News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by w4ffl35 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @01:49PM (#42533391)
> many of them are no longer hiring in the US, but in India, Poland and Brazil instead

This should be illegal.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by stickfigure on Saturday December 28, 2024 @03:19PM (#42534257)
Have you considered that the bitterness that drips out of your posts here might be part of the reason you're having trouble finding work?

Half the interview (ideally) measures technical competence. The other half is "would I like to work with this person?" I don't know what you're like in person, but if I looked you up and found your HN comment history, you'd be a no hire. Sorry.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by w4ffl35 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @04:11PM (#42534771)
> Have you considered that the bitterness that drips out of your posts here might be part of the reason you're having trouble finding work?

Bitterness? Have you considered that you're reading my posts wrong? Having a different political opinion than you does not equate to bitterness. No - I'm not bitter at all.

And as I've made quite clear on linkedin, I want nothing to do with an employer who tries to strong arm me out of my freedom of speech and expression, so I wouldn't work for the likes of you.

> I don't know what you're like in person

Correct you don't. I'm awesome.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by FreakLegion on Saturday December 28, 2024 @04:37PM (#42534981)
"No - I'm not bitter at all."

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42533933

"Having worked for a startup and lost my job to remote workers in a foreign country because they were cheaper and being told "we can hire 3 or 4 of them for the price of you" has left a bitter taste in my mouth."

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by w4ffl35 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @04:42PM (#42535017)
Thanks. Having a "bitter taste" in this metaphorical sense does not necessarily mean that a person is inherently bitter. I am not a "bitter" human. Nor would I say any of my posts are "dripping" in bitterness, as Schnitzer claimed.

But again - if someone wants to pass on a hire because of that post, be my guest. I wouldn't want to work for such a petty individual.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by coding123 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @05:53PM (#42535551)
These people are just suffering from ODD right now. They can't handle a world-view that makes them bad or evil, and so they will do anything they can to make you look evil/crazy/unhinged/depressed or bitter.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by FreakLegion on Saturday December 28, 2024 @06:07PM (#42535663)
I exclusively hire US citizens physically located here. Try again.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by w4ffl35 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @07:07PM (#42536102)
Its quite strange. I'm being piled on for saying that I support American workers over immigrants (which is literally Trump's position) and I am accused of being bitter. I'm actually doing great considering. Would love to have a job, but if society won't allow me, then I'll simply use the system and continue building video games, not my fault. Blame Elon etc.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by stickfigure on Saturday December 28, 2024 @09:50PM (#42537000)
You can take this any way you like, but I'm genuinely trying to offer constructive criticism. Whether you mean to or not, you come across as bitter and angry.

...also a little socially awkward? Why use my last name in this forum? Not that it bothers me; I deliberately maintain a public profile. But the convention here is to use each other's usernames, and you had to click through at least a couple links to see my name. Do we know each other? I presume not, or you would have used my first name.

There's something a little strange about it; either you aren't picking up on community social conventions, or you're deliberately trying to break them. It's just a small and almost insignificant data point, but if I had to take a totally wild guess, these sorts of subtle social issues are what interviewers are picking up on.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by w4ffl35 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @10:14PM (#42537146)
You have your full name linked in your profile. Look Jeff, you've offered up backhanded advice twice now in this thread. I'll offer up my honest feedback to you: you come across as rude and obtuse. We are having a discussion in this post about H1B, job shortages etc. Nothing I've said in any of these posts or comments is bitter or angry. You're free to read my words however you wish, but you might want to take a step back from your emotions, because they seem to have gotten the better of you. I'm a pretty happy guy. I'm not really sure where you're getting any of your intel from, but you're wrong. Now I've corrected you twice. Anymore insisting on your part is just trolling. Your "constructive criticism" has been rejected.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by w4ffl35 on Sunday December 29, 2024 @08:36AM (#42539844)
I had a free minute to look over my posts. They aren't bitter. If someone reads these posts as bitter or sees red flags that prevents them from hiring me, that is a petty employer with poor reading comprehension who is too involved in my personal life and I wouldn't want to work for them regardless. Furthermore, I haven't offered up enough information about my situation or experiences to make a real judgement about my personality. Anyone who hires or fires or makes other judgment calls in such a rash manner would make a terrible coworker, employer and business owner. Again - not someone I have any interest in spending time with. I need no education on the hiring process or sly backhanded tips that are meant to degrade and belittle me. I have no time for such people or their empty words, and I won't be baited into a ridiculous argument. If you would like to stay on topic and post information about your recent experiences in the job market, by all means, do so. I didn't make this post seeking advice or help. I'm looking for information for research purposes.

Offering one's advice when another hasn't requested it is condescending, especially when one knows absolutely nothing about the other person.

If you wish to imagine me as a bitter person sitting around cursing immigrants for my woes, so be it. You'll be wrong and dumber for it, but I'm not going to waste my time trying to convince some idiot otherwise.

I have nothing to hide. I shared this whole post on LinkedIn. I don't care if a potential employer reads it.

Just to reiterate: they don't like it? I don't care. I like working with people who aren't petty and obtuse. Having no job is better than walking on eggshells and being strong armed out of a political opinion by trolls like Jeff under the guise of "creative criticism".

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by tga on Sunday December 29, 2024 @09:13AM (#42540072)
You're spot on. Thanks for drawing this out and making it clear that, no matter what might be going on in the industry, the original poster's issue obtaining (and probably keeping) a job is about their contrarian attitude and lack of social skills.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by w4ffl35 on Sunday December 29, 2024 @09:23AM (#42540145)
What a goofy thing to say. I have excellent social skills and I do not have a contrarian attitude. The original post isn't even about my personal experiences. I've asked others what their experiences have been. Would you mind pointing to something outside of this post that would make you claim that I have a contrarian attitude and lack of social skills? Would you mind pointing to a specific job in which these alleged defects affected me negatively?

I recall holding down many jobs for many consecutive years and being let go of only one. I related why I was let go: the owner was able to hire cheaper foriegn labor - were you aware of this? The president said in 2016 that hiring h1b just to save a buck is something he would permanently end.

Here is a link to his statements. Were you aware of this as well?

https://x.com/JackPosobiec/status/1873172920396382490

I fail to see a contrarian attitude in this thread, but I do see internet trolls who smell blood and are attempting to bait me into a fight that won't happen. Good luck.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by namaria on Sunday December 29, 2024 @05:45AM (#42539137)
> society won't allow me

> not my fault

These are bitter remarks and giant red flags personality wise. Take responsibility for your own life.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by w4ffl35 on Sunday December 29, 2024 @09:08AM (#42540038)
Don't care. Didn't ask.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by w4ffl35 on Sunday December 29, 2024 @09:31AM (#42540189)
I believe thst it's just socially inept trolls who don't like my political statement. They're demonstrating their lack of ability to judge character - basing their whole assessment of my personality on alleged red flags in a few sentences that were made in response to their backhanded "advice". Typical internet incel behavior. I am not deterred.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by JustExAWS on Sunday December 29, 2024 @01:23PM (#42541742)
Blaming your lack of job opportunities on being White is bitterness.

