My interpretation is that federal agencies will stop providing non-English services, unless these are already happening at 0 cost. (For example, not instructing agents to speak only English, but no longer considering second language proficiency in future hiring.)
IANAL, but there may be legal complications, as order 13166's stated goal is to prevent title VI discrimination on the basis of national origin. However, the revocation explicitly states it should implemented consistently with applicable laws.
[1] https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/03/desi...
[2] https://www.transportation.gov/civil-rights/civil-rights-awa...
I've always wondered what this actually means in practicality. The NYC MTA is still going to print the instructions for riding the train in 7 different languages. Is Taco Bell in Tulsa not allowed to print the menu in English and Spanish anymore?
Like, what is the point of this. I'm willing to accept that it's just a feel-good for the President's base. Like Gulf of America.
It doesn't affect Taco Bell because that's a private corporation. And it doesn't affect transportation because that's also intended for travelers, visitors, etc. Nor would it affect health care.
But a good example would be driver's license exams. California offers those in 32 languages. Almost all states offer them in at least 2. If English is made the official language by legislation, there would be a strong argument to only offer driver's license exams in English.
It means the Federal government now has a reason to not offer services in any language other than English. Before, they would offer services in Spanish, Chinese(various dialects) and other popular languages. They no longer have funding or a mandate to do that.
As far as what that means for the government, it's hard to say because of the way government is structured here. Let's put executive orders aside and say that Congress passes a law declaring that English is the official language, and that all government communication shall happen in English and nothing else. Certainly that would apply to the federal government. It shouldn't apply to the states, because the Constitution doesn't grant that power to the federal government - but we've been blatantly ignoring the Constitution in that respect for almost a century now, so it wouldn't be surprising if we ignore it in this case too. It would almost certainly go to the Supreme Court, but it's hard to say whether they would strike the law down or decide to torture the Commerce Clause even more.
If they strike the law down or clarify that it only can apply to the federal government, then you'd probably see some states pass their own similar laws (or amend their constitutions) to achieve a similar effect. But other states would still use whatever language. If they say yes, the law can affect states as well, then obviously it would. But either way I think you wind up at a point where private parties use whatever language they feel like, while government communications are in English only (at least to some extent).
That's not true. For example, there was a story the other day of a librarian who was instructed to throw away all passport application forms in Spanish, as they would no longer be accepted.
If you go to the official Spanish page, you can see that the links to the forms are either broken or now redirected to their English version:
https://travel.state.gov/content/travel/es/pasaportes/requis...
That's just one example of many.
Hundred of technocrats and modern nobility cannot be wrong.
As to the stated wording though, "making English the country's official language" (which mirror's wording used in the most recent presidential address), the executive order has no power to do so, because it's not a law.
You’re not understanding the comment you are laughing at.
There was no legal change, there was an operations change in how the federal government does things.
It’s still legal to speak whatever language you want and you don’t need to speak English
It's all about twisting laws to disserve whatever collective they go after, so their voters (voters believing they are antagonists of the other collective) keep satisfied and vote again.
Meanwhile they give contracts and move money and services towards their friends, the ones that financed their campaign so they can bring the message about the evil collective to the voters.
One of the oldest tricks in the world.
The USA was built on immigration. It's called "the great melting pot" for a reason.
So at some point, you’re going to have to make accomodations for everyone, at least in the most popular languages because if you want new talent, you might be dealing with a family that has to bring their aging parents along if they want to migrate, or someone’s spouse.
Even amongst the older people of the family it didnt seem like a big deal.
> Japan is famously anti-immigrant though.
These misinformation needs to end. I'm tired of it. More than 20 years ago, this was true, but today it is certainly not. There are all varieties of non-Japanese working in convenience stores, factories, farms, and hotels all over Japan. Plus there are more non-Japanese attending uni than ever before. Many will stay for work. Plus, getting a skilled work visa in Japan has never been easier. Sure, not as easy as Germany, Australia or Canada, but still light years ahead of 20+ years ago. They even have a special highly skilled visa now that allows people to get permanent residence in 1 or 3 years. Again: 20+ years ago this was impossible to imagine. Today, it is the reality.This happens regularly enough that the average city dwelling Japanese person has to confront these negative aspects on a daily basis.
