdone public guidelines. A speed limit should be the limit. If we're agreeing on a Speed Recommended then it should be called that instead. Those are states with a speed limit and then they've encoded the limit in the law as (limit - 5). It doesn't change much except to annoy the pedants and make it harder to figure out what is actually legal.
Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by Brian_K_White on Thursday March 27, 2025 @01:47AM (#43490686)
The attitude that ignores the reality that there is no such thing as a perfect measuring instrument...

If you make the law that simplistic, then any good lawyer can void any ticket because no one can actually prove the charge. That will surely be better.

But if the limit is N and the claim is that you did N+10, then it doesn't matter how accurate the measurement is, you definitely did something over N. They don't have to prove something unprovable, they only have to prove that their measurments have always been consistently within a range of error that is nowhere near 10.

Removing some utility for abuse (which could also be targeted/prejudicial/discrimination abuse) is a net positive.

The real world is not as neat as ideals. The real world IS fuzzy, and can not be wished or ignored away.

Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by roenxi on Thursday March 27, 2025 @04:49AM (#43491542)
> But if the limit is N and the claim is that you did N+10, then it doesn't matter how accurate the measurement is, you definitely did something over N.

That isn't correct on a couple of levels. Firstly, the accuracy could be +-11 so the accuracy still matters for working out if something happened. Secondly if the accuracy is +-0.01 then if it clocks you at N+1 then we still know you've broken the law, no argument needed.

Fundamentally you're just arguing that the law is offset by 10. That doesn't really addressed the major issue, which is why offsetting the law by 10 has helped. We may as well offset the law by 0 - then the law could be interpreted by looking up the value in the rulebook instead of having to calculate a different value.

> The real world is not as neat as ideals. The real world IS fuzzy, and can not be wished or ignored away.

Sure, but we may observe that routinely offsetting the value in the law by a constant doesn't change that. In fact it only adds ambiguity because the constant probably isn't written down or consistently determined.

Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by m463 on Thursday March 27, 2025 @01:52AM (#43490708)
Shouldn't there be some fuzzy laws and some not?

Speed limits are something that people could break through a moment of inattention, so maybe there should be some resilience, even though there is a numerical limit.

On the other hand "high crimes and misdemeanors" might be purposefully vague.

Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by seb1204 on Thursday March 27, 2025 @05:54AM (#43491867)
Yes and no. The speeder will always drive on the limit plus tolerance. Trucks in Germany are limited to 80 km/h, there are still 'races' between two trucks overtaking each other at their 80.
Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by directgimkc on Thursday March 27, 2025 @02:46AM (#43490982)
Funny you should mention speed recommended, we have just the placard: https://imgur.com/a/R3ZeM5A

Usually spotted near very sharp turns on highway exits. They don't force you to slow down, but unless you want to suddenly switch lanes to ones 20 meters below you probably want to.

Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by BrawnyBadger53 on Thursday March 27, 2025 @11:05AM (#43494413)
Not having the fuzzy zone on speed limits will make people go too slow and build traffic. You're meant to drive right up to the limit and anyone with an analog speedometer has to deal with some visual inaccuracy. It is ridiculous to punish people because the speed limit was 45 and someone is going 46 when 45 isn't even clearly marked on the speedometer for these cars.
Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by msm_ on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @09:38PM (#43489563)
>Also, speed limits in some states can't be enforced from 0 to 5mph over the limit.

In my country that's also true (with marigin larger than 5mph), but my understanding is that that's because the measurements instruments (laser-based speed meters) are not perfect and it may be a mistake and not actual speed limit breach.

Some methods of measuring car speed don't have this limitation, like range-based measurements (check time when car enters road segment, when it leaves road segment, and make sure the average is under the speed limit).

Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by FireBeyond on Thursday March 27, 2025 @12:30PM (#43495294)
And less so now, but also speedometers. As I was growing up in Australia, there was a legislated margin of error of 10% for speedo inaccuracy. And I want to say some time in the late 90s, early aughts, that margin was changed to 3km/h across the board. I don't know how that interacted with speed camera tolerances.
Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by cjbgkagh on Thursday March 27, 2025 @02:05AM (#43490775)
Bureaucracies generally busy themselves by going after soft targets as they represent easy wins, an extra line item for the yearly review.

There is a popular Australian TV show called Utopia that satirizes modern Australian government bureaucracies, I am lead to believe that it is quite accurate.

That said I would expect clemency in the sentencing.

Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by throwaway2037 on Thursday March 27, 2025 @03:52AM (#43491285)

    > That said I would expect clemency in the sentencing.
I feel the same. Intent and impact matters. Intent: It is up to the judge to decide if the defendant's intent was pure/non-violent -- I believe it is. Impact: From the news, we can see the material never reached the defendant, and it was safely captured. So the actual impact is zero. (To be clear: I am not apologizing for him breaking the law!)

This is a great opportunity for the attorney general office to recommend a special punishment: A long suspended sentence (5 years is reasonable) with no jail time and a X-year (X=1?) commitment from the defendant to participate in a public education campaign.

Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by motorest on Thursday March 27, 2025 @02:46AM (#43490983)
> Everyone could have stopped, realizing it's obvious what's happening, give him a warning have him turn in this sample.

That would turn the task of importing plutonium as a low-risk, high-reward job. That is exactly the opposite of what'd intended.

It's well justified that the guy gets the maximum sentence. Feigning ignorance is not an excuse.

Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by bn-l on Thursday March 27, 2025 @05:18AM (#43491678)
Damn are you sure you’ve never been to Australia? I can confirm that your instincts are absolutely spot on about this country in general.
Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by pessimizer on Thursday March 27, 2025 @09:01AM (#43493155)
> And the best part for them, there is no repercussion for it. Everyone can turn around and publicly proclaim they just "did their job".

More than no repercussions; they all make a very good living from this. When Australia decides that they are going to ask to put him away for 10 years, they're saying that they're going to spend at least a million dollars on this incident. They know what happened, they know that it's a pointless expenditure, but they're still going to make it.

They're going to pay lawyers, use courtrooms and the time of judges, investigators and regular officers, all in the service of hopefully housing and feeding an unwilling adult for a decade. Triggered by a nerd importing an infinitesimal amount of plutonium for his nerd collection.

It will somehow be even more shameful when they go through all of this, and then the prosecutor drops the charges, or asks him to plead guilty for no time, no fine, and no record if not arrested for a similar thing outside of some time period. That will mean all of this was just makework.

My only conclusion is that either they don't have enough to do, or they are refusing to do things that are difficult. But either way this nonsense should be taken as an opportunity by management and the public which is currently highlighting government employees that it would be good to fire or replace. They don't have a problem with procedure, they have a problem with personnel.

Re:'Naive' science fan faces jail for plutonium import by SideburnsOfDoom on Thursday March 27, 2025 @10:43AM (#43494179)
> Is Australia particularly bad about it perhaps?

Australian border security is notoriously strict. So in this specific case, yes, and everyone knows it.