News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by drewg123 on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @03:40PM (#41238936)
"all-day battery life"

Ugh, Apple really has lowered expectations. In order to switch from my Garmin, I'd want at least a week.. Even my MS Band from 10 years ago had 48hrs of battery life.

Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by nickthegreek on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @03:44PM (#41238976)
At least it has this:

>Plus, a new better Battery Saver Mode extends battery life to up to 36 hours across both sizes, without compromising any of your health and fitness tracking or safety features.

I don't know if 48 hr battery is that much better. Charging it everyday is easier than remembering every other day. You basically have to jump from 24hr to a week battery for people to truly care.

Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by drewg123 on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @03:52PM (#41239063)
That's what I've gotten used to from my Garmin. It has a claimed 2 weeks of life, and I charge it once a week.

I pointed out the 48hr life because I loved the MS Band, and I can't think of anything it didn't do that any modern smart watch does for me that I actually care about. And it got the same or better battery life as is typical in the market today. And on much worse hardware.

Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by jsheard on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @04:04PM (#41239205)
Is that a MIP Garmin or an OLED Garmin? I've heard that their OLED battery life is getting better with newer models but usually you have to make a choice between battery life and sunlight readability (better on MIP) or brightness and vibrancy (better on OLED) with them.
Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by sdoering on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @04:15PM (#41239315)
It also heavily depends on the amount of notifications and the brightness of the display. As well as a few - to me not easily identifiable - other factors. In the last few weeks I had battery life between 30hours and nearly 6 days.
Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by drewg123 on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @04:14PM (#41239304)
MIP ... Garmin Fenix 6 pro.
Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by cogman10 on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @05:53PM (#41240244)
I have an OLED garmin (965). Battery life is about 1 week for me.
Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by gwill on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @03:52PM (#41239064)
my garmin is currently low and i have 4 days of battery life or 2-3 long runs with gps and bluetooth enable left. with physical shortcuts to payment and timers, i haven't worn my apple watch in weeks
Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by entropie on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @04:18PM (#41239348)
Especially if you do a bit of serious (long-distance) running, you can't get past garmin. My partner has recently reached the semi-professional level and nobody there actually uses anything else. A few apple enthusiasts often refuse at first, but they all switch at some point.

I'm not that deep into the fitness scene, but I'm convinced by the 14-day battery life. But I also understand if you find the look a bit unfashionable.

Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by intothemild on Wednesday August 14, 2024 @05:30AM (#41244263)
As a distance runner myself, this is accurate. I've known a few people who are hesitant to switch from Apple (or really any "smart watch"), but when they do, it's the same comment "Oh wow I didn't know these were so good!"

A common complaint I hear is "yeah but there's no apps! how do I add extra functionality to my watch?" .. they just don't believe you when you say "it's already there"

Smart watches are general purpose devices, more sandboxes than anything else.. where as Fitness/Sports Watches (Garmin/Coros/Suunto/etc) already have everything you need for Fitness/Sports, and things you didn't know existed. What's happened is that it's trivially easy for Fitness watches to add some smart offerings (Calls/Texts/Notifications) and also some apps...then it is for Apple/Google/Samsung to add fitness things.

Sure Apple and also Google did add in some training load/status/etc stuff.. which is great cool... but it's also still a device that I have to charge daily, instead of monthly. And then, when theres a fitness metric or long term stat I want to see, i have to give some third party developer my health data to do it.

An example of that last thing. I have a friend who's a triathlete, I'm going to travel to run a Half Marathon with him, he uses an Apple Watch SE, I'm on a Garmin Fenix 7x.

He's jealous of all the long term stats I have, like all the training load over time, adaptive workouts, etc etc. He's on that cusp of ditching a smart watch and getting a dedicated fitness watch. When I see him, and he sees what I can do on my watch.. he's gonna love it.

Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by paradox460 on Wednesday August 14, 2024 @03:54PM (#41249859)
Even then, the no apps claim is false. You can make apps for Garmin stuff. They're written in monkey c, and are quite nice

I've got one for my smoker, a fireboard app. Useful to see the temp on my wrist when I've got a brisket finishing

Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by entropie on Wednesday August 14, 2024 @06:52PM (#41251354)
I see it pretty much the same way; there are no apps and the appstore is very underwhelming. There is no quality control and one is not even able to purchase anything without credit card.
Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by intothemild on Thursday August 15, 2024 @08:14AM (#41255029)
I think people who want apps on a fitness watch, ultimately want different things. Personally, apps on a tiny screen is not a good experience to me. So I never use them.