I bet anytime a minority talks about unfair treatment you are dismissive

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by w4ffl35 on Sunday December 29, 2024 @01:44PM (#42541925)
Point me to the post where I blamed lack of job opportunities on being white, I'll wait.

You're free to infer what you wish about my view of minorities. I believe my "minority" wife would disagree with you.

Fair warning, before you go implying I'm racist again, you might want to read this comment:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42532586

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by JustExAWS on Sunday December 29, 2024 @05:04PM (#42543764)
> but I'm seeing many people claiming to be in the same situation as myself, and most of them claim to be white males

And then later on you asked was it because of racism.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by w4ffl35 on Sunday December 29, 2024 @05:14PM (#42543864)
Asking questions != "Blaming your lack of job opportunities on being White". You seem to be very confused.

And this:

> I bet anytime a minority talks about unfair treatment you are dismissive

is called an ad hominem logical fallacy. What was the point of throwing that in?

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by JustExAWS on Sunday December 29, 2024 @05:44PM (#42544146)
Yes, the typical cover…

“Is it true that Obama is a secret radical Muslim trying to bring Sharia law to the US?”

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by w4ffl35 on Sunday December 29, 2024 @05:50PM (#42544206)
Non sequitur. Do you have any real points to make or is your goal to simply paint me as a racist via logical fallacies? I recommend taking a break from the internet, your own predjudices are shining through.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by JustExAWS on Sunday December 29, 2024 @05:55PM (#42544257)
What exactly is supposed to be inferred by this?

> Furthermore, in the last two years I experienced two layoffs. In both situations it was white males let go in favor of Indian and KZ foreigners

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by w4ffl35 on Sunday December 29, 2024 @06:03PM (#42544337)
Nothing is supposed to be inferred, I've been very blunt. The post plainly states that I am seeing many people claim there is a racism problem in tech that disproportionately affects white males. I have personally experienced some of this, but one man's anecdotal experience does not speak for the entire tech industry.

I have asked others for their experiences, as the post concludes:

> I'm looking for people's personal experiences. Do they match up? Are you having a hard time finding employment? Have you been fired in favor of foreign workers? Is this racism / ageism / sexism at play or is that being overblown by political actors?

YOU stated that I have claimed that I am unable to find work due to racism. This is incorrect. I've never once made that claim.

YOU have stated that I disregard discrimination against minorities. This is incorrect. I've never once made that claim, and I reject your speculation, you're wrong.

YOU have implied I'm an Obama birther conspiracy theorist. That is incorrect. I've never once made that claim, and I reject your idiotic false logic.

YOU have a hang up, not me.

I have linked you to a comment I made that said I don't believe the overarching job shortage is related to being a white male. Interestingly, Bloomburg has posted stats that contradict my statement - tech jobs have actually disproportionately gone to minorities and people of color in 2023.

Your goal is to paint me as a racist, you've failed. You seem to have a problem, stop trying to hoist it on me. Go find something else to do with your time, I'm through with you.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by scarface_74 on Sunday December 29, 2024 @10:13PM (#42546086)
I have never even thought who was replacing me or worried about my job being replaced by “foreigners”.

I’ve had 10 jobs over almost 30 years and I’ve been laid off twice - once when a company got acquired and once this year and I got Amazoned last year. It’s never taken me more than a month to get a job once I started looking.

I kept my skill set and resume up to date, always prepared to interview and I have a great network.

Yes I am a minority and I’m damn good at what I do - strategic cloud consulting with an emphasis on application development. Yes I’ve worked for a FAANG (direct hire).

Trust me, companies didn’t just hire me either at BigTech or a strategic hire at startups or to lead million dollar+ projects because I’m Black.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by w4ffl35 on Sunday December 29, 2024 @10:51PM (#42546289)
Good to know. Thanks for your feedback. It certainly isn't fun to hire, train and then be replaced by foreigners. Going years without being hired is especially difficult. Being raised poor, white, hyper religious, kept out of college and forced to teach myself everything from high-school onward made the struggle even harder. I can imagine that being black as you say made your struggles different than mine, but difficult none the less. Keeping ones skills up to date certainly is essential. I too have never worried about foreigners replacing me. I do not have a great network. People most certainly don't hire me solely due to being white.

Interestingly, the current issue isn't so much getting hired as it is getting an interview at all. This has started after the rise of chatgpt. No one has bothered to ask me what the issue is and has instead jumped to conclusions which I'm personally quite entertained by. As I said in my original post: my situation is unique.

(Edited some words for clarification)

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by scarface_74 on Sunday December 29, 2024 @11:11PM (#42546399)
I didn’t claim that I had it harder either…

My mom was a well connected school teacher where I grew up and my dad a factory worker (both still living and just celebrated their 56th anniversary).

I was programming in assembly language on my Apple //e in 1986 in sixth grade.

The tech environment is one of the most egalitarian industries. I have never seen signs of systemic discrimination.

Surprisingly enough, the only reports I’ve heard about widespread discrimination are by Indians against other Indians…

https://www.reuters.com/business/sustainable-business/caste-...

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by w4ffl35 on Sunday December 29, 2024 @11:22PM (#42546458)
I can tell you that i have faced some extremely difficult adversities. I don't talk about it online or to people outside of a few that I hold very close. I didn't have an easy upbringing or life in general. I got lucky a few times, and I've pushed myself as hard as possible the rest of the way.

I'm not surprised by the stats you shared. The most discrimination and workplace harassment / bullying I've recieved is from white people. Me and the Indians, Russians and black people I've worked with got along great -- and some of the white people of course.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by derektank on Saturday December 28, 2024 @01:55PM (#42533449)
Why, exactly? These companies have foreign customers, it seems reasonable to expect that they would also want to have foreign employees that can speak the language, work in the same time zone, etc. And the demand for those employees is unlikely to be perfectly commensurate with demand for US based employees at all times. Seems like a ban would be pretty destructive, even if some of this hiring is an attempt at offshoring work US based employees would be doing.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by handzhiev on Saturday December 28, 2024 @02:15PM (#42533632)
If such a ban is in power, many companies will either close or move abroad. It's as simple as that. I agree, it will be totally destructive.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by w4ffl35 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @02:25PM (#42533712)
So be it.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by coding123 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @02:47PM (#42533930)
If this is the case, why do I get someone in India when I call US based companies for support (during their midnight)?

