News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dookie Demastered by aaronbrethorst on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @01:58PM (#41790805)
This is the best thing I've seen in a long time.

When an album hits a big milestone like its 30th anniversary

Oof, so this is what getting old feels like. Yikes.

Crank it as long as you want with “All By Myself,” arranged for the first time on a hand-cranked music box.

chef's kiss.

Re:Dookie Demastered by lelandfe on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @02:57PM (#41791393)
> this toothbrush plays Green Day’s “Pulling Teeth” while you brush. Finally, you can put Dookie in your mouth (not recommended).
Re:Dookie Demastered by agrippanux on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @03:47PM (#41791885)
When “Out Come The Wolves” by Rancid hit 20 years I was starting to feel my age.
Re:Dookie Demastered by pipes on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @04:40PM (#41792386)
I love this album. So many catchy songs. I prefer it to dookie too.
Re:Dookie Demastered by lawgimenez on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @07:00PM (#41793715)
Easily top 5 punk album of all time.
Re:Dookie Demastered by iwaztomack on Thursday October 10, 2024 @09:52AM (#41798829)
Not punk. Punk is about being bad at your instrument and looking ugly and being the underdog and still creating a community. When Dookie came out, every highschool and college kid was lined up to buy it, it had constant airplay, and was blasting in every classroom and dorm room. That's not punk: that is 100% mainstream pop. Which is Green Day in a nutshell. Commidified dissent x100.
Re:Dookie Demastered by lawgimenez on Thursday October 10, 2024 @10:41PM (#41805528)
I was talking about And out come the wolves, and still punk to me. Pixies is punk, replacements is still punk to me. No need to be a purist.
Re:Dookie Demastered by iwaztomack on Friday October 11, 2024 @07:21PM (#41814897)
College Alternative is not Punk.

I went to Pixies concerts when I was at BU in the 80's. They were a rich white kid college band.

Punk was a very specific movement.

It's like saying, "Yeah, impressionism is same as Cubism." No. It isn't. Don't rewrite history because it suits your invented personality.

Re:Dookie Demastered by SmellTheGlove on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @09:48PM (#41794717)
Everything after it was kind of a disaster though. Although I do have a soft spot for Indestructible.
Re:Dookie Demastered by the__alchemist on Thursday October 10, 2024 @10:23AM (#41799149)
Life Won't Wait and 2000 were fun!
Re:Dookie Demastered by adfm on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @05:43PM (#41793000)
"Energy" is 35. Feeling old yet? If so, go to the Punk Rock Museum in Vegas. They did us right.
Re:Dookie Demastered by SmellTheGlove on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @09:46PM (#41794705)
I just saw Rancid, Smashing Pumpkins and Green Day. All on the same tour. It was amazing to have that much of the first half of my life in one stadium.

Green Day are still in their prime in terms of a live show. Yeah it’s not 3 kids packing a basement anymore, but they absolutely crushed Dookie in their 50s. I felt not old for a couple of hours.

Re:Dookie Demastered by YuriNiyazov on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @11:10PM (#41795098)
Me too (Oracle Park), and I also relate to the not feeling old for a couple of hours - except the few times when I saw parents bring their kids to this show, and the kids were definitely not older than like, nine or ten, and were (!) mouthing the words to songs from Dookie.
Re:Dookie Demastered by codelikeawolf on Thursday October 10, 2024 @09:31AM (#41798612)
Oh wow, I realized it's turning 30 next year and my back just started hurting.
Re:Dookie Demastered by fragmede on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @02:24PM (#41791061)
The mere mention by the title had the classic phrase "Do you have the time..." blaring in my head as if it were thirty years ago, even if the last time I listened to that was at least a decade a ago. The nostalgia, right in the feels.
Re:Dookie Demastered by hluska on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @03:05PM (#41791494)
I hadn’t listened in Dookie in a very long time. Then my kid and I were talking about music and she wanted to know what kinds of music I streamed back in high school. :)

That turned into a talk about CDs and led into listening to Dookie with my eight year old. The album has aged very well. As an adult, I find that different songs are more appealing now than they were as a teen and in other cases, age has warped the meaning of the songs.

But as an album, it stands up really well. There are some other well known albums from the nineties that really haven’t stood up as well. I’d recommend another listen!

Though, “I declare I don’t care no more.” :)

Re:Dookie Demastered by iddan on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @05:41PM (#41792974)
As someone who was a teen about ten years ago I can confess it was still very relevant and I even got its CD (though honestly I listened to it mostly on my iPod Touch)
Re:Dookie Demastered by rhinoceraptor on Thursday October 10, 2024 @04:01AM (#41796652)
I'm 30 now, there's nothing I wanted more than the iPod Touch but I think I made the sales pitch to my parents too hard because I was very excited it had a web browser. I grew up without even basic cable but I did eventually get an iPod classic which I still miss having. I think it eventually met it's fate in the washing machine.
Re:Dookie Demastered by throwup238 on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @09:20PM (#41794617)
> There are some other well known albums from the nineties that really haven’t stood up as well.

