News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by awongh on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @09:23AM (#43411609)
I read a fair amount and I actually do research as leisure all the time, but I can’t stand these elitist and unoriginal think pieces about how much better and cooler this person’s habits are than yours.

>> for the leisurely researcher, self-study must include the discipline’s foundational texts

I feel like this person has some kind of dark academia aesthetic fetish that they need to hold onto to feel superior to everyone else.

I actually deeply agree with the advice in the OP around curiosity but personally I end up implementing it in a totally different way than they do.

Lately I’ve found that LLMs are an amazing tool for this free-floating “research”- for example “Summarize the top three theories about why suburbs exist and who said them”. The LLM as open ended semantic search engine / research tool is an amazing way to figure out the topology of a subject you want to dive deeper into.

I usually work my way down a content ladder from there to podcasts, wikipedia and finally to books.

The idea that somehow civilization is ending because of our media consumption habits and that “reading source material” will save us comes off as more an aesthetic fantasy than a real-world complaint about today’s culture.

I was around before the internet and I’m so thankful that so much more information is accessible now than it was when there were only books.

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by kevinsync on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @10:53AM (#43412803)
>> I feel like this person has some kind of dark academia aesthetic fetish that they need to hold onto to feel superior to everyone else.

The older I get, the more I'm convinced that people do this less to actually feel superior to others and more as a desperate act of establishing an identity, ANY identity, to simply feel seen and validated in spite of just being yet another person on the planet. This uniquely-human trait seems to run counter to the natural order, where spotted leopards, panthers, elephants, myriad birds all just exist and go about their lives, despite their objective, innate individualities.

We are curious creatures lol

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by cjbgkagh on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @11:02AM (#43412930)
Plenty of animals go out of their way to be seen. If it’s a pretty bird it’s most likely a male bird.

Animals at play do appear to show off to each other. Orcas wear salmons as hats as if it was a fast fashion trend.

I don’t think humans are unique in this regard at all.

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by woodson on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @11:12AM (#43413059)
These observations are interpretations of behavior viewed through human eyes. (What’s the concept of a “hat” to an orca?)

Perhaps we interpret their behavior this way because it is our behavior.

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by PaulHoule on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @11:37AM (#43413437)
As someone who's had quite a few dealings with animals (the family business is a horse farm) my interpretation is that human psychology is basically animal psychology with a "language instinct" bolted on as a peripheral.

You might very well misinterpret an animal's experience or motives but it is not just mistaken "anthropomorphism" but could just be the same kind of misunderstanding you might have about another person's experience or motives.

From time to time I see a paper proving that horses or dogs could do something that people who work with horses or dogs always believed they could do or that some bird or mammal has a "theory of mind" -- I believe all birds and mammals have a pretty good "theory of mind", it's just hard to do an experiment to prove it.

We've had a cardinal that has been coming to our window for a few years that we can't agree on naming "bad bird" or "noisy bird" that sets up a nest a few yards from a bird feeder and spends all day fighting it's own reflection in the glass. My interpretation, which could be wrong, is that it believes it is a very successful bird that has found an excellent nesting spot and finds meaning in its life by fighting off "competition" for its nest -- certainly it does not need to spend a lot of energy foraging and has the time and energy to peck at the window all day.

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by platz on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @11:41AM (#43413489)
How do you know the bird just isn't entertaining itself with its own reflection.
Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by PaulHoule on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @11:50AM (#43413589)
I don't, but your story could be accused of being anthropomorphic as much as my own. If it did have to work harder to forage though, it would have less time and energy to entertain itself.

A case where I know my own psychology has to do with it is the red winged blackbird which is a highly territorial bird which is always calling attention to nests that I'd otherwise ignore by buzz-bombing me and that I see high up in the air flapping frantically to nip at the tail feathers and harass huge hawks that are flapping languidly riding thermals. I see these birds sitting on top of "POSTED: NO TRESPASSING" signs all the time because these are convenient perches, although they have no idea that the sign fits their mindset really well. One of my photography goals in the next few weeks is to get some of those pictures though I don't have a particularly long lens so I'll have the problem that they'll probably try to buzz bomb me instead of sitting still to get their picture taken.

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by 3np on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @05:26PM (#43417486)
The same way you don't know if other humans are even conscious. Empathy.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Problem_of_other_minds

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by MisterTea on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @03:44PM (#43416487)
> As someone who's had quite a few dealings with animals (the family business is a horse farm) my interpretation is that human psychology is basically animal psychology with a "language instinct" bolted on as a peripheral.

Growing up with cats and dogs all my life I 100% agree with this. That has caused me to look at animals as individuals I can't communicate with instead of lower life forms that are brainless sacks of meat. They certainty are capable of thought and I am also convinced they share the same basic emotional states but humans have much more nuance and layers over them.

