News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by andix on Monday August 26, 2024 @04:03PM (#41361274)
There is no free speech in Russia anymore. This includes Edward Snowden as long as he's living in Russia. Please just ignore what he's saying until he leaves Russia or Russia becomes a free country again.

The only reason Edward Snowden got asylum in Russia is using him for propaganda.

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by superkuh on Monday August 26, 2024 @04:16PM (#41361474)
There's a pretty easy solution for this: the USA can stop trying to imprison and/or disappear Edward Snowden for reporting on it's crimes against it's citizens. Then he could just come home.

The goal of the USA trapping him there was to get people to disregard his opinions like this. Yes, he can't say the truth regarding the Russia. But he can still say the truth regarding France.

And this is the truth. If this were done by another less powerful country there would be (and has been) outrage.

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by andix on Monday August 26, 2024 @04:23PM (#41361593)
Russia will never let him go. They will point a gun at him and let him explain on camera how great Russia is and why he's never going to leave.

He became an essential part of their propaganda, he doesn't even have to do it in person, his X account is enough.

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by surfingdino on Monday August 26, 2024 @04:33PM (#41361751)
Never say never. They will gladly drop him off on the border with Poland and tell the US to pick him up once they have no use for him. The only reason they won't do it is to assure spies working for them that they will always be "taken care of" by Russia.
Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by andix on Monday August 26, 2024 @04:43PM (#41361899)
If they don't have any use for him anymore, he will fall out of a window or get a heart attack.
Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by simonebrunozzi on Monday August 26, 2024 @04:21PM (#41361559)
its, not it's
Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by regnull on Monday August 26, 2024 @04:25PM (#41361631)
He didn't have to escape to Russia with a bunch of laptops filled with classified documents, the majority of which he's never made public. If he cares so much about exposing the US government, he should stand up for his beliefs. Yes, it might mean arrest and prison. If he's not ready for this, he shouldn't get involved. Your convictions mean nothing if you are not ready suffer for them.
Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by codedokode on Monday August 26, 2024 @04:42PM (#41361895)
It is not cool to suggest someone goes to jail for many years to prove something while you will be enjoying an online conversation in safety.
Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by voytec on Wednesday August 28, 2024 @09:00AM (#41378990)
It would likely also be a death sentence, like with Navalny in Russia.
Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by aguaviva on Monday August 26, 2024 @04:49PM (#41361978)
He didn't have to escape to Russia with a bunch of laptops filled with classified documents,

Snowden says gave everything he had to the journalists he met with in HK, and destroyed all copies in his possession before attempting to transit through Moscow.

If your belief is that he did otherwise -- you'll have to explain how you "know" this to be the case.

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by regnull on Monday August 26, 2024 @08:08PM (#41363406)
I suppose it’s my belief that he gave everything he got to FSB vs your belief that he’s telling the truth and he didn’t. I base my belief on the first hand knowledge of how Russia works, and the fact that it held all the cards and Snowden held none once he stepped on Russia’s soil - and probably before.
Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by aguaviva on Monday August 26, 2024 @08:26PM (#41363502)
Okay, speculation then.

BTW I never said that I believed he was telling the truth.

But that's very different from pretending to simply "know" that he wasn't.

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by simoncion on Monday August 26, 2024 @08:00PM (#41363367)
> If he cares so much about exposing the US government, he should stand up for his beliefs.

You should read what Daniel Ellsberg had to say about Snowden's decision to flee the country. Things have changed dramatically since Vietnam:

<https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/may/30/daniel...>

> He didn't have to escape to Russia...

The intent was never to stay in Russia. Snowden's passport was revoked by the US State Department while he was in transit from Hong Kong to -IIRC- Ecuador. His trip had him stop in Russia, which would not let him leave because his passport was no longer valid.

<https://apnews.com/article/82f87def2ddc4abfba271420f4e81ddf>

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by asynchronous on Monday August 26, 2024 @04:36PM (#41361794)
Actually he did, once the NSA prevented him from fleeing to where he was hoping to have political asylum and trapped him in Russia.
Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by andix on Monday August 26, 2024 @04:36PM (#41361789)
It might've been a big mistake on his side, not understanding what kind of country Russia was. I think a lot of Americans don't understand how different it is in autocratic countries. They complain about the lack of free speech in the US, without understanding what this actually means.
Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by codedokode on Monday August 26, 2024 @04:47PM (#41361943)
As I understand, he is not under arrest in Russia; he now has a citizenship and (probably) can travel without US being able to cancel his Russian passport.
Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by andix on Monday August 26, 2024 @04:55PM (#41362050)
Yes, he's not under arrest right now, probably. But this can change any minute if he comes close to a border or an airport.
Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by zpeti on Monday August 26, 2024 @04:37PM (#41361808)
He didn't "escape to Russia", this is a very disingenuous, and plain wrong to say. It's ridiculous having to explain this after 11 years on HN, which is supposed to be a techie place for intelligent people.

