News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Being Forced to Sell Chrome Is Not Good for the Web by xigency on Friday March 14, 2025 @10:07PM (#43369289)
Arguably, Google divesting Chrome would be great for the web. This piece seems to be looking at Google at large (and I think all of Alphabet would be better scope there).

Certainly this would be unpopular here but I would be all for aggressive trust-busting beyond what the DOJ has done historically, including vertical integrations.

Right now tech is a strange feudal state with hundreds of thousands of small teams anchored to a few hydra-like super-corporations on a consuming destructive rampage. Somehow, with the most advanced computer and technological systems to ever be known by man, we're looking to increase working hours and cut benefits, for "profits" that are not quite realized by the labor class or the end users.

Gonna be interesting to see what happens. I know Wall Street will place their bets for what they want to happen right along side what's obviously going to shake out once the market becomes 'rational.'

Re:Google Being Forced to Sell Chrome Is Not Good for the Web by Spooky23 on Friday March 14, 2025 @10:45PM (#43369472)
The administration doesn’t give a shit about the web, and DOJ is a fully political entity. They’ll extort Google for whatever concession they want, and Chrome will remain.
Re:Google Being Forced to Sell Chrome Is Not Good for the Web by g-b-r on Friday March 14, 2025 @11:12PM (#43369637)
They'll demand half of Google's rare earths deposits
Re:Google Being Forced to Sell Chrome Is Not Good for the Web by tempodox on Saturday March 15, 2025 @02:31AM (#43370479)
Or just the keys to total surveillance and suppression of web content they don't like.
Re:Google Being Forced to Sell Chrome Is Not Good for the Web by fragmede on Saturday March 15, 2025 @03:52AM (#43370831)
Why would they need to do that when they already have the formula down? How much have you been hearing about all the protests?
Re:Google Being Forced to Sell Chrome Is Not Good for the Web by bmacho on Saturday March 15, 2025 @04:21AM (#43370948)
Why wouldn't they?

Also they have the have the formula because they've already done it. And it works, why wouldn't they want to keep doing it, but more?

Re:Google Being Forced to Sell Chrome Is Not Good for the Web by acdha on Saturday March 15, 2025 @09:40AM (#43372474)
Things are going to get more heated as the voluntary economic downturn heats up. The current protests get some coverage but we’re starting to see even the loyalists realize that they won’t be spared, and that is likely to increase protests considerably.
Re:Google Being Forced to Sell Chrome Is Not Good for the Web by bilbo0s on Saturday March 15, 2025 @02:49AM (#43370551)
Well now to be fair, total surveillance and suppression of any content they don't like is worth a whole lot more than rare earth deposits to a government.
Re:Google Being Forced to Sell Chrome Is Not Good for the Web by whatwhaaaaat on Friday March 14, 2025 @11:00PM (#43369558)
Did you have this same take when the Biden administration was paying tech companies to remove posts critical of the covid shots? Because that was proved to be true while the point you made is theoretical as of now.
Re:Google Being Forced to Sell Chrome Is Not Good for the Web by Centigonal on Friday March 14, 2025 @11:08PM (#43369606)
Do you want to cite a source?
Re:Google Being Forced to Sell Chrome Is Not Good for the Web by whatwhaaaaat on Friday March 14, 2025 @11:36PM (#43369769)
Have you been living under a rock? Here is a source from one of the “news” outlets the federal government was paying for hundreds of 90,000 dollar subscriptions.

https://www.politico.com/news/2024/06/26/biden-admin-cant-be...

Here’s one you likely won’t believe but that doesn’t mean it’s not true

https://nypost.com/2024/11/22/us-news/feds-blew-267m-on-misi...

How about one from Reuters

https://www.reuters.com/technology/zuckerberg-says-biden-adm...

Re:Google Being Forced to Sell Chrome Is Not Good for the Web by stopping on Friday March 14, 2025 @11:54PM (#43369843)
I honestly don't see what the issue is. "Pressuring" in this case just means "asking". Nobody was punished for not fulfilling these requests.

And funding research grants into studying misinformation doesn't really bother me either. Maybe there are better ways to spend the money but you could argue that about almost anything.

Also, none of what you linked points to the Biden administration paying tech companies to remove content.

Re:Google Being Forced to Sell Chrome Is Not Good for the Web by whatwhaaaaat on Saturday March 15, 2025 @12:24AM (#43369965)
The issue is that what constitutes misinformation isn’t always false. It simply goes against whatever the current administration wants.

For instance remember when the lab leak theory was misinformation? Even though we had Peter dazic at the nipah conference in November bragging about what they were doing. Even when Peter had been shopping around to various defense agencies to sell his bio weapon. Even after Ralph baric was caught doing this research at chapel hill after Obama supposedly stopped it so he went to wuhan. The federal government knew all of this but pushed and paid for the removal of this “misinformation” for years.

It’s no question if trump was pressuring and paying for social media to remove content he would be called all sorts of names.

2nd link gives some figures that were supposedly paid.

