News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by MadnessASAP on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @09:44PM (#42571134)
I have to wonder A) What does DRM realistically accomplish for the media companies? And, B) How are these DRM schemes actually being defeated? I do occasionally don my pirate hat* and have never had an issue finding what I want at the quality I want within an hour of a episode/movie being released to streaming. That would seem to indicate that these efforts at DRM are actually failing to have any noticeable effect at all.

[*] Jellyfin & and the -arr daemons are far more usable and stable then wading through the various streaming services interfaces, so I'll download episodes even though I do actually pay for the streaming services.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by majormajor on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @09:57PM (#42571186)
DRM has likely had a big impact in shifting the casual consumer conversation to "hey they're gonna start down on account sharing" from early-2000s style "here's a straight-up copy I made for you." And this helps prop up the "they'll get a Netflix account to binge the same three shows over and over" part of the business model. The cumulative monthly cost adds up but it feels cheaper than forking over a few hundred bucks for a few box sets + buying a disc player.

None of the hurdles stop 100% of people. But every hurdle causes some people to stop bothering.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by watermelon0 on Thursday January 02, 2025 @03:45AM (#42572798)
In many cases, downloading torrents and watching on a laptop/PC has a better UX than using streaming services.

For example, it's impossible to watch 4k content on popular streaming services if you use Linux, and even with macOS/Windows you need a specific combination of hardware + OS + browser, if a service even offers it.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by LegionMammal978 on Thursday January 02, 2025 @11:06AM (#42575612)
To be fair, UX isn't only about the point of consumption. 4k torrents don't grow on trees (luckily, 1080p is good enough for my own tastes), and for old or less-popular movies, it's often tough to find seeders, or they all upload at 100 kbps or only have half the file or something dumb like that. (At least on the public trackers I'm aware of: I have no clue what goes on in the super-duper-exclusive private trackers that some love to boast about.)

So I'd put accessibility and consistency as important parts of UX that torrenting can often miss out on. For the common person who is using Windows/Chrome, macOS/Safari, or a gaming console, those parts can easily be more important.

Of course, these methods start to shine when legitimate methods are even less accessible. For instance, U.S. sports streaming is an absolute mess with multiple networks, regional blackouts, etc., on top of buggy apps, so that you sometimes can't watch a game legally for any price. People have widely picked up illegal streams as an alternative, usually preferring familiar platforms like YouTube if the streams aren't taken down quickly enough.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by charrondev on Thursday January 02, 2025 @01:18PM (#42577067)
On private trackers you can sometimes even see 4k blurry remuxes up before the blueray is even available in your local area due to different release windows around the world.

As far as I’ve seen, they pretty much grow on trees as far as films are concerned. TV shows are a very different story though and outside of hugely popular series are far more inconsistent.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by thomastjeffery on Thursday January 02, 2025 @03:18PM (#42578359)
It has much better UX, but much worse accessibility.

You have to learn how to navigate an ever-dwindling list of trackers and probably a VPN, which is already too tall a hurdle for the overwhelming majority of people. Time is often worth the price of a 4K Roku and a subscription, even though that's still a technically inferior experience at the end of the day.

Piracy has two very hard problems: privacy and moderation. Moderation requires authority; authority requires trust; and trust relies on identification. I think we might be able to resolve this by replacing moderation with curation, but that's going to take a lot of ground-work that I'm too ADHD to do myself.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by paxys on Thursday January 02, 2025 @04:37PM (#42579213)
Without giving them any further instructions, ask all your non-technical friends and family members to (1) watch a popular movie on Netflix/iTunes/Amazon/Google Play and (2) torrent the same movie. Report back on how many are able to successfully do 1 vs 2. That'll tell you how good the respective user experiences are.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by jakogut on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @09:59PM (#42571196)
There's always an analog loophole. Even if the OS is unable to access the memory storing the decrypted data, you could always just plug the output of the machine into a capture card and capture the decrypted stream that way.

I suppose some monitors and TVs have "features" to cryptographically handshake with the GPU and ensure a secure link, but at some point the data must be decrypted and decoded to be displayed. This doesn't seem like much more than a speed bump for a motivated individual.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by tasn on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @10:10PM (#42571249)
The end goal is DRM all the way to the screen. No capture cards will be allowed.

It's a cat and mouse game, but I wouldn't discount these efforts as a mere speed bump. Screen enforced DRM will make things much harder. A motivated individual with the right tools and hardware hacking know how may be able to jailbreak a screen to record stuff, but that's going to make things out of reach for most people.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by soerxpso on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @10:38PM (#42571394)
It doesn't matter at all how out of reach it is for most people. As long as one kid in Russia can do it, the torrent is available for everyone in the world just as soon.

