News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by michaelteter on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @12:16PM (#40987485)
Inflammation seems to be a general enemy to health.

What is the evolutionary value of inflammation? It must have a reason for being such a prominent part of life…

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by ravenstine on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @01:40PM (#40988344)
Having no inflammation at all is a very bad thing. Too much inflammation is also a very bad thing. Hypothetically, there's an optimal level of inflammatory response. Evolution doesn't necessarily guarantee that, at least when it comes to a single mouse.

An individual organism surviving for the longest amount of time is not necessarily optimal at the species level. It could be that mice (for instance) have a bit too high of an IL-11 response, but there's either no evolutionary pressure against it or there's some species-level value to it.

Above all, since only one interleukin was targeted in the research, we can't assume that all inflammation is bad and that no inflammation is ideal.

On a related note, I wonder if there's anything commercially available that can suppress IL-11. Currently, I'm taking phycocyanin extracted from spirulina, which is supposed to suppress COX-2 and IL-17, but I don't see any research confirming whether it has an effect on IL-11. Would be cool if I've unwittingly begun extending my lifespan. :D

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by goda90 on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @01:49PM (#40988443)
> An individual organism surviving for the longest amount of time is not necessarily optimal at the species level.

Though it can be argued that among social, intelligent creatures, living grandparents holds value for the species. Humans and orcas both seem to benefit from them in many ways.

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by wubrr on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @01:56PM (#40988523)
I would imagine that if humans were immortal, the centralization of wealth and power under a few families would be even more extreme. Which is probably not good for the vast majority of humans.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by olalonde on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @02:30PM (#40988857)
Even if you were right, I'd still chose that society over death. I am not convinced though, wealth seems to dissipate over long periods (e.g. most billionaires today did not inherit their wealth).
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by wubrr on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @02:48PM (#40989043)
I mean, it's pretty hard to predict what such a society would look like, but it's plausible you'd just be a slave from birth until death (because poor slaves don't get the immortality pill).

> I am not convinced though, wealth seems to dissipate over long periods (e.g. most billionaires today did not inherit their wealth).

The single most reliable predictor of wealth BY FAR is being born into wealth. And arguably, it dissipates because it gets decentralized as it gets split up between heirs as it passed down to future generations which are typically less ambitious and focused on maintaining that power and wealth.

Imagine if Ghengis Khan, Stalin, Mao, Rothschild, Rockerfeller, all of the kings/royals/despots/dictators were immortal and still running the world - I don't think most people would want to live in that world.

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by olalonde on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @03:22PM (#40989379)
> The single most reliable predictor of wealth BY FAR is being born into wealth.

I highly doubt that. I would guess that income and age would be much better predictors for example.

> I don't think most people would want to live in that world.

I would, if the other option was death.

Regardless, I doubt any of them would still rule the world had they not died of old age. Regimes survive despite the death of their rulers and fall while rulers are still alive.

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by wubrr on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @04:05PM (#40989831)
> I highly doubt that. I would guess that income and age would be much better predictors for example.

I'm talking about predictors of wealth for a new person. The age and income are both zero. If you have their income - you probably have their wealth already as well - nothing to predict.

And for the record, coming from wealth is the strongest predictor of future wealth. [0][1]

> I would, if the other option was death.

But you have no choice/option in my hypothetical scenario - you're born a slave and you die...

> Regardless, I doubt any of them would still rule the world had they not died of old age.

Really.... ? Why? All of the people I mentioned, maintained and grew their wealth/power their entire life up until their death. Having power/wealth is just a huge advantage if you're trying to gain/maintain power/wealth.

[0] https://www.ctpublic.org/education/2019-05-15/georgetown-stu... [1] https://www.cnbc.com/2019/05/29/study-to-succeed-in-america-...

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by olalonde on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @04:37PM (#40990103)
> I'm talking about predictors of wealth for a new person.

That's almost a tautology then. If you only know one thing about someone, that's also necessarily the best predictor for anything about them. However, it doesn't tell us much about whether wealth does concentrate over time.

> Really.... ? Why?

