News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by coliveira on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @10:45AM (#42442288)
That's not true at all. Law is written like it is because courts give a lot of importance to what is written and changes in these written forms have many possible consequences. This, combined with the fact that our judicial principles go very far back (starting already in ancient times with the Romans), makes it very inconvenient to change language and terms used.
Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by jimmydddd on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @11:37AM (#42442778)
This is correct. If 50 cases interpret and define the word "includes" in a contract, and you decide to use the word "comprises," you may end up burning time and money in court and negotiations.
Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by unethical_ban on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @12:40PM (#42443382)
Do engineering specifications use the same center embedded sentences as legal documents?

IETF defines may, must, shall, etc. in every document but doesn't use the same format as law.

Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by rbanffy on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @03:29PM (#42444980)
Law and technical standards are two places where language must be extremely precise to avoid misinterpretation. And destroying Mars probes because of mismatched units.
Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by HeyLaughingBoy on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @05:43PM (#42446245)
I have two different but reinforcing memories that support this.

1) I remember being in a Requirements Review meeting and spending an entire hour debating the meaning of a word. Don't remember the word, but it was something like "includes".

2) I separately remember being in a Requirements review for a feature that concluded successfully. Then later in a Design Review for that feature. And after that, Code and Unit Test reviews of the same feature. Then, months later, the feature was presented to the person who asked for it in the first place and then said, "that's not what I wanted. I wanted xxx instead."

Yes, this person was at the Requirements and Design reviews!

Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by rbanffy on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @02:54PM (#42454321)
Oh… also detectives. My colleagues say I don’t interview users. They say I interrogate them.
Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by unethical_ban on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @05:55PM (#42446327)
Agreed. My point is that engineering documents read differently than legal documents, but have the same necessity for precision.
Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by rbanffy on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @03:31PM (#42445000)
This would be a good case for restricted versions of our commonly used languages with as few words and constructs as possible on a simple and consistent grammar. Much like a programming language for defining law.
Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by delfinom on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @03:44PM (#42445126)
But then a contract would never be able to describe modern day inventions, processes or procedures as deliverables lol
Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by kevindamm on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @04:07PM (#42445322)
You could, if you treated the object deliverable as a variable, with variables defined meta-circularly via a pre-representation.

To do it, lawyers would have to learn some category theory, but I think many of them would enjoy it.

Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by rbanffy on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @10:56AM (#42451545)
> but I think many of them would enjoy it.

Many probably discovered it already, without realizing it has a name.

Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by webspinner on Thursday December 19, 2024 @12:36AM (#42458718)
There was a book written about something like that in 1949. Well OK OK I'm half joking, since the book wasn't entirely about that!
Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by seritools on Thursday December 19, 2024 @09:19AM (#42461598)
Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by vivekd on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @06:09PM (#42446446)
In law such words are called terms of art - but most lawyers know them and there's no reason for their use to create incomprehensible documents. It's not like every other word is a term of art.

When I was I law school they taught us to write as clearly as possible and avoid legalese. Hopefully that catches on, I don't think legalese is good or necessary. Clarity is better

Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by MichaelZuo on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @10:09AM (#42451035)
Really the main problem is trust and credibility, or lack thereof. Which necissitates all of these adaptations.

There’s a famous story of Warren Buffet buying Nebraska Furnitur Mart with no paperwork whatsoever, just some verbal assurances, a handshake, and a TV interview with the esteemed owner.

Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by Breza on Friday December 20, 2024 @01:46PM (#42473674)
Well said. I spent years working with an attorney who was first an English major. He wrote the best contracts because his initial focus was making things readable and obvious. The legal formalities came second. I firmly believe that plain language will avoid legal disputes better than PUTTING A BUNCH OF LATIN IN ALL CAPS AD OSTENTATIONEM.
Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by psychlops on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @12:23PM (#42443198)
Despite your opening sentence, you didn't disagree with OP. "Courts" are a venue for other lawyers.
Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by jancsika on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @03:34PM (#42445028)
> Despite your opening sentence, you didn't disagree with OP.

They certainly did.

coliveira is saying a change in legal language opens up a contract to a reasonably different interpretation in the future. And we know it's reasonable (even likely) because there are myriad historical precedents where such ambiguities were used in the past to win cases against, say, GrantMoyer's Optimized Non-Standard Legal Language Law Offices. By using standard language that specific class of ambiguity issues goes away.