This has already been shown with videogame DRM like Denuvo. It's so hard to crack that only a handful of people know how, and yet they end up racing eachother so eagerly every time a new game comes out that it's usually done in under 24 hours. Unless you can beat "so secure that only a handful of people in the world can crack it" the situation will always be the same.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by jsheard on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @10:46PM (#42571448)
Denuvo has pulled back into the lead lately, it's taking a very long time for cracks to appear, if they ever do. For example Dragons Dogma 2 came out in March and still hasn't been cracked. Avatar: Frontiers of Pandora hasn't been cracked for a full year.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @11:16PM (#42571597)
Active player counts:

  Minecraft: ~185,000,000
  World of Warcraft: ~7,250,000
  Dragons Dogma 2: ~4000
This seems more along the lines of nobody bothers to crack games nobody wants to play.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by jsheard on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @11:21PM (#42571611)
DD2 is a single player game, those generally don't maintain their active player counts forever. It peaked at 228,285 concurrent (not total) Steam players which are pretty good numbers.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @11:31PM (#42571646)
The peak was the release, after which it promptly cratered. It was below half that within a month and below 14k the next month.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by pxoe on Thursday January 02, 2025 @10:41AM (#42575360)
This obsession with concurrent player counts, especially for single player games, is just obtuse. It's not actually telling what you want to believe.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by jsheard on Thursday January 02, 2025 @11:21AM (#42575779)
Even if we do go by concurrent players, Black Myth Wukong had one of the biggest launches in Steams history with a peak concurrent of 2.4 million players, and that hasn't been cracked either after five months.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by dvngnt_ on Thursday January 02, 2025 @12:35PM (#42576525)
there's only one person releasing cracks for modern denuvo and their last release was a year ago, and they're crazy
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by AnthonyMouse on Thursday January 02, 2025 @01:53PM (#42577444)
Apparently the people doing this kind of work have been disproportionately in Eastern Europe and what's going on in Ukraine has so disrupted that part of the world that they currently have bigger problems.

So then you're waiting for either that region to stabilize or demand for cracks to cause people somewhere else to get into the game, and in the interim you effectively have a temporary supply chain issue.

But it's hard to give credit for the ravages of war to the DRM pushers and it's not at all obvious that they've secured any kind of permanent advantage.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by mardifoufs on Friday January 03, 2025 @03:46AM (#42583830)
Who was cracking denuvo on a regular basis back in say, 2021, before the war started? Basically no one. So I'm not sure that's true.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by AnthonyMouse on Friday January 03, 2025 @11:06AM (#42586784)
There is an ocean of difference between "basically no one" and "actually no one" when you only need one person in the world to do it.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by theshackleford on Thursday January 02, 2025 @08:09AM (#42574092)
> This has already been shown with videogame DRM like Denuvo.

No it hasn’t.

> Everytime a new game comes out that it’s usable done in under 24 hours

This is not even remotely true and is not based in any kind of reality.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by Neonlicht on Thursday January 02, 2025 @08:55AM (#42574406)
Back in the day when piracy was quite literally just copy and paste it was a very active scene.

But cracking Denuvo takes real skill- and there's no financial reward in it. Back in the 90s bootleg DVDs and CD-ROMs had organised crime making money from it.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by rescbr on Thursday January 02, 2025 @01:34PM (#42577255)
Exactly.

Cracking Denuvo as a hobby is not something a sane person would do, and the downsides if caught are higher when one is fully employed.

At least to me, a decade has passed since I left college and had spare time and energy to tackle such projects just for cred.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by winocm on Saturday January 04, 2025 @03:54AM (#42593510)
I took a cursory look at breaking it and it seems rather trivial in retrospect, just annoying at best since you have to rebuild the executable’s imports, relocations and section headers, along with removing the giant bloat sections that they add (seriously, when the main .text section of a game is 4MB, and then their extra obfuscation sections end up being over 250MB, something is ridiculously wrong.)
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by tasn on Thursday January 02, 2025 @09:27AM (#42574673)
Not quite. The problem is that when you involve hardware, things are exponentially harder. When you tie it with content streaming, it's essentially a losing battle.

Hardware: makes cracking much much harder and out of reach for a lot of people. Even the people that can do it are going to be drastically slowed down due to this.

Streaming: means you can block specific device keys once you know they are compromised (the hacker managed to mod the TV to be able to record from it).

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by loeg on Thursday January 02, 2025 @12:01PM (#42576176)
Denuvo is winning, for better or worse. You can see some of the lead times for cracking these games[1][2]. It's, you know, often months+.

[1]: https://www.reddit.com/r/CrackWatch/comments/1hqd4p3/crack_w...

[2]: https://www.reddit.com/r/CrackWatch/comments/ieo7u4/crack_wa...

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by baby_souffle on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @10:57PM (#42571503)
> The end goal is DRM all the way to the screen. No capture cards will be allowed.

Sure, but the closer you get to the eye ball, the bigger the loophole is.

It's not common anymore, but _way_ back in the day, some releases were made *in the projection booth* with a semi-pro camera on a tripod pointed at the screen. (look for old NFO files with `TS` or `TeleSync` in them to get an idea of when this was common-ish)

The analogue loophole will remain open until there's a HDMI to optical nerve technology that we're all forced to get at birth.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by Wowfunhappy on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @11:02PM (#42571516)
> The analogue loophole will remain open until there's a HDMI to optical nerve technology that we're all forced to get at birth.