Because regimes change all the time despite rulers being alive. The death of a ruler by old age rarely triggers regime change, they just get succeeded by someone else. It's usually another event that triggers regime change (peaceful and violent revolutions, war, etc.). Immortal rulers wouldn't be immune to those events.

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by Retric on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @06:48PM (#40991053)
> If you only know one thing about someone

You can know a great deal about someone at birth, such as race, gender, country of origin, eye color etc. Yet you can accurately predict someone’s wealth at age 60 by looking at their parent’s wealth even though a babies income is generally 0.

Further wait until someone’s 10 and you can measure IQ, grades, etc and parents wealth is still #1. Wait even longer and high school GPA still isn’t nearly as useful.

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by superturkey650 on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @05:03PM (#40990325)
The biggest cause of regime change seems to be the succession of power and the fears around change occurring during succession of power. A ruler dying through old age is a common source of regime change in history as people with varying interests start vying for that position and ensuring the new ruler holds their same interests.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by olalonde on Thursday July 18, 2024 @05:46AM (#40993988)
It's the exception rather than the norm. Rulers are typically just replaced by their successors.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by wubrr on Thursday July 18, 2024 @04:33PM (#40999465)
I mean, I gave you multiple examples of some of the most powerful people that ever lived, none of which fall into this category you call the 'norm'. You just completely ignored that and continued with your baseless fantasy.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by olalonde on Thursday July 18, 2024 @10:44PM (#41001666)
Upon his death, Genghis Khan was succeeded by his son. Mao was succeeded by Hua Guofeng, vice chairman of the CCP. Stalin was succeeded by Nikita Khrushchev, First Secretary of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by wubrr on Tuesday July 23, 2024 @05:22PM (#41051045)
And the power was less centralized after each of these deaths.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by wubrr on Thursday July 18, 2024 @04:26PM (#40999402)
> That's almost a tautology then.

No... it's not? Do you know what tautology means?

> If you only know one thing about someone, that's also necessarily the best predictor for anything about them.

Except it's not the only thing you know about them... so your point is kinda meaningless.

> However, it doesn't tell us much about whether wealth does concentrate over time.

There are soooo many studies supporting this, like the two I linked above, not to mention common sense.

It's like the most basic game theory + common sense - you have X people competing with each other, you give (0.001 * X) of those people massive advantages - who do you think is going to be winning?

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by DaoVeles on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @05:13PM (#40990412)
Also the Chinese saying that goes "Wealth does not last beyond three generations". There are exceptions to this rule but it is fairly robust.

Part of it is wealth becoming diluted with offspring and secondly being raised in wealth diminishes people value of money until it is too late.

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by freen on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @07:02PM (#40991133)
In the United States, the single most determinative factor for lifetime earnings and life expectancy is the zip code you were born in and grew up in, up to age 13 or so.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by smegger001 on Thursday July 18, 2024 @12:17AM (#40992480)
Largely because it gets split amongst inheritors and they often are less able to manage wealth than the original accumulator of the wealth. Immortalis would not need to split their estate up every so often as death causes to happen now instead they would continue to accumulate more.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by widowlark on Friday July 19, 2024 @03:00PM (#41009869)
banks would not offer such lucrative interest rates if immortality was a publicly known trait
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by lawlessone on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @02:47PM (#40989025)
We'd certainly need to change our social system lot.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by netcraft on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @07:45PM (#40991340)
altered carbon is a great show that deals with this
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by hagbard_c on Thursday July 18, 2024 @08:00AM (#40994785)
If they were immortal they'd soon find a way to move beyond this planet, then beyond this solar system. Once that is accomplished there is a whole universe to colonise so I assume that is what would happen. It would be the only way really since the planet would otherwise quickly fill up and 'immortality' would end up a pipe dream due to endless conflict over land and sustenance.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by jvanderbot on Thursday July 18, 2024 @11:45AM (#40996779)
Ah yes, the "vampire spaceship" season of humanity.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by AlchemistCamp on Thursday July 18, 2024 @01:02PM (#40997594)
That's far from guaranteed.