Should US employees do support for Indian companies during our midnight too? I'm being honest, I can probably work for a few pennies since I was laid off months ago. Anything will help keep me going at this point.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by thinkyfish on Saturday December 28, 2024 @03:00PM (#42534051)
I've witnessed the answer personally. Indian immigrants working physically in US call centers.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by w4ffl35 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @02:25PM (#42533706)
If a company is operating in a foreign nation sure. If a company is operating in America on American soil and refusing to hire Americans because they want to save a buck, they should face penalties. I do not see hiring foreigners as being pro-American.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by layer8 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @02:43PM (#42533877)
More software companies are operating internationally nowadays than aren’t, I would assume. And publicly-traded companies are generally owned internationally to some degree. It’s rarely in the interest of a company to restrict themselves to a single country.

Furthermore, most of the hardware that you use directly or indirectly, wasn’t manufactured in the US. The globalization trend of companies, job markets, consumers, and supply chains being spread around the world will likely only grow. Most things are internationally interdependent nowadays, there’s no good reason for why the job market should be any different.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by dmantis on Saturday December 28, 2024 @03:31PM (#42534386)
When US sells stuff, it's all pro free-market. When US competes, there are tiktok potential bans and whining about workers from other countries. You can only pick one to be fair. You either don't sell your products to the outside world (and kill the economy) or provide equal opportunities for nations you earn money from.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by brianwawok on Saturday December 28, 2024 @02:35PM (#42533794)
Then make this choice when you own a company. What % of your paycheck are you willing to donate to being pro America?
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by w4ffl35 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @02:42PM (#42533872)
> Then make this choice when you own a company

Absolutely I would.

> What % of your paycheck are you willing to donate to being pro America?

This is a tu quoque logical fallacy. I'll cross that bridge if and when I come to it, but I can tell you that I'd rather take a pay cut than hire a foreigner.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by brianwawok on Saturday December 28, 2024 @04:38PM (#42534985)
Great! Then I encourage you to do so. And then after you do, we can come back and you can tell us how company X should do Y. Otherwise you are just sitting there complaining when you would likely do the same thing given the same choices.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by w4ffl35 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @05:14PM (#42535266)
Sure fund me and let's see what happens.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by bdangubic on Saturday December 28, 2024 @04:54PM (#42535124)
your heart is obviously in the right place but you could not be competitive. this is like I got a team of ballers and everyone is on steroids (which are legal). you have a high moral ground and care for your ballers and would never let them dope. your chances playing against my team are not going to be that great…
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by ipaddr on Saturday December 28, 2024 @05:11PM (#42535244)
Logically you should pay taxes on the money earned from American customers at American rates to the American government.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by maeil on Saturday December 28, 2024 @02:43PM (#42533880)
The comment is mostly talking about Silicon Valley big tech, of which exactly 100% operates in many countries.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by w4ffl35 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @02:48PM (#42533933)
Having worked for a startup and lost my job to remote workers in a foreign country because they were cheaper and being told "we can hire 3 or 4 of them for the price of you" has left a bitter taste in my mouth.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by maeil on Saturday December 28, 2024 @02:56PM (#42534011)
I can tell you that US tech companies making enormous amounts of money from your country's populace while contributing back near-zero jobs in return is just as bitter.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by c0redump on Monday December 30, 2024 @02:45PM (#42552708)
This line of reasoning is deeply flawed. If US tech companies are “making enormous amounts of money from your country’s populace”, then your country is getting something in return, e.g. access to Apples hardware products, amazons cloud, or googles search engine.

Why should it matter if they also open an office in your country?

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by maeil on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @11:44AM (#42567145)
It isn't at all, and having lived in countries on both sides of the coin, I can tell you that people are getting a worse product in return, without the local job creation. I've written more about it here [1]. A trivial example is Google Maps. I've gone a bit more in-depth on that example here [2]. In a nutshell, you get much less enshittification, far better customer support (humans instead of ML models), and all the other things that used to be completely normal but were slowly boiled away while getting people used to it in the name of shareholder returns.

For clarity, I took the discussion as being about software, as physical goods (including hardware) are an entirely different beast which my points don't necessarily apply to.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42538601

[2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42286046

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by akmarinov on Saturday December 28, 2024 @03:15PM (#42534209)
Getting the most product for the least amount of money is Capitalism 101. Companies don’t owe you anything past that and you should follow the same principle.

Do the least amount of work that’ll get you as much money as possible and always look for a better offer.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by w4ffl35 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @03:30PM (#42534373)
I'd prefer to take a pay cut and continue working - that's survival 101, which as a human is my primary concern.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by atemerev on Saturday December 28, 2024 @02:55PM (#42534003)
Under capitalism, a private company has duties to shareholders first. If you want companies has duties to their host country first, there are other social systems for that. Perhaps fascism.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by w4ffl35 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @03:01PM (#42534067)
I'd prefer fascism to globalism.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by atemerev on Saturday December 28, 2024 @03:32PM (#42534394)
Yes, you would. And I would prefer to eradicate all damned fascists out of the world, like we did in 1945. We are not the same.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by w4ffl35 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @03:45PM (#42534540)
I'm able to thrive under any political system. Globalism is just large scale fascism in my eyes.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by worik on Saturday December 28, 2024 @04:42PM (#42535020)
> Under capitalism....are other social systems for that. Perhaps fascism.

That is, obviously, a false dichotomy

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by TypingOutBugs on Saturday December 28, 2024 @02:49PM (#42533940)
What should be illegal, specifically? What concrete action should be made illegal?

These are people hired locally within their respective countries by local corporations owned by holdings in the US. How can you make it illegal for a company to hire people legally in other countries through their legal non-US incorporations?

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by w4ffl35 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @03:18PM (#42534242)
> many of them are no longer hiring in the US, but in India, Poland and Brazil instead

to reiterate what i've stated throughout this thread: passing up US workers in favor of hiring foreigners should incur heavy penalties. There is no shortage of American workers. If a foreigner wants to work for an American company, they should get a greencard and work in America.

If a company has a foreign office, of course it makes sense to hire people in that country, but that wasn't stipulated in the comment I replied to. Many companies are NOT based in foreign lands and still hire foreigners remotely, passing up Americans in the process, because those foreigners are dirt cheap by comparison. This should not be allowed.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by TypingOutBugs on Saturday December 28, 2024 @03:27PM (#42534326)
There’s three ways US companies can do that:

1. Hiring a company for a service

2. Hiring a contractor who invoices through their foreign company

3. Having an office in that country

Which one would you make illegal? I don’t even understand what the rule would be to defend or support here, in practice. Companies in the US cannot hire services from foreign countries?

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by w4ffl35 on Sunday December 29, 2024 @04:38PM (#42543498)
Anything that abuses loopholes in order bypass American workers for cheaper labor. This was a position Trump himself took during the 2016 election and during his first term.

I've made it abundantly clear that I am against this practice. H-1B is the current hot button policy that everyone is discussing. I would also like to see all other programs and policies involving the replacement of American workers with cheaper foriegn workers reformed, replaced, or repealed.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by coding123 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @04:32PM (#42534942)
I just think start with the moral issue first. Then legal experts can craft logic around that.