This is kind of a pointless tangent, but you might not have to go that far. It's probably hard to get a recording of the Apple Vision Pro for instance.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by baby_souffle on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @11:23PM (#42571617)
> It's probably hard to get a recording of the Apple Vision Pro for instance.

I hadn't actually thought about that! For 99.995% of my time on this earth, "screen" meant "flat, glass, viewed from some distance". I guess it's time to spend some time thinking about what new ways to exploit the analogue loophole are...

I wonder which part would be harder: designing something to fool the "am I on a head? Where are the eye balls looking?" bits or the optics needed to re-combine the stereo?

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by teeray on Thursday January 02, 2025 @10:07AM (#42575039)
Likely not an issue. Convincing consumers to strap a brick to their face has proven to be a persistent challenge, which even Apple has not been able to overcome. However, there is also a nontrivial percentage of the population who medically cannot use VR/AR. This population is large enough that there is a market for "2D Glasses" for removing 3D effects from movies in cinemas. Releasing a title as a VR exclusive means excluding this population from your sales figures entirely.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by Wowfunhappy on Thursday January 02, 2025 @09:45PM (#42581725)
Yes, this is why I called it "kind of a pointless tangent". :)

However, the reason I think it's only "kind of" pointless... it is in fact true that as far as I know, there is no way to pirate any of the "immersive" TV shows Apple has released. You can't watch them on any other VR headset, or even watch some 2D version on a flat screen.

Which means there are videos out there in the world right now which are immune from the analog loophole, at least as far as I know. It's a very small subset of all the content that has been produced, and it will stay that way, but it does exist.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by account42 on Tuesday January 14, 2025 @10:13AM (#42698172)
And no one I know was ever happy about accidentally downloading a telesync release. They were at best a stopgap for the FOMO crowd before a proper dvdrip inevtiably took their spot on the trackers. Yes you can make an actually high quality analog hole rip but it takes much more effort.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by geerlingguy on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @10:18PM (#42571294)
With how good modern screens are, and how good cameras are (and how easy both are to hack), you could always play back the video and capture the photons through the air.

There was something called Macrovision back in the VHS/DVD days that tried to defeat digital/analog conversion, and I'm sure visual techniques could be devised...

But I imagine someone with a good OLED and a good mirrorless camera (or even a cell phone nowadays) could make a pretty good 4K replication of any media that displays.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by Wowfunhappy on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @10:24PM (#42571323)
Especially when you add HDR to the mix, I think it's still extremely difficult to get a high quality screen recording, if only because it's so hard to get the exposure right.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by kuschku on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @10:44PM (#42571438)
You'd think so, but I've already run into a situation where DRM broke our screen capture for a live talk recording and I simply set up a camera to record the screen.

With a little bit of work (display a few calibration targets and build a quick and dirty LUT to match your display) you can get really convincing results.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by 3eb7988a1663 on Thursday January 02, 2025 @12:06AM (#42571796)
It was good enough for the moon landing. The video feed from Apollo 11 was some special format that was specially decoded onto a particular monitor. There was a camera pointed at the screen to rebroadcast the feed globally.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by Retr0id on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @10:35PM (#42571380)
You could record multiple exposures and merge them after the fact

(and I agree the result would likely be subpar, but better than it's ever been at any previous point in time)

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by Wowfunhappy on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @10:50PM (#42571469)
Yeah, I guess it really depends on what your standards are. It's certainly getting better but I have trouble imagining anyone would consider this a good solution. At minimum, if this was what pirates had to resort to, then I would think the DRM has done it's job, in that it very significantly degraded video quality for the pirates.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by sudosysgen on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @10:40PM (#42571409)
Modern dedicated cameras have far more dynamic range than any HDR TV in practice. The movies have to be recorded somehow :)
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by Wowfunhappy on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @10:45PM (#42571443)
> The movies have to be recorded somehow :)

I'd imagine they do this via huge (non-consumer level) cameras as well as by professional editors and graders who spend countless hours on the process.

But that doesn't really contradict your point. I don't know. I've never seen a good screen recording but I don't download pirated films so perhaps I've never seen an instance of someone really trying to get it right.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by sudosysgen on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @11:10PM (#42571553)
The cameras you can buy used for a couple thousand dollars have essentially the same sensors as huge cinema cameras, if not better in this application assuming you'll take stills.

Professional editors and color graders have to lower the dynamic range, because there is basically nothing that can get as bright as, say, the sun, and because basically no display can sustain peak brightness over the screen, which introduces an EOTF transfer curves, reducing the peak brightness and thus dynamic range.

You're right about pirated films, but that's because they're typically recorded in a run of the mill cinema while it's playing, not in controlled conditions in front of a carefully calibrated screen-camera combination taking a photograph of every frame.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by geerlingguy on Thursday January 02, 2025 @01:30PM (#42577209)
My A7C II ($2000-class mirrorless) has a sensor with far more range than any monitor I've ever been able to afford.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by jdietrich on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @11:06PM (#42571534)
Once upon a time, this was how all video-to-film transfers worked.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kinescope

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by loeg on Thursday January 02, 2025 @12:07PM (#42576232)
Also called Telecine (or at least, a very related process), as in: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Telecine_(copying)#Piracy
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by anfilt on Thursday January 02, 2025 @01:34AM (#42572248)
Probably would be better carefully tap into the signal lines to the LCD panel, and record and decode that data to then make a video. However if we assume that even the cable going to the panel is encrypted and the board on the panel is decrypting it. (although I have never messed with a panel like that). However it still has to got to drive the rows and columns of the display, so then data to column and row drivers is still in the open.