This seems like the primary basis for the racism.
The secondary basis is just general racism you are familiar with. Women regularly wil take the stares to avoid getting on the elevator with me. I have seen them stop and turn 180° to the stairwell. My friend with a big beard gets lots of wacky suspicion. We are stopped at every single airport in asia for a bag search, japan, korea, and taiwan. Japanese people have told us he looks like a terrorist cultist... Hes literally just a regular fat mexican with a beard.
What would be the benefit or reason for this? I am also a multilingual person, and in many of the communities where I work, the Spanish speaking population is a significant majority such that to mandate English would be sisyphean. Sadly I can't get anyone to speak German with me, despite that being equally represented among Americans at the founding of our republic.
I know an American who spent several years in Paris, working in English, and never learned more French than was necessary to order her coffee. And this is despite French being the national language of France. (Interestingly enough, France is very multi-lingual as well, with many regions having their own history and language like Provençal, or Niçois, Breton, etc.).
It's more about a recognition of the status quo (as another commenter pointed out, most people acquiring US citizenship are required to demonstrate the most basic level of proficiency with the english language), and ensuring a baseline of support, no matter where you are in the country. Multi-lingualism is a plus, and in no way hindered by having a national language
First of all, I appreciate that you’ve made sure to draw this distinction between official languages of the central government and national languages.
However, English is still an official language roughly on par with Hindi as a result of indefinite extensions that were provided for in the constitution (as well as protests and uprising). For example, parliamentary legislation is authoritative in English but must also be translated into Hindi.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Languages_with_legal_status_in...
If people are not forced to speak the official language they never learn and eventually self-isolate within their own communities. This leads to the Balkanization of the country. Canada is currently dealing with this in relation to its Indian population, which is approximately equivalent to the Hispanic population in America in terms of percentage of the population and the occupations they work in.
Canada has two official languages and knowledge of one or the other is theoretically required to immigrate there, but almost all government offices and most private banks provide services in multiple languages (e.g. Mandarin, Punjabi, Tagalog, Hindi, etc.), so it's quite common for immigrants to never bother learning English or French. There's also lots of entry programs which don't require the applicant to speak either of the official languages, as well as a lot of fraud in those programs that do.
This has not had positive effects on Canada's social cohesion.
Another (somewhat ironic) example is in Mexico City, where some local residents are upset about the influx of predominantly American digital nomads and retirees changing the character of the city because they do not speak Spanish.
I suppose you harbor similarly negative feelings towards affirmative action and the civil rights act?
My point in essence is that I feel like this particular policy comes more from a desire to make life harder for those people who live non-normative linguistic lifestyles rather than to foster strength of community as was implied above. I'm all for community but I also believe in supporting diversity between communities as well as within communities. Hopefully that makes my feelings about the civil rights movement &c. clear to you.
A community is shared. You can't have a community if you can't communicate with your neighbor.
Do you think it is a) easier and cheaper or b) harder and more expensive, to deliver services in a vast range of languages or a single language?
The logic of how you get from there to road maintenance... my god, the mental gymnastics it must take.
If you moved to one of those countries, you’re saying you would demand official government programs be in English? That seems arrogant to me personally.
And to refuse to provide services in other languages and then also refuse to offer courses, as in, “you're on your own now, good luck!”, is a real dick move.
Why are you for this? What problem does this solve, and how?
Seems to me we have made it 250 years without an official language and that this has caused approximately 0 problems.
If you want to become a US citizen, you have to show you're competent in English. [1] It's been this case for quite awhile.
I know that doesn't strictly mean that "English is the official language", but it is an official government body requiring you to know English in order to become a US citizen, so that seems a little official to me.
you can learn them all in your native language, and it really doesn't take a lot (done it).
by contrast, you then still need English competency to answer the questions.
I guess it depends on what that means. I'm for all services being in English at a minimum, that makes sense. I'm really not for removing obligations to translate or interpret.
Non-english speaking US citizens exist and interact with the government. For example, someone that's deaf. Or for reading, someone that's blind. Having access in those cases is important.
But further, there's a humanity aspect as well. Any asylum seeker can get railroaded. Or heck, a visitor from another country. If these people are accused of crimes they should have the right to understand why the government is punishing them if for no other reason than to give their side of the story.
