News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads ed... by somethoughts on Wednesday February 26, 2025 @06:33PM (#43189530)
It'd be interesting if a paper could present opposing op-eds side by side by authors that are clearly the strongest on each side of the discussion. Similar to collegiate debates or the argument/rebuttal style used for the ballot propositions we vote on.

Often times - in today's media one side will present the other sides case by only addressing some strawman arguments.

Re:Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads ed... by snowwrestler on Wednesday February 26, 2025 @07:38PM (#43190041)
One news organization, at least, is brave enough to deliver this vision:

https://theonion.com/opinion/point-counterpoint/

Re:Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads ed... by ineedasername on Wednesday February 26, 2025 @09:07PM (#43190519)
Thanks for the link, great read, and there were fine points made on both sides.
Re:Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads ed... by paulryanrogers on Wednesday February 26, 2025 @08:17PM (#43190256)
Perhaps. It can also produce or reinforce a false balance.

We don't have too many op eds defending the flat earth theory anymore. Sadly I've seen too many friends fall down such rabbit holes.

Re:Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads ed... by mitthrowaway2 on Wednesday February 26, 2025 @08:53PM (#43190439)
I think that if you put the strongest arguments for and against the flat earth theory together on the same page and with equal space, the result would not be a false balance. In fact I can't think of any better way to change flat earther minds.
Re:Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads ed... by paulryanrogers on Wednesday February 26, 2025 @09:08PM (#43190531)
IME, once folks attach some brief or figure to their identity, they turn off the logical part of their mind. They'll look for any support as an escape hatch from uncomfortable facts or conclusions.

It also takes a lot of energy and ink to continuously refute perspectives based solely on indoctrination, vibes, and straight up lies.

Re:Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads ed... by paulryanrogers on Thursday February 27, 2025 @07:08AM (#43193603)
^belief
Re:Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads ed... by namuol on Wednesday February 26, 2025 @09:36PM (#43190729)
> In fact I can't think of any better way to change flat earther minds.

You have a ruinously optimistic outlook for the average human, let alone a flat-earther.

Re:Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads ed... by 6stringmerc on Wednesday February 26, 2025 @09:08PM (#43190526)
That’s why Pastafarianism exists - okay, let’s “teach the controversy” but make sure it’s all the controversies.
Re:Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads ed... by Denkel on Friday February 28, 2025 @06:44PM (#43213424)
"together on the same space and with equal space".

If you do that, you are telling anyone that just overviews the articles that both views have the same validity and that is just a manner of disagreements between peers, and that is falling into their trap, by doimg that you are actively working FOR the flatbearth cause, even if you want to feel "fair", ypu are just the useful idiot they need to keep spreading and legitimizing.

Flat earthers should no be given even a second unless it is to mock them, we have known that the earth is "round" for 2 millenia, we cannot keep discussing the same things over and over just because a bunch of narcisists want to feel like "the know better".

Re:Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads ed... by oo0shiny on Wednesday February 26, 2025 @07:55PM (#43190163)
This is the general idea of the Tangle newsletter [1]. They pick a topic from the news and provide "What the Right is saying" and "What the Left is saying" about the topic.

[1] https://www.readtangle.com/

Re:Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads ed... by heresie-dabord on Thursday February 27, 2025 @01:58AM (#43192007)
Right and Left are a false dichotomy of strawmen. But such is US politics.
Re:Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads ed... by NoGravitas on Thursday February 27, 2025 @10:56AM (#43195529)
And somehow the "left" opinion is always actually a DNC centrist, while the "right" opinion is a member of the John Birch Society.
Re:Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads ed... by dougb5 on Wednesday February 26, 2025 @07:00PM (#43189744)
USA Today has had something like this for a long while [1], though whether they find the strongest voices on each side is debatable.

[1] https://www.usatoday.com/story/opinion/2018/01/26/why-does-u...

Re:Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads ed... by somethoughts on Wednesday February 26, 2025 @07:27PM (#43189961)
Cool. Wasn't aware of that.

Another one is ground.news [1] which lets you compare multiple headline news articles from various sources together.

[1]https://ground.news/about

Re:Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads ed... by jfengel on Wednesday February 26, 2025 @06:52PM (#43189687)
Newspapers generally run opinion pieces from an array of viewpoints.

They give the writers full freedom, which makes it hard to get strict point counterpoint pieces like that. And many editors are averse to a simple "two sides" narrative.