Basically, if an unemployed American that can write React code, that person should have a job before any H1B (or remotely hired person) at the same level, same remoteness status, etc... If all the Americans are hired, then H1B levels (and remote work Indians) may rise again.

I might have a larger shot at getting a job right now if I literally move to India and get in with one of these programming shops. Of course I won't participate in the night-time scamming operation of US grandparents.

By the way I'm half Indian

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by gloosx on Sunday December 29, 2024 @01:31AM (#42538092)
You don't need to move to India for that, it is enough to just bid for 3x less salary like an Indian and you will get the job from anywhere. Then you maybe will consider moving to India.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by coding123 on Sunday December 29, 2024 @11:46AM (#42541036)
They think you are fake if you do that. It doesn't work.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by seanmcdirmid on Saturday December 28, 2024 @01:50PM (#42533401)
Why should it be illegal for American companies to operate abroad when they have international revenue streams?
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by w4ffl35 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @02:22PM (#42533681)
If American companies are claiming a shortage of American workers, when clearly there is not a shortage of American workers, it should be illegal to hire foreigners. I do believe in the America First movement from this aspect, which is what got our next president elected.

Edit: lots of people abusing the downvotes here. Perhaps you should read the TOS.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by layer8 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @03:03PM (#42534094)
There is a shortage of American workers willing to work for internationally competitive salaries. This is similar in Europe, by the way. Industry associations claim that there is a shortage of skilled workers, whereas in reality there is only a shortage of skilled workers willing to work for low-ish salaries. On the other hand, paying everyone higher salaries across the board would have its own economic consequences.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by ungreased0675 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @04:17PM (#42534816)
I’m not sure that’s accurate. The primary complaint I see (and also have) is applying to hundreds of jobs and not even getting a screening call. Haven’t seen many complaints about lowball offers.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by throwaway48476 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @03:30PM (#42534374)
The economic consequences would be an increased percent of the economy going to wages instead of returned as dividends and stock buyback. Wage income also has a higher velocity of money increasing economic activity.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by layer8 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @04:04PM (#42534720)
Wage increases also drive inflation. And given the uncertainties of the present times, people might opt to save more of their earnings rather than spending it all.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by throwaway48476 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @04:08PM (#42534746)
This is why people should index wages as a percentage of the total enocomy. Because 'inflation' only means anything when compared to something else. Just saying inflation is meaningless by itself.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by layer8 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @04:23PM (#42534878)
I agree with binding salaries to an index. However, if the index is accurate (which is a whole other can of worms), then it implies that the buying power would stay the same, and you would need extra justification to add a pay raise on top.

Of course, in reality different products/services have substantially different price developments relative to inflation, and it’s difficult to predict whether essential costs of living will be relatively more or less affected by inflation.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by throwaway48476 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @04:27PM (#42534905)
It's simpler to just say wages are x% of gdp.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by layer8 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @04:31PM (#42534938)
Not sure that would make sense. And it probably would appear like communism to the US, because one company or industry increasing the GDP would then translate into benefitting the workers of all other companies/industries. Also, if GDP decreases, salary would have to decrease as well.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by throwaway48476 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @06:47PM (#42535973)
I don't think you understand what I said. Instead of nominally inflation which is gamed, use total wages as a percentage of GDP.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by layer8 on Sunday December 29, 2024 @10:29AM (#42540503)
Use it as what? As a measure of inflation? I don’t quite see the relation to the value of currency then, which is what inflation is supposed to measure.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by nuancebydefault on Saturday December 28, 2024 @03:58PM (#42534669)
America will be a lot poorer if the foreigners would not do so much of the work. This claim is in the same ballpark as saying we should not be allowed to use machines. I am really astonished that there are many people who obviously are able to read and write, but somehow don't understand economics 101.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by seanmcdirmid on Saturday December 28, 2024 @02:57PM (#42534023)
But they make a lot (most) of their money outside of the USA, so why restrict them to doing the work only in the USA? That will not only start a trade war, but give an unfair advantage to foreign companies (like SAP) who can open up R&D offices in the USA, Germany, or wherever they want.

America First is as old as the Great Depression years ago. They always fizzle out in the face of economic realities.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by maeil on Saturday December 28, 2024 @02:44PM (#42533894)
Right, then go get out of all those juicy international markets and see the majority of revenue evaporate.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by nickff on Saturday December 28, 2024 @02:27PM (#42533727)
There are a lot of companies; Americans have a spectrum of views, as do corporations. In addition, both individuals and corporations are capable of talking out of both sides of their mouth (or just plain lying).
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by w4ffl35 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @02:32PM (#42533771)
Yes there are a lot of companies, and yes people and companies can lie. I'm not really sure how this negates what I said or my view on the matter. Globalization is the antithesis of the America First movement.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by nickff on Saturday December 28, 2024 @02:36PM (#42533817)
Some industries do face shortages in short term skilled labor supply; they might be able to get more people trained up in 5-10 years, with enough investment, but you can’t get a journeyman ready in three months. Others just want more supply, to reduce labor costs and make domestic production cost-competitive with foreign equivalents. Neither of those groups is lying.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by w4ffl35 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @02:58PM (#42534028)
Then let them go through the immigration system, get a green card and start working in the US. The original thread here is me saying that it should be illegal / there should be penalties for hiring abroad when there are plenty of skilled American workers who are being turned down for the jobs which are going to cheap foreign labor.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by layer8 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @03:10PM (#42534157)
Not sure what TOS you are referring to, but regarding downvotes maybe you should read the top comment on: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36673613
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by w4ffl35 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @04:37PM (#42534982)
Guess things have changed on this site.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by layer8 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @06:59PM (#42536059)
The pg comments linked to above are from 2008. HN launched in 2007.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by w4ffl35 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @08:43PM (#42536664)
all the comments on that link are 2023. I'm not clicking through a bunch of sublinks.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by layer8 on Sunday December 29, 2024 @10:27AM (#42540487)
You’re just being obstinate. As someone elsewhere observed, it’s maybe no wonder that nobody wants to hire you.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by w4ffl35 on Sunday December 29, 2024 @04:31PM (#42543401)
Yes, and you're a ball of sunshine.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by maeil on Saturday December 28, 2024 @02:42PM (#42533868)
The irony is palpable.

For many years, FAANGs and the likes have made billions across the world without hiring any significant amount of people in nearly all of those economies. Zero profit for the non-US countries. Take a random one, Denmark. Google and Apple sure have been making great money off of the Danes. What has Denmark gotten in return for it? Nothing. It's all gone towards (generally US) investor returns, and US salaries.

