News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by alberth on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:00AM (#41936181)
What an amazing accomplishment JetBrains has done.

It's a bootstrapped, European company, doing $400M+ annually in revenue selling to developers (who are some of the most difficult buyers to convenience to pay).

https://www.jetbrains.com/lp/annualreport-2023/

Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by MangoCoffee on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:47AM (#41936707)
I do pay for software, even subpar ones like Telerik's controls, for a while.

I used to think I'd just use free open-source software until I became a developer myself.

Now, I believe people should be compensated for their work, even open-source developers who contribute their time and skills for free.

I think you meant Enterprise software that can cost a lot. a developer can't afford that.

Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by princevegeta89 on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:29AM (#41936507)
This company has always impressed me from the get-go. I started my journey with IntelliJ, and it was the best IDE I ever put my hands on. And ever since then, I kept using their other IDEs as well.

Somehow VS Code tried to swing me away from it, but it just never ever came close to whatever JetBrains could offer. And it's only going to keep getting better. It's great that it's now free for non-commercial usage. And when I really work on projects that make money, I don't mind paying $100 a year anyway.

Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by gspencley on Thursday October 24, 2024 @12:00PM (#41936826)
I suspect that JetBrains is trying to respond to the fact that Microsoft gives VSCode away for free and that's likely what is spurring the massive adoption of VSCode.

A colleague of mine at work, who is almost retirement age now and has 10+ years on me in the industry told me that the ONLY reason he uses VSCode is because it's free.

I'm with you, there are IntelliJ features (particularly the refactoring features that I use all the time and couldn't live without) that I just take for granted. And when I watch other devs do things the hard way in VSCode I wonder why it's is so popular. I think most devs just either don't know what they are missing, or it just comes down to cost.

I also often chuckle when people say "Oh there's a VSCode plugin that can do that." I'm not certain, but I don't think I've ever installed a single plugin in IntelliJ because it just does everything I need out of the box.

Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by princevegeta89 on Thursday October 24, 2024 @12:09PM (#41936893)
>> I suspect that JetBrains is trying to respond to the fact that Microsoft gives VSCode away for free and that's likely what is spurring the massive adoption of VSCode.

This is exactly the reason. When people use both VSCode and Jetbrains IDEs, a huge portion of them will end up becoming a Jetbrains user, and on someday, some of them can become paying customers

VSCode infrastructure is pretty broad and the community is pretty large. I only use it to make light code edits here and there but I would never put my whole project in it.

>>I've ever installed a single plugin in IntelliJ because it just does everything I need out of the box. Same here, the only plugins I installed were themes :)

Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by dragonwriter on Thursday October 24, 2024 @12:10PM (#41936898)
I prefer VSCode not mainly directly because it is free, but because a side effect of it being free is that it has support in its exosystem (often, but not always, also free) for everything I want to do, usually well before commercial IDEs. There are some things some commercial IDEs do better for some of the things I do... but none of them have the breadth of functionality in the VSCode ecosystem, and there is value to not switching IDEs for different tasks. And there are plenty of things where the best tool I’ve found is in the VSCode ecosystem, not a commercial IDE.
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by princevegeta89 on Thursday October 24, 2024 @12:28PM (#41937065)
I respect your opinion and what you said makes sense. That said, I find myself only ever using VSCode for "light" edits since it is somewhat faster to open and close from the terminal.
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by sofixa on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:06AM (#41936252)
> who are some of the most difficult buyers to convenience to pay

And who more often than not get their software imposed on by the orgs they work in, so it's doubly complicated - the developers have to be convinced themselves enough to be willing to convince their IT department/fellow developers to pay for.

Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by arkh on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:26AM (#41936469)
Most professional developers in Western countries should have the means to pay for their own license if really needed.
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by recursive on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:45AM (#41936694)
My employer has a policy forbidding the use of software that I personally paid for. Free software is fine for some reason.
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by aniviacat on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:59AM (#41936820)
If your employer allows you to pay for development software, they can get into legal issues.

Companies (depending on jurisdiction) are not allowed to make employees pay for items necessary for work.