Re:Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads ed... by EasyMark on Wednesday February 26, 2025 @09:10PM (#43190541)
it sounds like Bezos is opposed to any opposing opinions to "free markets" and those won't be found on the editorial page any longer except for occasional opinions
Re:Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads ed... by jfengel on Wednesday February 26, 2025 @09:31PM (#43190703)
Yep. I was referring to newspapers with some kind of journalistic integrity. Which the Washington Post used to be.
Re:Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads ed... by somenameforme on Thursday February 27, 2025 @12:55PM (#43196694)
I don't think this has been true, at least for most newspapers, for many years now. The NYTimes opinion pages are a complete echo chamber for instance, and if contrarian opinions are published, heads roll. For instance they "retired" their opinion head after he allowed the publication of an opinion piece from a Senator Tom Cotton suggesting that troops should be used to quell the violent/destructive riots in 2020.

Reading the opinion pages 30 years back everything was very different, but times have changed to where big name papers are mostly just the news shoehorned into a tidy bias confirming package. In many ways I respect what Bezos is doing because it entirely drops the farcical pretext of balance.

Re:Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads ed... by consteval on Thursday February 27, 2025 @03:37PM (#43198224)
I don't think this is true either, and the reason I say that is because it depends on who you ask.

Many will claim NYT has been overly generous in regards to Trump leading up to the election, often choosing not to comment on Trump's more suspicious speech and interpreting his words in a gracious context. While others claim NYT is has an obvious left-wing bias.

The fact people can't even agree which way the bias goes demonstrates to me the bias is not as severe as those aforementioned people claim.

Re:Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads ed... by somenameforme on Thursday February 27, 2025 @10:56PM (#43201541)
Right, and plenty of conservatives also claim that Fox News is not really conservative anymore. A fact one may not be aware of if they live in this bubble or that. The nature of echo chambers is that it normalizes far from normal behavior/views/actions to the point that then not going even further away from normalcy is seen as toeing the line or even yielding to "the other side."

This is, by far, the most destructive issue with the trend of media spinning everything to conform to the biases of their target demographic.

Re:Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads ed... by consteval on Friday February 28, 2025 @12:03AM (#43201884)
I completely agree, and I think this is most noticeable on online spaces like twitter. Relenting on a point even just a tad is perceived as being an agent of the "other side". So radical opinions, be it neo-nazism or white supremacy, end up shifting everything rightward. Because even though most people agree, usually that agreement needs to be qualified. And, you give an inch over and over and before you know it you're somewhere entirely different from where you've started.
Re:Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads ed... by Avicebron on Wednesday February 26, 2025 @06:45PM (#43189630)
I like the idea, I think they would need to be staggered though, Author A writes an article giving their best case supporting X, a week later Author B writes a rebuttal to author A (let's assume it's well thought out and civil because we can still dream) in a follow up article, this continues for as long as it's an interesting conversation. Probably a hard sell to the modern audience and attention span, but I would read it as long as they both were substantive and well-reasoned.
Re:Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads ed... by ncallaway on Wednesday February 26, 2025 @06:49PM (#43189662)
I think it's better to present simultaneously, but give the authors several rounds of drafting against each other, so they can update responses into their main body (similar to how supreme court opinions are authored and released).

You'd need a really strong editor to be in charge of the review/revision/back-and-forth process, so they could cut out shenanigans like an author withholding their strongest argument, only to include it in their final version.

I'd probably have a rule that no new arguments could be introduced into an article, other than as a direct response to anything _new_ that the opponent author included in their prior revision.

Re:Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads ed... by Avicebron on Wednesday February 26, 2025 @06:55PM (#43189707)
not sure I'm familiar with supreme court opinions, but are those drafts public?

edit because parent edited to talk about editor :): I think there needs to be transparency at the editorial level then, if the editor is making decisions they can write a reasoning behind each one and make it public.

Re:Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads ed... by ncallaway on Wednesday February 26, 2025 @07:39PM (#43190049)
> not sure I'm familiar with supreme court opinions, but are those drafts public?

No, they're infamously secretive. I think far too secretive, and that's a part that I don't think needs to be emulated.

While I do think there's value in having the drafting process "out of the public view" for an op ed, I'd agree in transparency after the fact. I could see just publishing all the revisions, editors notes, etc online alongside the actual final pieces.

Re:Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads ed... by Avicebron on Wednesday February 26, 2025 @07:54PM (#43190157)
for debate's sake, I'm genuinely curious, if there are "out of public view" drafting/editing how can it be hardened against building a meta-narrative by making sure the two opinion pieces aren't choreographed to make A or B look bad?
Re:Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads ed... by ncallaway on Wednesday February 26, 2025 @10:38PM (#43191078)
I think the only way it can truly be managed is by having the author of each side be a trusted and respected figure in their community. I think publishing the full drafts, editors notes, and revisions along with the piece would do a lot to make visible any deliberate efforts to frustrate one side.