Re:Google Being Forced to Sell Chrome Is Not Good for the Web by oneshtein on Saturday March 15, 2025 @04:06AM (#43370890)
There is still no evidence that SARS CoV 2 was leaked from Chinese BSL4 lab in Wuhan because evidence links virus to Russian BSL4 lab «Vector». For example, first report for atypical pneumonia with rate of 100 cases per day (700 per week) was on Oct 16 in Russia as reported by newspaper «Аргументы и факты на Енисее» №42. Many Russians medics had immunity to Covid19 already when epidemic started, as shown by their antibodies.
Re:Google Being Forced to Sell Chrome Is Not Good for the Web by stopping on Saturday March 15, 2025 @12:40AM (#43370035)
2nd link contains no such information. Nowhere in the article does it say tech companies were paid to censor anything.
Re:Google Being Forced to Sell Chrome Is Not Good for the Web by whatwhaaaaat on Saturday March 15, 2025 @01:45AM (#43370286)
You are right my apologies. It only says we paid a quarter of a billion dollars to “study” which in this case meant paying for “non profits” to comb through a bunch of nobodies posts online in addition to paying for government employees to be on site at twitter specifically.

So you’re right it doesn’t say the directly cut a check. Only paid for people to find it. Paid for the people to communicate the offending posts to the social media companies.

In addition to all this the Biden admin “coerced and pressured”.

I won’t accept this if trump does it and I won’t accept Biden having done it. I cannot fathom how anyone would, given how quickly the winds have changed in America. It should be painfully obvious that the tools “your side” uses will be used by your political enemies.

Re:Google Being Forced to Sell Chrome Is Not Good for the Web by Spooky23 on Friday March 14, 2025 @11:07PM (#43369597)
The constitution establishes that a core role of government is to provide for the general welfare of the people, and public health is part of that. I’m generally in favor with government efforts to combat misinformation.

I’m also fine with wartime propaganda within limits for similar reasons.

Re:Google Being Forced to Sell Chrome Is Not Good for the Web by LexGray on Friday March 14, 2025 @11:50PM (#43369829)
I am not fine with war time propaganda. I want to know what the government is choosing to do and why.

I am not against war and even the occasional puff piece about how sexy the latest military tech is sexy is fine. It still is necessary in this day and age to stomp those that strip others of human rights and lives, yet I cannot think of any military action since Vietnam I have felt comfortable that I have not been outright lied to about underlying causes, methods used, and the after affects.

My full adult life it has seemed the government is convinced it is the Illuminati with a mandate to gaslight the public. That bad decisions don’t matter and no one is responsible seems like a horrible status quo when lives, the environment, and our tax dollars are at stake.

9/11 turned wartime propaganda into an excuse to strip freedoms that certain parties have been lusting after and no promises were kept about timelines for them being returned. When trust is abused to that extent the government should lose any rights to do so again.

Re:Google Being Forced to Sell Chrome Is Not Good for the Web by CaffeineLD50 on Friday March 14, 2025 @11:52PM (#43369836)
Given the dreadful state of public health this is a total fail. Epidemic obesity alone is a nightmare: heart disease, cancer, stroke, you name it.

Trump, to his credit, is taking fentanyl seriously but heart disease is a bigger killer.

Re:Google Being Forced to Sell Chrome Is Not Good for the Web by bilbo0s on Saturday March 15, 2025 @02:57AM (#43370587)
but heart disease is a bigger killer

Can't blame Mexico and China for heart disease. So it's of little political value. A government will take on public health challenges whose root causes can be used to confer political value. Other public health challenges may be more serious, but they are worthless to a politician.

That's actually why politicians shouldn't be in charge of those sorts of things.

Re:Google Being Forced to Sell Chrome Is Not Good for the Web by whatwhaaaaat on Friday March 14, 2025 @11:36PM (#43369771)
Aaaand that is why trump won.
Re:Google Being Forced to Sell Chrome Is Not Good for the Web by simianparrot on Saturday March 15, 2025 @02:51AM (#43370559)
And after 9/11, wartime is all the time. Still enjoying the constant propaganda?
Re:Google Being Forced to Sell Chrome Is Not Good for the Web by victorbjorklund on Saturday March 15, 2025 @06:43AM (#43371592)
You are probably right.
Re:Google Being Forced to Sell Chrome Is Not Good for the Web by dehrmann on Saturday March 15, 2025 @01:36PM (#43373969)
Biden or Trump administration? This remedy was originally proposed under Biden's DOJ.
Re:Google Being Forced to Sell Chrome Is Not Good for the Web by Spooky23 on Saturday March 15, 2025 @01:44PM (#43374023)
It’s still around and the admin continued it.

Biden’s DOJ was slooooooowly pursuing anti-trust more seriously. That’s not a Trump priority. So what’s the reason?

Re:Google Being Forced to Sell Chrome Is Not Good for the Web by libertine on Saturday March 15, 2025 @02:33PM (#43374343)
Google would just need to buy many Trump coins on the next drop. If he ever got Russian money, that was a great opportunity for it.
Re:Google Being Forced to Sell Chrome Is Not Good for the Web by pessimizer on Friday March 14, 2025 @11:11PM (#43369628)
> aggressive trust-busting beyond what the DOJ has done historically, including vertical integrations.

