News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by wubrr on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @01:56PM (#40988523)
I would imagine that if humans were immortal, the centralization of wealth and power under a few families would be even more extreme. Which is probably not good for the vast majority of humans.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by olalonde on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @02:30PM (#40988857)
Even if you were right, I'd still chose that society over death. I am not convinced though, wealth seems to dissipate over long periods (e.g. most billionaires today did not inherit their wealth).
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by wubrr on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @02:48PM (#40989043)
I mean, it's pretty hard to predict what such a society would look like, but it's plausible you'd just be a slave from birth until death (because poor slaves don't get the immortality pill).

> I am not convinced though, wealth seems to dissipate over long periods (e.g. most billionaires today did not inherit their wealth).

The single most reliable predictor of wealth BY FAR is being born into wealth. And arguably, it dissipates because it gets decentralized as it gets split up between heirs as it passed down to future generations which are typically less ambitious and focused on maintaining that power and wealth.

Imagine if Ghengis Khan, Stalin, Mao, Rothschild, Rockerfeller, all of the kings/royals/despots/dictators were immortal and still running the world - I don't think most people would want to live in that world.

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by olalonde on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @03:22PM (#40989379)
> The single most reliable predictor of wealth BY FAR is being born into wealth.

I highly doubt that. I would guess that income and age would be much better predictors for example.

> I don't think most people would want to live in that world.

I would, if the other option was death.

Regardless, I doubt any of them would still rule the world had they not died of old age. Regimes survive despite the death of their rulers and fall while rulers are still alive.

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by wubrr on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @04:05PM (#40989831)
> I highly doubt that. I would guess that income and age would be much better predictors for example.

I'm talking about predictors of wealth for a new person. The age and income are both zero. If you have their income - you probably have their wealth already as well - nothing to predict.

And for the record, coming from wealth is the strongest predictor of future wealth. [0][1]

> I would, if the other option was death.

But you have no choice/option in my hypothetical scenario - you're born a slave and you die...

> Regardless, I doubt any of them would still rule the world had they not died of old age.

Really.... ? Why? All of the people I mentioned, maintained and grew their wealth/power their entire life up until their death. Having power/wealth is just a huge advantage if you're trying to gain/maintain power/wealth.

[0] https://www.ctpublic.org/education/2019-05-15/georgetown-stu... [1] https://www.cnbc.com/2019/05/29/study-to-succeed-in-america-...

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by olalonde on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @04:37PM (#40990103)
> I'm talking about predictors of wealth for a new person.

That's almost a tautology then. If you only know one thing about someone, that's also necessarily the best predictor for anything about them. However, it doesn't tell us much about whether wealth does concentrate over time.

> Really.... ? Why?

Because regimes change all the time despite rulers being alive. The death of a ruler by old age rarely triggers regime change, they just get succeeded by someone else. It's usually another event that triggers regime change (peaceful and violent revolutions, war, etc.). Immortal rulers wouldn't be immune to those events.

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by Retric on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @06:48PM (#40991053)
> If you only know one thing about someone

You can know a great deal about someone at birth, such as race, gender, country of origin, eye color etc. Yet you can accurately predict someone’s wealth at age 60 by looking at their parent’s wealth even though a babies income is generally 0.

Further wait until someone’s 10 and you can measure IQ, grades, etc and parents wealth is still #1. Wait even longer and high school GPA still isn’t nearly as useful.

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by superturkey650 on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @05:03PM (#40990325)
The biggest cause of regime change seems to be the succession of power and the fears around change occurring during succession of power. A ruler dying through old age is a common source of regime change in history as people with varying interests start vying for that position and ensuring the new ruler holds their same interests.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by olalonde on Thursday July 18, 2024 @05:46AM (#40993988)
It's the exception rather than the norm. Rulers are typically just replaced by their successors.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by wubrr on Thursday July 18, 2024 @04:33PM (#40999465)
I mean, I gave you multiple examples of some of the most powerful people that ever lived, none of which fall into this category you call the 'norm'. You just completely ignored that and continued with your baseless fantasy.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by olalonde on Thursday July 18, 2024 @10:44PM (#41001666)
Upon his death, Genghis Khan was succeeded by his son. Mao was succeeded by Hua Guofeng, vice chairman of the CCP. Stalin was succeeded by Nikita Khrushchev, First Secretary of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by wubrr on Tuesday July 23, 2024 @05:22PM (#41051045)
And the power was less centralized after each of these deaths.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by wubrr on Thursday July 18, 2024 @04:26PM (#40999402)
> That's almost a tautology then.

No... it's not? Do you know what tautology means?

> If you only know one thing about someone, that's also necessarily the best predictor for anything about them.