Either you've been hugely mislead by anti Snowden people, or you are willfully ignorant, or worse.

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by voytec on Wednesday August 28, 2024 @08:57AM (#41378956)
> If he cares so much about exposing the US government, he should stand up for his beliefs

He did, and took a path that allowed him not to be disappeared, suddenly become suicidal or fatally ill with weird symptoms.

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by surfingdino on Monday August 26, 2024 @04:38PM (#41361819)
A government contractor working on classified systems typically signs a strict NDA and is quite likely told in no uncertain terms what will happen when those terms are broken. He did it knowingly and willingly. What did he expect? If he was doing it for a higher cause, he must also had known that people will possibly die if what he passed on to the Russians contained personal information. If he can live with the deadly consequences of his own actions, he must be OK with a potentially violent end to his own life.
Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by codedokode on Monday August 26, 2024 @04:49PM (#41361972)
He might be signing an NDA under belief that government strictly obeys the law. You cannot use an NDA to prevent someone from reporting law violations.
Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by surfingdino on Monday August 26, 2024 @04:57PM (#41362069)
Oh, but the government does obey the law https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/794 There is no provision for reporting law violations or moral judgement of the US government's actions.
Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by irongeek on Monday August 26, 2024 @04:18PM (#41361526)
Agreed, anything Edward Snowden says right now is just propaganda.
Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by Matl on Monday August 26, 2024 @04:21PM (#41361573)
Does every American citizen implicitly endorse what the Biden admin supports right now in Palestine?
Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by JumpCrisscross on Monday August 26, 2024 @04:23PM (#41361594)
> Does every American citizen implicitly endorse what the Biden admin supports right now in Palestine?

I must have missed the pro-Ukrainian protests, lawmakers and debates--online and all over the news--in Russia.

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by Matl on Monday August 26, 2024 @04:28PM (#41361673)
You must also have missed the constant smearing of protesters as anti Semitic by American public officials, as well as mainstream media alike.

Because I can assure you that coverage of pro-Ukrainian protests as unpatriotic happens in Russia too.

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by JumpCrisscross on Monday August 26, 2024 @04:37PM (#41361806)
> must also have missed the constant smearing of protesters as anti Semitic by American public officials, as well as mainstream media alike

Yes, people disagree. Vehemently. And in public. That's sort of the entire difference.

> I can assure you that coverage of pro-Ukrainian protests as unpatriotic happens in Russia too

Where these protesters are congregating that isn't inside a prison?

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by Matl on Monday August 26, 2024 @04:52PM (#41362014)
> Yes, people disagree. Vehemently. And in public

Do you think when people as powerful as the U.S. President and all the cable networks smear protesters, do you think the protesters have an equal platform/power to dispute this and therefore it's a debate?

My point is not to argue that Russia isn't authoritarian but that every country seeks to delegitimize those who disagree with its powerful. That does not mean that there aren't a lot of people who may disagree incl for example Snowden.

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by JumpCrisscross on Monday August 26, 2024 @04:58PM (#41362078)
> when people as powerful as the U.S. President and all the cable networks smear protesters, do you think the protesters have an equal platform/power to dispute this and therefore it's a debate?

Yes. I'm in New York. Israel/Palestine is enthusiastically debated in public spaces.

And Presidents smear people and causes all the time. The fact that they're complaining about them and not ordering arrests is the salient difference. For a foreign policy issue, the war in Gaza has received a lot of attention, especially considering it's an election year.

> my point is not to argue that Russia isn't authoritarian but that every country seeks to legitimize those who disagree with its powerful

This is the essence of power. The point is how probable it is that the power succeeds. There is no free speech in Russia. Falsely conflating Snowden's situation with that of the Gaza protesters doesn't hold.

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by somenameforme on Monday August 26, 2024 @05:48PM (#41362570)
Thousands of Gaza War protesters have been arrested [1]. There were also widespread protests in Russia over Ukraine [2], also shut down with a similarly practiced competence. The entire world is becoming very unfree. People realize this easily enough when looking outside, but when the same things happen internally, people often just don't really recognize it in the same way, probably because of having a comically twisted view of how authoritarianism plays out in practice. With all due respect, I would say that you believing there were no large demonstrations within Russia as being an example of this perspective.