With an average fertility rate of 1, which is higher than that of many countries including where I live, even complete immortality would lead to an asymptotic population. Since some people will still inevitably die in accidents even if aging is solved, a fertility rate of 1 would be a declining population even with unlimited lifespans.

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by wubrr on Thursday July 18, 2024 @03:32PM (#40998957)
You're assuming everyone gets the immortality and is de facto benevolent. If you actually look at how the super rich and powerful have acted historically - its much more likely that the few richest/most powerful people would just take control of the earth, reserve immortality for themselves, and keep everyone else as a mortal slave.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by indoordin0saur on Thursday July 18, 2024 @10:36AM (#40995979)
I'd rather have the healthy and energy of a 25 year old and live in a world where there are people far richer than me than be a frail 80 year old where at least I know there aren't any trillionaires.

Another thought I had was that revolutions over inequality almost always happen when there's a large youthful population. The old just don't have the energy or the future-focused outlook for big change. Inequality might be less stable if all adults had the health of their youth.

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by wubrr on Thursday July 18, 2024 @04:31PM (#40999459)
> I'd rather have the healthy and energy of a 25 year old and live in a world where there are people far richer than me than be a frail 80 year old where at least I know there aren't any trillionaires.

That's a very specific scenario, where everything happens to be going great for you. Do you honestly believe wealth inequality has no negative consequences for those at the bottom?

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by indoordin0saur on Monday July 22, 2024 @12:29PM (#41036298)
No, I agree that extreme wealth inequality is not desirable. But the question I'm trying to get at is if we can have medicine that will make people live dramatically healthier lives isn't it worth it even if some billionaires get to hold onto their wealth a little longer?

"But if we cure aging won't that mean that the ultra-rich will never go away??" That's what these conversations always seem to devolve into and it seems to miss the bigger picture.

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by wubrr on Tuesday July 23, 2024 @05:19PM (#41051021)
I think it will be worth it, but we can't just assume that such a medicine will be available for everyone, or ignore the effects it will have on society.

Many medicines and treatments we have today are already basically available only to the wealthy.

Many prominent billionaires are on record spreading overpopulation FUD and anti-natalism, while having multiple children themselves.

In theory - I agree that having some kind of anti-aging treatment that is available for everyone would be awesome, but in practice it could end up as immortality for the very few, while making the vast majority worse off.

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by michaelteter on Friday July 19, 2024 @01:31AM (#41002214)
How long does it take for evolution to resolve that presumably long-term unintentional negative outcome?
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by Terr_ on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @03:33PM (#40989478)
> Though it can be argued that among social, intelligent creatures, living grandparents holds value for the species.

This is taken to an extreme in Larry Niven's "known space" setting. There's a bunch of interesting stuff I won't mention because spoilers, but imagine a very-humanoid race where the adults are not intelligent, but later they lose the ability to reproduce and gain hyper-intelligence, strength, and a ruthless drive to protect and advance their descendants.

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by robwwilliams on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @07:56PM (#40991393)
Selection only cares about reproductive fitness. There is some weak evidence that grandparents can improve their reproductive fitness by supporting the fitness if their progeny. Species level effects no an important player, although as our technological competence grows, this is likely to change.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by shiroiushi on Thursday July 18, 2024 @01:46AM (#40992822)
>Humans and orcas both seem to benefit from them in many ways.

For a second, I thought you wrote "humans and orcs..." I don't think orcs really value grandparents that much, but who knows: Tolkein might have completely maligned them as mindless monsters when they were in fact just a fast-growing pre-industrial civilization.

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by officeplant on Thursday July 18, 2024 @02:42PM (#40998522)
Real Orks know as long as you aren't painting yourself red you'll age slower, live longer, but not orkier.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by darby_nine on Friday July 19, 2024 @03:10PM (#41009970)
> Hypothetically, there's an optimal level of inflammatory response.

Surely this is directly dependent on the context of the organism.