Treat others as they would like to be treated.
I have never expected a foreign government to provide English-language materials (especially non-tourism related materials) on any of my travels to other countries. Why should that be an expectation?
Why should that be an expectation? Because if you or I am being held against our will, wouldn't it be nice if you had an interpreter who could translate what the officer, lawyer, and judge are telling you? IE, if they tell you "you have to do this to not be locked up for 10 years" wouldn't it be nice to know how to comply with a ruling against you? Wouldn't it be nice if when they asked you questions you could actually answer them?
[1] https://eucrim.eu/articles/directive-201064eu-on-translation...
Innocent people are arrested all the time. You can't just "obey all the laws" and assume you won't have a run in.
Without the legal protection to get a translator, you are assuming after being arrested you can simply call a translation service. Yet, you should know that most countries and most cops will take your cell phone.
It's a humanitarian principle that before being prosecuted you should at a minimum know why you are being prosecuted.
> I certainly don’t expect them to be provided freely.
I never said they had to (though I think they should). What's more important is that you have access to translation services.
Even so, having translation support regardless of how far off the beaten path you are is something that should be consider a human right.
You're also focusing on the low hanging fruit (a tourist getting falsely accused). What about voting materials or passport applications?
I do not expect other countries to make citizen-specific materials available to me in my language. I am also totally against making US-citizen-specific materials available in non-english language.
E.g. I do not want someone who doesn't speak English voting in local elections.
Right, because that's the strongest position for why we should have, at a minimum, translation services for someone facing imprisonment.
Why instead of addressing this case are you pivoting to an argument I did not and am not making? You are straw manning me.
> What about voting materials or passport applications?
Nice to have, not a need to have. With perhaps the exception accommodations made for someone that's blind. But that can literally just be a poll worker that helps someone fill out a ballot. No need to print out braille ballots.
Unfortunately our government does not engage in nuance well, so if I have to sacrifice translation services for criminal defendants in order to secure against ballots, passports, and other citizen-specific materials in foreign languages I am willing to make that tradeoff.
It certainly does and it's certainly not hard to put in exclusive language. There's no slippery slope here. A simple bill of "Anyone being prosecuted has the right to access translation services" would do (and we already have provisions like that in the criminal code). It can be amended right into our criminal justice legal code.
You are now creating a false dichotomy.
What ever happened to being a melting pot. And taking on the poor, huddled masses? Growing up in Virginia, we were always taught our variety was one of biggest strengths, not a weakness.
A quick Google suggests that about 22% of Americans are multi-lingual, and roughly 8% of Americans do not have English as their dominant language (though I suspect that entirely non-English speaking Americans are at least one order of magnitude less).
I think only about 2% of countries in the world don't have an official language (America among them), and yet about 50% of the world is multi-lingual, so having an official language doesn't seem like an obstacle for other governments when it comes to support.
I suspect that the lack of of national language has more to do with the power struggle between the federal government and state governments then any issue, which is why I find this latest executive order quite baffling (for a party that is in the process of dismantling federal government, this is very much a federal power grab).
With all of that being said, I see it both as a recognition of the status quo, and a commitment to what is one of the greatest strengths of the United States (a single-language, single-currency market). Our largest economic rival (China) also has an enormous single-language, single-currency market, but that strength is largely focused inwards, since the use of a non-romanised language makes it very difficult for the non-Chinese reading population to adop sub-parts of the Chinese language.
- Can't speak English at all: 1.3% (~3.9 million people)
- Speak English "not well": 2.9% (~9 million people)In France, same thing. In Korea, also the same. Also China. And Mexico. Canada mandates French and English.
I see nothing wrong with a country having an official language. That doesn’t preclude people from speaking their own languages, but of you want to live in country Y, then learning that language should be a prerequisite.
Trump's supporters are OVERWHELMINGLY people who would not travel to a non-English-speaking country for pleasure, except perhaps to an all-inclusive resort where they would never "have to" interact with a local (non-tourist-industry) person.
So they don't really empathize with the challenges of a less-fluent speaker in any locale. And we see that lack of empathy in many of the responses here.
They are also blissfully (aggressively?) unaware of how much their day-to-day existence, e.g. much of their food and clothing and other possessions and overall lifestyle, depend on people who don't speak fluent English.
