You can expand that Lagrangian out to look more complex, but that's just a matter of notation rather than a real illustration of its complexity. There's no need to treat all of the quarks as different terms when you can compress them into a single matrix.
General relativity adds one more equation, in a matrix notation.
And that's almost everything. That's the whole model of the universe. It just so happens that there are a few domains where the two parts cause conflicts, but they occur only under insanely extreme circumstances (points within black holes, the universe at less than 10^-43 seconds, etc.)
These all rely on real numbers, so there's no computational complexity to talk about. Anything you represent in a computer is an approximation.
It's conceivable that there is some version out there that doesn't rely on real numbers, and could be computed with integers in a Turing machine. It need not have high computational complexity; there's no need for it to be anything other than linear. But it would be linear in an insane number of terms, and computationally intractable.
I hear it's a bit more complex than that!
https://www.sciencealert.com/this-is-what-the-standard-model...
the thing about Lagrangians is that they compose systems by adding terms together: L_AB = L_A + L_B if A and B don't interact. Each field acts like an independent system, plus some interaction terms if the fields interact. So most of the time, e.g. on Wikipedia[0], people write down the terms in little groups. But still, note on the Wikipedia page that there are not that many terms in the Lagrangian section, due to the internal summations.
[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mathematical_formulation_of_th...
It's not impossible that the universe is somehow implemented in an "umpteen gazillion bits, but not more" system, but it strikes me as a lot more likely that it really is just a real-number calculation.
Getting rid of the event horizon is simply a question of increasing the angular momentum and/or charge of this object until the inequality is reversed. When that happens the event horizon disappears and the exotic object beneath emerges.
There's a pretty decent argument real numbers are not enough:
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-04160-4/ https://physics.aps.org/articles/v15/7
The trick is (as the sibling comments explain) that it involves an exponential number of calculations, so it's extremely slow unless you are interested only in very small systems.
Going more technical, the problem with systems with the strong force is that they are too difficult to calculate, so the only method to get results is to add a fake lattice and try solving the system there. It works better than expected and it includes all the forces we know, well except gravity , and it includes the fake grid. So it's only an approximation.
> Could a competent software engineer, even without knowing the fundamental origins of things like particle masses or the fine-structure constant, capture all known fundamental interactions in code?
Nobody know where that numbers come from, so they are just like 20 or 30 numbers in the header of the file. There is some research to try to reduce the number, but I nobody knows if it's possible.
>There’s a whole way of thinking about the world using the idea of computation. And it’s very powerful, and fundamental. Maybe even more fundamental than physics can ever be.
>Yes, there is undecidability in mathematics, as we’ve known since Gödel’s theorem. But the mathematics that mathematicians usually work on is basically set up not to run into it. But just being “plucked from the computational universe”, my cellular automata don’t get to avoid it.
I definitely wouldn't call him a crackpot, but he does seem to be spinning in a philosophical rut.
I like his way of thinking (and I would, because I write code for a living), but I can't shake the feeling that his physics hypotheses are flawed and are destined to bear no fruit.
But I guess we'll see, won't we?
[1] http://bactra.org/reviews/wolfram/ [2] https://writings.stephenwolfram.com/2020/04/how-we-got-here-...
But I think his articles about Machine Learning are excellent. [2]
[1]https://www.google.com/search?client=firefox-b-1-d&q=%22comp...
[2]https://writings.stephenwolfram.com/category/artificial-inte...
Most people in the field don't think his research will be fruitful, but that doesn't make him a crack pot
He also did some important early work on cellular automata if iirc.
Then he wrote "A New Kind of Science", which reads like an ego trip and was not received well by the community (it is a massive tome that could have been summarized with a much smaller book). He also tried to claim discoveries from one of his workers due to some NDA shenanigans (or something along these lines iirc). The latter doesn't make him a crank, just a massive egotist, which is a trait nearly all cranks have. Sabine Hossenfelder did a video on him and how he only publishes in his own made up journals and generally doesn't use the process used by all other scientists. I think a lot believe where there is smoke, there is fire. To his credit, she also mentioned that some physicists gave him some critical feedback and he did then go and spend a bunch of time addressing the flaws they found.
Wolfram's claim is that Cellukar Automata can provide as good or better mathematical model of the universe than current current theories, by commonly appreciated metrics such as "pasimony of theory" (Occam's Razor). He's not making claims about metaphysical truth.