I don't think the "out of public view" drafting makes a big difference around this. I actually think making the drafting and revision process public during the drafting would have more corrosive effects on the process. In that one side can push and set a narrative without the other side having opportunity to respond.

Anyway, I don't think any editorial system can be fully hardened against the editor leaving imprints of their viewpoints on the piece, but I think this approach would be significantly more transparent than the current state of play.

Re:Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads ed... by dghlsakjg on Wednesday February 26, 2025 @08:00PM (#43190181)
Pro/Con op-eds is one name this goes by, and used to be incredibly common.
Re:Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads ed... by weare138 on Wednesday February 26, 2025 @06:55PM (#43189712)
I'm from GenX and at one time that's what the opinion section in newspapers were like.
Re:Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads ed... by 63 on Wednesday February 26, 2025 @08:32PM (#43190337)
In fairness, at one point the extremes of the public's opinions were much closer. It''s easier to debate "should we raise taxes x% to accomplish y goals" than e.g. "should we invade Canada for quite literally no stated reason." Polarization is brutal to public discourse
Re:Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads ed... by andrepd on Wednesday February 26, 2025 @07:35PM (#43190017)
The major weekly paper in my country does this. It's always nice to read, even though I wish the articles were longer x)
Re:Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads ed... by archagon on Wednesday February 26, 2025 @08:50PM (#43190419)
Not every issue has two equal “sides.” Does every article about vaccine efficacy demand an anti-vax counter? And who gets to decide which “sides” are given a voice, anyway?
Re:Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads ed... by blackeyeblitzar on Wednesday February 26, 2025 @09:32PM (#43190707)
> Not every issue has two equal “sides.” Does every article about vaccine efficacy demand an anti-vax counter?

Any topic of current controversy, like vaccines, should have a counter. Even if you find it disagreeable.

Re:Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads ed... by archagon on Wednesday February 26, 2025 @09:48PM (#43190802)
Who defines “controversy,” then? If a topic has wide consensus but some think tank invests millions into propagating a contrary opinion, do they deserve 50% of the article?
Re:Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads ed... by typeofhuman on Wednesday February 26, 2025 @08:55PM (#43190450)
Re:Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads ed... by EasyMark on Wednesday February 26, 2025 @09:09PM (#43190536)
newsweek does it fairly often, although they aren't necessarily famous authors.
Re:Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads ed... by will4274 on Wednesday February 26, 2025 @09:12PM (#43190559)
RCP (www.realclearpolitics.com) does exactly this every day and has for almost two decades now. Unfortunately, RCP is currently majorly out of favor among liberals for... including in their polling average polls that showed Trump was going to win the 2024 election and linking to op-eds that agreed with Trump at the height of anti-Trump sentiment.
Re:Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads ed... by gregwebs on Wednesday February 26, 2025 @09:25PM (#43190664)
Breaking points is an independent media show on (YouTube and Spotify) that has both a liberal and conservative discuss current events.
Re:Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads ed... by hayst4ck on Wednesday February 26, 2025 @11:54PM (#43191481)
It's good to critically think about things, but "side-ism" seems like a completely intellectually bankrupt idea. Sideism is holding two things as equal and giving them equal exposure even though they are not equal.

The sides are largely between power and reason.

Reason is impotent, power is often cruel or manipulative.

If one side's beliefs are fundamentally related to what they think is the most "powerful" to express, and the other is open to being questioned and willing to change, then the system will be dominated by those with power.

What you have described is something that relies on good faith, but what happens when one side uses the pretense of good faith as a weapon to control the narrative. Even selecting the stories is a fundamentally "un-neutral" act, agreeing on the frame to discuss the issues is fundamentally a non-neutral act.

This idea of neutrality being "good" is an outcome of a two party system having to manage politicization in public school, so it holds both parties in equal standing without critically analyzing or making conclusions about party dogma. So "neutral" is a framing associated with goodness and well thought outness, but it isn't that.

Instead neutrality is implicit support for wrong ideas, reality denying ideas, or unpopular ideas.

One could say it's good to have an opinion piece titled "water is wet" next to one titled "water is dry," or more telling, "the earth is round" next to "the earth is flat."

By publishing both ideas, the platform is implicitly supporting flat earth-ism because it's giving it coverage far beyond how much it deserves to be covered.

Re:Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads ed... by jimmydddd on Thursday February 27, 2025 @08:50PM (#43200745)
Re: Strawman -- Lex Fridman often asks his podcast guests to steel man the opposing side's views. The guests who have well thought out opinions seem to do a really good job at this.