News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ad-tech setting 'Privacy-Preserving Attribution' is opt-o... by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Saturday July 13, 2024 @05:19AM (#40952816)
C. the main problem _is_ ads

Mozilla assumes ads are required.

Ad blockers assume ads are not required.

Ad blockers are probably more popular than Firefox.

The original web did not have targeted ads and did not require ads to exist. It has never faced an existential threat due to "not enough data collection and targeted advertising".

Ad blockers are correct.

Re:Ad-tech setting 'Privacy-Preserving Attribution' is opt-o... by immibis on Saturday July 13, 2024 @05:53AM (#40952953)
Mozilla is an ad company by its revenue sources.
Re:Ad-tech setting 'Privacy-Preserving Attribution' is opt-o... by whamlastxmas on Saturday July 13, 2024 @06:52AM (#40953254)
By this logic, every TV station and website whose main revenue is ads are also ad companies, which I don’t think is accurate.
Re:Ad-tech setting 'Privacy-Preserving Attribution' is opt-o... by Gud on Saturday July 13, 2024 @08:11AM (#40953614)
If their revenue is from advertising, they’re in the advertising business.

There are other business models out there.

Re:Ad-tech setting 'Privacy-Preserving Attribution' is opt-o... by harrisi on Saturday July 13, 2024 @06:59AM (#40953295)
Why not? What else would you call them?
Re:Ad-tech setting 'Privacy-Preserving Attribution' is opt-o... by michaelt on Saturday July 13, 2024 @08:53AM (#40953820)
We'd call them TV stations.

I mean, we call social media companies social media companies despite them being ad funded.

We call newspapers newspapers despite them being ad funded.

We call sports teams sports teams despite them being ad funded.

Re:Ad-tech setting 'Privacy-Preserving Attribution' is opt-o... by alexvoda on Saturday July 13, 2024 @09:00AM (#40953856)
And we have also learned to use taxonomies and hierarchies and sets. Therefore the intersection between the set tv stations and the set ad companies is the set ad-funded tv stations. Ad-funded tv stations are a subcategory of the larger ad companies category.
Re:Ad-tech setting 'Privacy-Preserving Attribution' is opt-o... by JTyQZSnP3cQGa8B on Saturday July 13, 2024 @08:24AM (#40953669)
The CEO of the biggest French TV channel once said "We’re selling eyeballs to advertisers," so yes, it’s accurate.
Re:Ad-tech setting 'Privacy-Preserving Attribution' is opt-o... by h0l0cube on Saturday July 13, 2024 @08:54AM (#40953826)
I agree that TV stations and websites don't have to be purely vessels for advertising, but in today's climate of slim margins – due to an expectation that everything is 'free' – and sliding ethics, advertising lends more and more bias to operations. And that bias has been there as long as there has been advertiser funded operations.

https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/news_hole

We could just return to a culture of paying for things (that are conspicuously not tracked) and this whole imposition of advertising in our daily consumption can go away. But the vast majority of people simply don't care.

Re:Ad-tech setting 'Privacy-Preserving Attribution' is opt-o... by michael9423 on Saturday July 13, 2024 @09:18AM (#40953955)
I think ads should not be allowed for anything at all in the digital world, including TV. In a world without ads, products would be known due to reputation. Ads are an assault on the limited resource of attention.

People say how can new products reach people, but the solution to that problem isn't ads but platforms/websites that catalog new products and allow for easy discovery.

Ads actually make the problem of finding new products worse because you only see a fraction of new products if you consume ads, primarily those from companies that already have lots of money to invest into ads.

Re:Ad-tech setting 'Privacy-Preserving Attribution' is opt-o... by h0l0cube on Saturday July 13, 2024 @02:40PM (#40955938)
It’s a nice dream, but enough people have to be willing to pay for things in preference to tolerating ads to not pay. Streaming services and some online news services provide this option, so it’s available. But asking for everything to be free and ad free is wishful thinking, at least outside government funded media (which is still paid by taxes)
Re:Ad-tech setting 'Privacy-Preserving Attribution' is opt-o... by account42 on Monday July 15, 2024 @10:44AM (#40968316)
> Streaming services and some online news services provide this option

Temporarily, before they inevitably add the ads back in even for paying users.

Re:Ad-tech setting 'Privacy-Preserving Attribution' is opt-o... by felurx on Sunday July 14, 2024 @04:22AM (#40959666)
Public service broadcasting is pretty nice too. (Of course it shouldn't be the only model, but I think it's often overlooked.)
Re:Ad-tech setting 'Privacy-Preserving Attribution' is opt-o... by lolinder on Saturday July 13, 2024 @12:51PM (#40955158)
Google income aside, Mozilla literally owns an ad company: https://blog.mozilla.org/en/mozilla/mozilla-anonym-raising-t...
Re:Ad-tech setting 'Privacy-Preserving Attribution' is opt-o... by nunez on Sunday July 14, 2024 @02:43AM (#40959290)
They are ad delivery vehicles (think: sports) and often structure programming around ad slots, so in some senses, they kind-of are.
Re:Ad-tech setting 'Privacy-Preserving Attribution' is opt-o... by michaelt on Saturday July 13, 2024 @08:47AM (#40953789)
Why stop there?