Sure, make it illegal for US companies to hire boatloads of people abroad. At the same time, other countries should ban those US companies from operating there.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by w4ffl35 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @02:45PM (#42533907)
Fine with me, I'm anti-globalization. I see no irony here. I'm pro-America First and really don't care about Denmark or any other random country.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by maeil on Saturday December 28, 2024 @02:52PM (#42533971)
Great! US tech is by far the biggest benefactor of it (and it isn't close), so you'll be much, much worse off, but good luck. Those in Denmark that you don't care about will rejoice.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by w4ffl35 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @02:56PM (#42534016)
It sounds like those in Denmark who are rejoicing over this are also anti-globalization, so its a win for everyone then.
[dead]
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by worik on Saturday December 28, 2024 @04:55PM (#42535130)
> Being anti globalization means everyone loses

Are you saying everybody gained from globalisation?

American steel workers?

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by maeil on Sunday December 29, 2024 @03:38AM (#42538577)
As I've explained here [1], when it comes to this topic (software), this take is on the level of "trickle-down economics". A good dose of protectionism means most people benefit, a very clear net positive for society as a whole.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42535968

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by nuancebydefault on Saturday December 28, 2024 @03:53PM (#42534622)
As a European it feels weird to know that 55 percent of US population/voters have a very similar opinion, while on this big US based blog these opinions get downvoted.

I will never ever understand what is currently and 8 years ago is/was going on in the US.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by layer8 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @04:01PM (#42534697)
With regard to the downvoting, that’s easy: HN members are far from being representative of the US voting population.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by hindsightbias on Saturday December 28, 2024 @04:51PM (#42535097)
People tend to vote with their emotions or ideology.

Even rich people aren’t that rational. They might get lower taxes but the number of millionaires tripled inder Biden.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by worik on Saturday December 28, 2024 @04:52PM (#42535110)
I think you might be confused about who your real enemy is.

It is not the Danes

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by w4ffl35 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @05:00PM (#42535175)
Strawman. I never claimed the Danes to be my enemy, that was a hypothetical presented by the person I was responding to. I am anti-globalization.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by worik on Saturday December 28, 2024 @05:03PM (#42535198)
> I am anti-globalization

Yes. You are confused about who you are at risk from

It is Americans who have it in for you. Fortress America will crater your life, your career, everything

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by ipaddr on Saturday December 28, 2024 @05:17PM (#42535291)
Google has an office in Copenhagen. They also have a data center. Apple has an office in Copenhagen.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by didgetmaster on Saturday December 28, 2024 @05:32PM (#42535412)
Is there some law that prevents the people of Denmark from buying Apple or Google stock? If not, then anyone there can make as much from stock appreciation in those companies as any American.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by wojciii on Saturday December 28, 2024 @05:57PM (#42535584)
This is a bad example.

Google hired some VM specialists who worked out of their Aarhus office. I think they used their research for Android.

I don't know if Google still does this, but we have (or had) a large number of people working on CS problems which they could use working at our universities they could attract.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by maeil on Saturday December 28, 2024 @06:47PM (#42535968)
It's negligible. Pick a random different country if you're co nvinced Denmark is an outlier. Compare vs. their jobs in the US. Now compare that to per-country revenue. Quite simply, the % profit margin per country, looking at their expenditures made in each country (incl. salaries paid in that country) vs their revenues there.

And then compare it to "what if Google wouldn't operate at all in Denmark", how much jobs that would create.

The great news is this isn't a hypothetical that can be waved away with "we don't know", because we have a golden example in South Korea, where the 10+ year delay that Google had in gaining market share has resulted in tens of thousands of local jobs that otherwise wouldn't exist.

Could every country have its own Google a la South Korea? Maybe not. But plenty could.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by hiAndrewQuinn on Monday December 30, 2024 @11:35AM (#42550828)
Voluntary trade benefits both parties by definition.

If Google is making money off of people in e.g. Denmark, it's probably also giving them something that is really valuable to them, like access to the Google search engine.

So I don't actually think Denmark would be better off by banning doing business with Google, Facebook, Netflix, etc.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by maeil on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @11:52AM (#42567202)
> Voluntary trade benefits both parties by definition.

It absolutely does not [1]. This kind of blanket statement is on the level of "market intervention is *always bad, the free market solves everything". Wishful Raegan-era thinking.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42567145

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by hiAndrewQuinn on Thursday January 09, 2025 @12:41PM (#42647961)
Why would Party A trade with Party B if Party A is not benefiting from it?
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by bdangubic on Saturday December 28, 2024 @01:59PM (#42533487)
globalization mate, globalization… there will never be a law in the US of A that prevents companies from finding cheap labor… more than a quarter (and ever growing) SWEs are no longer “on shore”
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by w4ffl35 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @02:22PM (#42533690)
I am anti-globalization, and pro-America first.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by bdangubic on Saturday December 28, 2024 @03:08PM (#42534142)
that is an oxymoron - america has been the main driver of globalization without a distant second. the “america first” is political garbage used to rile up rural america, it only exists in context “we’ll let american companies do whatever is necessary so that we keep being “global leader” …)
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by w4ffl35 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @03:14PM (#42534195)
American leaders have been the drivers of lots of terrible things that I disagree with. I'm still anti globalization and pro-America first which in the context of this thread translates to hiring American workers over foreigners when there is clearly no shortage of American workers.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by bdangubic on Saturday December 28, 2024 @03:23PM (#42534300)
brace yourself for the next two/four years as the incoming administration is on a mission to kill american workforce chasing every last dollar. I feel you but the pro-America means 180-different to you than what is about to hit us hard
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by w4ffl35 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @03:53PM (#42534623)
Perhaps. Most certainly the unelected musk / ramaswamy coalition is all about that. It's really up in the air how this will go. With the recent meltdown on X, I await Trump's words and actions. His base is unhappy, as is his inner circle. Musk is flailing, telling people to "fuck yourself in the face" etc. Does trump's base matter now that he's in his 2nd term, or will he tether himself to musk for the duration of his time in office? It will be an interesting 4 years.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by nirav72 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @08:53PM (#42536732)
> I await Trump's words

well..right now, it seems that Trump is siding with Elon on this. This hit the news today:

https://apnews.com/article/trump-maga-immigration-visas-musk...

Also remember - Trump doesn't need the votes anymore from his base. He could pivot on all of his promises or some of these things or make just enough of a visible attempt to give a perception of things are being changed. It wouldn't make a difference. He's said a lot of things and made a lot of promises since being elected the first time. Very few things actually trickled down to the average person. At least nothing that was a lasting change couldn't be undone by the next administration due to bad policy. I say this as someone who voted for him. (I knew what who I was voting for though and had very little expectations of change.)