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by bumby on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @08:53PM (#43418884)
Where do you draw the line? Do you think dung beetles have emotions? Not being snarky, I just think it’s a difficult idea to pin down.
Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by preciousoo on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @09:29PM (#43419099)
I mean, the whole predator/prey paradigm proves this, no? Both sides will act sneaky and use crafty mechanisms to get ahead of each other
Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by bumby on Thursday March 20, 2025 @11:00AM (#43424361)
I don’t think that fully encapsulates the issue. I can recognize some other being has subjective experience irrespective of any predator/prey relationship.
Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by MisterTea on Thursday March 20, 2025 @09:13AM (#43422777)
Why do you need a line?
Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by bumby on Thursday March 20, 2025 @10:24AM (#43423959)
Because we generally acknowledge a need to discriminate how we relate and interact with others. I treat a child differently than an adult, a dog differently than a human, and a plant differently from an animal. Humans as classification machines; I’m not sure we could interact in this world without it.
Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by Swizec on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @06:17PM (#43417834)
> I believe all birds and mammals have a pretty good "theory of mind", it's just hard to do an experiment to prove it

Our pet bird (sun conure) actively tries to lie and mislead when he's doing something naughty. Like he will go into the pantry to steal treats and quickly fly out pretending he wasn't in there when he hears you approaching.

This indicates he has some theory of mind. He has to understand there's a difference between what he knows and what we know, otherwise he wouldn't try to hide or obscure his actions.

And yes there is research showing/arguing that birds have theory of mind --> https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/144146926.pdf

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by mangomountain on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @08:15PM (#43418667)
Sun conjures are so smart this makes me smile :)
Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by Swizec on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @10:33PM (#43419411)
It gets better! He has learned that when he is naughty we will tell him to stop. If he doesn’t, we will eventually get up to come over and make him stop (shoo him away).

So now he uses that when he needs us to open a door. Threatening to be naughty is the most effective way to get human to come over. Then you fly to the door and human gets the message and opens door. Or treat box or whatever you want help with.

Little shits

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by roarcher on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @09:12PM (#43418998)
I used to have a cat like this. He loved to drink out of the toilet bowl, which he knew he wasn't supposed to do. I would hear him lapping up the water and as I approached the bathroom he would quickly exit, almost but not quite running so as to not look too guilty, head held low and giving me a side eye like he was trying to see if I knew what he was doing in there.
Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by paulgerhardt on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @11:23AM (#43413232)
“Faction” and “fashion” are etymological doublets. We wear trends as much to establish which tribe we are apart of as to impress potential mates.

The trend of Orcas wearing hats feels very much the same: https://archive.is/2024.12.15-213212/https://www.nationalgeo...

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by cjbgkagh on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @11:17AM (#43413140)
Since it’s a trend it comes and goes, and the behavior spreads in a manner similar to fashion trends.

Google pics for it, can you think of any other reason for an orca to wear a salmon on their head.

Song birds also have similar fashions in what they choose to sing and that spreads much faster than evolution can explain.

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by bumby on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @12:24PM (#43414101)
I think it’s latent status signaling. Humans are hierarchical primates and we search for status in our social groups. To that end, it’s not much different than other social creatures that seek social status in their tribe/pride/pack/pod.
Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by dkarl on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @12:25PM (#43414117)
Being "seen and validated" translates to "feeling superior" when people want to be seen and validated on a scale that very few other people are, and I think many people naively want this.
Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by TeMPOraL on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @04:31PM (#43416969)
Few would like to feel inferior in every dimension to other people in their group - because that effectively means they're useless to the group, beyond being a warm body to throw at problems requiring numbers; it means they're replaceable and will be replaced by someone better.

It feels to me that the ideas of social status, "feeling seen", finding connection, even finding meaning, all intersect in wanting to be unique along some dimension that at least part of your group values.

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by Lerc on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @04:48PM (#43417178)
>The older I get, the more I'm convinced that people do this less to actually feel superior to others and more as a desperate act of establishing an identity, ANY identity, to simply feel seen and validated in spite of just being yet another person on the planet.

I think this is broadly correct. I have had a sense for a while now that there are quite a few people express extreme versions of their opinions substituting amplitude for fidelity. A strongly held opinion isn't heard as much as a weakly held opinion forcefully expressed.

Part of this is down to mass communication and it occurs for all things. There are good apps for mobile phones that never get seen because the focus goes to the top few percent. The same is probably true for games on Steam. Most peoples' blogs will be read by fewer people than the number of blogs they read themselves for the simple reason that some blogs get millions of readers.

I can see the obvious frustration that must be felt when someone has an idea to share that they feel isn't being expressed. When it comes to emotional expression, small communities are required if you want to have a group that reciprocates attention. Most people don't want to be heard by everyone, they just want to be heard. What we have is an environment where a few people are heard by everyone and lots of people are unheard.

I think sites like HN, and the smaller subreddit communities along with discords (I miss IRC, It's still there, but the people aren't) work against that flow.

There's an element of social 'groupthink' pressure if communities of similar opinions cluster, more often against ideas than for, but I think that on these platforms it also meets a degree of resistance that helps balance things.

HN has Rust/AI/Bitcoin where there are always a few people who will express distain for the subject. Each of these seem weird if you actually consider the criticisms as being in good faith.

Why should people be annoyed about liking another programming language, or want to write things in it, or talk about it?

