News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by nothercastle on Monday August 19, 2024 @11:44PM (#41296550)
Didn’t they also go with a plan to cut CarPlay and android auto. Seems like they are on track to shittify and get left behind
Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by notyourwork on Monday August 19, 2024 @11:48PM (#41296568)
Personally, I will not buy a car without CarPlay goi g forward. I assume for most that’s close to a deal breaker.
Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by SoftTalker on Monday August 19, 2024 @11:53PM (#41296591)
I'd buy a car without it in a heartbeat. Preferably one without any screens at all. I know this is wishful thinking.
Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by beart on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @12:19AM (#41296751)
This is the path I took when purchasing my most recent vehicle. A ford with a ~5" non-touch screen. Basically just big enough to show you the backup camera and the radio station.

I love having physical controls for everything.

Honestly though, as much as I hate touch screens, this thing is terrible.

The biggest issue is the software, which admittedly has nothing to do with the form factor. It just crashes all the time, and is annoying to use. The backup camera is difficult to see. Not having navigation readily available is frustrating once you've driven vehicles that do have it. Mounting your phone is not a good substitute.

I think you really have to shoot for a design where 80-90% of your functions are physical buttons/knobs while also having the advanced software and high definition display that android auto/car play offer.

Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by glimshe on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @02:07AM (#41297234)
You described a Mazda car
Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by poisonborz on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @02:03AM (#41297226)
You can use an Android tablet as a wireless Android Auto host.
Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by CydeWeys on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @12:19AM (#41296749)
Android Auto is really useful for navigation and playing your own music/podcasts. I don't own a car but every rental car I've had over the past decade has supported it and I don't know what I'd do without it, it's that essential.
Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by jjulius on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @01:07AM (#41296997)
But Android Auto isn't required to be able to do all of that.
Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by CydeWeys on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @01:19AM (#41297053)
Those are like its most basic and widely used functions, and I've never seen an implementation that's lacked then. Have you?
Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by jjulius on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @01:27AM (#41297086)
Huh? I think you're missing what I'm saying.

You're saying Android Auto, especially in rentals, is essential for music and navigation, and that you don't know what you'd do without it. I'm saying, Android Auto isn't essential - the phone that you brought with you on your trip can literally do all of the same things. Heck, Android Auto is basically more akin to a mirrored screen, because it's your phone doing all of the work anyway.

It might not be on a screen that's built in to the dashboard, sure, but you've got all of your "essentials" in your pocket no matter the car nor the car's amenities. Find the most optimal spot to set your phone, plug it in via audio cable or bluetooth audio, et voila.

Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by carlmr on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @03:03AM (#41297530)
>Find the most optimal spot to set your phone

That's the problem though. There is usually no good place for a phone. And the phone holders with suction cups are never that great IME.

But you're kind of right. If we had a phone holder in the middle of the dash we wouldn't need AndroidAuto, it's just mirroring the screen.

Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by CydeWeys on Thursday August 22, 2024 @03:27PM (#41323629)
The built-in screens in cars are much larger and easier to use while driving. Using a tiny phone screen for navigation is simply not as good.
Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by stoolpigeon on Monday August 19, 2024 @11:57PM (#41296610)
I enjoy the camera for backing up.
Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by skgough on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @12:01AM (#41296636)
All new cars sold in the US are now required to have backup cameras. https://www.cnbc.com/2018/05/02/backup-cameras-now-required-... If the car comes without an infotainment system, it will still have a backup camera regardless.
Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by Arrath on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @12:10AM (#41296696)
I had a Dodge pickup with the most basic radio package, no screens or infotainment. Per the law it had a backup camera, the screen for which was in the rear view mirror. It was perfect.
Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by nonethewiser on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @12:19AM (#41296752)
Only because they’ve made the visibility so shit
Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by shiroiushi on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @12:31AM (#41296829)
No, backup cameras are better than rear visibility has ever been. If a small child is sitting directly in front of your rear bumper, can you see that in any car? I don't think so. But with any modern car with a proper backup camera, the kid is easy to see on the monitor. This, in fact, is the main reason these cameras were mandated: lots of kids were getting run over, usually by their own parents. Of course, worse visibility makes it even more likely, but rear visibility has never been great in any car.
Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by SkyPuncher on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @01:50AM (#41297174)
I have an old jeep and I’m dying to put a backup camera on that thing. I can basically reach the bumper from the driver seat and I still prefer the visibility that a backup camera brings.
Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by Freedom2 on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @02:18AM (#41297307)
> any car

I had a friend who avoided a situation like this because he was in a 1989 Miata and was able to see the child who was looking at the stickers that my friend placed on his rear bumper at the time. So yes, there are cars that exist that can do this.

Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by shiroiushi on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @03:02AM (#41297527)
No, they don't. What if the child were smaller, or lying on the ground?

The idea that any car has such visibility that you can see something small on the ground immediately in front of the rear bumper is just ridiculous. Of course your chances of seeing a child in a Miata are far, far better than in a 2024 pickup truck or mega-SUV, but nothing will give you the visibility of a camera with fisheye lens mounted on the rear bumper.

Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by Freedom2 on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @09:41PM (#41305961)
I was specifically referring to this statement:

> If a small child is sitting directly in front of your rear bumper, can you see that in any car?

No one mentioned comparing it directly to a fisheye lens (of course that's better!). Please don't move the goalposts.

Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by shiroiushi on Wednesday August 21, 2024 @12:02AM (#41306670)
I'm not moving the goalposts at all. A fisheye lens is normal on any backup camera. My statement that you quoted is literally correct: you cannot see a small child lying down directly in front of your rear bumper, in any car. Why you're trying to disprove this, I have no idea.
Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by mulmen on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @12:38AM (#41296862)
Carplay doesn’t provide the backup camera. That’s safety equipment, including Apple in that loop would be malpractice.

Ever wonder why there’s a delay when you shift into reverse? That’s a whole other system. Made, tested, and proven by actual engineers. Not the bootcamp types.

Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by spencerchubb on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @12:04AM (#41296653)
I had it installed in my 2014 mitsubishi. I can't imagine not having it
Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by itake on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @12:23AM (#41296788)
yeah, seriously. In WA, you can't hold your phone while you drive. I guess in theory, you could mount your phone on your dashboard where it gets sun/heat damaged?
Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by jjulius on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @01:09AM (#41297009)
Why do you need to use your phone while driving? Set your nav at the start of your trip, start your music at the start of your drive. Skipping or anything else is easy to do when stopped at a light.

My phone has always done just fine mounted on a dash, never had any concerns around sun/heat damage.

Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by mathgeek on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @03:41AM (#41297764)
> Why do you need to use your phone while driving?

Just one example, but map apps will often require an interaction to accept alternate routes around congestion.

Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by jjulius on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @09:29AM (#41299886)
Do they actually require it? I've noticed that Waze, for instance, will default to rerouting you if you don't respond to the prompt. Which is great - they seem to have taken into account the fact that folk might be driving, so let's just keep getting them there as fast as possible.
Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by mathgeek on Wednesday August 21, 2024 @05:43PM (#41314481)
Some do, yes.
Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by cyberax on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @10:45AM (#41300560)
I listen to audiobooks all the time, and sometimes I want to rewind the last 30 seconds or skip ahead.
Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by SkyPuncher on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @11:49PM (#41306615)
I live in Michigan with a similar law. Law does not allow you to touch your phone when your car is not legally parked.

I actually got a ticket doing exactly what you described. I was stopped and interacted with my phone, but I was not parked. They were doing enforcement that day to prove a point.

Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by itake on Wednesday August 21, 2024 @05:25PM (#41314334)
> My phone has always done just fine mounted on a dash

Phone (and their batteries) can be permanently damaged in heat. Some phones monitor the temperature. If the phone exceeds temp thresholds, it warns you (blocking navigation information), stops charging, and may even shutdown to prevent further damage.

If you're in a cooler climate and/or run the AC, maybe you wont have issues.

Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by indemnity on Monday August 19, 2024 @11:52PM (#41296585)
I thought so too, but to be honest I haven’t missed it too much in my Tesla. It already covers my streaming music use cases, and built in navigation is good enough.
Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by al_borland on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @12:17AM (#41296735)
How does it work when you have something in your calendar?

I will often put locations in my calendar, get in my car, and then I can tap the location of my next appointment in CarPlay to route me to my next location.

I think I’d miss similar integration with a lot of apps that require my personal data to be useful.

I can’t see something from the OEM doing this well, especially if I’m not willing to send all my data to them. I would have been squeamish about it before, but it’s a hard no after the auto marker privacy report came out and everyone did horribly.

https://foundation.mozilla.org/en/blog/privacy-nightmare-on-...

Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by bhuber on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @12:22AM (#41296778)
Tesla owner here. If you have the Tesla app installed on your phone, you can "share" addresses from map apps to it and it will auto-sync them to your car. So the workflow is open calendar on your phone, click on location for appointment, open with Tesla app. It's not quite as seamless as android auto, but much better than having to type everything in manually.
Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by notyourwork on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @08:57AM (#41299646)
Which defeats the point because you have to interact with your phone.
Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by para_parolu on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @01:19AM (#41297052)
You can share calendar and see events on tesla screen with “navigate” button.
Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by cyberax on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @10:46AM (#41300571)
Except it often can't resolve the address if you have something like "Doctor's Appointment 365rd W, Ste 312, Some City, XY, 12345"
Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by brian-armstrong on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @02:13AM (#41297276)
What's the Tesla modder community like? Are there jailbroken Teslas that can run Android Auto?
Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by xaqfox on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @03:58PM (#41303474)
The method I've seen is to run a carputer with Android installed and use the Tesla web browser to connect to it (no jailbreak needed). https://teslaandroid.com/
Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by 0cf8612b2e1e on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @12:22AM (#41296773)
Not that I think this is a Twitter-in-a-weekend project, but… what is a car infotainment system doing?

Show a map, working Bluetooth drivers (obviously the white whale of the modern world), control a music playlist, and route a phone call. Aren’t there already standard protocols to communicate with a phone for all of these things already?

Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by devbent on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @12:24AM (#41296795)
Auto adjusting other parts of the car based on what is happening, e.g. my car reduces fan speed when a call comes in.

Typically cars come with their own complete voice control system.

Customers expect much of the car to be accessible remotely and well, my GM Bolt EUV is far behind everyone else in this regard.

Re:GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US by shiroiushi on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @12:28AM (#41296821)
>Didn’t they also go with a plan to cut CarPlay and android auto. Seems like they are on track to shittify and get left behind

No, this isn't the case at all. To enshittify (you forgot the "en") means to get worse over time, as a result of poor management decisions that seek to increase profits. It implies that there was a time before, when the thing was actually good. But this is GM here: it's been making terrible cars for many decades now. I don't really see how it can enshittify.