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by r0ze-at-hn on Sunday July 21, 2024 @01:28AM (#41022636)
A way to look at this is that death is an evolutionary advantage for the species. Vertebrates have a PVN that control the HPA-Axis. As anything that contributes to the HPA-Axis such as pain, stress, or inflamation increases, the PVN shrinks and it fairly rapidly (evolutionary wise) behaves like a kill switch to the brain. Some pre-Vertebrates can effectively live forever and the mammals that live the longest have different hpa-axis loops. What is wild to realize is that there was probably a creature at some point that wouldn't die from pain until that was connected to this loop.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by moh_maya on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @12:26PM (#40987576)
Inflammation is typically experienced when the body is responding to an infection or injury. It is a normal, and as per current understanding, a necessary part of the body's immune response.

The Cleveland clinic has a nice, informative page if you want more information [0]

[edited to add]

The response of the innate immune system to the infectious agent / injury is what causes inflammation - i.e., for instance, fever, swelling, etc. It is a very very complex multi-cascade process, but one of the first responses to an injury, for instance, is the release of signalling molecules that results in localised swelling, slightly elevated temperature (which makes the tissue a little more inhospitable to bacteria / viruses), etc. all of which serve as the front line defense. <This is a severe over-simplification> Wikipedia has a good explanation that goes into the roles and triggers of the inflammatory response. [1]

Acute inflammation in response to infections and injuries is a good thing, and from everything we know, it is a necessary part of the immune response. The challenge is when the same inflammation response is mis-directed to target the body - for instance, in rheumatoid arthritis, and other inflammation related auto-immune disorders.

[0] https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/symptoms/21660-inflamm...

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inflammation?useskin=vector

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by andai on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @01:05PM (#40987963)
The latest Kurzgesagd video on exercise seemed to imply that (excepting sudden changes in activity level) caloric burn rate is constant regardless of lifestyle, but if you are sedentary, the "excess" calories are burned "unproductively" (e.g. increased inflammation).

So this seems to imply excess calories are a cause of chronic inflammation.

Also, the ketogenic diet has been shown to significantly reduce inflammation, though I'm not sure if that's from reducing carbs, or reducing something else associated with high carb intake.

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by biomcgary on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @02:20PM (#40988766)
Glucose and fructose will react non-specifically with proteins in the body, particularly when present in excess. These non-specific reactions are recognized as foreign and/or defective, which triggers inflammation. The apply named RAGE protein is one mediator of this response (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RAGE_(receptor)).

HbA1C results from the non-enzymatic reaction between glucose and hemoglobin. It serves as a measure of your long-term glucose level and is elevated in diabetics.

Low carb diets dramatically reduce this source of inflammation.

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by qorrect on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @01:40PM (#40988352)
This also lines up with something said in the book Lifespan about fasting reducing inflammation.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by Retric on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @06:57PM (#40991104)
> caloric burn rate is constant regardless of lifestyle

This is obviously false as stated, extreme athletes consume vastly more calories than sedentary people of their same weight. Phelps was rather famous for a 10,000+ calorie per day diet but even just manual labors need significantly more calories.

I’m assuming there’s some unspecified criteria such as while sleeping?

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by nonameiguess on Thursday July 18, 2024 @09:37AM (#40995468)
It's just plain not true. Claims like this coming out in the past few years are based on Herman Pontzer's research in which he measured activity levels and energy expenditure among the Hadza, a forager group in Africa, testing the hypothesis that they'd be using a lot more energy because of how active they are. He found their energy expenditure on average wasn't actually much different than the average for sedentary Americans and developed something called the constrained energy expenditure model. This just postulates that the human body has various ways of compensating in the long term for high activity levels. If less energy is available for basic life processes that are not critical to immediate survival, those process will be modulated downward. Importantly, one of these is inflammation, which is likely why exercise reduces inflammation. At the very extreme end of this, you see things like Marshall Ulrich when he was attempting to break the record for time running across the continental United States seeing things like his hair and nails stopped growing. Female endurance athletes commonly stop having periods. Male endurance athletes often have reduced testosterone production.