Why are there people who are certain AI is doomed to failure that are so concerned about the money of investors? Especially when many of the people who express such distain for AI generally do not look terribly kindly towards investors anyway. It's like they don't like rich people while simultaneously concerned that the rich might lose all their money.

Why are those who decry Bitcoin as a Ponzi scheme so angry about the fact that other people, who they disagree with and denigrate, are doomed to lose their money? Why are they so concerned for the finances for people they don't like?

I think the motivation behind all of them is they want their dissenting position to be heard. When these things are talked about people can see some degree of popularity for an opinion that they don't hold. It seems it isn't enough to think "I don't think that will work, but good luck to them."

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by bonoboTP on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @05:51PM (#43417675)
Most things people do, and the stories they weave around their lives are about finding ways that allow them to think of themselves as being a certain kind of person. More than money, more than others' opinions even.
Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by bsoles on Friday March 21, 2025 @10:08PM (#43442636)
I am getting old and I agree.
Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by nluken on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @09:52AM (#43412005)
I think you're generally right about the OP, but I don't see your alternative method as a tonic to the problem the author is discussing. I agree that treating reading as the only way to ingest information is probably wrong, and that the original post tends towards hierarchy in an almost reactionary way, yet at the same time I also see that many people tend to ingest information from other forms of media less critically than they might a book or written piece. I think this dichotomy derives from the different levels of focus we apply to different activities. Reading, even for leisure, demands a level of effort that forces you to focus and, in a way, analyze the information you're ingesting. By removing that barrier, you might fail to fully grasp the ideas that the primary source expressed.

In your use case, the LLM can be a great tool to get a start, but it's much easier to accept that output uncritically, which is especially problematic because it bears the biases of the training corpus. Sure, you can mitigate that issue if you're driven by the intellectual curiosity to dig deeper, which it seems you are, but at that point aren't you doing the kind of leisure research that the original post is talking about anyway? You're just using the initial steps to discover the "foundational texts", as the original post puts it, of the field. The LLM step becomes less material to the follow-up reading you've done after the fact.

Many, perhaps even most people will not make it to the second step. I see the lack of intellectual curiosity as a problem of focus more than anything else, and in my experience the overly rich media landscape of the internet does not concentrate that focus in most people.

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by jll29 on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @10:53AM (#43412815)
> I agree that treating reading as the only way to ingest information is probably wrong

The good news is that not only does the "private researcher" (curious individual person without a research background or job) nowadays have the ability to read online in far-removed libraries, they are even empowered to download the data of many studies, fire up their Jupyter notebooks to replicate some work.

The danger is that some wannabes create even more noise on the proper science channels that are already polluted by fraudsters generating fake papers via ChatGPT and friends... making it harder for the untrained eye to distinguish between respectable science and pseudo-science.

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by randomNumber7 on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @02:35PM (#43415715)
It's already hard to sort out the bs that respectable science generates.
Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by etiam on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @07:24PM (#43418300)
Splitting hairs maybe, but more like it's already hard to suppress enough of the bs to get at the respectable science...
Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by KerrAvon on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @06:40PM (#43418006)
I think there'd be some value in asking each of the major chatLLMs whether vaccines cause autism. If the answer is not some unequivocal variation of "no, aside from fraudulent and discredited research," you have a serious problem if you're relying on AI to do research for you.
Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by awongh on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @10:10AM (#43412246)
Yea, it's the classic conflation of the format of the media with other factors- it's not the fact that you're reading from a screen instead of a paper page that's making you intellectually incurious.

But the disingenuous thing is that I don't think these arguments are really meant to examine why people might be less curious- it's just to sound cooler than people who read the OP and imagine the writer in some cafe pouring over a big stack of hardcover books.

>> aren't you doing the kind of leisure research that the original post is talking about anyway?

I would say the distinction is that I don't need to be precious about why I would look at foundational texts. Maybe foundational texts are a bit over-hyped- anything written 100 years ago was made for the context of that time, and even if the ideas are universal to a certain extent, it's better digested through a modern lens in light of how those ideas have affected everything since then. How much more do you get out of an idea reading it from the original? It feels like there's a bit of a diminishing return in a lot of cases.

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by mobilejdral on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @10:06AM (#43412194)
The author also asks "If you were stranded on an island (or small hostile planetoid), what books would you want to have with you?" which I also can't answer.

I would fall into the category of someone who does research as leisure. I have been slowly unraveling the genetics behind gender dysphoria. Yes I have borrowed a few biology books from libraries, but it has mostly been reading 70 years of research papers, piecing together all the evidence to make a hypothesis, comparing it to all the research data and iterating. In the last year I have also started getting a fair number of WGS (Whole Genome Sequenced) files, and I have a whole separate pile of anecdotal that just because it isn't published doesn't mean I can ignore it either. These are about as far from books as you can get. It is something I do for leisure, so my investigation has been somewhat random, following whatever I found interating at that time including dead ends. Been doing this very open ended research for years now and at this point we have a really solid understanding of it, so the edge cases are actually now the fun stuff. I never would have made anywhere near the progress I did if I had been forced to start with reading a bunch of random unrelated biology books.

