News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NASA Says Boeing Starliner Astronauts May Fly Home on Spa... by WalterBright on Thursday August 08, 2024 @02:00AM (#41188546)
> I don't envy the engineers, either at NASA or at Boeing.

When I worked at Boeing, I talked with my lead engineer about this. He said there were indeed some excellent engineers who could not live with the possiblity of making a mistake. Boeing would find jobs for them that were not safety critical, like design studies of new aircraft. There they could be productive without the stress.

Personally, I found the stress to be motivating. It meant I was doing something that mattered.

Re:NASA Says Boeing Starliner Astronauts May Fly Home on Spa... by GMoromisato on Thursday August 08, 2024 @02:37AM (#41188720)
Very interesting insight. Thank you!

Right now, I’m sure Starliner engineers are under a lot of stress. But I really believe that the program will get through this and end up being successful.

Re:NASA Says Boeing Starliner Astronauts May Fly Home on Spa... by WalterBright on Thursday August 08, 2024 @03:16AM (#41188928)
It's a bit like finals in college. I knew that without the stress from the threat of failing the finals, I wouldn't apply myself to learning the material. Stress brings out the best in people.
Re:NASA Says Boeing Starliner Astronauts May Fly Home on Spa... by HPsquared on Thursday August 08, 2024 @03:56AM (#41189139)
It's like "angle of attack" in a wing (funnily enough, given the topic).

Increasing it works up to a point (increasing lift) but at the cost of increased drag and, at a certain point, a stall. I've found myself, at different points, "coasting" (gliding) and "stalling" (pulling up too hard when I'm not in the right conditions). Long-term burnout is like being "behind the power curve" and gradually losing energy.

Re:NASA Says Boeing Starliner Astronauts May Fly Home on Spa... by stavros on Thursday August 08, 2024 @04:45AM (#41189390)
I find the solution of giving non-safety-critical posts to the engineers that care most about safety very indicative of the culture at Boeing.
Re:NASA Says Boeing Starliner Astronauts May Fly Home on Spa... by Yeul on Thursday August 08, 2024 @07:33AM (#41190360)
It's space. If you want safe you stay at home. There will always be a risk when you ride a rocket into orbit.
Re:NASA Says Boeing Starliner Astronauts May Fly Home on Spa... by stavros on Thursday August 08, 2024 @07:45AM (#41190456)
Yes, there are no degrees of safety, might as well strap yourself to a cannon bomb and ride it!
Re:NASA Says Boeing Starliner Astronauts May Fly Home on Spa... by generalizations on Thursday August 08, 2024 @01:26PM (#41194053)
> engineers who could not live with the possiblity of making a mistake

The whole point, as I read it, is that those engineers could not handle "degrees of safety".

Re:NASA Says Boeing Starliner Astronauts May Fly Home on Spa... by 93po on Thursday August 08, 2024 @07:47AM (#41190466)
should we apply this to boeing's planes too?
Re:NASA Says Boeing Starliner Astronauts May Fly Home on Spa... by Loughla on Thursday August 08, 2024 @08:46AM (#41190940)
No because we're not talking about that.
Re:NASA Says Boeing Starliner Astronauts May Fly Home on Spa... by michaelt on Thursday August 08, 2024 @09:43AM (#41191410)
Yes, there will always be a risk when you ride a 737 into orbit too.
Re:NASA Says Boeing Starliner Astronauts May Fly Home on Spa... by 93po on Friday August 09, 2024 @10:49AM (#41202406)
this was pretty good
Re:NASA Says Boeing Starliner Astronauts May Fly Home on Spa... by Dalewyn on Thursday August 08, 2024 @12:17PM (#41193160)
Should be applied to aircraft in general, yes.

It is mind boggling just how many things need to work perfectly constantly consistently to maintain safe flight. This goes for both Boeing and Airbus (and Embraer, Cessna, et al.); all of General Electric, Pratt & Whitney, and Rolls Royce; etc.

Re:NASA Says Boeing Starliner Astronauts May Fly Home on Spa... by Twirrim on Thursday August 08, 2024 @12:18PM (#41193168)
Yes, just like you also do with Airbus too, and any other plane manufacturers. You already factor in risk every time you set foot in a car, too, and a car is a far more dangerous vehicle. Danger from crashing is an inherent danger in travelling faster than on foot, and when you're on foot you're also facing the risk of being hit by those moving in those fast vehicles.
Re:NASA Says Boeing Starliner Astronauts May Fly Home on Spa... by eqvinox on Thursday August 08, 2024 @05:46AM (#41189702)
"engineers who could not live with the possiblity of making a mistake" is not the same as "engineers that care most about safety"
Re:NASA Says Boeing Starliner Astronauts May Fly Home on Spa... by stavros on Thursday August 08, 2024 @05:57AM (#41189780)
You think they'll be sloppy about safety and then just kill themselves when someone dies?
Re:NASA Says Boeing Starliner Astronauts May Fly Home on Spa... by ahmedfromtunis on Thursday August 08, 2024 @07:05AM (#41190140)
Back when I started engineering school, we tended to add more constraints to systems than what they actually need believing that we were making them more secure and "safer".

"This will make sure we cover edge cases we're not aware of", we thought.

Later we discovered such systems are called "hyperstatic" and that they are actually more fragile and more prone to malfunction. What we should've aimed for are isostatic systems, where less constraints meant more stable systems.

I'm not saying Boeing engineering aren't aware of this. Of course they do. I just wanted to show an example of how trying to avoid mistakes *may* lead to less safe systems.

Re:NASA Says Boeing Starliner Astronauts May Fly Home on Spa... by stavros on Thursday August 08, 2024 @07:23AM (#41190265)
Sure, but this just assumes they don't know what they're doing (which, well, is probably true). It doesn't refute the point that you want to put people who are obsessive about safety in charge of safety.

