So my hope would be they would realize that, lean into it, and cut their other experiments or just not do movies as much.
I know for me anytime I see a new science fiction show on Apple TV I feel like it is at least worth checking out the first couple episodes, and I have not been upset yet.
It's a reddit link but some details in the comments and the original source did seem a bit tabloidy.
Rather put the money into an Apple Robot. The robot needs to have Eddye Cue eyes and that constant grin.
And there are extra characters who are not in the books at all.
So I'm pretty sure they're adapting heavily just to avoid the second and third book things.
Sometimes less is more.
I've read the "Second Foundation trilogy" written by other renowned sci-fi authors, as well as the later Foundation books written by Asimov. They had typical main characters with hero's arcs driving the story. I much preferred the originals.
Especially the first book. It's refreshing to read a story where events occur because of unstoppable historical forces instead of the superhuman actions of a hero.
If I wanted a story about a hero, I could read...well...just about any other book ever written.
Generally that takes the form of characters who experience things — ideally growing or changing in response, although many genres and formats don’t require that part. It’s unnecessary since part of the medium of television, unlike the novel, is people putting on a show to entertain you which is different from reading, an inherently more-individual experience. Part of what TV is selling is a group of people to hang out with every week. Generally.
Which is not to say always — shows like Twilight Zone and Tales from the Crypt proved the anthology format has a wide audience. But they had the advantage of a brand new paradigm each week, which creates a relationship with the show itself (but even TZ allowed the audience Serling).
Foundation def be done as anthology style episodes with some crossovers/overlap, but again practical realities make it difficult to guarantee narratively-necessary access to actors due to contract and scheduling factors, and you have the issue of both too big for standard structure and “not big enough” for a true anthology at its core. Not saying it couldn’t work it’d just be more difficult, which is not a quality that makes studios likely to invest.
Either way though, there are issues with the adaptation that are quite distinct from eschewing the episodic arc of the original trilogy. It's full of spiritual woo for one, which is entirely antithetical to Azimov's vision. It's also more than fond of sadistic violence. Azimov's whole method as a writer was to have smart characters solve difficult problems intellectually. 'Violence is the last resort of the incompetent' after all.
That recurrence that wouldn’t be possible for a Foundation series without suggesting characters themselves are repeating through time, which would seem to lean even harder into woo, which I’m sensing is not your bag.
On goodreads Foundation (which IMHO is not even among the best Asimov works) is rated noticeably higher than The Three Body Problem, and as a reader I feel it is justified.
If you take into account the novelty factor, it will probably sink to the average rating of mediocrity in a couple of decades.
Re: A hero's journey, hard disagree. There are numerous heroes in the original foundation series, and the later books have one very well drawn one - Golan Trevize, in addition to a host of memorable characters.
I used to go to the cinema almost weekly, but since a few years ago it doesn't seem worth it: The stories being told are shiny but flat.
Now I just watch the "good ol' movies" at home...
Ted Lasso, probably their biggest hit? Masters of the Air?
My favorite Apple TV series is actually "Lessons in Chemistry". The protagonist is Brie Larson. 2023 show.
On the sci-fi side, I really enjoyed Apple TV's Silo led by Rebecca Ferguson. Also 2023.
Just as an immediate reaction in the context of this thread: Silo.
Ask yourself: why do you even notice something like this, much less let it ruin your viewing experience? Why does it matter?
And to many of the current shows being produced, this seems to be more important than actually telling a good story.
And like I said, that is my main issue with these productions.
> my main issue with these productions.
My main issue is that most of the shows or movies these days are too dark and hard to understand without subtitles.
My main issue with subtitles is that I don't need the lyrics in the background sound interspersed with the dialog.
Some shows will have both, some will have just one or another. It various for foreign films. It will be "English (CC)" where you just want "English".
Proper subtitles just include verbal content like dialog or narration.
EDIT: For noworriesnate:
Would politely suggest you re-read: this thread wasn't a generic complaint about Apple TV+, or TV, or Woke, or the MSM, or the Liberals, or the Left, or Commies, or ideological programming, or anything else.
He made a very specific claim and challenge, which I thoroughly responded to, in the link provided. Here it is again: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41037962.
If you'd like to make a more specific claim, I have a feeling you're not mocking free speech advocates like them and will support you against the woke mob
The claim is absurd at its face. We can double check by visiting https://www.apple.com/tv-pr/originals/filters/series/2024/
- Lady in the Lake (protoganist: Natalie Portman, white girl, competent, no villain)
- Sunny (protoganist: widowed Rashida Jones, white husband died but I don't think that means he was a villain or incompetent)
- Presumed Innocent (protoganist: Jake Gyllenhall, white male DA taking on evil murderer as yet unidentified)
- Trying (white male and white female protoganists, family, def. not villains)
- Acapulco (no villain / antagonist / incompetent Hispanic male protoganist)
- Dark Matter (white male protoganist, no antagonist other than "can i get back to the main timeline", quantum reality exploration)
- Big Door Prize (white male protaganist, not evil or incompoetent, antagonist is a machine)
- Franklin (Ben Franklin biopic, white male)
- Jane (young not-white girl protoganist, poachers are african males)
That's just through end of April. No need to show further.
Ted Lasso is definitely a white male protagonist.
Presumed Innocent, The Big Door Prize, Dick Turpin, and this is all just from Apple TV. I think this 'problem' might be imaginary.
Specifically in this context/discussion I’d like to single out Foundation and Silo.
You're so used to see white male stars you're missing them, lol.
Foundation is only loosely based on the books but I can’t see anything people could attribute to being “woke”, aside from having some female lead characters.
Maybe you just don’t like female lead characters in stories?
- Claims that are obviously wrong
- Brief survey of Apple TV shows this is 100% false (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41037962)
- repeated invocations of 'my feminist wife said its okay' (indicating Woke imprinting showing itself in a false flag)
- slowly hopping around subthreads, only moving on from one after generating 2+ more replies. took 30 minutes and 4 replies to name a specific show
I'm sorry that the specter of "woke" is ruining your viewing experience but I absolutely can't relate.
Or honestly the entire history of X-men being a thinly veiled allegory of racism.
I can’t help be reminded about the outrage of having a black woman play the role of a comic book character that was an orange alien from Tamaran
I see his argument often, but it's always about how the art makes them feel instead of a Bechdel test for wokeness that we can apply objectively.
I hope I'm wrong and that Apple sees value in producing wonderful, niche TV. But at the same time that's not really Apple's ethos.