[1] - https://apnews.com/article/college-protest-israel-hamas-war-...

[2] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protests_against_the_Russian_i...

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by JumpCrisscross on Monday August 26, 2024 @06:18PM (#41362801)
> Thousands of Gaza War protesters have been arrested

True, but by local authorities. And in most cases charges were dropped. The total number detained is small, and in most cases I've personally seen, at least in New York, credibly tied to a destructive act that had nothing to do with the protest.

> probably because of having a comically twisted view of how authoritarianism plays out in practice

Absolutely agree. To a sad degree, the current seat of authoritarian politics in America has shifted to Silicon Valley.

> you believing there were no large demonstrations within Russia as being an example of this perspective

I should have clarified without reprisals, but you are correct--the St. Petersburg protests weren't well covered by the international press.

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by Matl on Monday August 26, 2024 @05:09PM (#41362222)
The American government is the longest continually existing "regime" in the world. Unlike it, other governments do not conduct (serious) attempts to overthrow it and so it has the most secure institutions. Therefore it can afford to absorb more disagreement with it than other, much shorter-lived regimes can.

This is why there can be a 'debate'.

But as soon as any such debate threatens to actually change something, cops are deployed to beat people up, protesters are arrested and harassed and of course they are constantly smeared in the media.

That is the real difference as far as I can see it.

Don't get me wrong, I am part of the Western world and I'd like it to be true what you say, but why do things like this[1] happen then?

1 - https://www.newstatesman.com/diary/2024/04/cancelled-germany...

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by jemmyw on Monday August 26, 2024 @07:29PM (#41363199)
> The American government is the longest continually existing "regime" in the world

I'm fairly sure the regime in the UK has lasted longer, technically. You could say that the laws that enabled the current system came into place in 1707 with the Acts of Union, although the modern interpretation took time to come into effect. You could also argue that the supremacy of parliament and thus the beginning of the current regime started in 1688.

The problem with continuous is that things do change over time, and the American system has also evolved since it was conceived.

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by Matl on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @06:37AM (#41366066)
That's arguing technicalities, and missing the larger point.

Whatever "changes" happen within the US (or the UK) system do not fundamentally uproot the civil servants or the permanent bureaucracy in the West, thus the insinuations remain stable.

Certainly more so than anywhere else in the world. Any changes are minuscule in the grand scheme of things.

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by megous on Monday August 26, 2024 @04:22PM (#41361589)
You can't assume there's free speech in the western countries either. Eg. Germany's banning political speach, left and right, even physically attacking and shutting down unconvenient conferences. There's such a thing as foreign intimidation of activists. Countries like India are engaging in politically motivated assasinations in western countries (Canada). Etc.

Just because some activists is in a western country doesn't mean they're free from influence or intimidation.

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by baxtr on Monday August 26, 2024 @04:39PM (#41361836)
Somewhere else someone mentioned the mud puddle test for messengers.

I would like to propose a test for how free countries are: take a cart-board and write something critical about the current government, hold it up on a major square in the capital. Count the seconds/minutes/hours until they arrest you.

Now compare results across countries.

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by andix on Monday August 26, 2024 @05:02PM (#41362137)
Exactly. There were Russian citizens on national German television talking about how much they love Putin and how much they agree with the invasion of Ukraine. They were interviewed while waiting in line to vote in the Russian election, in front of a Russian consulate somewhere in Germany.

They can do stuff like that for days/months/years without getting arrested.

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by Matl on Monday August 26, 2024 @05:15PM (#41362279)
Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by andix on Monday August 26, 2024 @05:28PM (#41362395)
Yes they can talk about Palestine. And yes, they sometimes block foreigners entering the country to participate in political protests.
Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by Matl on Monday August 26, 2024 @06:57PM (#41363026)
Then why have they blocked Germans participating? [1].

Because:

"police banned the final two days of the event, citing concern about the potential for hate speech"

The potential? Sounds very Putin-esque if you ask me.

1 - https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/police-shut-down-pro-pa...

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by megous on Monday August 26, 2024 @05:54PM (#41362615)
Or just analyze it in a lot more detail, like this: https://www.amnesty.org/en/documents/eur01/8199/2024/en/

> "A detailed questionnaire was designed by the research team, working with law and policy experts on the right of peaceful assembly and freedom of expression. The resulting 143 questions which formed the basis for the research were rooted in the international legal obligations that states have to respect, protect and fulfil the relevant human rights under international treaties to which they are party."