If we were to even assume the Column/Row drivers chips only accepted encrypted data they still have the individual traces coming out of them. The pitch of the traces is super tiny, but still possible to tap, but would be a massive pain, but still do able.

Although you can get devices that strip the encryption from an HDMI signal these days so it's kinda moot. So it's not exactly something anyone would need to do these days.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by rustcleaner on Thursday January 02, 2025 @01:14PM (#42577009)
This works for me! Nobody needs more than 480i anyhow.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by FMecha on Saturday January 04, 2025 @06:30PM (#42598457)
Except Cinavia, which worked on audio level, exists: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cinavia

Although it can only trip on certain devices or media players (mainly Blu-ray players, including PS3 onwards), I did read an idea that suggested Cinavia being placed inside an OS's kernel in a secure enclave to make it system-wide.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by orev on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @10:18PM (#42571295)
There are many USB capture dongles with chips that ignore DRM, easily available for cheap at popular online stores. Nobody has to go as far as jailbreaking screens.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by mysteria on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @10:26PM (#42571338)
In this case the piracy model might change into something like the software cracking scene where groups with specialized skills and equipment would be the ones doing the uploading. Regular people wouldn't be able to make copies with a capture card to send to their friends but popular films and shows would definitely still be released by those groups.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by Bancakes on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @10:33PM (#42571373)
Or I just split the raw pixel values from the monitors t-con board.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by rustcleaner on Thursday January 02, 2025 @01:12PM (#42576987)
I can always just not consume the media. I will never pay for that hot garbage anyhow.

DRM won't make me pay, it'll only take your trash out of my mindspace... which is probably a blessing anyway.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by loeg on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @10:28PM (#42571351)
Yeah, but pirate groups are getting the original streaming service's compression without re-encoding (so-called "WEB-DL"), even of 4k content. There's a weaker link somewhere.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by lksaar on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @10:34PM (#42571374)
WV L1 Keys/ PR SL 3000 keys require breaking into the TEE to steal those decryption keys.

Ever wondered why netflix 4k web-dls take a while for less popular shows?

Netfliy monitors these more tightly apparently and blacklist keys that are used to download. Then the group needs to buy some new device, the old one is burned.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by Retr0id on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @10:40PM (#42571404)
It's true that known-compromised keys get revoked, but it's possible to avoid them knowing you've compromised a particular device.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by jsheard on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @10:58PM (#42571504)
I think there's some kind of watermarking going on, so once a rip is released to the public they can trace it back to which device keys were used to decrypt it.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by Retr0id on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @11:02PM (#42571515)
Watermarking would require a separate version of each encoded file for each target device, which is not amenable to efficient CDN-ing.

It's quite easy to grab the encrypted media files, as they go over the wire - do this from two devices and compare what you get. (you don't need to strip the DRM to see if the two files are identical)

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by jsheard on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @11:09PM (#42571547)
They wouldn't necessarily need to serve different data to each client when they control the whole playback stack, they could get clever by including duplicate frame data with subtle differences and making each device key only able to decrypt one of the variants. Repeat that throughout a show to add additional bits to the signature until it's uniquely identifiable.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by Retr0id on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @11:10PM (#42571559)
But they don't control the playback stack, once the attacker has the keys. The attacker brings their own stack, decrypting the data with their own software.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by jsheard on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @11:18PM (#42571604)
That doesn't help the attacker if their key can only decrypt the subset of frames which Netflix wants them to be able to decrypt.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by magila on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @11:26PM (#42571634)
Watermarking was a problem when Widevine L1 was first introduced. Pirates seem to have found a way to scrub the watermark from their releases. Either that or someone is burning a _lot_ of cash on playback hardware judging from the rate of 4K WEB-DL releases.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by kimixa on Thursday January 02, 2025 @12:50AM (#42572030)
It doesn't need to be a lot - just replaced in the same cadence as the latency from initial broadcast to key revocation. Even if it's all in-house in Netflix and the watermark sufficient to identify the specific device key not all releases are made instantly after being made available on the platform, it still has to be downloaded, verified, watermark extracted before the key can be revoked.

If that's just a total of a single day, 365 cheap netflix devices per year certainly isn't out of the question, especially with the number of people involved in the many ripping groups.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by bccdee on Thursday January 02, 2025 @12:05PM (#42576217)
Depending on the bit size of a device ID, device-based watermarking should be easy to defeat using a quorum of devices to agree on bit values. It should only take around log2(n) attackers to defeat an n-bit watermark, so even with megabyte-sized device IDs, you only need about 23 devices to scrub the watermark completely.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by lksaar on Thursday January 02, 2025 @02:26PM (#42577795)
Interesting, I hadn't heard about that. But this knowledge is obscure by design I suppose.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by mike_hearn on Thursday January 02, 2025 @04:47AM (#42573095)
There is no analogue loophole, that's like 15 years behind the curve. Cinavia closed that a long time ago and meant that licensed devices like Bluray players, even TVs, can detect cammed recordings even those cammed in movie theatres.