If Mozilla produce software, funded by search engines, funded by ads, funded by laundry detergent manufacturers, are they a laundry detergent company?

Re:Ad-tech setting 'Privacy-Preserving Attribution' is opt-o... by shrimp_emoji on Saturday July 13, 2024 @08:59AM (#40953854)
Mozilla is an ad company under the new leadership, hence the assumption.

And exactly: I reject C. I reject the monetization of the web. It didn't need to happen; we just wanted it to happen in our greed. We bit the apple. Money is the root of all evil. It ruins everything.

Re:Ad-tech setting 'Privacy-Preserving Attribution' is opt-o... by disgruntledphd2 on Monday July 15, 2024 @11:21AM (#40968649)
Who pays for the servers?
Re:Ad-tech setting 'Privacy-Preserving Attribution' is opt-o... by Rinzler89 on Thursday July 18, 2024 @12:13AM (#40992452)
Hopefully nobody. The internet and servers existed before targeted advertising was a thing. The only thing targeted advertising enabled is trillion dollar valuations for some shareholders.
Re:Ad-tech setting 'Privacy-Preserving Attribution' is opt-o... by disgruntledphd2 on Saturday July 20, 2024 @02:31PM (#41018556)
Servers cost money though. And generally, they cost proportionately more the more users you have.

This means that the standard information wants to be free/free software arguments ultimately have costs to cover (like, you used to need to pay for GNU tools to cover the cost of postage and storage).

Any approach that ignores this economics is just gonna fail (and that would be sad).

Re:Ad-tech setting 'Privacy-Preserving Attribution' is opt-o... by amelius on Saturday July 13, 2024 @09:00AM (#40953862)
D. the main problem with ads is that they stimulate more unnecessary consumption

Ads are the wrong monetization model for the web. Instead of paying for information directly, you are now paying for information by buying something physical (most ads are about physical items). In this resource-limited world, this is clearly ridiculous.

Re:Ad-tech setting 'Privacy-Preserving Attribution' is opt-o... by nullindividual on Saturday July 13, 2024 @11:21AM (#40954597)
> D. the main problem with ads is that they stimulate more unnecessary consumption

Yes! If our culture(s) weren't so damned full of pure consumerism, forgetting the first 'R' in Reduce, Reuse, Recycle, we'd potentially be living in a healthier ecosystem.

And honestly, having gone from living with a hoarder to living with a tad more than essentials where I can see the damned floor in my house, it's such a f-ing relief.

Re:Ad-tech setting 'Privacy-Preserving Attribution' is opt-o... by BadHumans on Saturday July 13, 2024 @01:08PM (#40955301)
Not all ads are for physical goods.
Re:Ad-tech setting 'Privacy-Preserving Attribution' is opt-o... by johnnyanmac on Saturday July 13, 2024 @02:04PM (#40955685)
honestly the worst, most persistant ads are for games. The pump millions into it because they can utilize whales to make billions. Which means more ads.
Re:Ad-tech setting 'Privacy-Preserving Attribution' is opt-o... by heresie-dabord on Saturday July 13, 2024 @02:28PM (#40955852)
> D. the main problem with ads is that they stimulate more unnecessary consumption

The main problem with ads is... I do not want them.

My computer, my electricity, my network, my ISP contract, my privacy, my life and my decision.

This is a fork of Firefox that I support:

https://librewolf.net/

Re:Ad-tech setting 'Privacy-Preserving Attribution' is opt-o... by Barrin92 on Saturday July 13, 2024 @09:30AM (#40954013)
Consumers vote with their wallets and will virtually always take a free product with ads over anything else, so taking a dogmatic stance against ads is just going to be financial suicide. Ad blockers simply live on borrowed time until they're banned or made unusable. In which case if a competitor springs up, at some point they need money, which means they'll need to serve ads. Like say Brave, which blocks ads and then ... serves you their own ads.

The original web is irrelevant because it didn't sustain large economies. It's like comparing radio hobbyists to the central TV station, the economics change when you have to actually pay employees and serve a mass market.

Re:Ad-tech setting 'Privacy-Preserving Attribution' is opt-o... by lolinder on Saturday July 13, 2024 @12:54PM (#40955174)
> The original web is irrelevant because it didn't sustain large economies. It's like comparing radio hobbyists to the central TV station, the economics change when you have to actually pay employees and serve a mass market.

A large number of us wish that we could go back to a web that didn't exist primarily to sustain large economies. Back to a web that existed for academics and enthusiasts, a web where modern HN discussions would have been ranked in the lower half of quality instead of the top 5%.

That web existed as late as 2010 (already as a bit of an enclave, but a thriving one). It was killed by ad-funded social media and some of us are still bitter about it.