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by wasabi991011 on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @01:42PM (#43415088)
Sounds interesting, do you have somewhere I can read some of what you've learned across your research?
Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by mobilejdral on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @03:15PM (#43416185)
Sure, add a way to contact you to your account and I can send you over the current understanding.
Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by weakfish on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @03:42PM (#43416469)
Also interested.
Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by _fat_santa on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @09:54AM (#43412031)
Personally I still go on Wikipedia deep dives where you end up going from link to link for hours. I think the author is entirely incorrect with that quote, the whole idea of leasure research is that there are no rules, some will go ask an LLM, others will go read 'foundational text' while others will just browse Wikipedia.
Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by mmooss on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @10:52AM (#43412789)
If that's what you like to do, of course that's fine. If we are going to talk with each other about what we like to do, we need to agree on meaning.

In my thinking, the definition of research is to find truth. As ultimate solutions to that goal, Wikipedia and LLM output lack sufficient accuracy and lack verifiability. Many find them useful as bibliographic tools that point us to accurate, verifiable sources.

Also, research requires looking at the actual evidence - the primary sources; that's where the truth is, that's the foundation of the scientific method. Secondary sources filter the truth through someone else's interpretation, but for amateur researchers that may be all that's realistic - traveling to archives, building or using complex equipment is not realistic. Still, Wikipedia and (almost all) LLMs are tertiary or higher order sources: they are a combination of secondary or higher order sources - Wikipedia doesn't allow citing primary sources as far as I know (which would be necessary for Wikipedia to be a secondary source); LLM input is mostly secondary or higher order sources.

I don't object if you call reading Wikipedia, 'research'. I don't at all object to you doing what you value. But we are talking about two different things.

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by jksflkjl3jk3 on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @11:12AM (#43413066)
> the primary sources; that's where the truth is

Why is a primary source a better source for the "truth"? Often secondary sources have distilled the original rough ideas into more refined expressions of the original complex ideas. A secondary source will also have had more chances to catch any mistakes.

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by mmooss on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @11:42AM (#43413503)
The secondary sources take the primary source facts (if the author is serious and honest) and add someone's subjective perspectives, etc. Those facts are the 'truths'.

For more, look up reading on the scientific method and empiricism.

I'm not disparaging all secondary sources; I read them too. But there's a reason serious research requires primary sources.

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by BeetleB on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @11:51AM (#43413617)
I think people are confused by the definitions of primary/secondary sources.

As an example, almost all textbooks are actually secondary sources. The primary source may be a journal article. And yes, often, those secondary sources are far superior than the primary sources. Insisting on reading all those journal articles as opposed to a good textbook is simply indulging in a fetish, IMO.

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by mmooss on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @12:04PM (#43413788)
> I think people are confused by the definitions of primary/secondary sources.

Sorry:

Primary - the actual evidence. The actual letter written by Jefferson; the ice core itself, etc. For example, if you are an historian writing about Jefferson, you actually travel to the archive and read Jefferson's letters and look through the other papers, etc. - the actual stuff.

Secondary - the journal article, the scholarly book, based on primary sources (without those, it's just nonsense)

Tertiary - textbooks, news reports, etc. about the secondary source

Higher order - blog posts, social media, etc.: usually they haven't seen the evidence, haven't read the journal article, may have read the news report but often only read another social media post ...

> Insisting on reading all those journal articles as opposed to a good textbook is simply indulging in a fetish, IMO.

WTF do you know about me or anyone else to judge their choices? Your ignorance of the need for direct knowledge of things shines through. Here, the primary source is me; having no primary source your assertion isn't even secondary, just nonsense. Enjoy 'research' on social media.

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by BeetleB on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @12:22PM (#43414062)
> WTF do you know about me or anyone else to judge their choices?

I don't, and did not claim to. And yes, one can and usually does judge at some level. I don't need to know much about someone to have an opinion that intentionally touching random strangers' private parts in public is problematic.

Try not to be so sensitive. My comment was not a criticism of anyone.

> Your ignorance of the need for direct knowledge of things shines through.

Now who is making assumptions without knowing me?

I spent years being paid to do research at academic institutions, so it's not a random person on the Internet saying it. Sometimes the primary source is fantastic. More often it's inferior to better written pieces.

The reason journals like Rev Modern Physics have a high impact factor is precisely due to the fact that distillations can be superior to primary sources. It's a journal where a highly influential person in the field writes a (lengthy) journal article that is basically a well written, accessible tutorial of the whole field.

Have you tried reading Maxwell's original works? Do you not think there's a good reason pretty much every EM textbook teaches Maxwell's equations in a very different form from what he proposed?

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by robwwilliams on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @12:54PM (#43414454)
Thanks for your explanations. It would be lovely if primary sources and data were some kind of ground truth with a capital T. But no: they are often messy first pass experiments. If we knew what we were doing it would not be research ;-) A dose of Ian Hacking or Paul Feyerabend or Nancy Cartwright could be curative.
Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by Karrot_Kream on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @02:16PM (#43415502)
Many, many times in historical research the "primary source" (I'm using your definition here because in historical circles the primary source is not always the original artifact or document) is lost to time. It's then up to historians, anthropologists, and other researchers to figure out whether the artifact in question actually existed and whether there's agreement among other sources on what it said.