But this compensation is nowhere near 100% and it also isn't clear to what extent this is mediated by food availability and possibly the intensity of the activity. The Hadza don't have a lot of food and they're spending all day walking around. Similar studies have been conducted on the Amish, who are doing far harder manual farm labor and have enormous amounts of food, and these studies found much high energy expenditure among the Amish compared to post-industrial sedentary Americans, as well as an average 9% bodyfat for males for whatever that is worth. Similarly, the experiences of endurance athletes with bad health symptoms like amenorrhea and low bone mineral density are limited to people who feel pressure to be as small as possible and don't eat anywhere near enough food. Those who simply eat more don't have the same experiences.

As you stated, we also have quite a bit of clear cut existence proofs that energy expenditure is not simply constant among all people regardless of activity. Pontzer himself has studied some of these extremes to figure out how much energy a human actually can expend. From what I recall, it seemed to be around 3.5 times whatever your base metabolic rate is, at least in the long run. Over short bursts, energy expenditure can be up to 10 times base. The greatest longer duration energy demands he has seen in the field is the Tour de France for men and pregnancy for women, both of which are about equal and seem to represent the limits of what humans can do. Obviously, the people doing these things are eating far more than they would be if they weren't doing those things. Nutrition advice for athletes is nearly the opposite of what it is for the obese and sedentary. Eat sugar like there's no tomorrow. Get as many liquid calories as possible. Avoid high fiber because it'll sit in your gut forever slowing down all other digestion and making you uncomfortable. There's a reason for this.

Two of my favorite podcasts, Stronger by Science and Iron Culture, was in the former case and is in the latter hosted by one of the researchers who works in Herman Pontzer's lab, and he is constantly expressing frustration over how the findings and model get misrepresented by the time they telephone down to pop science communicators and diet influencers. The model simply says that expending X calories per day in exercise will not result in a net difference of X calories expended in total. It'll be some percentage less than 100. But it won't be 0%. Exercise and activity don't make no difference at all.

I'd never heard of this Kurzgesagt thing, but it appears to be a group of animators that make cartoon explainer videos of basically everything? That might be entertaining but is probably not the best way to learn about the frontiers of contemporary nutrition and exercise science.

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by ntSean on Thursday July 18, 2024 @08:56PM (#41001184)
Kurzgesagt mentions that their explanation is an over simplification; generally they are well researched and cite sources.

The video discussed is this one: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lPrjP4A_X4s

I enjoy your perspective on this topic!

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by andai on Friday July 19, 2024 @07:09AM (#41004947)
Thanks for the info. Sibling comment posted the video I was referring to. The video was apparently made in cooperation with Pontzer: https://sites.google.com/view/sources-workoutparadox
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by tempsy on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @12:55PM (#40987859)
There is a huge difference between inflammation in response to injury and chronic inflammation caused by lifestyle choices like poor diet.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by Teever on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @01:01PM (#40987917)
That's missing the point. If this technique can result in longer lives for people with both good diets and not, it is a genuinely novel innovation in human life span that can't be replaced with better diet alone.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by andai on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @01:07PM (#40987984)
The question was what are you giving up in exchange? Is this protein's function really just to reduce your quality of life and kill you faster?
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by Someone on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @02:02PM (#40988589)
It could well be that this protein is good for you when you’re young but not that good for you when you are older.

For example, young people might encounter more new infection sources, and thus need a faster/stronger responding immune system. This protein might be evolved for giving you that, with a side effect of having too strong an immune system at older age.

Evolution may not yet have found a solution that turns down its production at later age, or it might have evolved it at some time, but found its benefits do not outweigh the cost of maintaining the necessary control mechanism.

It’s far from a given that having more humans live to old age has evolutionary benefits.

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by tempsy on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @01:06PM (#40987969)
It's not missing the point. The point is that a lot of people live with chronic inflammation caused by poor lifestyle choices and that results in many diseases later in life, including Alzheimer's.

The point is that chronic inflammation is bad. The comment I'm replying to isn't recognizing that it's just saying "oh inflammation is fine because it's a response to injury" which is very much missing the point.

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by Teever on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @01:18PM (#40988111)
How much of the consequences of a poor life style can be mitigated by simply reducing the chronic inflammation response by the body?

I'd love it if cheap shitty food wasn't bad for me. At the end of the day a calorie is a calorie and many animals handle the stuff that shortens our life with no problem.