Some day Limp Bizkit will get the recognition they deserves.

Re:Dookie Demastered by akiselev on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @09:57PM (#41794761)
A crimes against humanity tribunal at the Hague?
Re:Dookie Demastered by KingMob on Thursday October 10, 2024 @12:27AM (#41795503)
"Nookie Demastered"?
Re:Dookie Demastered by 09thn34v on Thursday October 10, 2024 @08:50AM (#41798280)
finally someone says it. nickelback too
Re:Dookie Demastered by cloverich on Thursday October 10, 2024 @12:22PM (#41800446)
I will say I saw them in concert accidentally once (attending for the headliner, I had no idea they were also playing). I had no real interest in them musically, no hate or anything just no real interest, but wow. They were incredibly good performers compared to the 30 or so other rock bands I'd seen in my youth, easily top 3 performance wise. It really changed my view on the impact a live performance can have on your perceptions of a band and its music.
Re:Dookie Demastered by notjulianjaynes on Friday October 11, 2024 @05:37PM (#41814013)
100 gecs is more or less a Limp Bizkit tribute band IMO.
Re:Dookie Demastered by larodi on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @06:11PM (#41793288)
we definitely gonna rediscover what de-mastering means, when AI finally gets to master everything instead of us. can't wait for a wave of punk-pixel-human-in-the-wrong-loop-nostalgy much stronger than vaporwave.
Re:Dookie Demastered by rhinoceraptor on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @11:09PM (#41795091)
American Idiot also had it's 20th anniversary, I ordered the CD/bluray box set that comes out later this month.
Re:Dookie Demastered by aaronbrethorst on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @11:09PM (#41795093)
Shockingly apt timing.
Re:Dookie Demastered by samplatt on Thursday October 10, 2024 @03:36AM (#41796497)
Well, the first time around was Bush's re-election.
Re:Dookie Demastered by pavlov on Thursday October 10, 2024 @05:13AM (#41797050)
It’s pretty wild that the Republican Party has transformed so much that GWB and Cheney don’t vote for it anymore. It’s only been 16 years since they left office. (Cheney is officially supporting Harris, and Bush clearly is not on Team MAGA either.)
Re:Dookie Demastered by asveikau on Thursday October 10, 2024 @09:37AM (#41798679)
This is off topic, but I don't see Bush/Cheney as very different from Trump, and there is a straight line between those. The biggest contrast is that Trump jettisoned decorum and politeness. Bush was outwardly polite as he enacted the same kind of policy. I mean, the appointment of Samuel Alito is a prime example. Look how the Bush court appointments are unleashed now that they've got a few more like-minded colleagues.
Re:Dookie Demastered by krapp on Thursday October 10, 2024 @09:42AM (#41798730)
Yeah, I don't know why Trump is seen as such an iconoclast and anti-establishment type when politically he's a boilerplate establishment Fox News conservative. His personality is really the only thing that distinguishes him from the pack.
Re:Dookie Demastered by psb217 on Thursday October 10, 2024 @11:37AM (#41799988)
There's a big practical difference between chewing coca leaves and smoking crack. Also, the shift in personality and tone from Bush to Trump are... not small. The inconoclast and anti-establishment things are intentional, effective and, as you note, somewhat hypocritical branding on the part of Trump's PR team. After sitting through a few of his full length >1hr "speeches", it's incredible (in the strongest, most literal sense of that word) that he can even exist as a viable political candidate. If he were magically teleported back in time to the GW Bush years, current Trump would be laughed out of the room in pretty much any political setting.
Re:Dookie Demastered by asveikau on Thursday October 10, 2024 @12:01PM (#41800234)
> If he were magically teleported back in time to the GW Bush years, current Trump would be laughed out of the room in pretty much any political setting.

That's really not how I see it. Trump sits on the shoulders of those who came before and set the stage for the Trump policy. My Alito example above is an instructive one. Bush can be seen as laying a 20 year foundation towards overturning Roe or the Chevron doctrine. I remember when Roberts was appointed, mainstream press talked up how moderate and reasonable he was, but I never bought it -- and how we see he isn't.

The rhetoric appeals to the base... But that base got radicalized by prior eras. Decades of complaining about big government. Fox News demonizing Pelosi and "San Francisco values". Karl Rove's permanent campaign mode. Much of that discourse was fully formed in 2004. The Bush people knew to reign it in sometimes, that is the difference.