Of course you can try to play them with hardware that doesn't follow the rules. But there's a finite number of vendors, so that isn't necessarily easy.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by ls612 on Thursday January 02, 2025 @11:45AM (#42576016)
I’m confused, you’re saying the TV can tell if someone is pointing a camera at it? That seems highly doubtful.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by kbolino on Thursday January 02, 2025 @11:58AM (#42576145)
It doesn't detect the act of recording live, it detects that a piece of media was obtained via recording. So, you can still point a camera at the screen and obtain a video file without any disruption to the original signal. However, that file won't play properly on Cinavia-enabled devices.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by ls612 on Thursday January 02, 2025 @12:05PM (#42576213)
Any computer or phone can play it back I’m sure. It’s just an MP4 file. And with Airplay or an HDMI cable your TV can too?
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by kbolino on Thursday January 02, 2025 @12:21PM (#42576374)
It's not clear to me how widely Cinavia is actually deployed. The Wikipedia article hasn't really been updated in over a decade, and that's where I'm getting my info from.

However, the detection and enforcement can theoretically be done by any device or software that has access to the audio signal. The monitor, the GPU, the playback software, the operating system, etc. could each individually decide not to play the file, making it not work. Some of those can be bypassed in various ways, some can't. But instead of computers, there are smartphones, commercial media players/receivers, and televisions/projectors, which seem the most likely places to target for enforcement, and those would affect most people.

Nevertheless, I do wonder how real this actually is. Again from the decade-old Wikipedia article, it seems like Cinavia was meant to target both recording devices and playback devices. However, the Aurora theater shooting happened not long before the article stopped getting meaningful updates, and I wonder if public safety concerns stalled its deployment. Also, the article mentions that people were finding ways to remove or neuter the signal. I also didn't encounter any problems with what I assume to be protected media (a 4K movie and a 1080p TV show), either recording my screen with my Android phone, nor with playing it back on that phone and with VLC on my Windows computer with an nVidia graphics card.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by FMecha on Saturday January 04, 2025 @06:38PM (#42598487)
In practice, only licensed Blu-ray players (hardware and software) implement Cinavia. While there was an idea/fear that an OS can implement Cinavia system-wide, that did not happen (yet).
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by mike_hearn on Thursday January 02, 2025 @02:09PM (#42577621)
Depends who makes your computer, phone or TV and the licensing etc. The tech is perfectly capable of stopping that. The device detects the Cinavia watermark and simply silences the audio after a few minutes.

I don't know whether streamers use it but it was widely deployed in the era when movie piracy revolved around making pirated Blurays. For instance the PS3 would silence the audio on a burned Bluray that had a theatre or TV cammed title protected by Cinavia on it.

A lot of this is about catching the fat head though. People who play videos using some hacked up VLC on Linux don't bother the studios, they're long tail and don't make a revenue impact. They're after the ordinary people who want to watch pirated stuff on a regular home cinema system.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by bambax on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @10:09PM (#42571241)
Yes, DRM are a perfect example of the "Smart Cow" problem [0]. This is so obvious that, as you say (A) it's quite obscure why media companies still bother with DRM?

The only beneficiaries of DRM seem to be hardware vendors, and even for them it's unclear if it's a net benefit, since it makes everything more expensive.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smart_cow_problem

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by fluidcruft on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @10:15PM (#42571282)
Probably advantage of DRM is that circumvention can be criminalized and absence of DRM implies circumvention.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @10:37PM (#42571389)
What advantage does this have over just criminalizing the underlying infringement regardless of DRM?

Also, how does criminalizing it actually help anything, since the difficulty is in the scale of it happening and the difficulty of detecting it rather than the severity of the penalties, and imposing draconian penalties on random kids only turns the public against you?

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by fluidcruft on Thursday January 02, 2025 @01:43PM (#42577346)
I think it plays differently before a jury. Juries can easily understand copying files and could potentially invalidate. But it's different when lawyers get to move the conversation to scary hacker garble about technical skill and intent. Evidence of intent is the real value.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by AnthonyMouse on Thursday January 02, 2025 @02:03PM (#42577545)
Juries are far less incompetent than they're made out to be, not least because both sides get to describe what's happening.

