AXS Group LLC v. Internet Referral Services LLC (2:24-cv-00377) District Court, C.D. California
Amended complaint: https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.cacd.91...
Docket: https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/68163191/axs-group-llc-...
One item of the complaint is regarding the "secure.tickets" site, which I wrote about in an earlier comment below (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40906148#40910690).
Basically, brokers are using the "secure.tickets" and similar websites to proxy ticket barcodes to buyers, without going through the actual ticket transfer mechanisms on the primary ticketer AXS/TM, (similar to how this blogger does). Then resellers are delivering these ticket URLs, hosted on random websites, to Seatgeek and Stubhub customers, and those platforms are supporting their delivery by telling their customers that the tickets are legit. Sounds like AXS is fighting back against this practice.
Do other brokers, when they go and work around that limitation break the sales contact? Maybe. The legal system would churn an answer in a few years.
Do AXS et al with their "only we are allowed to engage in a secondary policy" are abusing their monopoly on original sales? The legal system would churn an answer about the legality of this in few years, but I think it's obvious they at least break rules in the spirit.
Sounds like something a VC would say.
Have you considered that inventing things and selling them are two different skill sets?
The patent system needs reform, not elimination.
Seems awfully self-centered.
But a true invention, a novel use of those laws, should be patentable. Are you saying that if you discover a novel use of natural laws, a product that could be capitalized, your own unique idea, that you should not be able to capitalize on it? Maybe this would work in a trek economy, but not with capitalism.
If your worried about innovation, how innovative could we be if discoveries/inventions were squandered because there are no protections if you happen to even mention your idea to someone?
Also, I don’t think any of the issues with Ticketmaster have anything to do with patents.
Nothing seems reasonable to me on the topic unless it comes with evidence as to how it would improve a system that would appear by any objective measure to be doing incredibly well.
And what does any of it have to do with ticket master? They’re awful in a lot of ways, but I’m not aware of patent trolling to be one of them. If they even have and enforce patents, I’ve not heard of them, and I work in live events so I’m fairly well-informed on that company. Everyone in the industry hates them, it's unlikely they’re doing anything awful that isn’t routinely mentioned.
No, it wasn't. The idea behind the system was to give people a financial incentive to be _open_. Patents are a trade with the commons; you would give up your secrets for a limited time period of exclusivity. People would innovate with or without patents, but they would keep that innovation to themselves.
With software, both sides of that bargain have changed. Secrets are harder to keep, and since everything moves so much faster, any given time period is much more damaging to the commons (e.g., 20 years is forever in software).
(I also don't think Ticketmaster affairs have anything to do with patents, FWIW)
It was developed to spur innovation, and that is still its main function.
What about chemistry that mad everything from baking recipes, optics for physics, paint for art, forging techniques... The list goes on and on.
There are so many subtle ways of doing things that were silo'd in small communities or regions.
"To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries"
This says nothing about publication, only about progress and exclusivity.
The big benefit of a functioning patent system is it allows people to make money just inventing things.
This group seems to have a “throw the baby out with the bath water” mentality when it comes to patents simply because of patent trolls, when the obvious solution is to just fix patent approval/litigation.
1. https://www.morganlewis.com/pubs/2022/04/russian-decree-unde...
> “What I can say for sure is that TicketMaster and AXS have had every opportunity to support scam-free third party ticket resale and delivery platforms if they wished: By documenting their ticket QR code cryptography, and by exposing apps and APIs which would allow verification and rotation of ticket secrets,” Conduition told me in an email. “But they intentionally choose not to do so, and then they act all surprised-pikachu when 3rd party resale scams proliferate. They're opting to play legal whack-a-mole with scammers instead of fixing the problem directly with better technology, because they make more money as a resale monopoly than as an open and secure ecosystem.”
from https://www.404media.co/scalpers-are-working-with-hackers-to...