In historical research at least having a primary source like the "actual letter written by Jefferson" is often rare and only found in more modern historical sources preserved by stable institutions. A great example is the Library of Baghdad where we know many texts existed but we still don't know the breadth of all the available texts nor their contents.

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by mmooss on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @03:18PM (#43416220)
Thanks and very interesting. Are you an historian?

> in historical circles the primary source is not always the original artifact or document

What does it mean in historical circles? I know people will often use a digital scan, a reliable transcription, etc., and not necessarily the original - but then isn't that based on the assumption that it's a reliable representation of the original?

I didn't mean to suggest primary sources (by my definition) are always available; I was just trying to give an example where 'primary source' connects the world of ideas to the physical reality. Yes, life, including historical research, isn't that neat and simple.

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by Karrot_Kream on Friday March 21, 2025 @07:57PM (#43441979)
I totally forgot to hit "Reply" to this. Apologies!

> Are you an historian?

I published some work in undergrad but stopped afterward (much to the chagrin of my professors.) I still keep up with historian circles, folks who either are academic historians or participate in the general community.

> I know people will often use a digital scan, a reliable transcription, etc., and not necessarily the original - but then isn't that based on the assumption that it's a reliable representation of the original?

Veracity of a source is a very, very complicated topic in historical research. Sometimes documents are authoritative. For example, the American Declaration of Independence is a well-preserved document that has been commented on millions of times at this point and has many, many copies. We can be very sure that the Declaration of Independence exists and says what it says. This isn't the case for a lot of historical documents.

Until use of the printing press became widespread in a culture, distributing copies of documents was laborious. Usually a scribe would have to read the original and copy it. Writing media from this time (paper, parchment, tablets, etc) were also usually expensive. Each document was usually considered an individual work of art and so even if a scribe was copying a document, we had no idea whether the scribe editorialized the work, forgot to copy some of the work, or otherwise modified its original intent. That means that while we may find a document with a title in our modern era, we don't know if that document was the authoritative original or even if the contemporary readers actually consumed the version of the document we have in our possession or a different edition.

Then there's the question of veracity of the claims of the document itself. A lot of surveys and statistics from historical writings are false. There are usually numerous cultural and political reasons for this (maybe the culture didn't count women as people, maybe the culture only counted landholders, maybe the author didn't see a certain tribe in the area as people to be counted, etc.) and so even when we're reasonably confident of when a document was authored and by whom it's hard to be certain of the veracity of its claims.

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by awongh on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @10:58AM (#43412893)
> In my thinking, the definition of research is to find truth

> the primary sources; that's where the truth is

I mentioned this elsewhere on the thread, but I also feel like the most influential primary sources are less important than secondary sources- if you read Marx, the social and political circumstances of his ideas are in the context of an industrial economy and just don't apply in the same way anymore.

You can draw your own conclusions directly from what's written, but what's the point of that? I feel like it's more useful to engage with those ideas keeping in mind all of the thought and history that's happened since- in that case you would wait a pretty long time to work backwards until you read the original.

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by mmooss on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @11:46AM (#43413539)
If you are researching economics, then Marx is a secondary (or higher order) source. The econmomic data used by Marx is primary.

If you are researching Marx the person or Marx's ideas, then [edit: Marx's writings would be primary sources, and then] what would you think of someone who only read others talking about Marx, but didn't read Marx's actual writings? It wouldn't make much sense for anything called 'research'.

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by awongh on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @12:15PM (#43413968)
> The econmomic data used by Marx is primary

Literally picking through tables of all economic data for the last century... shocked pikachu meme not sure what that would gain you....

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by mmooss on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @12:27PM (#43414136)
Well, that's how actual research is done - that's what people do. It defines research, it's how they write all those (research-based) books and journal articles. That's scholarship - science, social science, humanities, etc. That's why Darwin travelled all the way to the Galapagos Islands - he identified a place to do primary resesarch on the questions he was investigating.

Journalists also - they look at the actual evidence and turn it into something coherent and cohesive for others to understand; the location in the byline/dateline shows where they went - that is, that if they wrote about Odessa, the dateline should show if they actually went to Odessa and saw it for themself.

Back to research: If you mean it's impractical for many people, that's often true. Some topics require less expertise, expense, and time: for example, tracking local bird populations. But those real natural scientists, the amateur researchers who get published, that's what they are doing. Pretty amazing!

If you don't want to do it, that's fine; few do. If you want to read secondary sources on a topic - wonderful (but read good ones based on primary sources; only accept what is tied back to actual, hard-won facts - necessary are the footnotes, which connect the secondary claim to the primary fact). If you want to read tertiary sources, find quality ones. If you want to read social media, have fun but it's just entertainment - to the extent it's accurate, you can't know unless you already have expertise.

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by ants_everywhere on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @09:18PM (#43419036)
With Marx the literature is basically religious in nature so reading his successors without reading Marx would be like reading religious commentaries on the bible without reading the original bible stories. There could be reasons to do that (e.g. modern text is easier to read), but you'd be missing a lot.