And you can't even get evidence of intent from this anyway because DRM circumvention tools don't actually come with a ski mask and a set of lockpicks. You install a tool called "video downloader" which supports a hundred sites and 10% of them have some kind of DRM which it automatically strips in the background, you may not even be aware that it's happening when you use it.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by fluidcruft on Friday January 03, 2025 @09:14AM (#42585801)
I did suggest that juries are incompetent. 'Why did you seek and install "video downloader"?' is a valid and specific question that gets at intent.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by AnthonyMouse on Friday January 03, 2025 @11:08AM (#42586799)
They'd be using "video downloader" to download the videos regardless of whether they have any DRM or not.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by dannyobrien on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @10:12PM (#42571259)
IIUI it's mostly a question of a mess of contractual language and incentives. Rightsholders license content, and in their licensing contracts they require a certain level of DRM for certain products. So streamers, etc, implement the DRM to comply with those contracts. Nobody at any level has an incentive or leverage to change the contracts, so the DRM continues.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by codethief on Thursday January 02, 2025 @03:43AM (#42572791)
> IIUI

If I understand incorrectly?

(Jokes aside, though, I haven't been able to figure out what IIUI stands for.)

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by merrywhether on Thursday January 02, 2025 @10:48AM (#42575422)
If I understand it?
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by cryptonector on Thursday January 02, 2025 @11:06AM (#42575609)
That and also various principals are under the impression that DRM is possible, therefore they should implement it because it protects their IP, and protecting their IP is a fiduciary duty, therefore they must if they can.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by anticensor on Friday January 03, 2025 @12:54PM (#42587866)
> protecting their IP is a fiduciary duty,

This is not the case, unless we are talking about trade secrets, and in case of trade secrets, only applicable to board members and employees.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by cryptonector on Friday January 03, 2025 @02:59PM (#42588938)
That's not how copyright works. The copyright owners want to maximize earnings, and the licensees/distributors also want to maximize earnings -- they are typically for-profit businesses, and as such they have a fiduciary duty to maximize earnings. If they think that DRM will help them, they'll want DRM.

Of course for music DRM has proven to be pointless. People want to stream music, not buy music, and preserving media across so many media obsolenscence events has been such a pain that streaming is the only manageable solution for most people -- consumers don't want to make and manage copies anymore.

The same should apply to movies and such, but maybe not -- it's not clear yet.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by anticensor on Friday January 03, 2025 @03:42PM (#42589290)
> fiduciary duty to maximize earnings

This is not how corporate fiduciary duties work (courts repeatedly ruled there is no explicit responsibility to maximise profits or minimise taxes; Swedish Aktienbolaget are a notable exception there), though it is a common misinterpretation of them.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by roenxi on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @10:20PM (#42571302)
The sort of person who can set up -arr daemons isn't going to really be on the radar of anyone pushing DRM. Those skills are so rare people will pay for them. The point is that there is a huge market of people who barely know what an internet is but want to watch media. As long as they can't figure out how to get pirated content up and running quickly then DRM is doing its job.

Pirated content represents a relatively small and motivated community. There'll always be something like it, so the question for rightsholders is how to manage the size and visibility of that community.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by thaumasiotes on Thursday January 02, 2025 @05:54PM (#42579904)
> Those skills are so rare people will pay for them.

People will pay you to move dirt from one side of a lot to the other side.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by roenxi on Thursday January 02, 2025 @07:03PM (#42580489)
I'm not convinced you're making a point. Physical skills are also something of a rarity. Not as rare as technical administration, but manual labouring tasks are demanding and not for everyone. There are a lot of unfit, old, young or weak people who I wouldn't want to see hauling dirt because they aren't up to the challenge and wouldn't do a good job. Similarly there are a lot of clueless individuals who I would not want setting up -arr demons professionally.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by throwaway654322 on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @10:25PM (#42571324)
> B) How are these DRM schemes actually being defeated?

1. Disable video hardware acceleration in browser (preferably FF)

2. Open OBS studio

3. Record screen while streaming service of your choice is running.

Still works in modern OSs like Windows 10.

You're technically not circumventing the DRM decryption routines when you do this since the pixels displayed on screen have already been decrypted (just like recording cable to VCR post-decryption), so the legality of it is towards the lighter grey end compared to ripping DVDs. IANAL though.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by jsheard on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @10:34PM (#42571376)
That only works with the weaker tiers of DRM which are typically only allowed to stream low resolutions. As mentioned in the OP article, the stronger DRM tiers never make the cleartext visible to software and those are mandatory for high quality streaming.

Not to say the stronger tiers never get broken but it's a lot more involved than just recording them with OBS.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by kuschku on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @10:51PM (#42571470)
You can get HDMI capture cards that do 4K30 HDR while removing HDCP for $20.

Use Microsoft edge for playback (so you get 4K HDR). Stylish as addon to remove any player hud.

Especially useful if you want to legitimately use copyrighted content but obviously can't just use a pirated version.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by HeatrayEnjoyer on Thursday January 02, 2025 @09:58AM (#42574949)
Which cards strip modern HDCP?
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by ec109685 on Thursday January 02, 2025 @11:50AM (#42576071)
Something like this produces a clean hdmi stream:

ViewHD 2 Port 1x2 Powered HDMI 1... https://www.amazon.com/dp/B004F9LVXC?ref=ppx_pop_mob_ap_shar...

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by mike_hearn on Thursday January 02, 2025 @03:01PM (#42578183)
That page doesn't make any mention of HDCP stripping, and says it can only work up to 1080p anyway which isn't hardware protected to begin with.

Where is the evidence this device strips HDCP?