All the smart features i want on a watch is, Notifications, to know when someone is calling me, payments, and to find my phone.

Everything else is something I do on my phone.

Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by kbknight on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @05:05PM (#41239849)
Have had a Garmin Fenix for 4 years now. I will never again buy an Apple or Google smartwatch until they can complete on battery life.
Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by 8bithero on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @03:52PM (#41239057)
Personally I find notifications on a watch to be exceptionally annoying so I almost always have my watch set to sleep mode. The only thing I use the watch for is to tell the time, track my sleep, heart rate, and steps. I'm not sure if sleep mode affects the accuracy of the tracking but it does make my battery life last for a good 2-3 days.
Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by drewg123 on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @03:55PM (#41239102)
They are also a huge battery drain. I wish Garmin put the effort into their iOS app that they did with their Android so as to be able to filter notifications by app. Eg, I want iMessage notifications on my wrist, but I could care less about IG notifications, and I actively turn off bluetooth to save my battery life when my wife is forwarding me reel after reel...
Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by dktp on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @05:24PM (#41240021)
I'm in the same boat being extremely annoyed with notifications on the watch. But I just disabled them completely on my Garmin

There's a setting under Notifications & Alerts > Smart notifications > Status (switch to off). In the Garmin app

Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by lurking_swe on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @09:26PM (#41241674)
i disable all notifications except texts from my spouse and phone calls (from anyone). that’s my suggestion, it’s good balance. :)
Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by CooCooCaCha on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @04:12PM (#41239285)
Weird take. Do you think your Garmin and your 10 year old watch can do the same things as an Apple Watch? No.

Apple Watches are more like mini-iPhones. For example, I can take calls from my watch without a phone nearby, which is more appealing to me than multi-day battery life.

Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by giaour on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @04:45PM (#41239660)
Do you actually use the mic and speaker on your watch like Maxwell Smart, or do you need to also carry a bluetooth headset or pair of AirPods to take calls from your watch?
Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by CooCooCaCha on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @05:26PM (#41240033)
I do use the mic and speaker for short and simple conversations. Overall I like that I can go on a run and leave my phone at home while also being able to take a call if I need to.

Look, I’m not claiming it’s life changing. The way I describe the Apple Watch to people is that you can definitely live your life without it but the little conveniences add up.

It’s silly that I’m getting downvoted because it’s true. The Apple Watch and some android watches are more powerful devices more akin to a mini-phone. And because they’re more powerful they use more power. Do people really think Apple is purposefully gimping their own device or maybe there’s more too it than “these are all smart watches”.

I’m totally ok with charging my watch every night and the extra little conveniences I get from a more powerful device are worth it to me.

Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by pphysch on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @05:43PM (#41240162)
> The way I describe the Apple Watch to people is that you can definitely live your life without it but the little conveniences add up.

For a Garmin-style watch, the convenience of only needing a ~30min charge once or twice a month is pretty big.

Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by CooCooCaCha on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @06:17PM (#41240413)
I throw my watch on the charger when I go to sleep, so I don’t really seen the benefit. I’d rather have a more powerful device as a tradeoff.

If that matters to you then great but I take issue with putting all of these watches in the same bucket and pretending that they’re all the same except for battery life. It’s just not true.

Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by drewg123 on Wednesday August 14, 2024 @05:29AM (#41244248)
Your pattern would not work for me, and a few other the other commenters on this thread, because we value sleep tracking.

I had an Android Wear watch years ago (2016?) that started with 36hr battery life and did great sleep tracking and fitness tracking. Between updates and battery degradation, after a year or so, it would barely make it 18 hours. Then I had to start charging overnight so it would be charged enough for my 5am runs, and so I lost the sleep tracking feature.

Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by CooCooCaCha on Wednesday August 14, 2024 @09:14AM (#41245715)
Yeah that’s why Android sucks. Apple has way better hardware that lasts longer.
Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by alexey-salmin on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @06:06PM (#41240338)
Your take is much weirder for me. I barely even make calls on my phone nowadays but I use my Garmin watch many times a day. I also use them to track my sleep which would be very inconvenient if I had to charge them daily.
Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by CooCooCaCha on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @06:22PM (#41240455)
How is it a weird take? These devices serve different purposes, and their designs optimize for different things.

I like that my watch serves as a mini-iPhone, and I don’t mind charging it while I sleep. I like that I can install some of the same apps on my phone and watch.

Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by alexey-salmin on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @06:31PM (#41240539)
You wrote above that preferring a week-long battery life for a watch over an ability to make calls and install apps is a "weird take". For me it's exactly the opposite, I take the week-long battery any time. So if anything at all is weird here I'd vote for your viewpoint.
Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by CooCooCaCha on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @06:46PM (#41240639)
Congrats you completely misunderstood. Preferring a week long battery life isn’t weird.