“There are no significant partisan differences when it comes to international travel: 26% of Democrats and Democratic-leaning independents qualify as globe-trotters, as do 28% of Republicans and GOP leaners.”
https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2023/12/06/americans...
Does it provide you a coping mechanism to create caricatures of these people and then pontificate about them? What is the point?
Also, you're dishonest. I never compared Republicans and Democrats w.r.t. world travel. Many people are empathetic without traveling. Although people who have traveled wouldn't normally advocate for "English only, let's make life impossible for other travelers!" Has orange-diaper not already blown up the tourism industry? I'm sure that's coming soon.
Finally, I don't need some white guy to explain "bigotry" to me - it is evident throughout this thread, in the daily papers, and pretty much everywhere. But you mysteriously don't see that.
If you'd please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the rules when posting here, we'd appreciate it. In particular, please don't post any more personal attacks and please don't perpetuate flamewars.
We had to ask you about this just recently: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42951778.
No more of this, please.
Nearly everyone is susceptible to spreading bigotry. Telling them to stop is not the same thing as “calling them a bigot”.
I hear you on the tone but I strongly believe people should be able to call out bigotry without retribution. I will continue to do so in a non-aggressive style. If you still want to ban the account then c'est la vie.
dang responded to one of his other comments in the thread.
No national religion. No national language. No centralized identity registry. Social security numbers that are more like timid suggestions than actual identifiers. Opening a bank account with just two pieces of foreign identity. Enrolling your kids in school by simply showing up and filling some forms.
I grew up in a country where I was assigned at birth with one state religion (out of two), a national language (out of three), and an ironclad digital identity number.
The American approach felt like a breath of fresh air. I — and millions of others — could choose to be someone else than what the computer says.
But the rise of Trumpism disillusioned me. Now I’m back in my home country and happily paying taxes to the state church while my children enjoy free education in four languages. What seemed like an identity straitjacket when I was younger now appears more like a spectrum of cozy options that I know how to navigate. Meanwhile America looks hell-bent on acquiring the straitjacket.
US currency says "in God we trust". The government's official communications are in English.
For a lot longer, it’s said “E Pluribus Unum” (“From Many, One”). The phrase has been associated with the USA since its inception. Diversity is a traditional American value.
In my opinion, this sort of thing greatly weakens us as a nation and will eventually destroy us if we can't figure out how to find common ground again. It should be possible - we've come back from worse (say what you will about modern day US politics, it hasn't come to civil war yet like it did in the past). But I think if we're going to find common ground, part of it will have to involve cultivating a shared national identity like we used to have.
We never had any of these, except for, possibly, just one shared belief: the idea that a constitutional democracy was the best sort of government to live under.
What we did have was a media/cultural environment that glossed over the differences between people, minimized various minority demographics, and worked hard to convince everyone that "we're all Americans and we all believe, do and want the same things". But that wasn't true then, any more than it is true today.
I want our shared national identity to be limited to our belief in our form of government. I don't want to have to know the same songs, go to the same church, drive the same car, watch the same shows as everyone else, and I don't think they should have to do that w.r.t my choices (nor are they likely to want to).
That was the beauty of "American identity", but even the belief in our form of government has been severely eroded. By whom or why ... I'll leave unremarked upon here.
America's proper and authentic identity always is its pluralism, entailing all the conflict that brings. If America made one unique contribution to the world its that it has shown how identities, plural, can be built from the bottom up and are in constant tension with each other, and that this is a feature, not a bug.
An American government trying to impose identity, by renaming lakes and mountains, mandating language(s) or what have you is so performative it looks more like North Korean state television than culture, it's utterly foreign to Americans and going to fail for that reason. Americans are instinctively allergic to having culture, regardless from what direction, declared on them by fiat.
I think it's important to remind people what executive orders can and can't do. An executive order is an instruction sent to the government itself. It instructs government workers how to perform their job. It is not directed at the American public (though it can and does have an effect on the American public by way of government policy).
As such, this current executive order effectively does nothing. We've attempted to pass laws that make English the national language, but have consistently failed to do so.
And personally, I'm for having English be the national language of America (as a bilingual American myself), but this executive order does not make that so.