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by ec109685 on Friday January 03, 2025 @11:55AM (#42587258)
I can’t remember where it was referenced from, but you can see in the reviews too that it strips HDCP. Good point on it not being 4k though.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by kuschku on Thursday January 02, 2025 @01:09PM (#42576948)
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by mike_hearn on Thursday January 02, 2025 @03:03PM (#42578210)
That device makes no mention of stripping HDCP and I can't find any evidence it does that on the maker's website. What makes you think it will strip HDCP?
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by kuschku on Thursday January 02, 2025 @05:39PM (#42579757)
> I can't find any evidence it does that on the maker's website.

I believe that's intentional (it would be illegal to import if it was advertised).

> What makes you think it will strip HDCP?

I've got 6 in use for lecture/talk recording without worrying about HDCP. Especially useful for presenters casting to chromecast or presenters using macbooks with DRM software (as blackmagic SDI converters don't support HDCP at all)

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by mike_hearn on Friday January 03, 2025 @04:30AM (#42584099)
But lectures probably aren't DRM protected? HDCP isn't always on.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by kuschku on Friday January 03, 2025 @05:46AM (#42584480)
You'd think so, but it's not even close to true.

For example Macs and RedHat systems require HDCP if you've used Spotify or Apple Music since the last reboot (which applies to most speakers).

Some Chromebooks can't provide direct display out but cast to a ChromeCast instead, which also always requires HDCP.

We've also had talks on media and cultural studies which use a clip from e.g. a Netflix or Amazon Prime show as part of their talk. HDCP is almost guaranteed in this case.

If your HDMI chain signals that it can't handle HDCP, some computers will obey that (and downgrade or stop playback). But most broadcast HDMI tech can't even signal that HDCP is unavailable, so you'll get HDCP by default.

That's why every major venue, university or event has HDCP killers stockpiled. For 1080p60 that used to be cheap chinese HDMI splitters, nowadays it's mostly these Hagibis cards. If they're really fancy they'll have an HD Fury with HDCP removal license, but those cost ~$600.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by Thorrez on Thursday January 02, 2025 @02:36AM (#42572533)
Netflix limits FF and Chrome on Windows to 1080p. On Linux it's even worse: 720p.

And up through Dec 2023, FF and Chrome on Windows were limited to 720p. That's right, it wasn't until 2024 that Netflix on Chrome on Windows supported 1080p... That's what, 15 years after 1080p monitors became common?

https://web.archive.org/web/20231229030336/https://help.netf...

https://help.netflix.com/en/node/23931

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by jsheard on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @09:48PM (#42571151)
> How are these DRM schemes actually being defeated?

Stripping the more advanced forms of DRM usually relies on compromised device keys which can and will be revoked if it becomes known that they've leaked, so the details are deliberately kept very quiet. If you've ever experienced a device suddenly losing the ability to play 4K Netflix, it may have been because its keys were revoked.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by timewizard on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @10:39PM (#42571401)
They hate "losing" money more than they enjoy making it. It's worthwhile to mention that Hollywood was and still is a cartel system.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by userbinator on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @10:03PM (#42571218)
Media DRM isn't the real threat. This is a misdirection article.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by lotharcable on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @09:58PM (#42571190)
> A) What does DRM realistically accomplish for the media companies?

Control publishing rights, platforms, software and hardware that is used for the consumption of said media.

The publishers control the DRM, which then needs to be licensed by television makers, software writers, and such things. Then that gives them control over how is it presented, how it is sold, how it is consumed and it forces everybody to agree to their terms.

It is a power thing. They want to have power over other businesses. DRM laws help them do that.

> How are these DRM schemes actually being defeated?

Well I don't follow DRM piracy stuff, but at a high level the people that want to consume the media must be able to decrypt it to enjoy it. So if you buy one of these DRM devices and figure out how they work then you can decrypt anything that is compatible with them.

And you only need to decrypt it once since digital media can be copied a infinite amount of times.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @10:40PM (#42571407)
> It is a power thing. They want to have power over other businesses. DRM laws help them do that.

This is the argument for repealing them, which is why you rarely see them making it out loud.

Instead they come up with some rubbish about making it marginally more difficult (spoiler: it's still easier to pirate stuff than use legal services and the only thing actually preventing everyone from doing it is that some people want to follow the law). So it's good to knock those fake arguments down when you see them and leave no excuse to keep the bad laws that ought to be repealed.

Accepting their actual motivation like it's a legitimate reason to keep those laws is like saying the reason we should keep doing the stuff Snowden revealed is so the intelligence agencies can spy on the elected officials regulating the intelligence agencies.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by refulgentis on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @10:14PM (#42571276)
That things are just annoying enough to pirate that there isn't ever a freeforall, like limewire or kazaa, again.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by maeil on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @10:27PM (#42571341)
Depends, in certain locales pirate IPTV is very popular, arguably even easier than Kazaa ever was! Stick a USB in your TV, done.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by jhanschoo on Thursday January 02, 2025 @01:29AM (#42572225)
> A) What does DRM realistically accomplish for the media companies?