What is weird is saying an Apple Watch is inferior to a 10 year old watch because of the battery life, when these are different devices with different purposes.

Think about this for a second, would Apple purposefully gimp their watch’s battery life or maybe, just maybe, there’s more going on.

Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by joecool1029 on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @08:08PM (#41241205)
> Think about this for a second, would Apple purposefully gimp their watch’s battery life

Yes?

Design a device with just enough to get through the day, forces getting replaced in a few years when battery degrades. Apple is a hardware company with the capability to optimize battery life but they don't since 80% health on a batt that lasts a week won't force a replacement for most customers.

Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by CooCooCaCha on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @08:44PM (#41241429)
Yet apple device batteries last longer than any other brand. My Apple Watch is 5 years old and lasts at least a day and a half. It feels as fast as the day I bought it and still gets major upgrades.

My other apple devices are the same way. I switched to iPhone 10 years ago they’ve held up very well.

Your statement is ignorant.

Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by drewg123 on Wednesday August 14, 2024 @05:25AM (#41244229)
I replaced my first Garmin (640M) at roughly 5 years old due to physical damage (it got mangled badly enough that the part of the case that holds the band on broke off), and it was still getting roughly the same battery life as it did when it was new.
Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by joecool1029 on Wednesday August 14, 2024 @06:54PM (#41251362)
Keep in mind you're doing far less charge cycles than a device with shorter battery life, it's going to last longer than a device that gets a full cycle per day. Not unreasonable for it to have under 500 cycles in a 5 year period (where this would be unheard of in a primary cellphone).
Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by joecool1029 on Wednesday August 14, 2024 @06:51PM (#41251348)
> Yet apple device batteries last longer than any other brand

Citation? In my experience this isn't the case. 2-3 years heavy use and the batt needs replacement (less than 80% design capacity). Can sometimes get as high as 5 years on a lightly used device. It may work longer but its not going to hold anywhere near design capacity. The dual-cell low voltage charging standards other manufacturers use seem to hold up longer since the heat is reduced.

> I switched to iPhone 10 years ago they’ve held up very well.

Cool, stuff like my original SE's hold up fine (and got a security update like a week ago). I've just replaced the batteries 2 or 3 times because they age and performance declines. This is expected but I'm not going to cope on a battery with 60% of its design capacity and act like its just as good as new.

> Your statement is ignorant.

I forgot how hard some people will try to rationalize their behavior. I still think the statement holds true knowing how many people I've met clinging to devices with dying batteries and saying 'well I have an upgrade coming soon' rather than just replacing the fucking battery.

Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by alexey-salmin on Wednesday August 14, 2024 @12:29AM (#41242556)
> Preferring a week long battery life isn’t weird. What is weird is saying an Apple Watch is inferior to a 10 year old watch because of the battery life, when these are different devices with different purposes.

It's the same thing. I'm not going to wear two watches, a choice has to be made. Based on criteria important to me (and to the original commenter you jumped on) Apple Watch is clearly inferior.

Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by maxglute on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @04:38PM (#41239575)
Was hoping needle move to all-week within a few iterations but not even close.

Still enjoying my glorified fitness band watch with 2-3 week battery life.

Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by giaour on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @04:44PM (#41239643)
100%! I switched from an Apple Watch to a WiThings ScanWatch for the battery life. Sleep tracking and vibrating alarms are kinda useless if you are expected to charge the watch every night.
Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by rootusrootus on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @07:13PM (#41240809)
Why charge it all night? Just throw it on the charger when you get in the shower. Even if it doesn't hit 100% in the space of one quick shower, it'll easily add enough charge to go at least one more full day.

I don't think I'd want the extra battery life unless it was much longer. Like a month or more. Remembering to charge a device just once a week is harder to make a habit out of than just putting the device on the inductive charger every time I take a shower.

Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by giaour on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @08:42PM (#41241415)
I think this approach works for the newer and more expensive models but not for the SE (which is what I had). The SE's battery is only rated to last 18 hours and does not offer fast charging, so taking it off and sticking it on the charger when you go to bed made sense; otherwise, you need to charge it at alternating times of day or leave it off for 6 hours in the middle of the day.
Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by officeplant on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @06:41PM (#41240614)
Honest question. Do you not have 30 minutes to spare daily where you don't wear your watch and it could charge?
Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by giaour on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @08:38PM (#41241386)
I made the switch a few years ago, but I recall the Apple watch taking much longer than 30 mins to charge. The current iteration of the Apple Watch SE (which is what I had) claims that the battery lasts 18 hours and can charge from 0-80% in 90 minutes: https://www.apple.com/apple-watch-se/specs/

I'm much happier with a watch that does fewer things but does them well. Only having to charge it for ~30 minutes once every few weeks means that I can just leave it on all the time like the non-smart watches I used to wear.

Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by patwolf on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @10:22PM (#41241958)
I tried many Fitbits and Samsung watches before discovering the ScanWatch. I briefly get excited when a new Pixel or Samsung watch is announced, and then I remember I have no interest in charging it every night, or every week.
Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by aliasxneo on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @05:15PM (#41239935)
I have failed to comprehend the allure for precisely this reason. I've looked at adopting the Apple Watch a few times now, but as a person who struggles with insomnia and finds sleep tracking valuable, I'd have to buy a separate device to use with the watch because of the battery life. Or, I could just keep my current Fitbit which consistently lasts a week and gives me good enough information.
Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by rootusrootus on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @07:06PM (#41240774)
People make it out to be some big deal, but I don't really understand. I have an Ultra 2, and it goes an easy 2 days on a single charge. I wear it all day and all night (for sleep tracking), and put it on the charger when I get in the shower. When I'm getting dressed, I put it back on and it's good to go.
Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by willio58 on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @07:34PM (#41240951)
Same here. It's been great, and I'm on the Ultra 1 still.

I will say it wasn't great when I had the non-Ultra. It was fine at first, the watch would last a full day, but like 2 or 3 years later it would struggle if I did a lot of exercise in a day to make it to the time I go to bed.

I also recently went on a 5-day backpacking trip and it was a struggle to keep my phone and watch charged with an external battery. If the ultra lasted even 3 days instead of just 2ish on a charge this would have made it way easier. By the end of the trip to save charge I just gave up charging the watch.

Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by officeplant on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @06:39PM (#41240591)
I just charge my watch once I get home from work. Only takes 30-40 minutes. Its not gonna miss many bio-metrics while I watch an episode of a favorite show.
Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by brookst on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @05:39PM (#41240135)
FWIW the Android and Apple smartwatches will all charge nearly completely during a 15 minute shower. It's very possible to wear them for sleep tracking and only charge a bit a day.

But I agree there is a huge difference between once-daily charging and once-weekly charging.

Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by lurking_swe on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @09:19PM (#41241634)
not trying to sway you but just thought it’s useful to know, the apple watch ultra 2 easily lasts me 2.5 - 3 days without a charge with normal usage. That includes sleeping with it and some cellular-only usage as well.
Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by SirMaster on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @09:35PM (#41241714)
Is it that big of a deal?

You can't just throw it on the charger for a few minutes before bed and awhile during shower in the morning?

Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by mejthemage on Wednesday August 14, 2024 @10:55AM (#41246837)
The number one reason I forget my watch (Garmin) is because it was on the charger the once in like 10+ days I needed to charge it.

That is a big deal to me personally, that's an extra routine I have to incorporate into my day that given the option I'd rather not.

Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by trog on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @06:51PM (#41240682)
My Fitbit devices (first Ionic, and now on my second Sense) have spoiled me, I can't imagine having to think about charging on a daily basis. I get 3-5 days depending on what I'm doing.

I'm sure you get used to it and it becomes part of a routine but it's nice not having to deal with it daily.

Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by lawn on Wednesday August 14, 2024 @04:18AM (#41243809)
Indeed.

I went even further and got a Garmin Instinct 2X Solar with a battery life of a month.

I didn't understand how annoying it was to always charge the watch/Oura ring/Whoop band/phone until I got rid of them (except for the phone, that's still annoying).

Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by juntoalaluna on Wednesday August 14, 2024 @08:21AM (#41245241)
FWIW, I never ran out of battery with my Apple Watch. Charging it was part of my routine.

I changed to a Garmin this year (started to do ultra marathons) and I've run out a couple of times because I just don't remember to charge. Especially when using GPS and bluetooth audio with it massively bumps up power consumption (which felt less like the case on the Apple Watch)

Still prefer the Garmin, but just saying that I don't think battery life is the huge feature that people think it is.

Re:Google Pixel Watch 3: bigger, brighter, fine-tuned for fi... by Ajedi32 on Wednesday August 14, 2024 @10:20AM (#41246398)
I charge every night so all day is all I really need, but unless they're advertising at least 2 day battery life it's probably not going to consistently last all day (especially after a couple years of charge/discharge cycles) so that's a bit of a nonstarter for me.