Russia recently mentioned it themselves they they had no problems with Finland and Sweden joining it.
Regarding Russian imperialism. It's quite the coincidence Russia is more interested in the resource rich area of Ukraine and they started "the little green men" invasion a year after Ukraine setup gas exploration on Crimea ( with shell)
Oh wait. It's no coincidence
I'm not sure who you're considering as "no one", but looks like you're trying to speak for a lot of people.
Just because Russia failed to deter Finland and Sweden to join, doesn't mean that they didn't, or don't have major problems with it.
In fact it was not only a major grievance, it was part of Russia's ultimatum in December 2021 before invading Ukraine [0] - stating that FINLAND, SWEDEN, ALL SOVEREIGN STATES IN EUROPE LOST THEIR CAPACITY TO DECIDE ABOUT THEIR DEFENSIVE ALLIANCES AND THEIR DEFENSE POLICY.
Russia literally wanted to control and decide foreign and decency policy of o sovereign countries, so yeah, you need to review your facts with the documented evidence.
(Also, in case you didn't know, this violates many important documents the USSR and Russia signed in the past.)
As for Russia interests, you also seem to forget that Russia tried to take Kyiv and topple the government. Just because Ukraine managed to defend itself doesn't mean that suddenly Russia is only interested in the only land they managed to steal so far.
You also seem to forget occupied territory in Georgia, and they reinforced that they will protect the current pro russia party in Georgia[1] - perhaps a new Belarus is brewing?
It looks like you have a very selective memory.
[0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vladimir_Putin%27s_December_20.... [1]https://kyivindependent.com/russia-announces-willingness-to-...
> In fact it was not only a major grievance, it was part of Russia's ultimatum in December 2021 before invading Ukraine
Russia invaded in 2014, not in 2021... After Ukraine landed a landmark deal about gas with Shell
This predates your claims.
I'm not ignoring that Russia tried to topple Kyiv ( it tried to topple more countries than just that). But their primarely target is the east of Ukraine ( resource rich ) and Crimea ( for gas and their naval fleet).
- https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2022/08/10/ukraine-russ...
- https://www.reuters.com/article/business/ukraine-signs-landm...
TLDR: I think we mean the same, but the typo caused confusion :)
Ah, in that case, yes we agree - I even doubt anyone without a political agenda ever thought about that. I would even dare to say most people didn't even know the purpose of NATO, or even cared about it.
Now they know.
> Russia invaded in 2014, not in 2021... After Ukraine landed a landmark deal about gas with Shell
Yes but in 2014 the narrative was to "protect ethnic Russians", and not annex territory, that's what I meant by invasion and what set apart the 2022 invasion as its own event - but you're correct, its a continuation of the 2014 invasion.
I think this might be more than about resources. Russia has plenty of land and resources.
My take is more about the public perception of Ukraine, which Russia used to call "brothers" but always looked at them was an inferior ethnic group, and they made sure to make them pay heavy prices as a reminder for being an inferior people to Russians. That's why I think the question is:
What would Russians think of Putin if Ukraine joined and thrived in the EU, with better standards of living than Russia, as a democracy?
Of course, resources play a role in this, because Ukraine can never be a successful democracy for the Russian regime, it would be their end.
Many countries have joined NATO from their own initiative, because they knew wery well that Russia is willing to rob and murder any neighbors and those neighbors are too small to oppose Russia without allies.
Regardless whether those countries loved NATO or not, they all have made great efforts to join NATO, including by making various sacrifices, as renouncing to things that had belonged to them or accepting to finance various onerous contracts with companies located in NATO countries. The countries that have joined NATO have been willing to do this at considerable expenses, because any such expenses were less important than the risk of being vulnerable to Russian attacks.
Russia has a history of attacking their neighbors only days after those neighbors have lost their allies, so they could not count any more on anybody else for defending against Russian attacks.
Follow the white rabbit.
If everyone on my street joined an anti-mr street gang, I would be concerned.
Just a random example: Ukrainians destroying a memorial to soldiers from their own village who fought against Nazis in WW2 [0].
Another one: the deconstruction of memorial on top of the grave of Soviet soldiers[1].
Maybe you should ask yourself why you so readily latch on a single report and ignore dozens of others which don't fit your preferred narrative?
Don't listen to stupid Russian propaganda...
I have already given two links as an example of destruction of memorials to fallen Soviet soldiers who fought Nazis (to the tg channel of Ukrainian politician, who is in exile in Spain and has survived an assassination attempt). Would you like to see more?
As for the second part, listen to Israeli and Polish "propaganda" [0]:
"Israel and Poland, which have clashed repeatedly in recent years over differing interpretations of the history of the Second World War, came together on Thursday to issue a rare joint condemnation of Ukraine over its efforts to rehabilitate nationalists who collaborated with the Nazis.
The criticism came one day after Ukrainians marked the 111th birthday of Stepan Bandera, the wartime leader of the Organization of Ukrainian Nationalists (OUN), a violently anti-Semitic organization that collaborated with the Nazis. Among Holocaust historians, the consensus is that the OUN and its military offshoot, known as the UPA, were responsible for the deaths of thousands of Jews and up to 100,000 Poles during the war (estimates vary).