There are other writers who were writing before or at the same time as Marx on similar topics who were clearer in their thinking and their work is often surprisingly relevant even today.

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by mmooss on Thursday March 20, 2025 @12:51PM (#43425662)
Anti-liberalism and Marxism may be popular and therefore people join in dismissing Marx, but afaik Marx was and to some extent is (the ideas are from a long time ago) taken seriously as a serious theorist.
Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by ants_everywhere on Thursday March 20, 2025 @01:13PM (#43425956)
> Anti-liberalism and Marxism may be popular

I'm not sure whether to parse this as (anti-liberalism) and (Marxism) or as (anti-liberalism) and (anti-Marxism). But in case you meant the latter, Marxism is explicitly anti-liberal in the sense that he rejected the philosophical position that was called liberalism. And this vehement rejection has persisted through his followers. It's also anti-liberal in most broader senses.

> afaik Marx was and to some extent is (the ideas are from a long time ago) taken seriously as a serious theorist.

He's not taken seriously in philosophy or economics. There are some serious scholars who give him credit for contributions to early social science, although I think those scholars generally give him credit for ideas that were published and debated well before him and which he didn't really improve or advance.

Primarily he's taken seriously as an influential person in history, like Jesus, Buddha, Stalin, or Hitler. He was essentially a peripheral polemicist at the time of his death. The Soviets basically deified him because they needed something like a state religion, and they're responsible for whatever reputation he has today. But remember the Soviets were very big on propaganda, not so big on accuracy, and a lot of what people think they know about Marx is seen through the filter of authoritarian propaganda. Similarly a lot of what we know about Jesus passed through the filter of the Roman Empire and their desire to use him as the basis of an imperial religion. We're in a better shape with Marx, though, because we have many his writings (minus a significant amount of his correspondence which he and others destroyed).

There are, of course, economists and philosophers who consider themselves Marxists and who take him seriously. Often they're appointed to departments outside the main econ or philosophy department. For example, it wouldn't be unusual for a Marxist philosophy to be appointed to a German department or a history department.

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by mmooss on Thursday March 20, 2025 @08:08PM (#43430510)
You know well that contemporary conservatives call contemporary liberals, 'Marxists' (without knowing what they are talking about).

> There are, of course, economists and philosophers who consider themselves Marxists and who take him seriously.

We agree.

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by MITSardine on Thursday March 20, 2025 @09:24AM (#43422969)
Maybe I'm confused about what you mean by primary and secondary sources, but I think you have to be a little more nuanced; otherwise, it sounds like you're advocating for reinventing the wheel ad vitam aeternam. As opposed to "standing on the shoulders of giants" and all that.

For instance, I would consider a literature review a secondary source. It can come to some conclusions as to the credibility of a hypothesis given all this presented evidence (primary sources). This can be very precious work, as it would save a person interested in higher-level topics a great deal of time, and most likely (if the review is any good) be done with more competence than the interested person has (amateur or not).

An amateur (or indeed a professional) is more likely to find pertinent information in existing "secondary sources" (which can also be plural) than by trying to comb through a comparatively enormous volume of primary work they are not equipped to interpret and synthesize (or even find). Not just in my lazy opinion, it's indeed the consensus in science that the most recent review/synthesis work is a good starting point to any background information collection.

And why not, as a starting point, have a tertiary source point you towards adequate synthetic work. When you type "my topic of interest review" on google scholar and pick the most cited moderately recent review of the topic, are you not in effect relying on a tertiary source?

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by mmooss on Thursday March 20, 2025 @12:47PM (#43425606)
I think those are essential things to do and valuable regardless of what else someone does. I do them myself all the time. I think the literature review is an amazing tool - really the best tool for learning, IME - and one that most people in the world (outside the research community) overlook.

Here we are talking about research in the science sense; those aren't research. You couldn't publish a literature review as 'research', for example, or get a Ph.D. for one - 'here's my dissertation topic - a lit review of ...'!.

There is lots of actual potential research for citizen scientists to do. And if they want to just learn from what's been discovered already, that's great - I certainly do that.

I think it's important that people understand that reading a textbook or secondary source isn't scientific research. Confusingly, now that I think of it, if you say 'I researched which EVs have the range we need', people assume you did not do actual research of driving them all. But that's a different meaning for the same word.

In your field, is 'research' used differently?

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by ozim on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @10:46AM (#43412700)
Agree, OP is points to Thoreau, Sagan, Galileo - most people on the planet earth are not like that and those guys were heavily privileged.

Doing personal fancy research was not available before as it is now. Even though one still has to be rather privileged to have time to dig through obscure details that don’t make him money.

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by BeetleB on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @11:54AM (#43413660)
> Agree, OP is points to Thoreau, Sagan, Galileo - most people on the planet earth are not like that and those guys were heavily privileged.

Sagan was heavily privileged? I mean, yes, he was born in the US and could afford to get a Bachelor's degree, but other than that, he was not particularly privileged.

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by mmooss on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @10:39AM (#43412619)
> can’t stand these elitist and unoriginal think pieces about how much better and cooler

Aren't you saying the same thing, putting them down? You could both be curious about each other.