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by bdangubic on Saturday December 28, 2024 @10:04PM (#42537091)
if he is set of pilaging what he can for the next two years - this is 100% right. he’ll get buttfucked in 2026 midterms like in 2018… but I think he does want at least 4 years of full power and will want the votes for one more election cycle
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by w4ffl35 on Sunday December 29, 2024 @09:40AM (#42540233)
Yes like I said: > Does trump's base matter now that he's in his 2nd term?

I doubt it.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by isbvhodnvemrwvn on Saturday December 28, 2024 @03:08PM (#42534141)
Success of the US is largely a product of globalization and geography. The US would be nowhere close to where it is now without largely unrestricted capitalism and a global consumer base. It has always been like that, from being a colony, through making money on products of slavery, being industrial base for lots of the world in 20th century and now being the digital world capital.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by bruce511 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @03:34PM (#42534401)
I think it suks that your job got lost to a foreign worker. It's certainly no consolation that you are merely the latest casualty of globalization, along with your US manufacturing workers.

I say that sincerely- losing your job suks.

Of course the root of the problem, for you and steel workers, US that American consumers care more about money than where something is sourced. They buy the cheapest car, cheapest steel, cheapest computer etc. So to survive companies have to reduce costs, which inevitably means off-shoring.

Tarifs are a solution, but are simpler to do on physical imports than on remote labor. Basically though they help by driving up local prices, allowing say American Steel to compete.

Yes, prices going up (inflation) is a side effect, and yes salaries have to remain fixed (else the import is still cheaper) so disposal income, and hence standard of living have to come down. That's a feature not a bug.

Alternatively taxes could be slashed, requiring massive reductions on spending on military, social security and Medicare. That would mean some job losses in the military-industrial sector, but frankly that's probably a good thing.

Social Security and Medicare are unpopular to cut, but its easily done, and a necessity to make significant cuts. I think the electorate has given a mandate to the govt to do this, do I expect they'll do it. (Trump campaigned on this, so its pretty much what people clearly want.)

I know attempts at American isolationist policies have not worked in the past, but I expect it'll be different this time.

The alternative to this approach would be higher taxes on companies and the mega rich - along with reduced military spending and increases to the social security net. That's the route most of the other countries took, but how many billionaires can Poland boast?

Sure they're sucking up programmer jobs, but there aren't too many companies complaining about that.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by w4ffl35 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @04:32PM (#42534943)
> Social Security and Medicare are unpopular to cut, but its easily done, and a necessity to make significant cuts. I think the electorate has given a mandate to the govt to do this, do I expect they'll do it. (Trump campaigned on this, so its pretty much what people clearly want.)

Can you please point me to Trump campaigning on this? I heard him say the exact opposite repeatedly in his speeches at his rallies.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by bruce511 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @11:12PM (#42537459)
Trump lies all the time. So what he says and what he campaigns on are different things. He says he is pro-women (but acts the opposite) pro-US (but sources all his grift from China), says he wants to bring down prices (but plans on tarifs to raise them).

He claims no affiliation to Project 25 (but then hires all those planners into key positions), claims to be pro-worker, but eliminates labor protections and gives tax cuts only to rich people.

The American public are smart. They are not easily duped. They understand that when he says Social Security and Medicare are bring left alone, he intends to cut them.

They understand that campaigning on fiscal responsibility means widening the deficit. They understand that improving health care means taking it away and giving health care companies more profit.

This is the future he campaigned on - this is the future they voted for. This is no a politician changing between campaign and office. His intentions, interests, and affiliations - his transactional nature - are front and center and have been all along.

This is the man the people have decided will best lead them. This is democracy in action.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by wakawaka28 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @11:51PM (#42537620)
All politicians lie.

>The American public are smart. They are not easily duped. They understand that when he says Social Security and Medicare are bring left alone, he intends to cut them.

That's ridiculous. Your central premise seems to be that because Trump has lied before, we live in opposite land. Not only that but that the American public is 100% behind the opposite of what they were promised, which is also very bad for them and their families personally. Your rationale makes absolutely no sense.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by bruce511 on Sunday December 29, 2024 @12:22AM (#42537762)
Yes all politicians lie. But Trump doesn't lie like that, he lies about everything all the time. He lies about things that are obviously untrue, right there in front of you.

He's not a "liar" in the way most people are. He's a liar in the sense that you are in on the lie, that you understand the lie is a lie.

This is not "some of the act" - its his whole shtick.

Yes, I think most of what he does will be very bad for most of the people who voted for him. Yes I think they voted for the exact opposite of what is good for them.

But this is a guy with a 4 year term already behind him. This is a guy running to stay out of jail. This is the guy people voted for. More than in 2016, more than in 2020. More across all demographics. More in 90% of counties .

The voter understands the pain that is coming, and embraces it as necessary for the coming greatness. The willingness to put their own suffering aside, to willingly endure the oncoming hardships, to vote against their personal best interest is admirable.

At least I assume this is what happened.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by wakawaka28 on Sunday December 29, 2024 @02:36AM (#42538352)
>But Trump doesn't lie like that, he lies about everything all the time. He lies about things that are obviously untrue, right there in front of you.

Again you describe what most politicians do. Trump's lying is not quantitatively nor qualitatively more severe than any other politician at that level, certainly not more than Biden or Kamala.

>He's not a "liar" in the way most people are. He's a liar in the sense that you are in on the lie, that you understand the lie is a lie.

I don't buy this.

>But this is a guy with a 4 year term already behind him. This is a guy running to stay out of jail. This is the guy people voted for. More than in 2016, more than in 2020. More across all demographics. More in 90% of counties .

Need I remind you that Biden pardoned his son for a huge period of time and undisclosed crimes which he himself might be complicit?

>The voter understands the pain that is coming, and embraces it as necessary for the coming greatness. The willingness to put their own suffering aside, to willingly endure the oncoming hardships, to vote against their personal best interest is admirable.

I don't think this is what happened. Although the Trump campaign did make vague references to temporary pain, it explicitly denied that any benefits would be cut or taxes increased (except for the tariffs). People are suffering because of high inflation and a stagnant economy. They see hundreds of billions of dollars go abroad as we struggle to cover expenses at home. They are not down for more taxes, reduced benefits, or any such thing. You're bending over backward to say that voters want the exact opposite of what they were promised, and that's ridiculous.

I don't know how many people think our Western lifestyles are sustainable. One thing is for sure though. If you're a politician and you admit defeat, and say we can't possibly have the lifestyles we've had for many decades without some kind of awful intervention like a massive war, high taxes, or cuts to essential services, you're guaranteeing your own loss. People want to believe there is a way, and they're not ready to give up their way of life yet just because some politician says they aren't being reasonable or they don't deserve it.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by bruce511 on Sunday December 29, 2024 @08:54AM (#42539956)
>> Again you describe what most politicians do. Trump's lying is not quantitatively nor qualitatively more severe than any other politician at that level, certainly not more than Biden or Kamala.

I'd argue that it is much worse - but each to his own bubble.

