News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hinkley Point C: Building Britain's first nuclear reactor... by roenxi on Monday September 23, 2024 @06:21AM (#41624418)
> As the cost of Hinkley Point has increased, the backers have had to provide more funding. The souring of relations between Britain and China saw CGN stop providing any more money, leaving EDF to fund the shortfall. EDF has called upon the UK government to help out with the escalating cost but it has refused. EDF was fully nationalised in 2023, leaving the French taxpayer to pick up the tab for the cost overruns.

That paragraph might be the high point of the article.

Re:Hinkley Point C: Building Britain's first nuclear reactor... by snalty on Monday September 23, 2024 @06:31AM (#41624483)
It's about time our national infrastructure benefitted from foreign taxpayer money, considering how often it's been the other way around! Especially with the railways.
Re:Hinkley Point C: Building Britain's first nuclear reactor... by blitzar on Monday September 23, 2024 @07:38AM (#41624984)
We were laughing at the stupid foreigners who don't understand maths when they bought these things from us. Humble pie is a wonderful dish.
Re:Hinkley Point C: Building Britain's first nuclear reactor... by Hikikomori on Monday September 23, 2024 @06:33AM (#41624500)
Didn't you put yourself in that situation?
Re:Hinkley Point C: Building Britain's first nuclear reactor... by ben_w on Monday September 23, 2024 @06:59AM (#41624681)
In UK elections, because it's not a 2-party system, the winner usually has less than half of the votes.

But even if they didn't, losers don't have to take it quietly.

But even if they did, governments are complex representatives, not ongoing referendums on each individual topic, so we can agree with 80% of the party we vote for and strongly disagree with the rest of their policies.

The cynical alternative is that democracy is a way to get everyone to shut up: if you voted for them it's your fault, if you voted against them you need to obey the will of the people (if you voted for a minor party you wasted your vote), if you're too young to vote then you're naïve to real issues, and if you didn't vote at all then you silenced yourself.

(Sometimes I'm the cynic).

Re:Hinkley Point C: Building Britain's first nuclear reactor... by pjc50 on Monday September 23, 2024 @07:51AM (#41625078)
> democracy is a way to get everyone to shut up

Democracy is a way to get people to acquiesce without violence. If you look at history, it's remarkable how common insurgencies and succession crises or breakaway warlords are.

Re:Hinkley Point C: Building Britain's first nuclear reactor... by tonyedgecombe on Monday September 23, 2024 @08:40AM (#41625416)
It's like a release valve, no point in going out rioting if you can vote the bastards out in the next election.
Re:Hinkley Point C: Building Britain's first nuclear reactor... by imtringued on Tuesday September 24, 2024 @05:47AM (#41634849)
This is also how most professional licensing works. The idea isn't that the license guarantees quality, it's that the license can be revoked when the licensee in question makes an egregious mistake.

Democracy isn't about voting people in. A monarchy or dictatorship can be voted in and stay permanently. The point is to vote people out of power.

Re:Hinkley Point C: Building Britain's first nuclear reactor... by mncharity on Tuesday September 24, 2024 @06:04PM (#41641455)
A recent discussion[1] suggests China's ~500 CE Keju imperial exam was designed as a royal ranking system to reduce violent political fights between noble houses. But at a cost of stagnated innovation.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41624827

Re:Hinkley Point C: Building Britain's first nuclear reactor... by Gud on Monday September 23, 2024 @07:43AM (#41625016)
*representative democracy, the lowest form of democracy.
Re:Hinkley Point C: Building Britain's first nuclear reactor... by inglor_cz on Monday September 23, 2024 @07:01AM (#41624696)
FPTP systems suffer from a very high percentage of wasted votes. If voting systems were judged like normal IT systems, FPTP would be considered defective by design.
Re:Hinkley Point C: Building Britain's first nuclear reactor... by DrScientist on Tuesday September 24, 2024 @04:57AM (#41634559)
FPTP has the redeeming property of being unstable. A fully proportional system ends up with a status quo, with people who are good at doing deals in power - this an recipe for a cesspool of corruption and indolence.

I favour the middle ground of alternative vote.

Re:Hinkley Point C: Building Britain's first nuclear reactor... by lostlogin on Monday September 23, 2024 @06:41AM (#41624542)
I don’t understand this comment - could you explain why?

Do other countries benefit from UK railways?

Re:Hinkley Point C: Building Britain's first nuclear reactor... by matt-p on Monday September 23, 2024 @06:50AM (#41624605)
Majority (particularly by ticket sales) of uk train operators (TOCs) are foreign owned[1] and operators are "TBTF" and subsidised by the government, in 2023 this was over 4 Billion pounds, meanwhile each TOC is paying out millions in dividends to share holders[2].

1 - https://www.rmt.org.uk/news/rmt-reveals-that-75-of-uk-rail-n... 2 - https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/rail-factsheet-2023...

Re:Hinkley Point C: Building Britain's first nuclear reactor... by bpye on Tuesday September 24, 2024 @10:42AM (#41637005)
That said the current government have introduced legislation to bring these TOCs into public ownership as franchises expire [0]. Rolling stock and freight will remain privately owned so it isn’t quite a return to the days of British Rail, but the privatisation experiment is coming to a close.

