News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft disguises Bing as Google to fool inattentive se... by jjcm on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @03:57PM (#42627367)
Disclaimer - I used to work on Bing like... 8 years ago.

There's probably some debate around whether this is nefarious or genius, but I'd lead towards the later. "google" has always been one of the number one search terms, and the amount of people who would open chrome, search for google in the address bar, then open google in the google search results, then do their search, was wild. There's a very large percentage of less technical people who aren't looking for Google, they're looking for search, and in their mind the two are the same.

They likely don't care what search engine they're using, so I suspect this actually captures a very large amount of search volume, while still solving the intent of the user.

Re:Microsoft disguises Bing as Google to fool inattentive se... by quink on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @04:03PM (#42627426)
> They likely don't care what search engine they're using

That's nothing, for our next iteration our navigation system will take you to the nearest Woolworths because they've got a commercial partnership with us even though the customer quite clearly said 'Coles'. It's likely they don't care.

Re:Microsoft disguises Bing as Google to fool inattentive se... by netsharc on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @06:59PM (#42629244)
Huh, imagine if current operating system trends are applied to car computers. "To store your seat settings across reboots, get our Comfort subscription. [Subscribe] [Not Now]".

In fact, how shitty have OSes become that they are nagware now?

Re:Microsoft disguises Bing as Google to fool inattentive se... by Dylan16807 on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @03:10AM (#42632130)
If you want to make it more accurate, the car started in the Woolworths parking lot or something. But that doesn't capture many of the other aspects. Hmm.

My best attempt at this car analogy is more like... you walk over to some idling Lyft drivers and say you need an Uber to Coles. And then one of them drives you to Coles instead of driving you to the nearest Uber idling spot.

Re:Microsoft disguises Bing as Google to fool inattentive se... by shiveenp on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @04:15PM (#42627571)
This comment tells me everything I need to know about the kind of people that work at Microsoft.
Re:Microsoft disguises Bing as Google to fool inattentive se... by ed_mercer on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @04:17PM (#42627604)
Which is... that they're all geniuses?
Re:Microsoft disguises Bing as Google to fool inattentive se... by not2b on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @04:32PM (#42627816)
More like, they think that deceiving people for profit is genius.
Re:Microsoft disguises Bing as Google to fool inattentive se... by vasco on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @04:06PM (#42627461)
It's genius to copy your competitor because the user might not notice and you can also solve their problem? I don't think it's genius.
Re:Microsoft disguises Bing as Google to fool inattentive se... by jrochkind1 on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @04:03PM (#42627418)
If they didn't care what search engine they were using, would it be necessary to make it look so much like the google homepage?
Re:Microsoft disguises Bing as Google to fool inattentive se... by geodel on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @04:07PM (#42627477)
Because they think it is genius.
Re:Microsoft disguises Bing as Google to fool inattentive se... by tokioyoyo on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @04:20PM (#42627652)
Older people don’t understand the idea of “search engine”, they understand “google”. They don’t realize you can “google” through Bing as well. I hate it, but it is what it is.
Re:Microsoft disguises Bing as Google to fool inattentive se... by jrochkind1 on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @08:49PM (#42630039)
I mean, i would describe what you are describing as them actually caring a lot what search engine they are using, but possibly out of ignorance.
Re:Microsoft disguises Bing as Google to fool inattentive se... by from-nibly on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @04:11PM (#42627525)
Misleading people is always nefarious full stop. It's not your job to decide whether or not someone else cares, it's theirs.
Re:Microsoft disguises Bing as Google to fool inattentive se... by ClassyJacket on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @04:11PM (#42627522)
That makes no sense. If they don't care what search engine they're using, why do it?
Re:Microsoft disguises Bing as Google to fool inattentive se... by szundi on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @04:03PM (#42627409)
With all due respect, still feels bs to rationalizing the intentional misleding of these poor people. It is not a coincidence that Google and search is the same in their heads.
Re:Microsoft disguises Bing as Google to fool inattentive se... by ocdtrekkie on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @04:28PM (#42627756)
Is it bad to mislead these poor people when the outcome is better? Google is not good at returning results and is exceptionally good at directing nontechnical users to malicious ads. Bing is saving people.