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by awongh on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @10:53AM (#43412817)
I commented on the article so I suppose I'm engaging with the ideas.

To be clear, I also think it's a shame that people don't read as many books these days, I don't read a huge amount but I feel like I'm at the higher-end of my social circle in terms of reading volume.

Mostly, I don't like the trope that there's some kind of moral imperative to Read More Books and that Things Used to Be Better. Overall I'm philosophically disinclined to draw the conclusion that phones/attention/social media are bad and reading more will improve society. I also have TikTok but I don't think it makes me a worse person.

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by fastasucan on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @10:01AM (#43412144)
>> for the leisurely researcher, self-study must include the discipline’s foundational texts

Leisurely and "must include" sounds very contradicting.

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by deegles on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @11:05AM (#43412977)
Yes, because of course I have 20 extra hours per week to dedicate to focused research
Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by 42lux on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @11:02AM (#43412933)
It really reads like he would like to be a British country parson in the 19th century.
Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by somethingsome on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @11:56AM (#43413682)
I didn't read the post yet, but

>> for the leisurely researcher, self-study must include the discipline’s foundational texts

It completely depends on the depth at which you are researching for leisure. If you like to do it to learn some stuff, just using LLMS, wiki and books is perfectly fine!

If you're trying to make a breakthrough in human understanding, it is useful to understand very very well the foundations. It is not required, sometime, another background is enough to see clearly some research issue.

But as you're doing research for fun, if you want to push the boundaries, having very strong foundational knowledge is awesome and very empowering.

Take for example the LLMs, you have many levels of comprehension that you may aim for (just an example):

- simply using occasionally (existance awareness)

- experimenting with prompts engineering (exploratory research)

- studying the neural architectures (understanding better what's going on)

- understanding how the architectures are validated (if they are...)

- finding limiting cases (deeper exploratory research)

- thinking about in under the perspective of bayesian/classical statistics (research at the normal mathematical/engineering level)

- going deep into characterizing the architectures in terms of manifolds, or any other suitable structure that you believe is true (deep fundamental research)

- opening up new questions about what can be learned and why (leading to another research field)

The first 3 are available inside a LLM, on Wikipedia and in books. The rest you need to fetch some papers. The more you go down the path, the more obscure the papers gets.

Up to the end, the last point, where you land in survey papers for the other field, and then you can start again with new questions. The good thing is that most of the fundamental research can be readily applied to understand the new field! It's like a jump start.

But at the end of the day, depending on which depth you want to do your leisure research, the deeper you go, the more foundation papers become important, not just from their content, but also the powerful ideas that can be transferred in other research projects.

Maybe.. One thing that is missing from what I say is that it's not about the quantity, or even the quality of the material you read. But it depends on engaging in deep thinking about it! Someone can spend his life reading and not become smarter, maybe only more knowledgeable.

I my opinion, deep thinking is maybe the most fun and useful skill in leisure research, as in paid research.

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by citizenpaul on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @02:04PM (#43415373)
I've been finding that digital only sources have been declining in quality for probably 5 years now. I have actually greatly reduced my reliance on them due to the fact that anytime HTTP is involved you add a layer of potential marketing obscuring the goal. I've been finding especially lately that I would have been better just getting a book. In fact I've greatly increased by personal library after years of stagnation as the online source quality has decreased.

Books are dense on info (assuming its not a churned out book which are also a problem now with self publishing) the internet tends to be full of fluff and greatly increases the time that I spend sifting rather than just learning and researching. My best purchase in the last couple years is a 10.3" ebook reader. Technical subject books don't work well on smaller readers and it makes a huge difference in quality of my personal development/research/learning.

I do agree that right now LLM's can help you a lot when you are starting on especially on a subject you know little about. However this will absolutely be poisoned over time because marketing will always creep in until it dominates the HTTP source. There is simply too much money to be made jamming a product in someones face no matter how subtle over providing impartial information when it comes to HTTP. The subtle ads are the most insidious because they can often waste lots of your time without you realizing it. Sometimes for years if you don't realize you were evangelized rather than educated.

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by SamPatt on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @03:26PM (#43416304)
The majority of online content can decrease in quality while LLMs can increase in quality.

If the decrease in quality is noticeable to you, then it can be accounted for by future model makers. We already know that quantity isn't everything.

The average coming down only creates a stronger contrast for the high-quality work. As a writer, I'm excited about having LLMs available to help me. They're already indispensable.

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by citizenpaul on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @08:22PM (#43418712)
I'll give an example a while ago I wanted to learn a new'ish tech. I did some research LLM and search which led me to an online course. I figure eh $20 is probably worth it to hear from someone that has used it.

After a couple of chapters I realized the author had no idea what they were doing and were literally reading page for page word for word from the official documentation. Valueless Trash masquerading as information. We've only just started down this forever merry-go-round of AI slop regurgitating and obscuring the often free source material for nothing more than profit off other peoples work.

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by spudlyo on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @05:01PM (#43417285)
> However this will absolutely be poisoned over time because marketing will always creep in until it dominates the HTTP source.