And allowing employees to pay can easily be misinterpreted into subtly pressuring employees to pay.

Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by sudhirj on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:56AM (#41936796)
This is usually because the software you pay for yourself has licensing terms that don’t allow commercial use or reimbursement. See the JetBrains personal license terms itself. Understandably, the company will find it easier and cheaper to forbid use than hire a lawyer to check each license for each software that each employee wants to use.
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by jen20 on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:27AM (#41936488)
That doesn’t make it permissible to run the software on company equipment, necessarily.
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by dragonwriter on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:59AM (#41936822)
Yeah, specifically it will frequently (1) violate employer policy to use it on emoloyer equipment if not approved and, providing licensing is required, licensed by the employer, and (2) violate the license of the software to use it when it is not licensed to the employer.
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by sofixa on Thursday October 24, 2024 @02:33PM (#41938243)
It's not about having the means, it's about most companies having policies and processes structured around common software used by all employees in a similar position to allow for collaboration, and to ensure compliance with whatever governance and licenses apply. You don't see orgs where some devs can choose GitHub, others GitLab. IDEs are more interchangeable, of course, but each developer having to set up their own config from scratch (correct plugins, build config, testing framework, etc.) would be a colossal waste of time for no reason.

Some bigger orgs allow flexibility (devs can pick Mac or Linux-based laptops, VS Code or JetBrains as the IDE, etc.), but not bring your own with your own license.

Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by Nullabillity on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:27AM (#41936486)
This seems to be what JetBrains has been betting on for a long time. Don't need to build a competent text editor if you can give management the right buzzwords.
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by homebrewer on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:34AM (#41936566)
Since it's a tool for writing code and not prose, it does not have to be a competent text editor if it's a competent "AST editor", which it very much is. Much more so than any alternative, commercial or otherwise.
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by memsom on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:59AM (#41936817)
I have access to both an MSDN subscription paid through my employer and Rider that I pay for myself. I use Rider over VS2022. Why? VS2022 is slower and way more flaky with Android development. Rider has Resharper built in. I like that I can use 1 IDE vendor's products for everything I need (Pycharm, IntelliJ, Rider, RustRover and Android Studio.)
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by sfn42 on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:36AM (#41936591)
Are you implying that JetBrains ides are not competent?

Compared to their alternatives like Eclipse, Visual Studio etc I think they're a huge step up. If you're a fan of simpler tools like vim, emacs or vscode etc I can see that they may not be to your taste, but I think their products are great. They're easy to get started with, powerful when you learn to use them, relatively bug free and I'd say they significantly boost my productivity.

Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by sourcepluck on Thursday October 24, 2024 @03:28PM (#41938860)
I think that may very well be the first time ever I hear Emacs called a "simple tool"! :L
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by adham-omran on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:59PM (#41942112)
It could be said that all it does is one task, interpret Emacs Lisp, thus simple
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by kazinator on Friday October 25, 2024 @12:35AM (#41942248)
But then we would have difficulty explaining why that one task takes 300,000 lines of C.
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by sfn42 on Friday October 25, 2024 @02:50AM (#41942858)
I don't really know anything about it. In my mind it's similar to vim or vscode, a text editor where you can add lots of functionality but without the customization it probably doesn't do that much useful stuff for you.
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by peutetre on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:03AM (#41936223)
> selling to developers (who are some of the most difficult buyers to convenience to pay).

All of whom, strangely, expect to be paid for their work.

Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by jchw on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:26AM (#41936473)
I dislike this implication that developers are greedy when the real tension is commercial interests vs mutually beneficial communal interests. Of course everyone expects to get paid, but developers love community projects and protect them fiercely because there's no natural force that can. It's all up to the people themselves.

Sure, some minority of people are just greedy and rude. I think most people aren't. As far as being stingy goes, I believe I have paid more for software so far than most people will in their entire life time by probably multiples and I'm happy to continue to do so, and I will also be on every thread about a CLA rug-pull as well, because BS is BS, no two ways about it.

Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by BadHumans on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:39AM (#41936630)
> Sure, some minority of people are just greedy and rude.