>> Need I remind you that Biden pardoned his son for a huge period of time and undisclosed crimes which he himself might be an accomplice?

ahh yes, the mythical Biden crime family... Any minute now there's be some evidence of literally anything - anything at all... No wait, before we get to evidence we'll at least have an idea of what crime he's supposed to have committed? (The drug and gun charges are fair enough - but they're very much related to Hunter - not to Joe.)

>> They are not down for more taxes, reduced benefits, or any such thing.

That's a pity then. 'Cause that's what's coming. That's obvious to anyone who's paid the slightest attention to the Republican agenda for this term. I _assumed_ that voters understood that's what they were voting for - whereas you're correcting me to explain that they were simply duped. (I'm not in the US, so it's hard to see that from here, so thank's for the correction...)

>> I don't know how many people think our Western lifestyles are sustainable. >> ... >> People want to believe there is a way, and they're not ready to give up their way of life yet just because some politician says [it's not possible].

So they cast a vote based on wishful thinking? Ironically I think the current lifestyle is sustainable in the long term, with only minor lifestyle changes. But it would seem then that your voters would prefer to simply pretend the problems don't exist? That they can magically go back to 50 years ago?

I must say, it sounds like you have less faith in the US voter than I do...

>> it explicitly denied that any benefits would be cut or taxes increased (except for the tariffs).

I mean sure, if you call it a "tariff" not a "tax" then maybe it sounds better. But they're the same thing no? Given that it was such a focal point of the platform I'm pretty sure Republican voters understand that.

On the benefits front - a target cut of $2 trillion was made very clear. Looking at govt spending how exactly can that number be reached _without_ cutting benefits?

I guess the next 4 years will play out, and either it'll be better or worse. My money is on worse (just based on the economic impact of the policies already announced) but I don't have a crystal ball, so I guess anything is possible...

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by wakawaka28 on Sunday December 29, 2024 @10:34PM (#42546192)
>ahh yes, the mythical Biden crime family... Any minute now there's be some evidence of literally anything - anything at all... No wait, before we get to evidence we'll at least have an idea of what crime he's supposed to have committed? (The drug and gun charges are fair enough - but they're very much related to Hunter - not to Joe.)

What more evidence do you need besides Biden pardoned his son in general for any and all offenses he committed in a 10 year period? The laptop has been acknowledged by even the pro-Democrat media now, after years of trying to bury the story and censor everyone on the topic. There is evidence of crimes related to Hunter's position on the board of Burisma, a Ukrainian oil company. Biden had a lot of political protection to cover this up which is falling apart now.

>So they cast a vote based on wishful thinking? Ironically I think the current lifestyle is sustainable in the long term, with only minor lifestyle changes. But it would seem then that your voters would prefer to simply pretend the problems don't exist? That they can magically go back to 50 years ago?

>I must say, it sounds like you have less faith in the US voter than I do...

I say it's wishful thinking because the bottom line is we are going deeper and deeper into debt, outsourcing everything, and this election is the first sign in a long time that the public is waking up to their own demise.

>On the benefits front - a target cut of $2 trillion was made very clear. Looking at govt spending how exactly can that number be reached _without_ cutting benefits?

That was quite literally a random number that the campaign picked. I don't think they know how to cut $2 trillion. They promised not to cut benefits. Ending the wars might help, and maybe some things can be made more efficient. But a noticeable reduction in government benefits won't fly.

>I guess the next 4 years will play out, and either it'll be better or worse. My money is on worse (just based on the economic impact of the policies already announced) but I don't have a crystal ball, so I guess anything is possible...

My money is on worse. Not because Trump has the wrong idea, but because it's never gone any other way in my lifetime really, and I don't think he is a magician. I think a lot of people recognize that we're in a lot of trouble but don't see a way out. They can't even stop their jobs from being given to foreign workers and overseas companies. Many of them are struggling to get by. I myself make "good" money but I don't know when or if I will be able to buy a house or retire. Don't even get me started on the dating/marriage market.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by devops99 on Sunday December 29, 2024 @02:40AM (#42538367)
> Trump lies all the time.

Of course the politician does this, but if you think this somehow granted you carte blanche to write out of your ass you are a special kind of delusional.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by wakawaka28 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @11:46PM (#42537601)
>Social Security and Medicare are unpopular to cut, but its easily done, and a necessity to make significant cuts. I think the electorate has given a mandate to the govt to do this, do I expect they'll do it. (Trump campaigned on this, so its pretty much what people clearly want.)

No he didn't campaign on this. It's not easily done either. You're talking about people's families who paid into the system and were promised to be paid, and their kids certainly aren't going to be paying those bills when nobody is doing great financially speaking.

Maybe the government's promises can't be kept, but the politician that voluntarily casts the elderly into destitution or drastically increases taxes on workers is not going to last long.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by krapp on Saturday December 28, 2024 @01:53PM (#42533430)
On what basis? There is no right to employment in the US Constitution, and companies are simply practicing good capitalism by purchasing the most effective workforce at the lowest cost from a global labor pool.

If you want to live in a society where your life has value beyond that which a market rapidly converging on slave labor and AI can extract from you, I guess maybe move to a country where "socialism" isn't a dirty word.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by thatcat on Saturday December 28, 2024 @02:28PM (#42533742)
There is no right to globalism in the constitution either: any and all of those behaviors can and should be regulated if it is in the best interest of the US citizens.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by krapp on Saturday December 28, 2024 @02:48PM (#42533934)
There is no right to globalism, and thus the US government isn't forcing companies to be globalist. Globalism is simply the inevitable result of capitalist incentives in the global marketplace, and the US has benefited greatly from it. Not all Americans, obviously, but certainly those that capitalism is intended to benefit (the capitalist class.)

And I guess the petite-bougeousie of the American tech class is getting a rude awakening that they're just labor after all, and thus not entitled to eat from the table they set.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by thatcat on Saturday December 28, 2024 @03:52PM (#42534613)
>inevitable result of incentives

Market incentives are influenced by policies the US gov sets, so globalist capitalists monopolizing US markets is the inevitable result of US gov policies. Ever heard of Anti-trust laws? They could be updated for the global economy any time.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by krapp on Saturday December 28, 2024 @04:18PM (#42534834)
Banning all American companies from outsourcing or hiring foreigners would result in complete financial isolation, collapse and likely balkanization of the US, and ironically far worse employment prospects for Americans than currently exist. All modern Western capitalist power depends upon the exploitation of a foreign underclass.

Yes, theoretically, the US could pursue its own Sakoku as a suicidal policy of "nativist" self-reliance but the premise that they ever would is ridiculous. I know people in this thread couldn't care less, but policy is set by people who actually do.

