Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen...
by rbanffy on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @03:29PM
(#42444980)
Law and technical standards are two places where language must be extremely precise to avoid misinterpretation. And destroying Mars probes because of mismatched units.
Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen...
by HeyLaughingBoy on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @05:43PM
(#42446245)
I have two different but reinforcing memories that support this.
1) I remember being in a Requirements Review meeting and spending an entire hour debating the meaning of a word. Don't remember the word, but it was something like "includes".
2) I separately remember being in a Requirements review for a feature that concluded successfully. Then later in a Design Review for that feature. And after that, Code and Unit Test reviews of the same feature. Then, months later, the feature was presented to the person who asked for it in the first place and then said, "that's not what I wanted. I wanted xxx instead."
Yes, this person was at the Requirements and Design reviews!
Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen...
by rbanffy on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @02:54PM
(#42454321)
Oh… also detectives. My colleagues say I don’t interview users. They say I interrogate them.
Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen...
by unethical_ban on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @05:55PM
(#42446327)
Agreed. My point is that engineering documents read differently than legal documents, but have the same necessity for precision.
IETF defines may, must, shall, etc. in every document but doesn't use the same format as law.