Look at it another way, if dogs can't eat chocolate but humans can, is the problem with chocolate or with dogs?

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by BostonFern on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @01:29PM (#40988201)
A calorie is certainly not just a calorie. Different foods are metabolized differently and affect the body in different ways, regardless of otherwise equal caloric values. Take fructose, glucose, and ethanol as an example.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by Teever on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @05:10PM (#40990394)
How is it that you're making my point in an attempt to refute my point, without seeing that you're making my point for me?
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by shiroiushi on Thursday July 18, 2024 @04:34AM (#40993637)
The problem there is with dogs, and has nothing to do with calories. Dogs (and many other animals) are simply not able to tolerate chocolate like humans can. Conversely, humans can't tolerate eating rancid meat and cat poop, but dogs can eat those things easily and not get sick. Lots of substances are poisonous to certain species, and non-poisonous to other species.

Also, the reason chocolate is unhealthy isn't because of the cacao plant, it's because of all the added sugar used to make it taste good, since raw cacao (or cocoa, which you get after cooking it) is horribly bitter.

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by chiefalchemist on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @03:44PM (#40989586)
What happens when you eliminate the "good inflammation" in those with bad diets? Then what? There's likely going to be unintended consequences, naturally. My point, eliminating one symptom usually means eventually creating another.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by pjc50 on Thursday July 18, 2024 @05:25AM (#40993899)
> caused by lifestyle choices like poor diet

If you can prove this .. which things specifically is this linked to? There is a lot of completely terrible nutrition "science" out there.

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by jvanderbot on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @12:40PM (#40987721)
Chronic inflammation is bad. Is chronic inflammation always caused by auto-immune? Or is it also caused by things like pollutants, poor diet, or other "first world" problems?

I ask because I used to be very concerned with particulate matter (I still am, but I used to too), and it seemed a big problem with that was it triggering inflammation.

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by andai on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @01:12PM (#40988037)
It's been a while since I looked into this, but diet is a major factor with inflammation. Sugars, seed oils and grain-fed dairy. (Also if you eat the grains yourself!) Keto lowers it, caloric restriction lowers it (conversely excess calories coupled with sedentary lifestyle increase it), intermittent fasting lowers it.

I forget about exercise, I think it's a case of temporarily increasing it (hours) and then lowering it long-term.

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by datameta on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @02:24PM (#40988802)
Speaking from personal experience diet plays as much a role as medication in decreasing inflammation. Sugars, gluten, and some* nuts and seeds are indeed pro-inflammatory (many seeds and nuts are anti-inflammatory)
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by loulouxiv on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @07:18PM (#40991211)
How did you measure inflammation level ?
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by felixg3 on Friday July 19, 2024 @03:04PM (#41009911)
CRP, Calprotectin are easily measurable, not so sure TNF-Alpha and Interleukins?
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by doe_eyes on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @01:02PM (#40987927)
I don't think there's a pattern suggesting that. Many autoimmune diseases are more prevalent in less polluted parts of the world. The strongest links appear to be genetic, in that some diseases (e.g., Sjogren's syndrome) are clearly more common in people of certain geographic descents.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by jvanderbot on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @02:20PM (#40988770)
I'm not asking if autoimmune is caused by pollution or development. I'm asking if they both have similar effects.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by datameta on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @02:26PM (#40988819)
There is no distinction regardless of cause, imo. Stress can epigenetically cause an autoimmune disease, and so can pollution (including smoking), excessive alcohol, processed food diet, sedentariness, etc. Often it is a number of factors that can lead to a chronically overactive immune response.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by datameta on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @04:37PM (#40990102)
I forgot to add, some have higher genetic predisposition for an autoimmune disorder, and diet/environment/lifestyle can switch those gene sections on.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by jb1991 on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @01:25PM (#40988175)
Asthma is another example of a terrible problem caused by chronic inflammation.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by biomcgary on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @01:29PM (#40988206)
Antibiotics and sanitation have dramatically changed the fitness landscape and humans haven't accumulated enough generations in the new landscape to adapt genetically.