Re:Dookie Demastered by psb217 on Thursday October 10, 2024 @01:58PM (#41801440)
In this case I'm talking strictly about his persona, on-stage performance, and overall "vibe". To an extent, these traits are orthogonal to his claimed policy/politics in the traditional sense, which I agree are basically a continuation and in particular areas an amplification of earlier trends in the Republican party. Eg, I grew up in Houston in the 80s and 90s with parents that listened to Rush Limbaugh on a regular basis, so the general direction of intent isn't unexpected. The way in which that intent is expressed is however well outside what would have ever made it to the "main stage" 20-30 years ago. It's a culmination of decades of propagandic ground laying. I suppose "any political setting" was too broad a claim. I was implicitly ignoring anything short of running for national office.
Re:Dookie Demastered by vundercind on Thursday October 10, 2024 @11:15AM (#41799714)
Two things stand out:

1) Positions and messaging strategy. Trump tends to take up the positions you hear Republican voters talk about over a coffee at the diner or over a beer on an aluminum-hull outboard motor fishing boat. As with Democrats, typical Republican planks aren’t terribly close to what their voters want, so (Trump proved) you can win elections by targeting this unmet demand directly.

“Why don’t they just build a wall?”; “Fucking NAFTA, sold us all out”; “gotta do something about that trade deficit with China” and/or other comments on restricting trade with China; “Obamacare sucks” but also kinda vaguely supporting something to fix healthcare (this muddled set of positions came out rather directly in Trump’s speeches—sometimes it’d sound like he was about to advocate single payer); “we should stop being the world police for free” and/or “Europe’s freeloading on NATO”; lots of complaints about illegal immigration’s and crime generally; Washington corruption (“drain the swamp!”); et c.

If you know many Republican voters, not politicians, you may recognize that as stuff that’d inform their wishlist. Trump heard that, and just… did exactly that, turned around and said exactly those things instead of taking up the typical Republican platform. Got him elected. He even sort-of followed through on some of it. This is true for at least the first election, his positions this time seem to have gone a bit more tail-wagging-the-dog (creating issues and demand for a particular solution to the created issue, through messaging, rather than going to where voters already are on existing issues)

2) Relatedly, and especially because he did follow through on some of it, he’s the only big two party Presidential candidate since perhaps 1980 to not be fully on-board with neoliberalism. That’s definitely remarkable. Vance alluded to this at one point in the recent debate.

(Disclaimer because it’s a polarizing topic: observation without condemnation should not be taken as support)

Re:Dookie Demastered by amy-petrik-214 on Sunday October 13, 2024 @01:13PM (#41829686)
Well after Bush and his comrades Dick and Colon (nee Cheney; Powell), we had the TEA PARTY MOVEMENTS whose thesis was very simple: "politicians, as people, they suck, 400 million are suffering for their aggrandizing shittiness, lets get some people in there to fuck some shit up". And so they did, and they did. And this become the new norm. And now DC had been made even further ugly and toxic. Then Trump appeared, and he basically said the same exact thing as the tea party movement "Draiiinnn the Swap!!", and now - yes - even more ugly and toxic.

All of these has been fueled by social media, which to reduce some of the complexities, determined that "if we divide and polarize american politics we make boatloads of money"

Re:Dookie Demastered by ssharp on Thursday October 10, 2024 @08:18AM (#41798099)
Another strange part of getting old:

The gap between Dookie and American Idiot seems significantly longer to me than the gap between American Idiot and today, yet it's half as long :/

Re:Dookie Demastered by icambron on Thursday October 10, 2024 @11:55AM (#41800182)
I notice this one a lot. My sense of time is attached to how much I’ve changed, and my rate of change—-at least for music consumption—-attenuates as I age, dilating time. A couple years can seem like an eon when you’re 14 and each new album transforms you. Now a decade of music feels static and irrelevant and I barely notice it go by.

Related: it sure seemed like the mid-90s were special for rock music; I was 13 when Dookie came out and I felt (still feel) like I was in a sort of alternative renaissance, just crammed with amazing new music. But I’m sure every generation feels that way about whatever happened to be popular when they were teenagers.

Re:Dookie Demastered by xnorswap on Thursday October 10, 2024 @11:50AM (#41800108)
I find this phenomenon fascinating, one's formative years are forever stretched in the mind.

In my head-canon the distance between windows 3.1 and windows 95 is an entire era of computing, likewise the gap between windows 98 and XP.

The reality is that it was just a few years in each of those cases. At my age now a few years seem to go by so fast I can almost forget to run windows update in that time, let alone be mentally invested in learning a new OS entirely. Getting old sure has it's downsides.

Dookie is part of a similar phenomenon, it's "Great old music" and American Idiot is "new rubbish", separated by a gulf of forever in between.

( Please don't take this literally, I'm not actually critiquing either album, just where my own sense of "forever in the past" vs "this is too new" lies. )