[0] https://bills.parliament.uk/bills/3732

Re:Hinkley Point C: Building Britain's first nuclear reactor... by griffzhowl on Monday September 23, 2024 @06:46AM (#41624575)
Privatization of UK rail services meant that they were given out on government tenders to "private" companies, and a few of these companies that won the tenders are owned by foreign govts. Netherlands is one I believe, maybe France too.
Re:Hinkley Point C: Building Britain's first nuclear reactor... by lpribis on Tuesday September 24, 2024 @11:06AM (#41637336)
Some examples:

- c2c and Avanti West Coast: partially and fully owned by Trenitalia which is wholly owned by the Italian government

- London Overground, Chilltern Railways, CrossCountry, Grand Central: Owned by Deutche Bahn until June 2024 which is wholly owned by the German government

- Elizabeth line: Wholly owned by MTR transport which is wholly owned by Hong Kong government

I'm sure there are a lot more I missed. It doesn't just appy to foreign governments either. The UK government subsidized all TOCs with taxpayer money, many of which turned around and gave out dividents to shareholds (foreign government or not).

Re:Hinkley Point C: Building Britain's first nuclear reactor... by griffzhowl on Monday September 23, 2024 @06:51AM (#41624622)
OTOH if I understand it right the French "taxpayer", i.e. govt, will be the beneficiary of the above-market price for electricity produced by the plant that the UK has guaranteed, presumably for the lifespan of the plant, which is 60 years. So I presume that will be a net gain for France, otherwise there would be no sense in continuing with the project.
Re:Hinkley Point C: Building Britain's first nuclear reactor... by davedx on Monday September 23, 2024 @07:05AM (#41624722)
Weren’t those agreements made way back before the giant cost overuns?
Re:Hinkley Point C: Building Britain's first nuclear reactor... by pfdietz on Monday September 23, 2024 @07:17AM (#41624815)
Yes. Huge mistake for France, that.

Fixed price contracts in the nuclear industry have rarely if ever worked out well for the suppliers. Contrast this with renewables which typically come in within 10% of the contracted price.

Re:Hinkley Point C: Building Britain's first nuclear reactor... by tonyedgecombe on Monday September 23, 2024 @08:42AM (#41625440)
Yes, it seems the only projects that have larger cost overruns than nuclear power stations is dealing with nuclear waste.
Re:Hinkley Point C: Building Britain's first nuclear reactor... by chickenbig on Monday September 23, 2024 @09:07AM (#41625651)
Don't forget the Olympics, with a format designed to minimise the learnings.

Note that the point of the article was that the design is being proven, lessons are being learnt, and the skills of individuals and organisations developed, which reduces the risk of overruns etc.

Re:Hinkley Point C: Building Britain's first nuclear reactor... by pfdietz on Monday September 23, 2024 @09:09AM (#41625665)
Hasn't it already greatly overrun the initial promises? I mean, that's the whole reason France is crying for relief here from the UK. Anyway, claims that nuclear will show good experience effects this time, for sure, are to be treated with skepticism.
Re:Hinkley Point C: Building Britain's first nuclear reactor... by chickenbig on Monday September 23, 2024 @12:00PM (#41627499)
> Hasn't it already greatly overrun the initial promises? Hinkley Point C got the green light in 2016 with an estimated £18bn build cost

  The most recent estimates put costs as high as £34bn at 2015 prices, £46bn in today’s money.
I believe the range is £31–35 billion in 2015 prices, so between 75% and 100% overrun.

> that's the whole reason France is crying for relief here from the UK.

The overrun combined with COVID combined with the spike in inflation and also CNG being frozen out of the UK nuclear market/cooling of relationship with China.

> claims that nuclear will show good experience effects this time, for sure, are to be treated with skepticism.

Agreed, which is why the second unit at HPC will be interesting.

Re:Hinkley Point C: Building Britain's first nuclear reactor... by chickenbig on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @01:29AM (#41643967)
I take it you are referring to https://x.com/BentFlyvbjerg/status/1662016016493191169

Interestingly the nuclear data implies that those (45% of) projects not in the tail (defined as >= 50% cost overrun) have a mean overrun of 17.33%.

120% = 0.45 * X% + 0.55 * 204% therefore X% = (120% - 0.55 * 204%)/0.45 = 17.33%

Re:Hinkley Point C: Building Britain's first nuclear reactor... by actionfromafar on Monday September 23, 2024 @08:50AM (#41625498)
Depends on what, if any, penalties there are for discontinuing.
Re:Hinkley Point C: Building Britain's first nuclear reactor... by chickenbig on Monday September 23, 2024 @09:05AM (#41625638)
> that the UK has guaranteed, presumably for the lifespan of the plant, which is 60 years

https://www.gov.uk/government/collections/hinkley-point-c

  The Hinkley Point C CfD provides a Strike Price for the developer of £92.50/MWh (2012 prices), reducing to £89.50/MWh (2012 prices) if EDF take a FID on their proposed Sizewell C project, for a 35 year term from the date of commissioning.
> I presume that will be a net gain for France

I think the project has a certain momentum to it. Also failing to complete the project would rather call into question their competence for the EPR2 build-out in France.

Re:Hinkley Point C: Building Britain's first nuclear reactor... by dingdingdang on Monday September 23, 2024 @06:30AM (#41624476)
Absolutely. Thanks for the highlighting! Edit: It's a two-in-one good news afaiac: China withdrawing funding(/influence) and some sort of accountability applied to mega projects rather than just throwing (and eventually devaluing) more and more money at things.
Re:Hinkley Point C: Building Britain's first nuclear reactor... by the_mitsuhiko on Monday September 23, 2024 @06:47AM (#41624583)
I’m not sure what the win is here. I doubt the French tax payer is winning and the French government is trying for the UK to help with the bill.
Re:Hinkley Point C: Building Britain's first nuclear reactor... by chickenbig on Monday September 23, 2024 @06:46AM (#41624577)
And this level of risk (and realised overrun) accounts for part of the higher CfD price at the start.