Re:Jeff Bezos' revamp of 'Washington Post' opinions leads ed...
by hayst4ck on Wednesday February 26, 2025 @11:54PM
(#43191481)
It's good to critically think about things, but "side-ism" seems like a completely intellectually bankrupt idea. Sideism is holding two things as equal and giving them equal exposure even though they are not equal.
The sides are largely between power and reason.
Reason is impotent, power is often cruel or manipulative.
If one side's beliefs are fundamentally related to what they think is the most "powerful" to express, and the other is open to being questioned and willing to change, then the system will be dominated by those with power.
What you have described is something that relies on good faith, but what happens when one side uses the pretense of good faith as a weapon to control the narrative. Even selecting the stories is a fundamentally "un-neutral" act, agreeing on the frame to discuss the issues is fundamentally a non-neutral act.
This idea of neutrality being "good" is an outcome of a two party system having to manage politicization in public school, so it holds both parties in equal standing without critically analyzing or making conclusions about party dogma. So "neutral" is a framing associated with goodness and well thought outness, but it isn't that.
Instead neutrality is implicit support for wrong ideas, reality denying ideas, or unpopular ideas.
One could say it's good to have an opinion piece titled "water is wet" next to one titled "water is dry," or more telling, "the earth is round" next to "the earth is flat."
By publishing both ideas, the platform is implicitly supporting flat earth-ism because it's giving it coverage far beyond how much it deserves to be covered.
The sides are largely between power and reason.
Reason is impotent, power is often cruel or manipulative.
If one side's beliefs are fundamentally related to what they think is the most "powerful" to express, and the other is open to being questioned and willing to change, then the system will be dominated by those with power.
What you have described is something that relies on good faith, but what happens when one side uses the pretense of good faith as a weapon to control the narrative. Even selecting the stories is a fundamentally "un-neutral" act, agreeing on the frame to discuss the issues is fundamentally a non-neutral act.
This idea of neutrality being "good" is an outcome of a two party system having to manage politicization in public school, so it holds both parties in equal standing without critically analyzing or making conclusions about party dogma. So "neutral" is a framing associated with goodness and well thought outness, but it isn't that.
Instead neutrality is implicit support for wrong ideas, reality denying ideas, or unpopular ideas.
One could say it's good to have an opinion piece titled "water is wet" next to one titled "water is dry," or more telling, "the earth is round" next to "the earth is flat."
By publishing both ideas, the platform is implicitly supporting flat earth-ism because it's giving it coverage far beyond how much it deserves to be covered.