In a joint letter to civic leaders in Lviv and Kyiv, Israeli ambassador Joel Lion and his Polish counterpart, Bartosz Cichocki, expressed concern regarding efforts to honor Bandera and Andryi Melnyk, the head of a competing faction of the OUN.
In Kyiv on Wednesday, local officials raised a giant banner with Bandera’s picture over the city administration building, prompting anger from Jewish activists. That came just over a week after the Lviv Oblast Council approved funding for a 2020 celebration in honor of Melnyk.
“Remembering our innocent brothers and sisters murdered in the occupied territories of Poland 1935-1945, which now constitute a part of Ukraine, we the Ambassadors of Poland and Israel believe, that celebrating these individuals is an insult,” Lion and Cichocki wrote.
“Glorification of those who promoted actively the ethnic cleansing is counterproductive in the fight against Antisemitism and the reconciliation of our People,” they continued.
...
Thursday’s letter is the second time that Lion and Cichocki have come together to call for a change in Ukrainian memory policy. In June, the pair signed a joint letter to the mayor of the Ukrainian city of Ivano-Frankisvsk, protesting the unveiling of a monument honoring Roman Shukhevych, a collaborator with the Nazis who was implicated in the murder of countless Jews and ethnic Poles.
Following Ukraine’s 2014 revolution, the former Soviet republic’s parliament passed a series of bills known collectively as the Decommunization Laws, meant to sever the country’s ties to its Russian and Soviet past. One of the bills prohibited what it called the “public denial of the legitimacy of the struggle for independence of Ukraine in the twentieth century.”
In practical terms, these bills paved the way for the rehabilitation of Ukrainian ultranationalist figures who had collaborated with the Nazis.
Over the last several years, streets all over Ukraine have been named after far-right figures and steps have been taken to rehabilitate their images, casting them as fighters for democracy whose followers saved Jews from the Germans.
Asked about the letter, Ambassador Lion told The Times of Israel that Israel and Poland “have a common interest in combating Holocaust denial and rewriting of History.” "
[0] https://www.timesofisrael.com/in-row-over-holocaust-history-...
The idea that any of these stupid monuments have anything to do with the actual reasons the 2014/2022 invasions were launched.
Or that Putin actually cares about Nazis. Or that you actually care.
Or that any of this stuff has any relevance as a topic, next to the reality of the current war itself.
It's all just dumb propaganda.
Oh, I do care a lot. My grandmother survived the blockade of Leningrad, and another relative survived in a Nazi concentration camp.
About that "politician", Andrij Shariy whom you are citing as some kind of a credible figure, if not a martyr of sorts -- from WP:
In a 2010 article, "Blue Rust. Dictatorship of Sodomites"[4] Shariy expressed an opinion that due to death sentences for same-sex and adultery relationships in Iran after the Islamic revolution the situation with prostitution, pedophilia, and rape in Iran was much better than in Ukraine.”[79]: 46–47, 57 [81] In the summer of 2020, journalist Sergei Ivanov posted screenshots of Anatoly Shariy's publications from 2010 in which he showed understanding for the extermination of homosexuals and Roma in gas chambers during the Third Reich.[82][83]
No credible information has emerged about the alleged attempts on his life. However he is under investigation by the SBU for inciting nationalist hatred. In 2021 Shariy apologized "for his past from 11 years ago" and claimed his views had been changed since then.[84]
"And about gays. I am a simple guy from Karavaevka. My childhood passed in the Soviet Union. I have never seen those "gays" ...I was certain that they would attack me with obscene offers... but I must say that I have never had a problem with a gay person in my life."What matters here is that you seem to happy to hold him up a credible, interesting useful and inspiring source of information.
You couldn't disprove the fact that ...
I don't dispute any of it. There's no need to because it's simply not relevant to the current situation.
Just like your comments to this thread.
It was yet another "Bandera, Bandera" thread.
So nothing emerging from it would have relevance to anything.
As you knew when you started it.
It's just such an obviously insipid and vacuous comparison. It's difficult to see why you went down this track, other than as an excuse to thrown down more of your favorite scare imagery and talking points.
I love how you are skirting the topic of the ideology of post-2014 Ukraine.
But "Ukraine" as a country does not. And none of this stupidity is any way relevant to the current (very much Nazi-like) invasion by Russia that you are continually apologizing for. And whose true causes you know perfectly well, and are continually attempting to distract attention away from with finger-pointing tactics such as these.
That is the cardinal error you are making here.
See, you are at it again.
These certain people include Ukrainian Foreign Ministry, as you could see in the comment you couldn't pass by but clearly hadn't bothered to read.
Also the mayors of Ukrainian cities who approve naming streets after "heroes" of OUN. This includes Stepan Bandera Avenue in the center of the Ukrainian capital [0].
Then try writing letters to them, perhaps? I'm sure they'll be happy to hear from you.
It's comical to see how your russophobia doesn't allow you to acknowledge objective reality.