I often remind myself that we are in the golden age of LLMs, like the pre-enshitification days when Google would nearly always return relevant and useful results, and I felt like with access to the Internet I could learn anything.

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by citizenpaul on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @08:19PM (#43418686)
This exactly mirrors my expectations.
Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by laptopdev on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @08:14PM (#43418660)
Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by jbverschoor on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @04:51PM (#43417197)
It’s all the same duplicated/ copied information. No fact checks, no references. It’s exhausting to read the same stuff over and over again

Long live LLMs

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by wisty on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @05:27PM (#43417495)
I don't think it's a silver bullet, but reading source material is often quite informative.

Did he say anything else was important? I'd have to read the source material.

Why did he say you should read the source material?

Did he consider counter-arguments?

Was his overall argument more nuanced?

How did he come to the conclusion that you should read source material?

Was this his main point, or a secondary point in a list of several different arguments?

Honestly, a lot of academia seems like social media. People take a one-line summary and argue over the merits, often without any real idea of the source material.

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by rottc0dd on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @06:11PM (#43417798)
But, media consumption habits to a certain degree, do dictate our thinking and how much and how long we can actually concentrate, no? I also agree that we need not do everything the same way we have done before and there are different ways to achieve the end.

>> I feel like this person has some kind of dark academia aesthetic fetish that they need to hold onto to feel superior to everyone else.

We all have our bias. We settle with and swear by a way we end up finding to work for us for right reasons.

I notice this a lot while doing math. I would normally start with books because they already have predefined structure and have all the topics a person would normally need. I buy 3 or 4 books for which solutions are available. I start with book and then I would listen to lectures. If I do not understand, I would read some other book on same topic. I would have one book which I can understand better than other. Then try to solve many problems from all the books and look up solutions.

Though this is so time consuming and demanding with a full time job, when I engage with learning, I try to engage in this manner. If somebody asks me, I would recommend this because for fairly technical topics because other ways have left me with vague understanding but not good enough mental model to make me relate to problems in terms of the abstractions from those topics. That does not mean this is the only way and each might have to find thier own path.

LLM has been godsend for me too here, particularly when I am trying to fill my gaps in understanding while reading technical books. And it is much more easier to listen or see, than to read. So, given our current landscape and how much time is spent with work, it is true that it is getting harder and harder to read and almost not feasible for many of us.

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by LennyHenrysNuts on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @09:06PM (#43418958)
If I have to use an LLM, then I don't want to learn it. I have no interest in having my "food" chewed for me.

I'll do it the way I always have - read, cogitate, experiment.

That's not to say I don't think others should use LLMs by the way, knock yourself out.

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by ants_everywhere on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @09:36PM (#43419135)
I use LLMs quite a bit (as you can see, for example, on my stream). I also consume a lot of podcasts, YouTube videos, Wikipedia articles, and books.

My personal take is LLMs and podcasts are not great for research. Wikipedia is generally outstanding for science and related topics, although it's clearly astroturfed on topics about companies and some political topics. Podcasts typically cover things very shallowly but can sometimes be useful if there's a topic well served by the interview-a-day format. YouTube has a lot of treasure but you need to be able to search and not get distracted by clickbait.

LLMs function exceptionally as next generation search engines. But their knowledge for research bottoms out very quickly unless you know a lot about the subject and are able to prompt it effectively.

For example, I asked ChatGPT o1 your question about suburbs and its answer was basically total nonsense. The third theory it mentions was white flight and the post WWII era, which can't possibly explain why suburbs exist internationally and have since ancient times. There's probably a better prompt where you define what a suburb is and why you're interested in it and otherwise give it some good parameters and it gives you some more relevant information.

BTW I more or less agree that foundational texts can be very important to read. Not always, of course, but often enough that if you read a lot you should consider it. Often I find they bring considerable clarity to a subject.

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by awongh on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @10:39PM (#43419436)
I thought I got a pretty good response- not o1: https://chatgpt.com/share/67db7ea5-f770-800e-bd6f-67945f5842...

Maybe you meant that it immediately went to USA specific, but you can always change your question to clarify.

Basically, if I'm unfamiliar with the topic this gives me a solid basis to ask begin to ask follow-up questions that use the terminology of the field, or start to find out what is regarded as important.

I actually find it quite easy to go deep into a topic in a way that would be impossible in wikipedia, simply because if the topic becomes too dense for me it's hard to navigate your way back out- the wiki article begins to read like gibberish. With an LLM you can simply ask it to rephrase or clarify something.

Re:The Lost Art of Research as Leisure by ants_everywhere on Thursday March 20, 2025 @01:20PM (#43426068)
Yeah I mean that it went USA specific and also time specific. If you know enough to ask clarification that's great. But the problem with research is I don't know what I don't know, so when it puts me in a very small part of the problem space it's hard for me to see how little knowledge I've gained.

In this example, I wouldn't personally consider any of these theories for why suburbs exist. They're all important reasons for the expansion of US suburbs during one time period. But that doesn't answer the question of why, for example, there aren't forces that pin everyone either to an urban or rural existence without suburbs. The answer to that question would involve rather different concepts than the answer it gave IMO.