In particular you can tell, just from how his stuff is written, that he is at some level constitutionally incapable of incorporating other people's knowledge or ideas into his own thoughts. There are basically no references to other models, no time spent showing how ideas ladder up to known facts; no implication that that even ought to be done, that his statements ought to be demonstrated before the reader will take them seriously; almost all references are to his own work and his unproven and mostly unconcrete models; yet he refers to his own thing as though they are canonical fact; no attention is paid to making sure the ideas make sense to the reader or allow one to do useful conclusions ... it all reads like an unhinged manic episode (not in the clinical sense, maybe (I don't really know how that's defined), but in the colloquial sense).
Now, it seems to me that a manic episode can eventually find really good ideas. Maybe at some level that's what that mode of thought is for: finding things that are really, really out there in the landscape of thoughts. But in the meantime it is utterly offputting and reads as "insane" rather than "brilliant". I know enough math and physics to at least evaluate a good chunk of it and I can't distinguish it from random BS crackpots online except that the pictures are better.
Many of the quantum and general relativity behaviors seem to be some kind of limits (compared to a newtonian universe where you can go arbitrarily small/big/fast/far). Except quantum computing, that one's unlocking even more computation instead so is the opposite of a limit and making it harder rather than easier to simulate...
I don’t know why so many people feel like it would be an optimization?
Storing a position is a lot cheaper than storing an amplitude for each possible position.
One-hot vectors are much more compressible than general vectors, as you can just store the index.
Also, it is momentum and position that are conjugate, not momentum and speed.
I'd be interested to know where those so many other people who feel that would be an optimization are, because I don't often see opinions like this at all, only either rigorous physicists posting equations and papers, or people not knowing anything about it at all to even philosophize about it.
(1) quantum mechanics means that there is not just one state/evolution of the universe. Every possible state/evolution has to be taken into account. Your model is not three-dimensional. It is (NF * NP)-dimensional. NF is the number of fields. NP is the the number of points in space time. So, you want 10 space-time points in a length direction. The universe is four-dimensional so you actually have 10000 space-time points. Now your state space is (10000 * NF)-dimensional. Good luck with that. In fact people try to do such things. I.e., lattice quantum field theory but it is tough.
(2) I am not really sure what the state of the art is but there are problems even with something simple like putting a spin 1/2 particle on a lattice. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fermion_doubling
(3) Renormalization. If you fancy getting more accuracy by making your lattice spacing smaller, various constants tend to infinity. The physically interesting stuff is the finite part of that. Calculations get progressively less accurate.
I don't think so.
In classical physics, "all" you have to do is tot up the forces on every particle and you get a differential equation that is pretty easy to numerically work with. Scale is a challenge all of its own, and of course you'd ideally need to learn about all the numerical issues you can run into. But the math behind Runge-Kutta methods isn't that advanced (really, you just need some calculus to even explain what you're doing in the first place), so that's pretty approachable to a smart high schooler.
But when you get to quantum mechanics, it's different. The forces aren't described in a way that's amenable to tot-up-all-the-forces-on-every-particle, which is why you get stuff like https://xkcd.com/1489/ (where the explainer is unable to really explain anything about the strong or weak force). As an arguably competent software engineer, my own attempts to do something like this have always resulted in my just bouncing off the math entirely. And my understanding of the math--as limited as it is--is that some things like gravity just don't work at all with the methods we have at hand to us, despite us working at it for 50 years.
By way of comparison, my understanding is that our best computational models of fundamental forces struggle to model something as complicated as an atom.
You can’t simulate a molecule at accurate quark/gluon resolution.
The equations aren’t all that complex, but in practice you have to approximate to model the different levels, eg https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLMoTR49uj6ld32zLVWmcG...
So we don't have a set of equations that we could expect to model the whole universe in any meaningful way.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newton%27s_law_of_universal_gr...
Maybe still too ambitious, because I haven't heard of such a program.
Could a competent software engineer, even without knowing the fundamental origins of things like particle masses or the fine-structure constant, capture all known fundamental interactions in code?
I guess I'm trying to figure out the complexity of the task of universe creation, assuming the necessary computational power exists. For example, could it be a computer science high school project for the folks in the parent universe (simulation hypothesis). I know that's a tough question :)