News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by DevX101 on Thursday August 01, 2024 @01:12PM (#41131302)
I wonder how many of these 100,000 cars purchased were due to Elon's false claims that self driving would have been available and INCREASED the value of the cars.

At the time, I found his claims hard to believe but I didn't have much conviction given his extremely strong track record up to that point.

Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by pavlov on Thursday August 01, 2024 @01:28PM (#41131434)
A corporation like Hertz has the resources to evaluate Musk’s claims before committing to buy 100,000 cars.

If they truly believed these cars would soon drive themselves, that’s entirely the fault of executives who didn’t do the minimum due diligence. Spending $100k to get a few consultants’ opinions would have been enough to pop that bubble.

Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by rchaud on Thursday August 01, 2024 @01:35PM (#41131491)
According to the Bloomberg Businessweek story, Hertz top management were a couple of finance bros from private equity. They appointed a Goldman CFO as CEO, one with no background in automotive/transport industry. The whole Tesla bet appeared to be part of a executive fever dream to rebrand Hertz as a vanguard of the future.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39928913

Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by JohnFen on Thursday August 01, 2024 @04:12PM (#41133087)
> Hertz top management were a couple of finance bros from private equity.

That explains quite a lot, right there.

Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by brigadier132 on Thursday August 01, 2024 @01:44PM (#41131586)
Hertz is not an exciting company, the only people that want to be involved are people interested in money.
Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by vel0city on Thursday August 01, 2024 @02:40PM (#41132156)
It's exciting in the same way fireworks or a train accident or a raging city fire are exiting. We're expecting to see some crazy big booms given the reagents at play.
Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by benopal64 on Thursday August 01, 2024 @01:56PM (#41131717)
Have you ever had a Hertz Donut?
Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by lenerdenator on Thursday August 01, 2024 @01:44PM (#41131594)
Sounds like it's time for some lawsuits against the board/management from shareholders.

EDIT: Not understanding the downvotes.

Board members and executives have a fiduciary duty to shareholders. They let their hubris get the best of them and that left the company with a fleet of assets that are depreciating rapidly, even by automotive standards. Thus the company is not returning as much value as it could if it had purchased more traditional vehicles.

"I have a fiduciary duty to shareholders" can't just be used by executives and board members to explain away budget cuts and massively upending peoples' lives with layoffs. It should cut both ways.

Or are we going to just finally admit that this excuse only serves to protect management and capital?

Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by alwa on Thursday August 01, 2024 @02:16PM (#41131925)
I don’t know, but I suspect people may be reacting negatively because, as they say, hindsight is 20/20. The bet didn’t work out, but that doesn’t mean it was a self-evidently stupid thing to try from the perspective of 2020/2021.

It seems to me that sometimes somebody has to try a thing for us all to find out that it doesn’t work. If people with money in the company were sure it was a dumb idea all along, couldn’t they have sold their shares? Or even done fancy options trades to profit from their contrarian certitude?

Why would a court be involved in something like this, where management very clearly said what they were going to do, they did it, and it just didn’t work out the way they’d hoped?

Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by lenerdenator on Thursday August 01, 2024 @04:21PM (#41133182)
>hindsight is 20/20

If Tesla's lack of parts is the problem - and the article asserts that as a possible problem - then it's nothing to do with hindsight. Tesla either had the demonstrable ability to provide repair/replacement parts on time, or they didn't. You get that in writing and you have people actually dig to see if the supply chain was there. That's something you check before you ink the deal.

The article also mentions that there are other EVs in the fleet that haven't caused the financial problems. In other words, there's something about how Hertz structured the Tesla deal that was less-than-brilliant.

> Why would a court be involved in something like this, where management very clearly said what they were going to do, they did it, and it just didn’t work out the way they’d hoped?

Because they may not have done their due diligence in signing the deal with Tesla, and it's costing shareholders money. Making bets is one thing; making one that deals with something outside of your ken is another. Your job as a board or c-suite is to find the people to give you the straight dope on things you don't know about, not be distracted by new shiny from Silicon Valley.

Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by hluska on Thursday August 01, 2024 @02:39PM (#41132144)
In 2020 (one year before Hertz made its purchase), Tesla models 3 and Y were retaining 90% of their resale value after three years.

That resale value retention was harmed by two things that would not have been evident when they purchased the EVs:

1.) Tesla started cutting prices on new EVs.

2.) Incentives to purchase new EVs stayed high.

If we interpret fiduciary duty that broadly, I think I better start cutting grass instead.

Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by ghaff on Thursday August 01, 2024 @04:05PM (#41133016)
There are a lot of reasons to think the execs who made the decision were stupid--and yes, it's easier with hindsight. But the reflexive "they should have been sued" or even tossed in jail you get here for a lot of things gets pretty dangerous and can very easily be extended to engineers who make a mistake. It does encourage the others perhaps but probably isn't what you want to do in general.
Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by lenerdenator on Thursday August 01, 2024 @04:32PM (#41133307)
> There are a lot of reasons to think the execs who made the decision were stupid--and yes, it's easier with hindsight. But the reflexive "they should have been sued" or even tossed in jail you get here for a lot of things gets pretty dangerous and can very easily be extended to engineers who make a mistake.

Who's saying that engineers should be thrown in jail for making a mistake?

I'm saying that there's reason to believe that maybe Hertz's leadership didn't do their jobs. Lawsuits for that kind of thing are filed all. The. Time. in this country. If we're here to create value for shareholders by any legal means, and they don't do that, well... the monetary loss and resulting lawsuit is the risk that justifies the insane amount of money people in that level of the company make. Who knows, maybe the suit would be tossed.

If they don't want to deal with that, maybe a nice six-figure and full benefits compensation package would be more their speed.

Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by lenerdenator on Thursday August 01, 2024 @04:25PM (#41133217)
> 1.) Tesla started cutting prices on new EVs.

Sounds like the executives who did the deal should have come to an understanding with Tesla about not doing things to massively dilute the value of the fleet.

Either they forgot to, or they bought the bullsh*t. Either way they're incompetent and don't deserve more money than most people will make in their entire lives within the span of a few years of work. Drag them in for a deposition to find out which one it was and recover some of the money.

Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by Kon-Peki on Thursday August 01, 2024 @05:14PM (#41133697)
> Hertz top management were a couple of finance bros from private equity. They appointed a Goldman CFO as CEO, one with no background in automotive/transport industry. The whole Tesla bet appeared to be part of an executive fever dream to rebrand Hertz as a vanguard of the future.

Mark Fields, who had spent ~30 years at Ford and was fired for not moving them fast enough into EVs, was the interim CEO while they searched for and found the Goldman guy for their permanent CEO. It was Fields that announced the deal with Tesla, although you have to wonder how much of it was already in place - he had been CEO for like 3 weeks at that point. Or, you know, maybe his thought process was "I'm not making this mistake twice" and the finance bros loved it and that's why they hired him.

Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by ghaff on Thursday August 01, 2024 @01:36PM (#41131502)
Yes, should have been blindingly obvious at the time to anyone who did minimum investigation that full autonomy within the (short) lifetime of a rental car was a complete fantasy.

I find it easier to believe that Hertz thought electric vehicles would be a big consumer draw but, as a sometimes renter, I have trouble seeing the appeal of dealing with something unfamiliar as a renter aside from maybe a one-time novelty.

Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by haliskerbas on Thursday August 01, 2024 @01:40PM (#41131553)
I rent a car around 6 times a year and I like trying out a different vehicle as often as I can. Adding car charging time into my short vacation in an unknown place, and being on the hook for returning it charged, etc. Might as well not deal with the hassle!
Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by JohnFen on Thursday August 01, 2024 @04:16PM (#41133121)
> I like trying out a different vehicle as often as I can.

Interesting. I rent just about that often, but I try to get a car that I'm already familiar with. If I'm renting a car, I'm probably somewhere that I'm not familiar with and have my hands and brain full of other stuff that needs attention. The last thing I want to do is add "get used to a different car" to that list.

Most EVs, and Teslas particularly, have very different controls than the cars I am used to. I actively avoid them all mostly for that reason.

Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by ghaff on Thursday August 01, 2024 @04:24PM (#41133207)
I'll rent something that is similar to the vehicles I own but maybe somewhat different to try out. However, absent special needs, I wouldn't be inclined to rent something radically different unless it was a utilitarian sedan or something like that. But I wouldn't rent an electric car except as a novelty.
Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by pavlov on Thursday August 01, 2024 @02:05PM (#41131813)
I'm surprised that Hertz didn't build chargers on premises for this fleet.

I can see why car rental companies expect fossil fuel cars to be returned with a full tank, but for an electric car, they can charge it themselves. Being able to return the car without having to worry about recharging would make the electric cars more attractive.

Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by nunez on Friday August 02, 2024 @12:02AM (#41136007)
They invested significant capital in doing exactly that...at their prime locations (airports).

The challenge here is that they didn't invest in building charging infrastructure at ALL of their locations (neighborhood centers, small airports, hotels, etc).

This is problematic because a renter that decides last minute to one-way their car from a prime location to a non-prime location without charging first essentially took that car out of rev service for the day. An ICE car would never have that problem.

This, of course, was fine when used EVs barely lost their value, but now that they depreciated like a rock since 2023, these cars are a cumulative black hole in forward revenue.

Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by ghaff on Thursday August 01, 2024 @01:46PM (#41131606)
Exactly. I might rent a Tesla once just to see what it was like. But figuring out how to return a car fueled is enough hassle as it is. Rarely rent a car these days. Uber/Lyft has covered a lot of the edge cases in the US but still do it a few times a year.
Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by vel0city on Thursday August 01, 2024 @02:45PM (#41132204)
Exactly. Given the lower "fuel" cost and lower cost for employees to spend time "refueling" they should have accepted anything above like 20% with no cost. Their costs for recharging on industrial electric should have been like a dollar or two on an average battery, they should just leave them plugged in most of the time pulling little power. Dumb they weren't always guaranteed to be like 90+% and free over 20% charged on return.
Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by taylodl on Thursday August 01, 2024 @02:02PM (#41131782)
Which is even worse: Hertz has no idea who their customer is!

I make 2-3 long trips per year, and I rent a car for each. Why?

- I buy cheap, reliable transportation with a focus on commuting. You don't want to be in my car for several hours on a long trip.

- If I break down, the rental company takes care of it. I don't have to find a shop and wait for a part.

- I save a fortune. I know people who base their car-buying decision based off the couple of long trips they make per year. They end up paying 2x - 3x more for their car than I've paid for mine. They also typically have higher fueling costs and higher repair costs.

- When I do get an EV, I don't have one yet, I won't worry about range anxiety

That last point is what I never understood about Hertz - you should be pitching your rentals to EV owners as a solution for range anxiety on long distance trips. Easy peasy! You get sales. Not here's unfamiliar technology you're using in an unfamiliar place, figure it out! How did they ever think that was a smart idea?

Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by ghaff on Friday August 02, 2024 @10:21AM (#41139011)
I don't really consider several hours a long trip. I routinely do 2-5 hours on a weekend and can't believe that's so unusual or that a family or a group wouldn't want a vehicle set up for the purpose. Of course, others have different needs.
Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by foobarian on Thursday August 01, 2024 @01:49PM (#41131643)
I'm sure they did get consultants opinions and do due diligence. But the funny thing about leadership is, they can be prone to going against the grain of armchair quarterbacks with no skin in the game who always say no. Given who the interim CEO team was they probably ignored (or, not ignored but considered and went against) the reports in favor of a risky bet.

It didn't happen to work out. However if it did, they would be hailed as visionary heroes.

Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by mathgradthrow on Thursday August 01, 2024 @01:33PM (#41131474)
>that’s entirely the fault of executives who didn’t do the minimum due diligence

Entirely? Like 100%?

Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by ghaff on Thursday August 01, 2024 @01:37PM (#41131527)
Yes? It was their decision.
Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by marcosdumay on Thursday August 01, 2024 @01:49PM (#41131638)
I think the GP is trying to say that Tesla shouldn't be allowed to publish wild lies on their marketing material.
Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by pavlov on Thursday August 01, 2024 @02:08PM (#41131847)
The law is very different when a corporation is lying to retail customers in their marketing material vs. lying to another corporation in a B2B deal.