My guess is that when content platforms negotiate with IP holders, there is some need to show that some DRM is in place.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by pornel on Thursday January 02, 2025 @07:44AM (#42573951)
Piracy is just a convenient excuse.

DRM is really about control. It's a technical trick that thanks to DMCA anti-reverse engineering clauses becomes a legal trick to dictate exactly who and how can play the content, much tighter than what copyright and consumer laws allow by default.

For example, without DRM you couldn't effectively sell separate licenses for computer screens and TVs, because users could just connect their computer to a TV.

DRM allows negotiating everything about distribution, up to who pays who for having a button on the TV remote.

Those who control the DRM have a veto power over everything, and have it viciously enforced internationally thanks to it being tied to copyright.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by pie_flavor on Thursday January 02, 2025 @02:16PM (#42577699)
What are you talking about? You can connect your computer to a TV just fine. No, lost sales are not 'just a convenient excuse', the sales they lose to piracy are far more numerous than the ones they'd gain with this fictional system that relies on people being willing to throw away money for no reason. 'It's about control' is a favorite element of conspiracy theories but corresponds to no real-world corporate need.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by n144q on Thursday January 02, 2025 @11:25AM (#42575824)
DRM has definitely made pirating more difficult, and that is good enough for media companies, even though it is not enough to stop all forms of it. Also as others have pointed out, often it has more business/legal meaning than technical meaning.

One example -- it has made creating pirated videos almost inaccessible to most people. In the past, if all other methods fail, you can always just record your screen with a common recording application. That's not possible with GPU enabled DRM, which is enough to stop a casual consumer to share a movie to their friends (even at a less ideal quality).

> have never had an issue finding what I want at the quality I want within an hour of a episode/movie being released to streaming.

That's because you are consuming mainstream/popular media. You often won't find recordings of a lot of performance art (ballet, concerts etc)* and I-am-not-going-to-name-it-content because there is a lot less demand.

* an interesting exception is that a lot of content released via Blu-ray gets decrypted, ripped and torrented.

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by tonymet on Thursday January 02, 2025 @11:48AM (#42576049)
It seems to have been a success. Prior to DRM, pirated material was much more common than paid streaming services. Now that has been reversed.

Now that streaming is commonplace it seems less necessary, but it was an essential stepping stone and an ongoing defense against piracy

Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by rustcleaner on Thursday January 02, 2025 @01:08PM (#42576934)
DRM is the camel-nose of a worldwide technocratic North Korean-style digital future.
Re:The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM by thomastjeffery on Thursday January 02, 2025 @02:45PM (#42577991)
DRM implements the same problem Copyright does, but in a different place. To explain that, here's some backstory:

Copyright defines art as a good (instead of a service), and demands everyone play along. An artist can use their copyright to monopolize both the distribution and the derivation of their work. Effectively, this places a wall between any would-be collaborators, because collaboration is derivative. In a world without copyright, you could collaborate with the work of Disney by making derivative work. With copyright, however, Disney can demand you stop that work by monopolizing its copy. By abusing this demand, Disney can entrench itself as the only Mickey-Mouse compatible corporation.

In the software world, collaboration of work requires source code redistribution. Because of this, the social incompatibility that copyright is founded upon translates into literal software incompatibility; including proprietary software platforms and libraries. For example, Microsoft Office has entrenched itself as the "industry standard" for rich text and spreadsheets by leveraging the incompatibility of its data formats. While collaboration isn't impossible, Microsoft is granted a legally-enforced anticompetitive advantage from its copyright monopoly.

NVIDIA uses the copyright monopoly of its CUDA implementation to sell more hardware. It is able to do this because the hardware and software engineers are both part of the same vertically-integrated corporation. Because of copyright, AMD's software engineers are not allowed to collaborate with the CUDA developers, and AMD drivers cannot be made CUDA compatible.

This is where the story gets to DRM: Apple, Amazon, Facebook, Google, and others are all vertically integrated hardware-media-advertising corporations. Each of them wants to abuse their respective copyright monopolies (their media businesses) to sell hardware, just like NVIDIA does with CUDA. To accomplish this, they told us the exact reverse story: Digital Rights Management.

The story of Digital Rights Management says that hardware needs to be incompatible in order to enforce the copyright monopoly. See what they did there? Now any anticompetitive advantage that we get in our hardware and advertising businesses was all just from us doing whatever it takes to support those poor starving artists!

I can hear you asking yourself, "But where is the hardware incompatibility?". That's the extra sneaky bit on top. Unlike having a clear winner and a loser like NVIDIA and AMD, hardware-media-advertising corporations are all winners. Each one of them benefits from the other using DRM. All of their moats intersect into one giant ~~swamp~~, I mean lakefront development.

Here's an example to chew on: App Stores. Both Google and Apple have their own separate incompatible app stores. Sure, it's a loss to Google when a popular app only works on iOS, but that's a two way street. The important part is that they have a moat at all: when the little guys try to make a competitive alternative, they drown. There is plenty of room for two players at this game, and the intersection of moats guarantees there will never be a third. Even when Apple's moat starts to flood Android Island, what's left standing will be worth more than a drained swamp.