If a user is not equipped to determine the difference between Google and Bing, you should not redirect them to a website which is 80% ads.

Re:Microsoft disguises Bing as Google to fool inattentive se... by gazchop on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @04:10PM (#42627515)
I haven’t heard anyone utter anything but disgust at accidentally using bing. They know.

The fact windows is full of dark patterns to try and get you to use it is pathetic disrespectful hubris not genius.

Re:Microsoft disguises Bing as Google to fool inattentive se... by RajT88 on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @04:20PM (#42627650)
It can be both. And it is.

Machiavellian, even.

https://ianchadwick.com/machiavelli/chapters-15-21/chapter-1...

Re:Microsoft disguises Bing as Google to fool inattentive se... by suddenexample on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @04:23PM (#42627688)
The ones debating whether this is nefarious or not are the ones ruining the tech industry. This is absolutely nefarious. Whether or not it's a clever path to promotion due to corporate incentives is irrelevant.

I'm curious what part of Microsoft's culture enables these satirically slimy product decisions. In theory, other megacorps should be no better, but somehow they seem to maintain a bar that Microsoft always manages to stoop below

Re:Microsoft disguises Bing as Google to fool inattentive se... by CobrastanJorji on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @04:34PM (#42627838)
Disclamer - I owned a restaurant that gave Pepsi products to customers who explicitly ask for a Coke.

There's probably some debate about whether this is nefarious or genius, but I lean towards the later. "Coke" has always been the number one request from our patrons, and the amount of people who just wanted any soda but said "coke" was wild. there's a very large percentage of poorly palated patrons who aren't looking for a Coca-Cola, they're looking for a soda, and in their mind the two are the same.

They likely don't care which soda they're drinking, so I suspect this actually captures a very large amount of soda sales, while still solving the intent of the patron.

What's that? There's a process server outside? Whatever for?

Re:Microsoft disguises Bing as Google to fool inattentive se... by quink on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @04:47PM (#42627986)
A perfect analogy, if I were to trust the glass with my deepest darkest secrets, had a relationship with it going back decades, expect it to point me to the right direction and keep track of much of my correspondence, and so on and so forth.

OK, maybe a glass of soft drink somehow doesn’t do that, but I suppose it’s perfect analogy adjacent.

Re:Microsoft disguises Bing as Google to fool inattentive se... by tedunangst on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @06:15PM (#42628892)
I have no idea why there's a process server outside, but rest easy, it's nothing to do with serving Pepsi.
Re:Microsoft disguises Bing as Google to fool inattentive se... by lukevp on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @04:37PM (#42627879)
This was so offensive to imagine as a Coke fan, great choice of metaphor!
Re:Microsoft disguises Bing as Google to fool inattentive se... by jjcm on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @05:37PM (#42628531)
I definitely get what you're saying - there's an element here of taking what a customer asks for and returning something different, but I think it's an imperfect analogy.

It's not bringing them a Coke, it's bringing them a dispenser that says "Cola" next to a fridge with options. For people who just want Cola, it's immediately available. For those with a brand choice, there are additional options.

The reality I'm trying to portray though is that the demographic of people who search "Google" in a search field rarely overlaps with the demographic of people who are opinionated about their search tool, so this ends up serving a segment of the population in the way they expected.

Re:Microsoft disguises Bing as Google to fool inattentive se... by blibble on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @07:14PM (#42629373)
> I definitely get what you're saying - there's an element here of taking what a customer asks for and returning something different

taking money for this is literally Google's business model

search for geico, entire initally visible results page is other insurance companies

Re:Microsoft disguises Bing as Google to fool inattentive se... by m3kw9 on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @05:47PM (#42628611)
It’s a cheap trick from some 20 year old fresh out of college. It works though but it makes Microsoft look soft and somehow non professional. But still good for them if they get to convert a few users
Re:Microsoft disguises Bing as Google to fool inattentive se... by bhelkey on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @05:02PM (#42628178)
> I owned a restaurant that gave Pepsi products to customers who explicitly ask for a Coke.