I work for a healthcare company, and we definitely put in charge of safety people who stress about a patient coming to harm, not people who are so-so about it.

Re:NASA Says Boeing Starliner Astronauts May Fly Home on Spa... by ethbr1 on Thursday August 08, 2024 @08:10AM (#41190657)
I read GP as relocating people who were paralyzed by safety.

E.g. the developers who never ship code because they always want to write the better version of the thing, that they thought up while building the current version

At some point you have to look at a less than perfect design and answer the question of whether it's good enough for the requirements at hand.

Re:NASA Says Boeing Starliner Astronauts May Fly Home on Spa... by WalterBright on Thursday August 08, 2024 @02:19PM (#41194626)
It's about engineers who are paralyzed by the thought that if they make a mistake, people will die.

It's not about striving for perfection.

Re:NASA Says Boeing Starliner Astronauts May Fly Home on Spa... by ethbr1 on Thursday August 08, 2024 @06:24PM (#41197006)
Are those things different? (honestly asking)

It feels like the same coin to me: inability to accept calculated risk.

Re:NASA Says Boeing Starliner Astronauts May Fly Home on Spa... by eqvinox on Friday August 09, 2024 @10:29AM (#41202187)
You can strive for perfection and still have a grounded outlook on tradeoffs. Those people would in fact be very good for engineering security-critical aspects IMHO. I don't think "striving for perfection" in itself implies the inability to accept a calculated risk, or some type of paralyzation.

I'd look at this the other way around, there are people who don't strive for perfection, simply delivering something when it just meets expected bars, not giving any thought beyond that. I wouldn't want those people to design my safety systems, they'd just leave possible improvements lying on the ground by not caring to think a little beyond the boundary of their "box".

Re:NASA Says Boeing Starliner Astronauts May Fly Home on Spa... by ungreased0675 on Thursday August 08, 2024 @11:16PM (#41198515)
Are there any layperson accessible books that explain these systems concepts? I’m curious if there’s a crossover application to organizational systems.
Re:NASA Says Boeing Starliner Astronauts May Fly Home on Spa... by ahmedfromtunis on Friday August 09, 2024 @06:41PM (#41205963)
Not that I'm aware of. This was taught as an introductory course in mechanical systems design or something like that (it was many years ago).

But yeah, I frequently apply this concept way beyond its initial purpose, especially in matters that relate to managing human relations both professional and personal which, sometimes, closely resembles the application of the illusion of choice.

I'll do some research to see if there are any books that I can recommend.

Re:NASA Says Boeing Starliner Astronauts May Fly Home on Spa... by Gracana on Thursday August 08, 2024 @08:01AM (#41190567)
It sounds like they'd burn out and quit, and management would rather find them a place where they can stay than lose them.
Re:NASA Says Boeing Starliner Astronauts May Fly Home on Spa... by WalterBright on Thursday August 08, 2024 @02:21PM (#41194652)
It's not about burnout. It's about otherwise competent engineers who are paralyzed by fear of making a mistake.

Finding a productive place for them, where their expertise counts, but peoples' lives don't hang on the results, is just good management.

Re:NASA Says Boeing Starliner Astronauts May Fly Home on Spa... by cptskippy on Thursday August 08, 2024 @09:58AM (#41191586)
You think the entire Starliner project is just engineers being sloppy?
Re:NASA Says Boeing Starliner Astronauts May Fly Home on Spa... by stavros on Thursday August 08, 2024 @10:41AM (#41192058)
Of course not, if there's one thing Boeing is famous for right now, that's their attention to safety.

I believe their motto is "Safety to the Max".

Re:NASA Says Boeing Starliner Astronauts May Fly Home on Spa... by cptskippy on Thursday August 08, 2024 @11:11AM (#41192365)
So why do you assume that they'll be slopping and kill themselves? Why is that the only option? Couldn't someone make a mistake? Couldn't the person just be riddled with guilt and just abandon their career.
Re:NASA Says Boeing Starliner Astronauts May Fly Home on Spa... by jjk166 on Thursday August 08, 2024 @11:14AM (#41192408)
I'd prefer not to believe they tried to screw up on purpose.
Re:NASA Says Boeing Starliner Astronauts May Fly Home on Spa... by WalterBright on Thursday August 08, 2024 @12:44PM (#41193513)
Right. Some want to work on the hard safety issues because they do care about it.
Re:NASA Says Boeing Starliner Astronauts May Fly Home on Spa... by HeyLaughingBoy on Thursday August 08, 2024 @11:01AM (#41192263)
That's not remotely what he said.
Re:NASA Says Boeing Starliner Astronauts May Fly Home on Spa... by prewett on Thursday August 08, 2024 @03:15PM (#41195156)
I think parent meant that some people did not want to be in a position where they could make a mistake that mattered (that is, they are uncomfortable being responsible for safety). Those people were put on projects where failure had few consequences. This is the kind of person unwilling to have a safety-critical position.
Re:NASA Says Boeing Starliner Astronauts May Fly Home on Spa... by tracker1 on Thursday August 08, 2024 @11:22AM (#41192496)
It's hard for me to imagine... I've been in a position to work on training software for some aerospace equipment and maintenance, but even that was well defined before I touched it. The closest I've come to that level of stress was working on security provisioning around financial systems. Hard to imagine being responsible directly for people's lives, not just livelihood.
Re:NASA Says Boeing Starliner Astronauts May Fly Home on Spa... by tiahura on Thursday August 08, 2024 @10:23PM (#41198316)
Hard to imagine being responsible directly for people's lives

Don’t you drive?