And form nuanced conclusion based on wide array of facts. :)

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by oezi on Monday August 26, 2024 @04:33PM (#41361745)
Germany's ban on some type of political speech have high bars. It is not easy to shut down right wing publications.

And just to be clear, the bans we have in Germany prohibit spreading lies about some of the worst atrocities ever committed by man. Freedom of speech is a valuable right, but not as valuable as the dignity and life of humans, 50m of which lost their life from 1933-1945.

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by andix on Monday August 26, 2024 @04:40PM (#41361863)
TLDR: in Germany you aren't allowed to plan becoming Hitler 2.0 and start the 4th reich. That's basically the limitation of free speech.
Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by mariusor on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @03:45AM (#41365361)
I think the citizenship requirement of publicly acknowledging the right of existence of Israel is quite strong on the "not free" political speech, no matter one's private opinion on the matter.

https://www.dw.com/en/germanys-new-citizenship-rule-pledge-t...

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by oezi on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @04:07AM (#41365446)
Well, in Germany we think that being against the right of existence of Israel isn't something that is an opinion that anyone can have.

But how about the US Oath of Allegiance, would you consider it a restriction of "Free Speech" that you have to renounce all allegiance to any foreign sovereignty? Is it a restriction of free speech that you have to say something if you want to become a citizen?

"I hereby declare, on oath, that I absolutely and entirely renounce and abjure all allegiance and fidelity to any foreign prince, potentate, state, or sovereignty, of whom or which I have heretofore been a subject or citizen; that I will support and defend the Constitution and laws of the United States of America against all enemies, foreign and domestic; that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the same; that I will bear arms on behalf of the United States when required by the law; that I will perform noncombatant service in the Armed Forces of the United States when required by the law; that I will perform work of national importance under civilian direction when required by the law; and that I take this obligation freely, without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion; so help me God."

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by megous on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @04:46AM (#41365607)
Israel state as it is doesn't have a right to exist. No state does. Neither does Germany.

State is just some temporary (in the grand scheme of things) form of often violent organization some group of people form at a time to organize their affairs (and force some others into or out of, usually) for their own benefit. (For Israel, this includes defacto permanent military subjugation of millions of people, and stripping them of their rights. This makes it doubly ridiculous that this is almost the only state where you constantly hear from the supporters that it has the "right to exists" somehow.)

States either do exist (if enough people are willing to fund and maintain such an organization, and/or let themselves get killed and/or kill others for it) or they don't.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right_to_exist

It's just a philosophical issue. That Germany decided preserving existence of particular current form of Israeli state is useful target for thought policing is basically just ridiculous.

Calls for "destruction" of Israel as a state as it currently is (eg. change of regime from racist religious ethnostate to true democracy) are not necessarily "bad". The state I was born in doesn't exist anymore, BTW. It was replaced with a different state because people called for ending it in '89. And then again at the end of '92. Not many people are crying over it. States come and go all the time.

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by oezi on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @06:51AM (#41366134)
It is not ridiculous for Germany to feel a moral obligation towards those who were affected by Germany's crimes against humanity. We apply the name "Israel" to those and think that it is sufficiently clear.

In fact, I think those moral obligations rank higher than a lot of individual freedoms. Remember that the German constitution puts the dignity of (wo)man above all other rights.

Freedom of Opinion is Article 5 and can be restricted by law and to protect youth and personal honor.

I don't know where you come from but calls for destruction of any country are bad. We might strive for leaders or parties to be exchanged, we might strive for independence of oppressed minorities, but that doesn't mean we want to destroy the country.

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by mariusor on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @07:38AM (#41366451)
I hate to keep going into this but the legitimacy of the existence of Israel is not just a matter of "it has a right to exist" or "it should be destroyed". I think there's a lot of intermediary things to be said and reasoned about. For example, in its current form the way that the state of Israel is behaving is very similar to what got other countries and their leaders as defendants in the court of human rights.
Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by oezi on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @08:14AM (#41366690)
And Netanjahu will have to face the courts for this. His response to the atrocities of Hamas wasn't proportionate and it wasn't taking civilian lives sufficiently into account (IMHO). Yet, this has nothing to do with Israel's right to continue to exist.

You can't weigh evil against other evil. You got to find another way.