Natural selection is for reproductive fitness. Before antibiotics, dying after child bearing years didn't have enough effect on fitness to overcome the value of preventing death from infection at younger ages.

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by ortusdux on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @12:29PM (#40987604)
'If you don't have inflammation, then you'll die':

https://www.livescience.com/health/immune-system/if-you-dont...

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by kneel on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @12:27PM (#40987585)
Your body attacks substances that appear foreign, whether they're actually foreign or not is another issue.

Human bodies did not evolve for high macro diets, the high levels of sugar (among other molecules) in our diet glycosylate proteins they touch, warping their folding shape and causing inflammation as the body mistake itself for foreign invaders.

Probably a reason why fasting has become so popular, people are walking around with high levels of damage from dense caloric food, a fast allows your body to go through a cycle of catabolism/autophagy. Clearing our the misfolded/damaged proteins lowers inflammation.

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by epgui on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @03:30PM (#40989450)
Just off the top of my head (I am a biochemist), without inflammation you:

- cannot heal when injured

- cannot fight back against pathogens and die from random infections easily

- develop cancer faster and more often

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by DaoVeles on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @05:31PM (#40990540)
Thanks for the additional context.

Generally, the opposite of one bad idea is usually another bad idea. Too much is bad, too little is bad - the middle ground is ideal.

For example - Too much water is drowning, doesn't mean we should advocate against water.

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by thijson on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @01:59PM (#40988557)
I know that some parasites secrete substances that reduce our immune response, for example hook worms. People that have autoimmune diseases of the gut sometimes see a benefit to purposely infecting themselves. I think our current genetic make up was selected by evolution to handle a high parasite load.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by andai on Friday July 19, 2024 @07:14AM (#41005011)
Interesting theory. I think it's also still mostly optimized for a pre-agricultural diet.

Keto has been shown to be helpful with a huge number of health issues, and from my understanding humans spent most of the year in ketosis (or all year during the ice ages?).

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by MVissers on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @12:24PM (#40987553)
I’d guess it helps short-term survival.

Eg: Rest your twisted ankle through pain and inflammation instead of keeping to use it.

Even though it increases recovery time, better be on the safe side of decreased usage to avoid further damage.

Which is why in modern times RICE speeds up recovery (rest, ice, compression, elevation) in twisted ankles.

But we have ratio- which mammels didn’t have for millions of years.

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by scns on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @01:29PM (#40988204)
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by datameta on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @02:32PM (#40988875)
My hunch feels validated. I think it highly depends on area affected because vasoconstriction decreases limphatic throughbout as well as bloodflow. Still highly case-by-case but I think lowering inflammation in load bearing or complex joints like knees or ankles is conducive to nominal operation and therefore healing. (100% rest not recommended, as repair byproducts accumulate and don't clear away, and decreases bloodflow rsults in lower delivery of nutrients, building blocks of tissue, etc.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by netcraft on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @12:24PM (#40987557)
I just came to ask basically the same question. Why does inflammation exist, what is its purpose, how did it evolve, are there downsides to blocking it?

We have entire classes of drugs including OTC ones whose entire job is just reducing inflammation, its indicated in tons of diseases and conditions, lots of health industry people (and snake oil salesmen) tell me that x and y and z cause it, but I dont really know what it is.

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by calibas on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @01:03PM (#40987940)
Inflammation actually speeds up healing, at least when things are working right.

Edit: To add, much of our medicine treats symptoms, not causes.

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by byteknight on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @01:49PM (#40988458)
A super uneducated piece of input for thought:

Perhaps it is not that it is evolutionarily beneficial, but rather a byproduct of other evolutionarily beneficial processes? Such as sending larger amounts of blood to an affected region.