Re:Ad-tech setting 'Privacy-Preserving Attribution' is opt-o... by Barrin92 on Sunday July 14, 2024 @12:45AM (#40958893)
Multiple things exist on the internet at once right, I mean we're having this discussion on an old-school website right now, it didn't go away, that's the nice thing about the internet, pretty much unlimited space.

But it also strikes me as very odd if not elitist to say you'd wish for a web when it consisted of academics and enthusiasts. Because for everyone who doesn't come from money or academia, like me, the fact that there's a real economy underpinning the web now means I have a job that actually feeds my family. (I in particular don't work for an ad company for what it's worth).

It's one major business model that keeps the lights on in a lot of places and to say we should all be enthusiasts, who in this industry do a lot of work and get almost no compensation just doesn't work for most people. And is also just bad for software in general.

Re:Ad-tech setting 'Privacy-Preserving Attribution' is opt-o... by ajb on Saturday July 13, 2024 @10:08AM (#40954204)
I'm a bit puzzled by this comment. By saying you have an option "C" you are indicating that there is some other factor, intrinsic to ads, that you object to. Which is a valid position - others have mentioned some- but, you don't say what that factor is. My curiosity is piqued! Can you elucidate?
Re:Ad-tech setting 'Privacy-Preserving Attribution' is opt-o... by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Saturday July 13, 2024 @04:37PM (#40956695)
https://github.com/piki/netcat/raw/master/scripts/web

The web is not TV. At least it did not begin that way. The above is from the mid-1990s when the web was nothing like TV, not even close. The first paragraph is prophetic.

For a "non-profit" organisation, Mozilla is extremely focused on making/keeping the web a source of profits for a selected few.

Giant websites calling themselves "tech companies" are nothing like newspapers. Newspapers sold a product: journalism. Readers paid for newspapers. These giant websites do not sell a product. They do not hire journalists to produce news. These websites are free. If they chanrged for access few people would pay. They use the products of other peoples' labor as bait to lure in ad targets because the product of their own labor has no such value, it draws no significant audience. They are intermediaries, middlemen.

Mozilla wants to encourage and protect this behaviour, not change it. Make ads "private". Mozilla is along for the ride. Keep the money flowing.

Re:Ad-tech setting 'Privacy-Preserving Attribution' is opt-o... by ajb on Sunday July 14, 2024 @12:43PM (#40961888)
I was around in the 90's, yes.

If newspapers are your model of a better alternative - pre internet, newspapers were funded largely by advertising. Yes, they also took subs and sales, but they could not operate on that alone. A very large amount of product and service discovery -not just consumer, but B2B -happened by means of ads (including classifieds) in newspapers and professional magazines. Have a look at a 19th century issue of "The Engineer" or "The Builder", it's very enlightening.

If we want to get rid of the current internet giants, we need to figure out what can replace them so effectively that businesses dump them like they did the newspapers.

Re:Ad-tech setting 'Privacy-Preserving Attribution' is opt-o... by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Monday July 15, 2024 @07:34AM (#40966900)
If want to use analogies when discussing the (unnecessary) presence of advertising on a computer network, the presence or (regulated) absence of advertising on highways and in public outdoor areas is a better analogy. The internet (and web) are supposed to be a public resource. It is nothing like a privately-owned TV network or newspaper. A client for accessing the web does not need to support advertising.
Re:Ad-tech setting 'Privacy-Preserving Attribution' is opt-o... by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Saturday July 13, 2024 @11:41PM (#40958673)
It's possible to use a computer network for commercial transactions. For example, use the network to transfer data to browse selections of products and services, make payments and complete purchases.

It's also possible to use a computer network for advertising. For example, putting ads one every page of every website so when a www user is reading some noncommercial page, ads are everywhere. Or when a www user is communicating about noncommercial topics over someone else's website,^1 ads are everywhere.

1. A dumb idea because of "tech" company surveillance and ads

IMHO, the two are not mutually inclusive. Perhaps there are only so many widgets that can be sold over the web. But with ads, there is no limit. The ads are not there to provide "free" services despite the messaging from Silicon Valley. The ads are there so that so-called "tech" companies can make money. They do not even have any widgets to sell. They have nothing that web users will pay for. Thus, surveillance and ads.

A common retort every time someone mentions that the original web had no ads usually goes something like "The early web sucked" or "I don't wan't to go back to the early web". But that is not the point of mentioning the original web. With today's hardware, there is no going back. The internet is incredibly fast now. It does not have to suck anymore.

The point of mentioning the early web without all the ads is that bogus claims by entities like Mozilla that "the web needs ads to survive" or by Google that they are "making the web faster" while still delivering same/more ads are pure nonsense. The web does not need ads. Ads are what makes the web slow. Google deliberately adds delay to webpages when they "load" so ad auctions can take place.

At the same time, it is common to HN commenters reminiscing about the early web and complaining about the current web.