Re:Why the Weak Nuclear Force Is Short Range
by ajkjk on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @03:33PM
(#42716532)
His writing is clearly narcissistic, but I don't mean that in the "unlikeable personality" way but in the "this person cannot perceive the universe except with him at the center of it way".
In particular you can tell, just from how his stuff is written, that he is at some level constitutionally incapable of incorporating other people's knowledge or ideas into his own thoughts. There are basically no references to other models, no time spent showing how ideas ladder up to known facts; no implication that that even ought to be done, that his statements ought to be demonstrated before the reader will take them seriously; almost all references are to his own work and his unproven and mostly unconcrete models; yet he refers to his own thing as though they are canonical fact; no attention is paid to making sure the ideas make sense to the reader or allow one to do useful conclusions ... it all reads like an unhinged manic episode (not in the clinical sense, maybe (I don't really know how that's defined), but in the colloquial sense).
Now, it seems to me that a manic episode can eventually find really good ideas. Maybe at some level that's what that mode of thought is for: finding things that are really, really out there in the landscape of thoughts. But in the meantime it is utterly offputting and reads as "insane" rather than "brilliant". I know enough math and physics to at least evaluate a good chunk of it and I can't distinguish it from random BS crackpots online except that the pictures are better.
In particular you can tell, just from how his stuff is written, that he is at some level constitutionally incapable of incorporating other people's knowledge or ideas into his own thoughts. There are basically no references to other models, no time spent showing how ideas ladder up to known facts; no implication that that even ought to be done, that his statements ought to be demonstrated before the reader will take them seriously; almost all references are to his own work and his unproven and mostly unconcrete models; yet he refers to his own thing as though they are canonical fact; no attention is paid to making sure the ideas make sense to the reader or allow one to do useful conclusions ... it all reads like an unhinged manic episode (not in the clinical sense, maybe (I don't really know how that's defined), but in the colloquial sense).
Now, it seems to me that a manic episode can eventually find really good ideas. Maybe at some level that's what that mode of thought is for: finding things that are really, really out there in the landscape of thoughts. But in the meantime it is utterly offputting and reads as "insane" rather than "brilliant". I know enough math and physics to at least evaluate a good chunk of it and I can't distinguish it from random BS crackpots online except that the pictures are better.