You're conflating 2 different things together. I don't think most people are rude. I think most people are greedy.

Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by jchw on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:44AM (#41936680)
They are two things but they are not vastly unrelated. In this context the rudeness would mostly come from entitlement which is definitely related to (and still distinct from) being "greedy".

As far as "most people are greedy" goes, that really comes down to how you quantify "greed" and I really think we're better off agreeing to disagree on this point.

Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by ozim on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:11AM (#41936304)
Given amount of open source available for free I can easily say your statement is totally wrong.
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by desiderantes on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:23AM (#41936435)
Doing charity work does not mean you don't expect to be paid for your regular work. Also, a lot of companies do pay devs to work on open source projects.
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by sangnoir on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:40AM (#41936647)
Open source isn't charity - just like playing non-professional sports isn't charity: the vast majority of participants see it as a hobby or social activity. A minority get paid, and a minority of the minority "break even", but vast majority are playing in self-organized leagues and pick up games, which are in no shape or form charities (even if the public can watch for free as a side-effect).
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by izacus on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:23AM (#41936427)
Huge majority of OSS developers (especially for big projects) are paid for their opensource work too.
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by mnau on Thursday October 24, 2024 @12:00PM (#41936830)
The 2024 Tidelift state of the open source maintainer report (https://explore.tidelift.com/2024-survey) disagrees. And that is probably the most comprehensive one that actually favors large projects, because of Tidelift business model.

> The portion of respondents who reported they are unpaid hobbyists remains at 60 percent, the same as in last year's survey.

Only 12% checked "I'm a semi-professional maintainer, and earn most of my income from maintaining projects." 24% checked "some of my income from maintaining projects"

Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by izacus on Thursday October 24, 2024 @12:04PM (#41936858)
The site keeps shoving a data colleciton popup in my face so I can't read it - what's the sample/methodology for a "maintainer" here? Do they normalize against the usage of their output projects at all?

Are those projects the size of Jetbrains IDEs - e.g. Linux kernel, ffmpeg, VIM, Emacs, etc. ?

Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by monsieurbanana on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:46AM (#41936704)
I don't think so. If you're saying that in big projects (e.g. Linux) most developers are paid, sure, but those projects are a drop in the ocean of open source projects. I doubt very much that there are more paid than unpaid OSS developers but neither of us are bringing numbers.
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by javajosh on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:21AM (#41936401)
We expect to get paid for satisfying someone else's requirements. We do not expect to get paid to scratch our own itches.
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by pjmlp on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:21AM (#41936405)
That is exactly the point, those using the free tools expect to be paid, while feeling entitled about those free tools capabilities and zero monetary contributions.
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by mattgreenrocks on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:31AM (#41936533)
Thankfully, most developers aren't like the vocal minority on certain sites (cough) that allege they could write something in a weekend and thus they shouldn't pay for it.
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by fkyoureadthedoc on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:11AM (#41936302)
I'd love to pay for a lot of software and dev stuff. Convincing my job to do so is such a pain that I don't even try. I do pay for WebStorm and DataGrip myself though.
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by mirekrusin on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:33AM (#41936555)
Sadly developers don't have buying power. Microsoft is good example of company which understands it and lobbies its presence through channels that do make those cross company decisions.
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by lolinder on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:39AM (#41936644)
I just pay for a license myself for both work and personal use [0].

I personally have enough buying power to afford it, and it's more than paid for itself over the years by giving me a leg up over coworkers who try to make do with free tools. People I work with think I have some superhuman ability to navigate, understand, and modify huge codebases and don't believe me when I tell them that it's just because I learned how to use JetBrains IDEs fluently.

[0] This is explicitly allowed: https://sales.jetbrains.com/hc/en-gb/articles/207240855-Can-...

Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by mrgoldenbrown on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:52AM (#41936752)
Does your workplace explicitly allow you to use personal software on work equipment, or do you just not mention it and hope nobody notices? Just curious, as not all places would allow this.
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by lolinder on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:54AM (#41936778)
Yes, devs are explicitly allowed to use any editor they want. I'm not the only one who brings my own JetBrains, but I'm in a tiny minority.
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by jmb99 on Thursday October 24, 2024 @01:04PM (#41937416)
This is not common, at least from my experience (in western companies). Even if devs have root (not a given), the policy is generally that employees cannot use paid software that the company hasn’t licensed
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by qsort on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:12AM (#41936307)
> who are some of the most difficult buyers to convenience to pay

Citation very much needed?

Unless you're talking about enterprise software specifically, developers are probably among the most willing to shell out cash for software, it's the general public who seems to be fine with ad-ridden spyware freemium nonsense as long as it's free.

Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by mike_hearn on Thursday October 24, 2024 @12:00PM (#41936823)
It's hard because developers don't usually have spending authority or budget. Often, nor does their manager or their manager's manager. To get the company to buy something you have to escalate to an absurdly high place in the org chart and so devs will often try to cobble something together out of free stuff, even if it's far less efficient, because spending developer time doesn't require permission whereas spending credit card balance does.

Unrelatedly, there's also to some extent an expectation that everything is free, even for commercial users. The most common pricing question I get about my product is "can't you make it free for commercial projects that don't have revenue yet", i.e. effectively asking me to become investors in their own venture. Because often they want to make a product company, but not spend any money to do so.

Source: I run a small software company that sells to developers.

Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by pjmlp on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:23AM (#41936423)
Every single time someone posts about some commercial tool, in a website dedicated initially to startups, there is always a set of replies with half-baked open source alternatives to use instead.
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by dewey on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:21AM (#41936404)
Developers regularly underestimate the work required to build something and will spend a lot of time building something themselves vs buying someone else's tool for $5 / month.

Source: Myself

Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by michaelt on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:19AM (#41936386)
There's a long history of the likes of Redis, MongoDB, Grafana, Terraform etc first releasing their product as free and open source to get adoption, hoping to make money by some indirect means, then relicensing to closed source later on because nobody pays for something they can get for free.

And pretty much all major programming languages and libraries are given away for free too. Someone tries to introduce BitKeeper, a commercial version control system, for the Linux kernel? They won't stand for it, some's gotta clone it and give the clone away for free.

Hell, I've heard loads of people here on HN complaining when a SaaS company introduces features exclusively useful to large corporations - like single-sign-on integration - then wants to get paid for them.

There's a handful of exceptions. For example game developers will pay $$$ for "Unity" and store their assets in "Perforce" and suchlike. And I believe it's possible to pay for Visual Studio.

Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by pjc50 on Thursday October 24, 2024 @12:09PM (#41936894)
This is where remembering the free-costless and free-libre distinction is important. Linux is free-libre, so it's natural that it insists on its dependencies being free-libre.

Free-libre is necessarily also free-costless, but not the other way round.

> Visual Studio

It's interesting that everywhere I've worked as a Microsoft shop happily pays for MSDN, which gives you not just VS but a huge amount of other stuff.

Perforce handles large binary assets much better than git. There are also paid for closed version control systems that are really bad but get used anyway, such as in IC design.

Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by shaky-carrousel on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:52AM (#41936761)
People usually dislike bait and switch schemes.
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by crop_rotation on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:17AM (#41936366)
No, non developers are more likely to buy software for what they need for their profession (that is why tons of terrible software exists everywhere for such tasks). Ad ridden spyware is mostly for consumption things like games and random websites. On HN every now and then you will see people saying you can do anything with nano and vim/emacs and only recently some of them have started using LSP. Anything that is not totally free and open source gets 100 denials on HN.
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by pjmlp on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:19AM (#41936391)
It is the new Borland, hopefully they won't follow into the Inprise phase.
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by corytheboyd on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:43AM (#41936675)
This isn’t a rebuttal, just my complementary $0.02 on top.

It’s more complicated than “developers are cheap”. They understand software complexity, and when paying is justified. They know what a clear online grift looks like. They have and make free software. I’m happy to pay the JetBrains subscription because it’s actually good enough to warrant the price. You can’t trick a carpenter into buying a poorly build and/or overpriced cabinet by putting a fancy handle on it.

Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by TiredOfLife on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:14AM (#41936333)
Now they are european. They started as fully Russian company. But they are a truly rare example of a company that actually left russian market. Unlike Apple or LG.
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by kimixa on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:26AM (#41936476)
I always thought the company was Czech? Though I think the founders were Russian nationals.

I guess it depends on what you consider a "Russian Company".

As a British national living in the USA, does that mean if I start a company it'll be a "British Company" forevermore?

Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by BjoernKW on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:49AM (#41936726)
Before 2022, their de-facto headquarters and most of their employees were still located in St. Petersburg, even though the main company was registered in Prague.
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by dragonwriter on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:52AM (#41936758)
> Now they are european. They started as fully Russian company.

The heavily populated parts of Russia, including the part where JetBrains was operating, are in Europe. (Russia’s not part of the EU, obviously, but “European” and “EU” don’t mean the same thing.)

Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by piskov on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:39AM (#41936628)
Kudos to Jebrains basically gifting Rider to Russians making it free of mandatory license and possibly malicious cracks
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by einpoklum on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:18AM (#41936379)
Did they have Russian developers and let them go? Or do you mean the ownership has changed?
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by zorgmonkey on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:24AM (#41936441)
My understanding is they relocated the developers who were in Russia
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by lolinder on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:26AM (#41936467)
Correct, though they also lost some who were not willing to relocate.
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by einpoklum on Thursday October 24, 2024 @02:11PM (#41938006)
That's really too bad, and not fair to the Russian developers. More 'collateral damage' from the NATO-Russia conflict.
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by lolinder on Thursday October 24, 2024 @02:14PM (#41938039)
Yeah, it sucks that Putin decided to invade a sovereign nation that was home to a bunch of JetBrains employees.

His war has turned the world upside down in a lot of ways, and I really do feel for the Russians and Ukrainians who he's dragged down with him. I have coworkers who regularly have to take shelter from his bombing campaigns.

Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by exceptione on Thursday October 24, 2024 @04:58PM (#41939692)
Ukraine is not part of Nato, but that would have been a good way to avoid 'conflict'.
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by wiseowise on Thursday October 24, 2024 @05:38PM (#41940091)
> More 'collateral damage' from the NATO-Russia conflict.

What has NATO to do with Russian invasion of Ukraine?

Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by int_19h on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:45PM (#41942040)
Many tech companies that had large dev teams in Russia have mostly relocated them. Acronis is another example of a company that was originally entirely Russian that is out of the market completely, and from what I heard, well over 90% of the devs relocated.

It will be very interesting to see the effects of that brain drain long term.

Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by mathverse on Thursday October 24, 2024 @11:59AM (#41936818)
They are a russian company. Russians despite their evil empire are smart and capable people.
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by weaksauce on Thursday October 24, 2024 @12:12PM (#41936914)
they aren't a russian company. they were founded in the czech republic... they may have been a country that was aligned ideologically with the ussr during the cold war but that's not the same as being russian.

https://blog.jetbrains.com/blog/2022/12/06/update-on-jetbrai...

> The Czech Republic is a member of the United Nations, NATO, the European Union, the OECD, the OSCE, the Council of Europe and the Visegrád Group.

Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by mathverse on Thursday October 24, 2024 @12:16PM (#41936951)
The company is not czech. Russians are an overwhelming majority of the employees.
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by mckravchyk on Saturday October 26, 2024 @04:08AM (#41953353)
A country that was aligned ideologically with USSR is an understatement. They were under occupation as a satellite state. Those people did not sign up for communism in 1945 willingly.
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by charkubi on Thursday October 24, 2024 @12:07PM (#41936884)
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by mathverse on Thursday October 24, 2024 @12:17PM (#41936964)
Majority of employees are russians including the C level
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by SkiFire13 on Thursday October 24, 2024 @12:04PM (#41936862)
It was founded by russian nationals but the company is formally czech and is more connected to the west than to Russia.
Re:JetBrains Rider is now free for non-commercial use by mathverse on Thursday October 24, 2024 @12:16PM (#41936959)
The majority of employees and C-level are russians. It is a Russian company.