News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by lb1lf on Saturday September 21, 2024 @03:03AM (#41608076)
Presumably as Porsche is not about efficient transportation; it is about emotion, driving as an experience, making a statement, etc.

Chances are there will be - or, at least, Porsche appears to bet there will be - a sufficient number of well-heeled enthusiasts who prefer the sound, smell and vibration of an ICE to the quiet performance of an electric motor.

I am really curious to see how this pans out in a generation or two - I suspect nostalgia plays a significant role in the 'performance cars should have ICEs' mindset, so what happens when the generation who grew up on EVs enter middle age and have the disposable income for a performance car?

As for the rest of us, if, say, 1 in 1000 cars in a couple of decades' time burns fossil fuels, it is hardly going to be a nuisance. I'd be more worried (If I owned an ICE-powered vehicle) about the infrastructure needed to get the fossil fuels I needed in the tank.

(Glancing anxiously over at my 1949 S1 Land Rover (1.6l I4 petrol) and 1981 Land Cruiser 42 (3.4l I4 diesel) - neither of which are performance cars by any stretch of the imagination! The 3B engine in the Land Cruiser will merrily chug along on just about anything vaguely combustible you pour in the tank, though.)

Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by sheepdestroyer on Saturday September 21, 2024 @03:46AM (#41608300)
"it is about emotion, driving as an experience, making a statement, etc"

These kind of motivations need to be heavily vilified and taxed.

Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by lb1lf on Saturday September 21, 2024 @03:54AM (#41608343)
Oh, they will be, no worries - doubly so as the fuel they need goes from being a necessary evil of civilization to a niche product for enthusiasts.

There's going to be along tail of ICE vehicles out there, though - say, I have a tractor on my farm (which is not being worked commercially, it is basically an expensive and time-consuming hobby seeing as my wife's family has tilled this plot of land since the dark ages. Literally.)

Anyway, even if diesel prices soar to $25/l (That's $100/gal for the metrically challenged), with our current usage, it will still be cheaper to buy diesel at that cost than to invest in a new, EV tractor. Hence I can't see that tractor going anywhere anytime soon.

Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by inglor_cz on Saturday September 21, 2024 @04:01AM (#41608369)
Your proposals are a bit contradictory. If you heavily tax something, it becomes a money source for the government; does it then make sense to try to extinguish said activity through artificial social aversion? Also, whatever is vilified by the government, but stays legal or at least feasible, will act as a magnet for the counterculture.

If you really hate something, just propose an outright ban. It would work for Porsches; no one can secretly grow a Porsche in his backyard.

Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by wiseowise on Saturday September 21, 2024 @03:55AM (#41608349)
They’re already heavily taxed. But why vilified?
Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by Tade0 on Saturday September 21, 2024 @05:04AM (#41608628)
There's a huge overlap between people who seek out such experiences and those who drive recklessly and modify their exhausts.
Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by mistercheph on Saturday September 21, 2024 @06:23AM (#41608972)
Or maybe you're not particularly interested in cars or the people who are interested in cars and you can't tell the difference / assume all of "those" people are the same,
Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by Tade0 on Saturday September 21, 2024 @06:35AM (#41609025)
I actually am - mostly the engineering part of them though and to me, to paraphrase a prominent local motoring journalist, motoring is dead - EVs are a transition propulsion method and the end state is no motoring as we currently understand it and maintaining a car broadly considered lame.

The only people I've met who are car enthusiasts and don't go for the reckless/loud style of driving are people like my friend - a car mechanic who managed to form a single, road worthy Nissan Z31 from two defunct halves.

Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by aziaziazi on Saturday September 21, 2024 @05:30AM (#41608736)
A tax can help common infrastructures (building road) or limit something (cigarettes price)

Some people think the ICE car tax(es) already in place are not sufficient compared to the damage they cause. To reduce usage, both tax and public opinion (shaming, vilifying) works great.

It’s regrettable the efforts only focus on a car motors, the most dangerous property of a car is it’s weight (and emissions depends on that weight).

Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by jprete on Saturday September 21, 2024 @06:41AM (#41609059)
Vilifying things doesn't accomplish anything because the negative opinion becomes a cultural split. People don't care about the hatred of their out-group and lots of people will seek it out to burnish their status with the in-group.
Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by wiseowise on Saturday September 21, 2024 @12:29PM (#41610955)
The cars in question are luxury cars that are dime a dozen. I understand heavily taxing ordinary ICE cars, but why luxury ones?
Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by pokerface_86 on Saturday September 21, 2024 @04:28AM (#41608477)
you must be european
Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by sheepdestroyer on Sunday September 22, 2024 @06:32AM (#41616095)
Muricah much, or just trolling ? I though that was not the style here
Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by pokerface_86 on Sunday September 22, 2024 @08:29AM (#41616585)
i’m not particularly supportive of people who think fun needs to be vilified and taxed out of existence. it just so happens that this mindset is common among europeans who will never be able to afford a nice vehicle
Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by chii on Saturday September 21, 2024 @05:41AM (#41608782)
Why should something be heavily vilified and taxed simply because you personally dislike it?
Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by bn-l on Saturday September 21, 2024 @06:02AM (#41608872)
Because it’s a dead-end tech that’s holding us back and destroying the place where we all live. If you insist on pursuing it for your own pleasure, knowing what we all know now, you may be a villain.
Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by mensetmanusman on Saturday September 21, 2024 @07:27AM (#41609288)
Most emissions come from grid energy. The greens cancelled nuclear and were the real villains in the end.
Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by chii on Saturday September 21, 2024 @06:11AM (#41608911)
but the grandparent poster's problem isn't with ICE itself, but with "emotion, driving as an experience" etc.

In other words, the grandparent poster's argument is merely that people shouldn't be basing decisions on their (flawed) emotional attachment to driving as an experience, and would like such to be shamed and vilified.

This is a moralistic argument. It has nothing to do with environmentalism, but is using climate change as a platform to push a personal agenda or world view. In other words, it's a woke argument.

Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by xattt on Saturday September 21, 2024 @05:58AM (#41608851)
It’s not vilified. It’s the recovery of environmental costs associated with ICEs as well as subsidizing a lower barrier to entry for EVs.
Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by pkphilip on Saturday September 21, 2024 @06:44AM (#41609074)
There are plenty of place around the world where there isn't sufficient capacity in the grid even for powering the houses.. let alone EVs
Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by _factor on Saturday September 21, 2024 @06:59AM (#41609152)
It’s amazing how much the luxury car industry has advertised what is essentially a shaking and noise complement to going fast.

The “smooth” revs. The “visceral” feel. The “connection” to the road. It’s just a few metal cylinders going up and down real fast, tuned to sound nice in a packaged product.

It’s like brainwashing. Impressive really. I like going to the track when I can, but that’s a bit different. The statement is the work you’ve put into your car, not how “exclusive” your statement is.

Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by 123yawaworht456 on Saturday September 21, 2024 @04:27PM (#41612477)
people who drive expensive cars don't care about twitter opinions.
Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by cbeach on Saturday September 21, 2024 @03:49AM (#41608310)
> performance cars should have ICEs

After driving a fast Tesla, stepping into an ICE performance car feels like going back to a steam engine. A very slow, unresponsive steam engine.

When avid petrolheads try a fast EV and feel the instant torque it will be an epiphany for them. Only the most stubborn will stick with fossil cars.

Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by lb1lf on Saturday September 21, 2024 @04:14AM (#41608430)
-True, but I believe (at least this holds true for me) - the tinkerability, if you like, of ICEs is much higher. You can work on them at home, install all sorts of modifications and upgrades - real or perceived - to a much larger extent than you (currently) can on your EV.

It all depends on what makes cars interesting to you, of course - but a lot of the car enthusiast clientele would merrily start tinkering with their pride and joy even if all is well, just because they can.

Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by pixxel on Saturday September 21, 2024 @07:41AM (#41609342)
You’re wasting your time if you have to explain passion and soul, of which these types have neither.
Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by smileysteve on Saturday September 21, 2024 @07:47AM (#41609371)
You can still modify an electric car's suspension with shocks, springs, anti roll bars, and performance tires.
Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by prds_lost on Saturday September 21, 2024 @04:11AM (#41608422)
Which ICE performance car? I went from an SRT8 back in 2012 to a Tesla Model 3 performance + mods and now most recently went back to ICE via an AMG GT63. I can confidently say that the GT63 is leagues more fun than the Tesla ever was. Sure the Tesla was quick off the line, but outside of that it felt sterile and the ride was quite uninspired.
Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by foobazgt on Saturday September 21, 2024 @06:06AM (#41608886)
Model 3's didn't exist in 2012. Did you mean something else? I've driven an M3P for 5 years, and I wouldn't call it sterile.

I haven't been cross shopping it with vehicles that cost 3x as much and get only 15% of the mileage, so maybe I'm missing something? But weighing 10% more and taking 20% longer to reach 60 doesn't seem particularly compelling.

Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by mistercheph on Saturday September 21, 2024 @06:32AM (#41609010)
If it's the only car you've driven for five years of course it doesn't feel sterile, it's a wonderful car, and nothing against it, but it is not a fun car / "enthusiast" car insofar as enthusiast refers to the thin slice of all automotive enthusiasts that are primarily interested in handling that is dynamic and communicative
Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by foobazgt on Monday September 23, 2024 @12:33PM (#41627884)
> If it's the only car you've driven for five years of course it doesn't feel sterile...

I don't understand what you're trying to say here, but clearly we disagree. To each their own.

Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by wiseowise on Saturday September 21, 2024 @04:00AM (#41608367)
Instant torque is cool, but goddamn it is soulless.
Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by teo_zero on Saturday September 21, 2024 @04:06AM (#41608390)
I'm sure they said the same when they saw the first photographs and compared them with paintings.
Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by stonogo on Saturday September 21, 2024 @04:23AM (#41608458)
you might note that people still paint.
Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by lowdownbutter on Saturday September 21, 2024 @04:57AM (#41608598)
Well that also needs to be heavily vilified and taxed.
Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by nasmorn on Saturday September 21, 2024 @07:03AM (#41609164)
Since paintings are mostly made by someone they are under income tax which is at least in my country the highest percentage of all taxes. Plus VAT like everything else. A painter this easily pays 60% tax on what you have to pay
Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by avereveard on Saturday September 21, 2024 @05:37AM (#41608765)
Ah yes we should all live in a gray bloc working in a gray factory until the end of time

Vilifying a d taxing any luxury not only is a ludicrous position, it will only make inequality worse. Its not like the 0.1% will renoujce to it, and taxes don't matter to them.

Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by wiseowise on Saturday September 21, 2024 @12:28PM (#41610946)
The parent comment you're replying to is a sarcasm.
Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by 082349872349872 on Saturday September 21, 2024 @04:48AM (#41608568)
If you want instant torque with soul, try a horse.

(the catch: this instant is often one which you weren't expecting, and if you are lucky it will mostly have been applied along the craniocaudal axis)

Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by smileysteve on Saturday September 21, 2024 @07:45AM (#41609360)
Yet the manual transmission is dying out too.
Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by apelapan on Saturday September 21, 2024 @05:20AM (#41608687)
Eh, no?

One car being objectively faster than another does not mean that it is more fun.

And even if one vehicle is more fun in some total measure, it will not be fun in all the same ways as all other fun vehicles.

There are plenty of people who alternate between something like a modern Mercedes V8 and a classic Mini. There is no question of which one is faster, but it might be the slow one that gives the most joy of sporty driving

Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by avereveard on Saturday September 21, 2024 @05:29AM (#41608733)
Thats a very common misconception. Being very fast doesnt necessarily make a car very fun.
Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by nottorp on Saturday September 21, 2024 @05:33AM (#41608746)
I suppose you don't know how to drive a manual either :)
Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by foobazgt on Saturday September 21, 2024 @05:51AM (#41608821)
I drove stick for a couple of decades. They were fun at the time (except in traffic jams), but I'm no Luddite. I can enjoy being thrown back into my seat with roller coaster acceleration without the accompaniment of vroom vroom noises, exhaust, and shifting.
Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by nottorp on Saturday September 21, 2024 @07:48AM (#41609378)
I did test drive a Tesla and i agree any electric motor does the throwing back better than combustion.

But being thrown back is not the fun part. The fun part is controlling the car around those bends on a mountain road.

Anyone can floor it in a straight line.

Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by foobazgt on Monday September 23, 2024 @12:31PM (#41627869)
The model 3 is a track car [0], literally with a tunable track mode. It weighs less than other track competitors like the M3 competition. It is fun in the bends.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oXqxiSZAevY

Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by xcv123 on Saturday September 21, 2024 @07:07AM (#41609193)
The fastest EV is nothing compared to the fastest ICE.

Top fuel dragsters accelerate from 0 to 100 mph in 0.8 seconds.

I have tried fast EV and it's boring. I prefer my loud meth injected turbo diesel BMW (520 lb/ft at the wheels, pulls like a Tesla but is not boring to me)

Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by xenospn on Saturday September 21, 2024 @07:28AM (#41609292)
911 Turbos are faster than Teslas. Regardless, EVs feel like driving a washing machine. Some people are just not into that, or expect more. I’ve never been excited by any EV I sat down in, no matter how quickly they go 0-60.
Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by dahart on Saturday September 21, 2024 @10:18AM (#41610142)
> 911 Turbos are faster than Teslas.

Nope. Tesla Model S Plaid beats the 911 Turbo S. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_fastest_production_car...

Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by smileysteve on Saturday September 21, 2024 @07:44AM (#41609354)
I was at a local track in my older bmw (non M), a Tesla 3 (on lowered springs) was next to me in the grid. It did not compete with the corvettes or Porsches but with the Miatas and Me, it just weighed too much in the turns to carry the speed.
Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by smileysteve on Sunday September 22, 2024 @04:16PM (#41619704)
The owner, who also tracks a Corvette, said he might upgrade the shocks next. I imagine sway bars could help too.
Re:Porsche's Idea for a Six-Stroke Internal Combustion Engin... by svara on Saturday September 21, 2024 @06:26AM (#41608988)
If you're into that exotic hobby long after ICE cars are obsolete, you'll need to purchase synthetic fuel for it or purchase the equivalent amount of CO2 direct air capture. Sounds okay to me.