Except it's not the only thing you know about them... so your point is kinda meaningless.

> However, it doesn't tell us much about whether wealth does concentrate over time.

There are soooo many studies supporting this, like the two I linked above, not to mention common sense.

It's like the most basic game theory + common sense - you have X people competing with each other, you give (0.001 * X) of those people massive advantages - who do you think is going to be winning?

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by DaoVeles on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @05:13PM (#40990412)
Also the Chinese saying that goes "Wealth does not last beyond three generations". There are exceptions to this rule but it is fairly robust.

Part of it is wealth becoming diluted with offspring and secondly being raised in wealth diminishes people value of money until it is too late.

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by freen on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @07:02PM (#40991133)
In the United States, the single most determinative factor for lifetime earnings and life expectancy is the zip code you were born in and grew up in, up to age 13 or so.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by smegger001 on Thursday July 18, 2024 @12:17AM (#40992480)
Largely because it gets split amongst inheritors and they often are less able to manage wealth than the original accumulator of the wealth. Immortalis would not need to split their estate up every so often as death causes to happen now instead they would continue to accumulate more.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by widowlark on Friday July 19, 2024 @03:00PM (#41009869)
banks would not offer such lucrative interest rates if immortality was a publicly known trait
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by lawlessone on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @02:47PM (#40989025)
We'd certainly need to change our social system lot.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by netcraft on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @07:45PM (#40991340)
altered carbon is a great show that deals with this
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by hagbard_c on Thursday July 18, 2024 @08:00AM (#40994785)
If they were immortal they'd soon find a way to move beyond this planet, then beyond this solar system. Once that is accomplished there is a whole universe to colonise so I assume that is what would happen. It would be the only way really since the planet would otherwise quickly fill up and 'immortality' would end up a pipe dream due to endless conflict over land and sustenance.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by jvanderbot on Thursday July 18, 2024 @11:45AM (#40996779)
Ah yes, the "vampire spaceship" season of humanity.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by AlchemistCamp on Thursday July 18, 2024 @01:02PM (#40997594)
That's far from guaranteed.

With an average fertility rate of 1, which is higher than that of many countries including where I live, even complete immortality would lead to an asymptotic population. Since some people will still inevitably die in accidents even if aging is solved, a fertility rate of 1 would be a declining population even with unlimited lifespans.

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by wubrr on Thursday July 18, 2024 @03:32PM (#40998957)
You're assuming everyone gets the immortality and is de facto benevolent. If you actually look at how the super rich and powerful have acted historically - its much more likely that the few richest/most powerful people would just take control of the earth, reserve immortality for themselves, and keep everyone else as a mortal slave.
Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by indoordin0saur on Thursday July 18, 2024 @10:36AM (#40995979)
I'd rather have the healthy and energy of a 25 year old and live in a world where there are people far richer than me than be a frail 80 year old where at least I know there aren't any trillionaires.

Another thought I had was that revolutions over inequality almost always happen when there's a large youthful population. The old just don't have the energy or the future-focused outlook for big change. Inequality might be less stable if all adults had the health of their youth.

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by wubrr on Thursday July 18, 2024 @04:31PM (#40999459)
> I'd rather have the healthy and energy of a 25 year old and live in a world where there are people far richer than me than be a frail 80 year old where at least I know there aren't any trillionaires.

That's a very specific scenario, where everything happens to be going great for you. Do you honestly believe wealth inequality has no negative consequences for those at the bottom?

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by indoordin0saur on Monday July 22, 2024 @12:29PM (#41036298)
No, I agree that extreme wealth inequality is not desirable. But the question I'm trying to get at is if we can have medicine that will make people live dramatically healthier lives isn't it worth it even if some billionaires get to hold onto their wealth a little longer?

"But if we cure aging won't that mean that the ultra-rich will never go away??" That's what these conversations always seem to devolve into and it seems to miss the bigger picture.

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by wubrr on Tuesday July 23, 2024 @05:19PM (#41051021)
I think it will be worth it, but we can't just assume that such a medicine will be available for everyone, or ignore the effects it will have on society.

Many medicines and treatments we have today are already basically available only to the wealthy.

Many prominent billionaires are on record spreading overpopulation FUD and anti-natalism, while having multiple children themselves.

In theory - I agree that having some kind of anti-aging treatment that is available for everyone would be awesome, but in practice it could end up as immortality for the very few, while making the vast majority worse off.

Re:Mice live longer when inflammation-boosting protein is bl... by michaelteter on Friday July 19, 2024 @01:31AM (#41002214)
How long does it take for evolution to resolve that presumably long-term unintentional negative outcome?