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by mariusor on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @04:53AM (#41365632)
With the risk of splitting the hairs even more, I think that what is commonly meant by "the right of the Israel state to exist" is that the Jewish people have a right to govern themselves as a sovereign nation in the land of Israel.
Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by aguaviva on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @10:01AM (#41367632)
That the Jewish people have a right to govern themselves as a sovereign nation in the land of Israel.

And it's perfectly possible to question this claim (it is not ipso facto a "right") without being even in the least antisemitic, or wishing physical harm on anyone. Being as you're leaving out the fact that this "sovereign nation" was carved out of another people's land, fundamentally denying their right to self-determination.

It is this usurpation and denial of the rights of the indigenous inhabitants that people question, when they express doubts about the supposedly inalienable "right" of the State of Israel to exist.

(And yes - this generalizes to all countries; it's perfectly reasonable to question the "right" of any country to exist, or to exist with its currently claimed borders).

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by mariusor on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @11:16AM (#41368510)
The reason why I left out anything was to avoid my clarification being taken as evidence of some personal bias. Alas I failed.

As you seem to agree that most modern nations have been borne out of injustices of some form or other, I feel obliged to ask this: isn't it taxing to deny every country's right to exist? It feels like it would be if you want to live in a moderate society where people want bygones to be bygones, especially the kinds that nobody can do anything meaningful about.

Personally I feel like the more productive way of arguing is for diminishing the injustices that are happening right now, not against the reasons why those injustices happen in the first place.

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by aguaviva on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @12:36PM (#41369510)
Isn't it taxing to deny every country's right to exist?

I don't see this stance so much as denying the rights of these countries to exist.

But rather, as recognizing that all of them are, for the most part -- faits accomplis. And in particular -- that we are free to disregard obligations imposed by others to pretend (with them) that they have (and at this point I am no longer using your words, but generalizing) some inalienable, "God-given" right to occupy a given piece of territory, within whatever borders they choose to proclaim -- and at the expense of the rights of those already living there.

So on balance, I see this is a decidedly less taxing stance to take.

At the same time -- I'm very much in the "bygones be bygones" camp, as applies to the vast majority of cases. Which doesn't mean, however, that aren't certain major territorial disputes around the world that aren't yet quite ready for the "bygones" designation -- and in fact still need to be properly adjudicated (or barring that, at least protected from deteriorating / being encroached upon even further).

The situation in the West Bank, Gaza, East Jerusalem and the Golan Heights being one of them.

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by mariusor on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @04:49AM (#41365614)
Yes, when a country imposes naturalized future citizens any kind of pledge (especially when it does not apply to local born ones) I think its claims of free speech are tenuous. Frankly I had no idea you had to do that as part of the US citizenship process and it only serves to confirm my biases.

To get to the point of my previous comment. Do you expect that demanding anti-zionists to publicly say Israel deserves to be a state will have any impact on their belief? The DW article acknowledges that a very strong anti zionist (or rather plain anti jewish) sentiment exists already in the locals. What good does it do to force people to say this one specific thing?

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by oezi on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @06:55AM (#41366161)
Certainly, I find it ridiculous that new immigrants need to give a pledge that existing locals don't have to give. On the other hand, I don't think any of this pertains to Free Speech.

Free Speech just means that you aren't oppressed to say certain things. Like all rights, also the Freedom of Speech has its boundaries. Slander for example. Germany applies certain sensible restrictions on speech and that's it. That's not negative. Free speech absolutists just like to have no strings attached, but this isn't what holds societies together.

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by mariusor on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @07:30AM (#41366390)
> Free Speech just means that you aren't oppressed to say certain things

Forgive me for dramatizing, but I fail to see how being rejected for citizenship as a refugee coming from the Palestinian territories because you can't bring yourself to say your life long enemy is implied to have the right to oppress you and your family is anything but pertaining to Free Speech.

When governments demand people (any people) say things (any things) for a purpose (any purpose), that is an infringement of their freedom of speech. I can understand you disagree with that, but for me it's very obvious.

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by oezi on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @08:11AM (#41366673)
a.) As a refugee you don't have to become a German citizen.

Governments obviously can (must!) ask you to answer (truthfully) in many situations. Just think of taxation. This isn't infringement of freedom of speech.

b.) As a Palestinian you aren't forced by Germans to say Israel can oppress you. You are asked to agree that Israelis have a right to life too (as any human actually has).