Vertical integration was a huge part of what they went after historically, until a bunch of people "convinced" the US that the standard should be "consumer harm." The cool thing about consumer harm is that you can come up with any bullshit argument about how prices will go down and access and quality up in the future from some merger, and nobody can disprove it because it's a counterfactual (he said, she said.) And when prices go up, it's just <shrug>, who could have known?

I know what vertical integration is today, though. It's not a hypothetical, it's a selling point to investors. I can just tell you no. Any clear metrics or standards for antitrust action can't be tolerated. The goal is to force us to go on vibes. Then they say we have bad vibes.

Competition brings down prices. Laissez-faire leads to pseudo-Communism with royal families, courtiers, and technicians making up the top 10%, and everybody else gets to be a (debt) slave i.e. feudalism.

We should err towards breaking more things up than would be ideal, not less. If I make you divest from something, you sell it and get whatever future value out of it today. It's not a punishment according to SCOTUS when they're looking at TikTok (which is why they said the TikTok ban wasn't a bill of attainder.) We charter these companies, and they operate for our benefit, which is why we grant them limited liability and a whole bunch of other treats. What you divest is going to go to somebody just like you, but someone who is not financially entangled with you. The only reason you want to keep it all is to do things that I don't want you to do with it, I don't want you doing unproductive market manipulation, I want you to put that energy into competing.

Re:Google Being Forced to Sell Chrome Is Not Good for the Web by crabmusket on Saturday March 15, 2025 @06:48AM (#43371623)
> The only reason you want to keep it all is to do things that I don't want you to do with it

Surely, the reason you want to keep it is because owning and controlling thing A and thing B allows you to make more profit personally than being a controlling owner of thing A or thing B.

That said, I agree with your post and also think nations should err more on the side of breaking things up.

Concentrations of power distort markets and resist democratic control.

Re:Google Being Forced to Sell Chrome Is Not Good for the Web by gtsop on Saturday March 15, 2025 @04:38AM (#43371018)
> Somehow, with the most advanced computer and technological systems to ever be known by man, we're looking to increase working hours and cut benefits, for "profits" that are not quite realized by the labor class

Somehow?? This is capitalism 101. Not a "strange feudal state" nor anything else.

Re:Google Being Forced to Sell Chrome Is Not Good for the Web by boxed on Saturday March 15, 2025 @06:50AM (#43371629)
> Arguably, Google divesting Chrome would be great for the web.

Because then Chrome would slowly rot since there's no one to fund development, leading us to WebKit being the only engine, as Firefox is also defunded. I don't see how that's better.

Re:Google Being Forced to Sell Chrome Is Not Good for the Web by pmontra on Saturday March 15, 2025 @07:27AM (#43371821)
The new owner of Chrome can sell it to the manufacturers of Android devices. Royalties.

They can even make it closed source or enforce a not for commerce license. That would make manufacturers choose between paying those royalties, installing Firefox, investing in their own browser (a fork of Chrome or their very own tech.) Some of them will pay royalties.

Re:Google Being Forced to Sell Chrome Is Not Good for the Web by quinnirill on Saturday March 15, 2025 @07:05AM (#43371707)
That’s assuming the divested Chrome would then proceed to lose its gigantic market share and thus the mind-boggling proceeds from defaulting to Google as the search engine. They might even be able to afford a bigger development team, if need be.
Re:Google Being Forced to Sell Chrome Is Not Good for the Web by burnerthrow008 on Saturday March 15, 2025 @07:32AM (#43371836)
But what makes you think the DoJ allow Google to continue paying Chrome to have Google as default? Google is already not allowed to pay Apple to be default.
Re:Google Being Forced to Sell Chrome Is Not Good for the Web by wffurr on Saturday March 15, 2025 @07:47AM (#43371902)
>> Google is already not allowed to pay Apple to be default

The antitrust remedy isn’t set until the September hearings and won’t take effect until after years of appeals hearings.

Re:Google Being Forced to Sell Chrome Is Not Good for the Web by rishav_sharan on Saturday March 15, 2025 @11:24AM (#43373112)
Why do you think so? Google can continue to contribute to chromium as they are doing now, alongwith other contributors like Microsoft
Re:Google Being Forced to Sell Chrome Is Not Good for the Web by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Saturday March 15, 2025 @01:38PM (#43373978)
Why do browsers need to be free?
Re:Google Being Forced to Sell Chrome Is Not Good for the Web by nerdix on Saturday March 15, 2025 @06:46PM (#43375644)
As long as OS vendors are allowed to bundle browsers with their OS then any paid browsers is at a huge disadvantage. Most people are going to pay for a browser when their OS comes with a free one that is good enough. Thats how Microsoft killed Netscape Navigator.
Re:Google Being Forced to Sell Chrome Is Not Good for the Web by thfuran on Saturday March 15, 2025 @10:45PM (#43376616)
I think google should be forced to divest AdSense.