Americans can compete with Indian, Chinese and Mexican labor when they're willing to work for Indian, Chinese and Mexican wages, end of.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by thatcat on Saturday December 28, 2024 @05:50PM (#42535527)
why would an american with a high cost of living (result of policy choices) be expected to work for a mexican wage? ill work for a mexican wage when i have a mexican cost of living, end of.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by krapp on Saturday December 28, 2024 @07:06PM (#42536094)
>why would an american with a high cost of living (result of policy choices) be expected to work for a mexican wage?

Because they're competing against Mexicans who will do the job at that wage, and probably automation and AI, and there is no universe in which American companies simply decide to spend more on local labor without commensurate benefit. It isn't any American employers' problem that the market has determined the value of US labor to be less than the cost of living, and not worth investing in.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by snihalani on Sunday December 29, 2024 @02:00AM (#42538219)
this 100x^
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by thatcat on Sunday December 29, 2024 @03:54AM (#42538644)
Perhaps the company should relocate to india or mexico and enjoy their infrastructure, labor, crime, and culture as a single package. Did you already forget crowdstrike? How much did that cost? Seems like your numbers are missing the tail end risks of reducing standards because that is an externality. Maybe that's why immigration isn't regulated by companies.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by brickfaced on Saturday December 28, 2024 @04:28PM (#42534909)
Just not true. The H1B visa program didn't exist until the 1990s.

In fact, until passage of the Hart-Celler Immigration and Nationality Act of 1965, the US was under strict immigration restrictions established by the Johnson-Reed Act of 1924. During that time we assimilated the Ellis Islanders, beat the Great Depression, out-produced the Axis to win World War 2, split the atom, rebuilt Europe and Japan, electrified the country, fed the world with our Green Revolution, invented the transistor, cured polio, invented the integrated circuit, and built the Empire State Building, Golden Gate Bridge, Hoover Dam and interstate highway system. Cheap tech labor benefits a small club of men at the top, such as Elon and paulg. It is not essential to the success or prosperity of America or the American people.

An America where children must study 24/7 and work 80 hours a week as slavish, soulless drones to compete with indentured servants from every corner of the world is not a country I want to live in. It's not the country I was promised nor the future I voted for, and I'm going to fight to make sure it doesn't happen.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by krapp on Saturday December 28, 2024 @05:32PM (#42535419)
>During that time we assimilated the Ellis Islanders, beat the Great Depression, out-produced the Axis to win World War 2, split the atom, rebuilt Europe and Japan, electrified the country, fed the world with our Green Revolution, invented the transistor, cured polio, invented the integrated circuit, and built the Empire State Building, Golden Gate Bridge, Hoover Dam and interstate highway system. Cheap tech labor benefits a small club of men at the top, such as Elon and paulg. It is not essential to the success or prosperity of America or the American people.

To be clear, you're implying that all of these things, specifically, were the result of American anti-immigration policies and high wages for American workers?

Because I'm pretty sure America needed plenty of foreign help to split the atom, and that socialist programs like the WPA built much of the infrastructure you're talking about, and the interstate highways were built by government contractors and prison labor. And Americans may have invented the transistor, but the patents originated with Canadian, Austrian and German research. Of course, the cheap labor of manufacturing in China and elsewhere in Asia is responsible for the ubiquity and low cost of just about all electronics sold in the US. Almost everyone has something made by Sony or Panasonic, but no one has a Zenith TV anymore.

The "Green Revolution"... depended entirely on the cooperation of foreign governments, investment and labor. The US absolutely did not "feed the world with our Green Revolution," just as the US did not "win World War 2."

>Cheap tech labor benefits a small club of men at the top, such as Elon and paulg. It is not essential to the success or prosperity of America or the American people.

What's funny is that we're here on a board built for and primarily used by Silicon Valley tech people who make six figure salaries on the back of that labor, from H1-B visaholders to the South Americans cleaning their toilets down to the child slaves mining rare earth elements in the Congo, and were fine with it up until someone talked about them the way they talk about the foreign help.

And let's not pretend tech was ever about the success or prosperity of America or the American people. Ya'll got in it because you wanted to exit a billionaire like Zuckerberg or Musk with a little effort and a bullshit gimmick, while someone whose name you can't bother even trying to pronounce serves you a catered lunch at the commissary.

Yeah, sorry, you're just another one of the tomatoes.

>An America where children must study 24/7 and work 80 hours a week as slavish, soulless drones to compete with indentured servants from every corner of the world is not a country I want to live in.

Stop voting for the people who keep making it worse, then. Did you really think the globalist billionaire who never worked a real job and rarely paid his (often foreign) employees was a hero of the working man?

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by thatcat on Saturday December 28, 2024 @06:31PM (#42535835)
>Green Revolution"... depended entirely on the cooperation of foreign governments

Habor-bosch fed the world, green rev was a gift of that refined process to a country that couldn't feed itself.

>And Americans may have invented the transistor, but the patents originated with Canadian, Austrian and German research

which of course would have been useless without boolean logic, invented by an american.

Most of your argument is a straw man against america the narrative. The US civil engineer corps developed the most useful part of our infrastructure - the hydroelectric dams. Historically, I don't think the designs of critical national infrastructure was outsourced to immigrants to save a few bucks because to do so would be shortsighted and irresponsible.

>you voted wrong

as if there was a real choice offered and people should be assumed to have voted wrong and held accountable.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by brickfaced on Saturday December 28, 2024 @08:36PM (#42536612)
>Because I'm pretty sure America needed plenty of foreign help to split the atom

The whole point of my comment was that such truly high-skilled immigrants were able to arrive and thrive during the term of the Johnson-Reed Act. The rest of your critique on that point is ill-founded and irrelevant.

>Almost everyone has something made by Sony or Panasonic, but no one has a Zenith TV anymore.

Yes, tariffs will be needed to reshore those industries.

>The "Green Revolution"... depended entirely on the cooperation of foreign governments, investment and labor. The US absolutely did not "feed the world with our Green Revolution," just as the US did not "win World War 2."

You'd do well to read a biography of Norman Borlaug. He did a lot more than repackage Haber-Bosch. American charity during the 1960s and 70s is the only reason tens if not hundreds of millions of Indians are alive today. Whether that's ultimately in America's best interest remains to be seen.

The sweeping socialist polemics and corny "y'all" was very funny, thanks for the laugh.

Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by w4ffl35 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @02:23PM (#42533697)
Bringing down the American economy when there is no shortage of American workers. I'm no advocate of socialism. And I'm anti-globalization.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by wakawaka28 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @11:55PM (#42537634)
No, "We the People" grant property rights and other favors to businesses. If they act against the best interests of the country then they can be appropriately taxed. There's no need to resort to full blown communism on account of unpatriotic behavior from our businesses.
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by aio2 on Saturday December 28, 2024 @02:15PM (#42533630)
No it shouldn't be lol
Re:Ask HN: Are you unable to find employment? by psiconaut on Saturday December 28, 2024 @02:16PM (#42533642)
You can always migrate.