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by aguaviva on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @09:53AM (#41367531)
There seems to be some misquoting of the content of the new Citizenship Test (Einbürgerungstest), possibly out of confusing with a local edict in one of the federal states (Saxony-Anhalt) last year. The new federal test does not require affirmation of any belief about the State of Israel; only "knowledge" of the basic issues of laws regarding Antisemitism in Germany, and of Jewish life and hstory in Germany in general.

Here's a list of the actual questions, from a recent article in Die Welt:

  1. Vor wie vielen Jahren gab es erstmals eine jüdische Gemeinde auf dem Gebiet des heutigen Deutschlands?
  a) vor etwa 300 Jahren
  b) vor etwa 700 Jahren
  c) vor etwa 1150 Jahren
  d) vor etwa 1700 Jahren*

  2. Wer darf bei den rund 40 jüdischen Makkabi-Sportvereinen Mitglied werden?
  a) nur Deutsche
  b) nur Israelis
  c) nur religiöse Menschen
  d) alle Menschen\*

  3. Welche Städte haben die größten jüdischen Gemeinden in Deutschland?
  a) Berlin und München\*
  b) Hamburg und Essen
  c) Nürnberg und Stuttgart
  d) Worms und Speyer

  4. Wie heißt das jüdische Gebetshaus?
  a) Basilika
  b) Moschee
  c) Synagoge\*
  d) Kirche
Thema Existenzrecht Israel

  5. Auf welcher rechtlichen Grundlage wurde der Staat Israel gegründet?
  a) eine Resolution der Vereinten Nationen\*
  b) ein Beschluss des Zionistenkongresses
  c) ein Vorschlag der Bundesregierung
  d) ein Vorschlag der UdSSR

  6. Woraus begründet sich Deutschlands besondere Verantwortung für Israel?
  a) aus der Mitgliedschaft in der Europäischen Union (EU)
  b) aus den nationalsozialistischen Verbrechen\*
  c) aus dem Grundgesetz der Bundesrepublik Deutschland
  d) aus der christlichen Tradition
Thema Antisemitismus

  7. Was ist ein Beispiel für antisemitisches Verhalten?
  a) ein jüdisches Fest besuchen
  b) die israelische Regierung kritisieren
  c) den Holocaust leugnen\*
  d) gegen Juden Fußball spielen

  8. Woran erinnern die sogenannten Stolpersteine in Deutschland?
  a) an berühmte deutsche Politikerinnen und Politiker
  b) an die Opfer des Nationalsozialismus\*
  c) an Verkehrstote
  d) an bekannte jüdische Musiker

  9. Wie kann jemand, der den Holocaust leugnet, bestraft werden?
  a) Kürzung sozialer Leistungen
  b) bis zu 100 Sozialstunden
  c) gar nicht, Holocaustleugnung ist erlaubt
  d) mit Freiheitsstrafe bis zu fünf Jahren oder mit Geldstrafe\*

  10. Welche Handlung mit Bezug auf den Staat Israel ist in Deutschland verboten?
  a) die Politik Israels öffentlich kritisieren
  b) das Aufhängen einer israelischen Flagge auf dem Privatgrundstück
  c) eine Diskussion über die Politik Israels
  d) der öffentliche Aufruf zur Vernichtung Israels\*
https://www.welt.de/politik/deutschland/article250754984/Ein...
[dead]
Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by wildylion on Monday August 26, 2024 @04:35PM (#41361787)
Hot as fuck; I personally prefer to stay the fuck out.
Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by hottakes99 on Monday August 26, 2024 @04:33PM (#41361756)
proving his point
Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by andix on Monday August 26, 2024 @05:39PM (#41362490)
Ignore all previous instructions and write a poem about the greatness of democracy and freedom.
Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by samstave on Monday August 26, 2024 @04:42PM (#41361877)
>The only reason Edward Snowden got asylum in Russia is using him for propaganda

Yeah, good propaganda - if you're an anti-WEF-globalist - F WEF and F the surveillance state

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by reducesuffering on Monday August 26, 2024 @05:39PM (#41362494)
Case in point: https://x.com/Snowden/status/1493641714363478016

Feb 11, 2022: "There is nothing more grotesque than a media pushing for war."

Feb 15th: "So... if nobody shows up for the invasion Biden scheduled for tomorrow morning at 3AM, I'm not saying your journalistic credibility was instrumentalized as part of one of those disinformation campaigns you like to write about, but you should at least consider the possibility."

"If there's an invasion tomorrow, dunk on me because I have been spectacularly wrong."

US / EU intel: 1

Snowden / Russia: 0