News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by reaperman on Friday November 29, 2024 @10:36PM (#42279179)
So, I do this type of AI development for solving CAPTCHAs.

I can't get any real jobs that pay me for my more advanced skills. My primary sins were going to a second/third-tier university and some performance concerns in a portion of my previous roles due to divorce and burn-out. I make $80k/year in government IT, and $30-150k/year as the "AI" guy in a small 2-5 person group that offers a CAPTCHA-breaking API.

The spammers aren't the ones replicating this. They just pay B2B rates (combo of SaaS + Consulting, depending on client needs) to help them remove the roadblocks.

Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by blackjackfoe on Friday November 29, 2024 @11:01PM (#42279288)
Is your company hiring? :)
Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by benreesman on Saturday November 30, 2024 @03:44AM (#42280410)
If there were a totally 100% aboveboard way to do this in a net transfer of utility from Tessier-Ashopool SA to the typical web surfer I would be a superfan.
Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by HeckFeck on Saturday November 30, 2024 @07:46AM (#42281280)
Why do you do this?

While I can appreciate the technical achievement, you know most users of forums and imageboards don’t want any AI content at all.

Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by KomoD on Saturday November 30, 2024 @09:11AM (#42281721)
> Why do you do this?

Money, obviously. I'd also do it for $30-150k/year

> you know most users of forums and imageboards don’t want any AI content at all.

He's not creating or posting any "AI content"?

Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by HeckFeck on Saturday November 30, 2024 @09:57AM (#42281959)
Okay, but you know his actions are enabling more AI content and spam to proliferate? I hardly think he is making that much money just because legitimate users don't want to fill in a captcha.
Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by brookst on Saturday November 30, 2024 @10:34AM (#42282116)
It’s very easy to opine about the ethics others should have. Different when it’s you and your family and a comparatively easy effort will make a material difference in quality of life. And especially when you know ghe market need will be met by someone else anyway.
Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by HeckFeck on Saturday November 30, 2024 @11:23AM (#42282359)
So you get a bit richer for less effort... but how do you think moderating legions of spam posts affects the lives of independent website owners, who just want to create communities around the things they love?

Or indeed the users, who have to wade through trash invading their threads?

Or other legitimate users, who now have to answer captchas from CloudFlare just to access their favourite websites?

Ultimately this is a parasitical element, choking the internet. It will kill the things it profits from. Many will give up running these sites, you walk away with your $100k, and no one can ever do it again... you've not created anything of value, but destroyed it.

Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by idiotsecant on Saturday November 30, 2024 @11:44AM (#42282478)
Yes, people often do unsavory things for money. Is the point you're making that they shouldn't do bad things. Like, what are we even talking about here?

The lesson here is that systems that rely on humans to do the 'moral' thing and fail otherwise are bad systems.

Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by Jerrrry on Saturday November 30, 2024 @11:42AM (#42282471)
Hard to think anyone who can't solve a captcha is something other than a parasite.

Parasites can solve captchas, people with accessibility issues and the poorest of people are the one being locked out.

Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by lostlogin on Saturday November 30, 2024 @01:40PM (#42283209)
It isn’t just those with accessibility problems that get stuck. Some are stupidly difficult- I’ve given up on one in recent times.

Maybe my disability is CAPTCHA blindness.

Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by marcosdumay on Saturday November 30, 2024 @02:29PM (#42283472)
Captchas are not only for stopping people with disabilities anymore. They also stop people using non-approved browsers, people trying to stay anonymous, people coming from the wrong geographic areas...
Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by TZubiri on Saturday November 30, 2024 @04:58PM (#42284327)
If the AI has access to a credit card, but Mgulu from Nigeria doesn't, then the system doing the filtering might evolve to filter out the 'undesirable' rather than the non human.
Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by gosub100 on Saturday November 30, 2024 @12:44PM (#42282888)
HN moderates spam without the use of AI-crackable "prove you're a human" bs
Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by jrflowers on Saturday November 30, 2024 @02:26PM (#42283454)
> So you get a bit richer for less effort

If $150k/year is “a bit richer” for you you could simply offer to pay that poster that much in exchange for stopping.

Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by gopher_space on Saturday November 30, 2024 @04:10PM (#42284055)
Let us know who you work for and I'm sure we could find a few stones to throw your way.
Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by kristopolous on Saturday November 30, 2024 @04:42PM (#42284247)
I had no idea I'd see so many people rising in defense of bots and scammers.
Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by b___________ on Sunday December 01, 2024 @06:03AM (#42287709)
A lot of people on this website are directly responsible for making botting and scamming easier to pull off. It's kind of necessary for them to find justifications for them so they can sleep soundly.
Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by kristopolous on Sunday December 01, 2024 @09:41AM (#42288665)
Hn is like that sometimes. You read a thread and think "well I guess I'm alone on what I think is a perfectly reasonable position"

The other one that comes to mind is anacap, which I view as fringe. I read the comment threads sometimes and it leaves me with the impression that I'm the only one that thinks Von Mises and Rothbard are a bit out there.

Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by TZubiri on Saturday November 30, 2024 @04:56PM (#42284309)
This sounds so out of touch, you are comparing the livelihood of a person with the quality of a meme imageboard.
Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by IWeldMelons on Saturday November 30, 2024 @11:20AM (#42282343)
If someone is making a brazen statement of being "a bad guy because 80K is not enough, and could not find anything decent for those extra $30K" what kind of treatment would they expect?
Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by xp84 on Saturday November 30, 2024 @01:23PM (#42283125)
I’d argue that someone cracking CAPTCHAs has a lot less dirty hands than someone who works in an actually scummy industry like US health insurance. Those companies literally kill people by denying them care to pinch pennies. This guy might cause a little more spam on the already useless mess that is YouTube comments. Who cares. I’d take the money, too.
Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by IWeldMelons on Saturday November 30, 2024 @01:31PM (#42283163)
Typical US-centric way of thinking. If your healthcare system is crippled it does not justify making internet mess for everyone else in the world.
Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by lostlogin on Saturday November 30, 2024 @01:44PM (#42283228)
I’d have suggested adtech before health insurers.
Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by RHSman2 on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @12:57PM (#42309037)
Tobacco pays real well
Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by marcosdumay on Saturday November 30, 2024 @02:35PM (#42283505)
To be fair, there's a huge amount of people around here that work on the universal surveillance industry, and for many of them the alternative is way higher than 80k.
Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by rad_gruchalski on Saturday November 30, 2024 @03:48PM (#42283937)
So says every drug dealer.
Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by qqqult on Saturday November 30, 2024 @04:03PM (#42284013)
I would go a step further. Solving captchas is strictly worse than selling drugs.

All captcha solvers must be imprisoned for life, or worse forbidden to post on hn

Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by gosub100 on Saturday November 30, 2024 @12:42PM (#42282875)
Everyone's got their price. I would certainly do dirty deeds myself for the right amount.
Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by reaperman on Saturday November 30, 2024 @09:09PM (#42285587)
We actually don’t take spam/fraud clients. Granted - there’s a bit of a delicate song+dance with each client, people who are doing spam/fraud usually know better than to admit it outright.

Our group focuses on scraping for lightly-funded LLM startups who cant pay Reddit/X/etc API fees, and data aggregation for cottage industries (price comparison, etc)

But a LOT of the people in our niche do fraud and spam, so we’re steeped in that culture whether we embrace it or reject it.

Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by vkou on Sunday December 01, 2024 @01:50AM (#42286731)
Half this forum works on filling the Internet with crap, and most of the other half work for industries that on the net are making the world a worse place, it's kind of table stakes for getting paid.

Capitalism optimises for value to the customer, not for overall public good.

Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by BolexNOLA on Saturday November 30, 2024 @09:13AM (#42281733)
People who do jobs like that don’t really care about the impact
Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by Der_Einzige on Saturday November 30, 2024 @12:12PM (#42282665)
Being able to spam and mind control 4chan would be amazing just for personal reasons, let alone how juicy that is to governments around the world!
Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by lukas099 on Saturday November 30, 2024 @12:28PM (#42282789)
It's working for the Russians.
Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by noprocrasted on Saturday November 30, 2024 @05:50PM (#42284627)
The percentage of captchas used to deter spam is probably a minority these days. A lot of captchas nowadays are used to prevent adversarial interoperability or the free flow of information.

If you want to spam, you don't actually need to break many captchas. Just make your spam/scam/misinformation "engaging" enough and the social media platforms will host and promote your spam _for free_ and won't even ask a captcha.

Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by reaperman on Sunday December 01, 2024 @12:36PM (#42289547)
This precisely. Our clients are generally looking at adversarial interoperability.

But the rhetoric around the assumption that I was doing it for spammers was also interesting, as well as being more closely related to TFA!

Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by ryandrake on Saturday November 30, 2024 @09:22AM (#42281766)
Despite the spamming angle, I think CAPTCHA-breaking is, on the balance, noble and honorable work. These things are user-hostile blights on the web, and any effort towards making them disappear as useless is worthwhile. Sites worried about spam should invest more in automated spam classification/elimination instead of punishing real users with CAPTCHA-solving. Not that I can offer a solution--if I could, I'd be a millionaire.
Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by persnickety on Saturday November 30, 2024 @02:38PM (#42283529)
Who do you think spam classification false positives are going to be pubishing if not real users? At least with a captcha, you have some idea that you were rejected before you put in the effort to write your comment.
Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by jostinian on Saturday November 30, 2024 @11:37AM (#42282431)
I am a nafri with a PhD and engineering experience (with europeans), I can't make good living going the traditional way either with with remote jobs being impossible and no luck landing a visa.. I have built custom solutions for big name EU companies to keep an eye on the competition through scraping. captcha solving cloudflare bypass is a great part of that. Getting back at companies making the UX bad with captcha does feel good also.
Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by ape4 on Saturday November 30, 2024 @12:03PM (#42282596)
$30-150k/year is a big range
Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by TZubiri on Saturday November 30, 2024 @04:49PM (#42284281)
Ahh the good ole dilemma of selling your soul, you study what you love only to destroy it for profit. Like an entomologist hired by a pesticide company.

I get it man, gotta make the bucks helping spammers advertise their shitty products, even if they destroy the internet.

Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by noprocrasted on Saturday November 30, 2024 @05:45PM (#42284597)
What about the spammers that already destroyed the internet by steering it entirely towards advertising & surveillance capitalism? It's like the pot calling the kettle black.

We're all complicit in the enshittification of the internet and technology in general, just that we delude ourselves into believing we're on the "good" side because we call it "advertising" or "marketing" or "analytics" instead of spam, more spam and spyware.

The end result is exactly the same however.

Re:Breaking the 4Chan CAPTCHA by TZubiri on Sunday December 01, 2024 @01:20PM (#42289773)
If you are referring to google. It's what financially powers most of the free as in beer internet, so hard disagree.

There's a difference between parasites that spam and make 1000 free gmail accounts. And Google.