The latter can still be fraud, but the bar is much higher. Hertz would have to show that Tesla actually promised self-driving in a contract.

Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by ghaff on Thursday August 01, 2024 @01:52PM (#41131663)
Perhaps. But it was pretty obvious at the time that they were wild lies. Not excusing Tesla but one would hope that very well-paid execs would get it--but that may be optimistic.
Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by nashashmi on Thursday August 01, 2024 @01:56PM (#41131714)
Well paid executives learned to rely on vendor statements and vendor litigation. They don't question it. If you offer them a magic wheel, they will buy your magic wheel (after you have the right bonding and insurance backings).
Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by rvnx on Thursday August 01, 2024 @02:01PM (#41131774)
And the practice shows that if you have billions it's totally ok to lie or to infringe copyright (e.g. large AI companies, or search engines).

It's only a problem if you are poor.

Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by marcosdumay on Thursday August 01, 2024 @03:11PM (#41132502)
Oh, yes. It was blatant incompetence.

But more than one part can be guilty.

Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by quantified on Thursday August 01, 2024 @02:11PM (#41131888)
That depends entirely on the quality of the consultants and how they framed the assignment.
Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by woodruffw on Thursday August 01, 2024 @01:35PM (#41131498)
It’s not this simple, typically. Diligence can mean requesting internal documents or statements, which doesn’t prevent a thoroughly dishonest partner from just plain lying about their capabilities. It doesn’t seem inconceivable to me that Hertz performed that kind of diligence, perhaps not recognizing the kind of shyster they were dealing with.
Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by chadrs on Thursday August 01, 2024 @01:44PM (#41131590)
and even if some analysts at Hertz could did their job, I'm sure they were promptly ignored by executives who just liked Elon's vibe.
Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by rsynnott on Friday August 02, 2024 @07:13AM (#41137853)
A company like Walgreens had the resources to evaluate Holmes' claims before committing hundreds of millions on a Theranos scheme. And yet...

Big companies seem to be worse than you'd think at filtering out obvious nonsense vendor claims.

(Notably, people at Walgreens were going, "er, yeah, not sure about this, seems like bullshit", but they were overruled by the decision-makers).

Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by nashashmi on Thursday August 01, 2024 @01:52PM (#41131666)
> strong track record

The only record he had was ambition. Otherwise, his companies' record is filled with delays. And his personal record is filled with hostilities.

If you mean to say his ambitious and callous track record gave you hope that you will see rogue bullish auto driving, I understand you. I am still waiting for this to happen. I am expecting him to launch a self drive that is both bullish and dangerous and a mess on the roads.

Otherwise, his other claim that CURRENT vehicles (at the time) will be upgraded to self driving, was entirely a let-down and an opener for lawsuit and false advertising.

Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by rtkwe on Thursday August 01, 2024 @01:35PM (#41131487)
Hertz's big purchase seems to have happened in 2021, by then it was pretty well established that Musk constantly promises FSD will be ready and operating either 'next year' or 'in a few months' in a pattern stretching back to the late 2010s.
Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by rvnx on Thursday August 01, 2024 @01:56PM (#41131706)
Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by rtkwe on Thursday August 01, 2024 @02:21PM (#41131970)
Oh yeah he's never stopped claiming it's just around the corner because it helps prop up sales and gets people to spring for the FSD extra package at great profit for Tesla. I think it's nearing a decade since he started the cycle at this point?
Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by lawn on Thursday August 01, 2024 @01:22PM (#41131393)
> given his extremely strong track record up to that point.

I'm sorry, I can't tell if this is sarcasm or not.

Re:Hertz accelerates sales of Tesla vehicles as value crumbles by nunez on Thursday August 01, 2024 @11:54PM (#41135962)
Hertz bought a ton of Teslas because their used value was extremely high at the time (excellent for the rental car business) and they wanted to be seen as a leader in rental car innovation. Nothing to do with FSD (which was never enabled in any of their cars)