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by meindnoch on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @02:22PM (#40988786)
Inflammation is needed so you don't die from infections and injuries.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by farseer on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @12:28PM (#40987589)
Probably has to do with our immune system and microbial threats. You can reduce inflammation using steroids for example but also reduce your immunity as a consequence.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by jb1991 on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @01:30PM (#40988223)
Long-term steroid use has many many significant side effects as well, like ruining your bones.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by hooverd on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @12:38PM (#40987693)
Having an immune system. Healing. Exercise causes acute inflammation which signals your body to repair itself. Chronic inflammation is the real problem. And dose, I guess.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by shawnz on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @01:15PM (#40988072)
For this reason anti-inflammatory drugs make exercise less effective: https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2017/08/170828125123.h...
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by yieldcrv on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @01:30PM (#40988217)
> It must have a reason for being such a prominent part of life…

the answer is always "it doesn't kill or sterilize you before you reproduce"

I don't understand the point of the retroactive why's. some mutant nutted in a bunch of folks, the end.

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by sqeaky on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @01:51PM (#40988472)
"Retroactive Why's" are useful because on evolutionary timescales, and it must be if it impacts mice and people, even a very tiny selective pressure causes harmful traits to be selected against.

If as few as 1 in 10,000 reproductions were prevented by a trait then we should expect that trait to be gone in a million years. And our last common ancestor with mice was likely 65 of those past.

Harmful traits can linger if they confer some other benefit. Other's have already worked through this and are rightfully asking, "If this is so harmful it should be have been selected against, what does it do to help us get to successful reproduction in the environment it evolved in?"

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by yieldcrv on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @04:42PM (#40990140)
okay so explain our short telomeres promoting cancer

what are armchair archeologists going to say, “thats because it enabled strong community ties and the humans with long telomeres didn't value life as strongly” as opposed to being a total freak accident that had nothing to do with anything

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by sqeaky on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @05:32PM (#40990557)
> okay so explain our short telomeres promoting cancer

They don't kill us before we procreate. Evolution checks out at childbirth so you get "genetic drift".

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by yieldcrv on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @05:45PM (#40990653)
> the answer is always "it doesn't kill or sterilize you before you reproduce"

QED

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by sqeaky on Thursday July 18, 2024 @11:04AM (#40996246)
Compare to inflammation which might kill 1 in 10,000 before reproduction. Cancer in seniors doesn't.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by bell-cot on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @12:29PM (#40987612)
I'm not in biology/medicine, but my impression is inflammation is mostly about fighting off infectious diseases. Which, historically, have been a leading killer of mammals.

If current conditions (whether for lab mice, or humans) have removed ~99% of the deadly diseases from the equation - then it's kinda like someone who's heterozygous for sickle cell being stuck in a malaria-free region.

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by ajuc on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @01:41PM (#40988363)
If they released these mice to live in unsanitary wild environment it could turn up they lived shorter/less healthy lives on average because they were less adapted to fight all the pathogens.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by Tagbert on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @04:32PM (#40990061)
Inflammation is part of the immune response. It’s generally a good thing if it happens when needed and if it stops when the stimulus is gone. If your immune system is stimulating inflammation for false positives or continuously that is when damage can occur.

Next time you think about consuming a product that claims to boost your immune system, ask yourself if you really want to increase your chances of inflammation or not. they are two sides of the same system.

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by takinola on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @07:26PM (#40991251)
Dumb question: What is inflammation? I know what it sounds like but I realize I am not quite sure what it is.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by tim333 on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @07:47PM (#40991352)
"body's response to an illness, injury or something that doesn't belong in your body (like germs or toxic chemicals)."

If you get a splinter in your finger and it goes red and swollen that's inflammation. It's like the first line general response before things like the immune system kick in.

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by lern_too_spel on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @09:21PM (#40991736)
Limited lifespan is an evolutionarily successful tactic and is a nearly universal trait among living things. Now that we have brains that can do higher order thinking, we can override these and other traits that helped the species survive but are detrimental to individuals.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by steve1977 on Thursday July 18, 2024 @01:25AM (#40992732)
What is the evolutionary value of longevity?
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by jitbit on Thursday July 18, 2024 @05:21AM (#40993888)
Inflammation is a reaction to infection or physical damage.

It (1) isolates the damaged tissue from the rest of the body (2) launches countermeasures against most probable threats

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by nswest23 on Thursday July 18, 2024 @02:33PM (#40998438)
Inflammation clearly has a biological purpose - the problem is that the modern world is full of so many things that seem to cause excess inflammation.