On the other hand, any good faith definition of "superstitious" is a pejorative that holds the belief to be irrational. So when GrantMoyer's Optimized Non-Standard Legal Language Law Offices uses its patent-pending optimized, non-standard language in their contracts, they are throwing out all the superstitious terminology on the basis that nothing bad will actually happen as a result of doing this. (At least, aside from things like random chance or any of the other true reasons that just happen coincide with superstitious falsehoods.) That's a bad idea-- it isn't supported by historical precedent, and it is likelihood to cause predictably bad outcomes in the future.

The only mitigating factor is this weasel sentence:

"Except sometimes the superstitions are right."

But to be generous we must take that to mean only the truism that superstition sometimes coincides with things like random chance. (Otherwise it'd be like saying no one goes to a particular restaurant anymore because it's so crowded, which is funny but incoherent.)

Edit: clarifications. Also, in closing, Your Honor, I call for one of those "bad court thingies." :)

Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by snowfarthing on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @01:38PM (#42453438)
I like to use the word "superstition" to describe my attempts to prevent migraines by wearing sunglasses, eating chocolate, and avoiding orange juice. I only have vague corollaries to believe these are helpful (particularly since I don't get migraines often, as awful as it is when I get hit by one), so it's not fair to attribute any of these with certainty -- but it's also not fair to dismiss them out of hand, either.

Sure, some "superstitions" are the result of random folklore, and can be ignored without consequence. (Knock on wood!) But others are the result of meme-ized facts, passed on via something that's folklorish and easy to remember to share.

Thus, it is fair to use the word "superstition" to describe something you think might be harmless, but may actually have serious consequences, if ignored, after all.

Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by Dylan16807 on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @11:41PM (#42458481)
I'm pretty sure "superstition" was meant more weakly and "sometimes they are right" was meant more strongly than you're interpreting it.

It's irrational to think the awkward phrasing is actually better, but when you're being judged by other people sometimes they're going to enforce the bias.

Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by sdwr on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @12:40PM (#42443380)
There's a constant tendency here to assume other people don't think, they blindly copy what's popular.

Everybody learns partially through pattern recognition, partially from trial and error, partially from armchair reasoning. And functions mostly by repeating what they already know.

But it's emotionally satisfying to put all the negative parts onto others (cargo cult sheeple reciting magic spells), and save all the positive identifiers for yourself (brave scientist uncovering truths about the universe)

Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by Dylan16807 on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @02:05PM (#42444206)
Okay, but I don't see that happening here? Like, nobody is comparing my code to legalese. And if they did, I'd apologize profusely if normal people had to interact with my source code on a regular basis! I wouldn't try to defend writing it the same way I write it when a single digit number of people have to read it ever. And lots and lots of people have to read and follow laws.
Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by freejazz on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @02:42PM (#42444521)
Laws are precise, unlike your posts here, which are obtuse.
Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by FuriouslyAdrift on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @03:04PM (#42444758)
When I worked at a law firm that specialized in corporate law (in IT), they had a dedicated team just to find ways to exploit errors with wording and commas in contracts.
Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by rbanffy on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @03:32PM (#42445003)
Lawyers and hackers are very similar professions.
Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by singleshot_ on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @03:36PM (#42445036)
I would tend to disagree with that, but if you’re also an attorney with a cybersecurity background, I’d love to know why you think this.
Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by mewpmewp2 on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @04:40AM (#42449197)
What about any sort of inspectors who try to find flaws in things, like e.g. buildings or otherwise?
Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by ursamin on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @03:38PM (#42445062)
language lawyer: This is using a restricted (and much aligned) meaning of the word "hacker" and not the one codified by members of Hacker News.
Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by fragmede on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @03:50PM (#42445188)
(maligned)
Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by ValentineC on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @09:07AM (#42450510)
Just being pedantic and curious here: I'm assuming you're using "lawyer" casually with a "language" qualifier, not authorised to give professional legal advice, or specialising in legal language nuances?
Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by rbanffy on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @10:55AM (#42451527)
> specialising in legal language nuances?

Hackers (in the HN sense) also excel with programming language nuances.

Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by Galacta7 on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @05:21PM (#42446020)
See also theologians and philosophers (also good at finding loopholes in theories).
Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by IshKebab on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @06:20AM (#42449630)
The article disagrees with your comment. They found that the plainer English laws would be no less enforceable.

Here's an example. Patent lawyers absolutely love the word "plurality", a very uncommon word in normal English. They mean "more than one", but why don't they say that? It's not only clearer but it's also less ambiguous (check the many definitions of "plurality").

It's because they are copying a rule without thinking about it. Other examples of that:

* "an historical occasion" - this is wrong, it's "a historical occasion", but people hear it and think it's some special rule

* Not using "I" in research papers, even with a single author! There's no rule that requires this but people think there is. I read a paper once that used "I". It was great.

Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by lupire on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @11:08AM (#42451692)
"an historical" is because that's more fluid to pronounce, not because of a false rule.
Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by cgriswald on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @12:06PM (#42452370)
The use of “an” with “history” is likely a holdover of its French origins where the h isn’t pronounced or from English dialects where the h isn’t pronounced. It’s essentially a learned behavior at this point. If it was used solely because of ease of pronunciation we’d expect also to see “an history”, “an high five”, “an hit record”.

But, in any case, for those who pronounce the h, “a historical” is easier to say.

In the case of lawyers I’d suspect tradition first and fear of typos reversing meaning (“ahistorical”) second.

Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by IshKebab on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @04:08PM (#42455220)
So you would say "an history lesson"? No.
Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by dpe82 on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @05:51PM (#42456390)
I say "an historical event" and I also say "a history lesson".
Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by IshKebab on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @06:08PM (#42456521)
Precisely. That is incorrect because the purpose of "an" is to make the first part of a word easier to say, and "historical" and "history" start in exactly the same way.

You're only doing it because you've heard other people do it and you think there's some special rule for it. Maybe subconsciously even.

And don't say "you can't say something is wrong in language because prescriptivism Vs descriptivism etc."

Yes generally it is the case that language is defined by how it is used. This is an exception, where something has a very very clear purpose and usage, and you're doing it wrong.

I actually can't think of any clearer cases where the prescriptivists are right. It would have to be something so obvious you don't even think about it, like using spaces between words. Yet for some reason everyone messes up "a historical". It's as bizarre as if everyone omitted spaces before "historical" but not "history" or any other words.

Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by dpe82 on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @08:23PM (#42457371)
Hah, ok.

The grammar police have yet to pull me over. I'll continue speaking as I do, thank you.

Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by eynsham on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @12:06PM (#42452367)
> ‘an historical occasion’ - this is wrong

There is nothing wrong with the use of ‘an’ before ‘history’ and the forms of that lemma. It is unusual, and perhaps pretentious or otherwise silly, but only in the same way as ‘connexion’ is an unusual (&c) but perfectly correct spelling.

Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by IshKebab on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @04:07PM (#42455207)
It is one of the few things in language that definitely is wrong.

The point of saying "an" instead of "a" is to make it easier to say a following word that starts with a soft sound (there's probably a technical term).

"A igloo" is hard to say, so we change it to "An igloo" which is a lot easier.

"A history lesson" is not hard to say so there's no need for "an".

Have you ever said "an history lesson" or even heard anyone say that?

No. Of course not.

Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by sfn42 on Thursday December 19, 2024 @10:21AM (#42462252)
I would assume it has to do with the next word. You wouldn't say "a occasion", you say "an occasion" so then it's natural to say "an historical occasion" as well.

Not arguing correctness, just intuition.

Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by JoshuaDavid on Thursday December 19, 2024 @02:02PM (#42464643)
It depends on pronunciation, not on the first letter. This is why you say "an MBA" not "a MBA". If you are from a region that pronounces "historic" as "'istoric", then "an historic occasion" sounds fine and "a historic occasion" would sound weird.
Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by eynsham on Friday December 27, 2024 @04:38PM (#42526284)
> Have you ever

Yes, often.

Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by snowfarthing on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @01:29PM (#42453336)
I like to use words like "thus", "hence", and "therefore" a lot -- but this is because, as a mathematician, I picked up a style of writing that has been deeply influenced by the mathematics I learned.

For that matter, the first day I was in Great Britain, I noticed that the other Americans I met had British accents, and I noticed in the few hours talking with them, I was already picking up on the accent myself.

It's only natural to pick up the language and idioms of the cultures you happen to be immersed in!

(And this applies to Law and Engineering as much as anything else, too.)

Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by IshKebab on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @06:11PM (#42456536)
I agree, but "thus", "hence" and "therefore" are fairly normal words. "Plurality" and the grammatical structures of lawyers are on another level.

I would say maths has its own issues with language accessibility, but they're a bit different from law. Probably the biggest problem is naming everything after people instead of coming up with meaningful names.

Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by DiggyJohnson on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @06:21PM (#42456611)
I'm writing a nonfiction book about why people play a certain video game. It's been interesting to switch between 'I' for when I'm making a novel or specific point and 'we' when I need the first person but what I'm saying is the consensus point or common experience. I recommend the same in academic writing. I'm sure that this is a flamewar topic now that I think about it though, aha.
Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen... by coliveira on Thursday December 19, 2024 @12:06AM (#42458578)
Agreed, I'm a proponent of using "we" in technical communication, because the "I" is not important and should not be emphasized. This goes against popular writing advice, but I don't think the advice is good.