Did you tell them they were drinking Pepsi or ask some variant of "Is Pepsi okay?"

Re:Microsoft disguises Bing as Google to fool inattentive se... by CobrastanJorji on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @07:05PM (#42629288)
In response to their request, I said nothing and brought them a red and white paper cup with "Cola" written on it in the Coca-Cola font.
Re:Microsoft disguises Bing as Google to fool inattentive se... by riiii on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @05:25PM (#42628416)
Are you from the PR Disaster Mitigation Department trying to find justification for this?
Re:Microsoft disguises Bing as Google to fool inattentive se... by bhelkey on Friday January 10, 2025 @11:34AM (#42657158)
What are you talking about?

A pretty common interaction is:

Me: Can I have a coke?

Waiter: Is pepsi okay?

Me: That's fine

Waiter: brings a Pepsi

It seems that the above commentor doesn't have this exchange but instead silently substitutes.

Re:Microsoft disguises Bing as Google to fool inattentive se... by tbrownaw on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @05:06PM (#42628216)
> Disclamer - I owned a restaurant that gave Pepsi products to customers who explicitly ask for a Coke.

I have in fact heard "coke" used as a generic before. Just like google, kleenex, champaign, cheddar, ...

Re:Microsoft disguises Bing as Google to fool inattentive se... by pests on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @05:22PM (#42628395)
This example was doomed from the start because of this fact.

A lot of the US south uses the generic "coke."* It is not uncommon for this conversation to play out: "Can I get a coke?" "Sure, which kind?" "A Coke" (or a pepsi, or fanta)

In my neck of the woods we call it "pop" which always sounded strange to me in isolation.

* As famously depicted in the 2003 Harvard Dialect Survey.

Re:Microsoft disguises Bing as Google to fool inattentive se... by CobrastanJorji on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @12:24PM (#42636380)
That's what makes it work as a metaphor, I think. Our former Microsoft friend above says that when people ask for "google search," what they mean is "any search engine," just as people in Georgia say "coke" when they mean "a soda." You say the right response is "sure, what kind," but the Microsoft solution is to serve them a Pepsi that they disguised to resemble a Coca-Cola at first glance.
Re:Microsoft disguises Bing as Google to fool inattentive se... by ziml77 on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @05:13PM (#42628284)
But at the very least they need to say "No Coke. Pepsi."
Re:Microsoft disguises Bing as Google to fool inattentive se... by lesuorac on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @05:27PM (#42628428)
To avoid the whole question of if they carry pepsi or coke I usually just ask for a pepsi-coke and I've yet to run into any problems.
Re:Microsoft disguises Bing as Google to fool inattentive se... by scotty79 on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @06:13PM (#42628871)
I don't see anything wrong with that. Coke is pretty much generic term. And Pepsi and Coke and other brands of cola flavored sweetened water are all pretty much the same.

People shouldn't be drinking this stuff at all anyways. It should be mandatorily white labeled anyways.

Re:Microsoft disguises Bing as Google to fool inattentive se... by knowitnone on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @08:42PM (#42629993)
except you can kill someone by switching their choice of foods. why would you do that?
Re:Microsoft disguises Bing as Google to fool inattentive se... by thaumasiotes on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @09:08PM (#42630152)
> there's a very large percentage of poorly palated patrons

You should look into writing poetry. ;D

Re:Microsoft disguises Bing as Google to fool inattentive se... by kalleboo on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @10:48PM (#42630695)
If you ask someone for a Kleenex, are you going to be angry if they give you some other brand of paper tissue?
Re:Microsoft disguises Bing as Google to fool inattentive se... by alt187 on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @06:29AM (#42633117)
I don't care either way. Brands don't exist, grow up.
Re:Microsoft disguises Bing as Google to fool inattentive se... by lobsterthief on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @08:33AM (#42634016)
Sorry to break it to you, but yes they do.