News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by BobAliceInATree on Wednesday June 26, 2024 @05:13PM (#40804651)
The sad reality is that you can spend a lifetime collecting something, the but likelihood that any of your potential heirs is also interested in it, is pretty close to zero. That's true of multi-million dollar vintage computers, or your childhood stamp collection that's mostly worthless. Paul's mistake was not properly establishing a foundation & endowment to maintain this musuem, which almost certainly leaks lots of money.

I personally have a decent art collection that I've amassed over the past couple decades. I have a few pieces earmarked in my will to specific friends & family that have really liked certain pieces (they don't know), but the reality is that my estate executor is going to sell the vast majority of it, and at 50¢ on the dollar of what I paid.

Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by bombcar on Wednesday June 26, 2024 @06:01PM (#40805086)
You're not going to get 50 cents if I know anything about it.

Maybe if you started selling today you could get that, an estate auction will get a few pennies.

Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by BobAliceInATree on Wednesday June 26, 2024 @06:47PM (#40805449)
A few of my pieces are quite desirable and valuable, most of them not. I looked at the numbers, and all together 40-50% of what I paid is the ballpark of today's value, not including any consignment fees.
Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by bruce511 on Wednesday June 26, 2024 @10:37PM (#40806682)
I've said this before, and for you I'm assuming there's no rush, but the best person to sell the "valuable" part of the collection is you.

Now granted, most collections are not art - so I'm assuming you gave fewer distinct pieces than say stamps.

My dad had a serious stamp collection. Had he died with it complete, we would have sold it for a few $ to a dealer. The cost of (him or us) going through it to find "the good stuff would be too high.

Take your art. Unless you've cataloged it, had it appraised, and keep that updated every few years, your heirs will likely just sell it as a job-lot to a dealer. Given his costs, and risks, he'll pick a small number (like $50 per). Your Rembrant is his to find.

What my dad did was sell off the expensive stuff himself before he died (and told us). He knew what he had, and where to find it. (He discovered that selling is different to buying, but that's another thread). At least we knew that what was left was basically worthless and we could donate it with a clear conscience.

Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by dehrmann on Wednesday June 26, 2024 @11:32PM (#40806921)
> He discovered that selling is different to buying, but that's another thread

You got me curious...

Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by bruce511 on Thursday June 27, 2024 @12:07AM (#40807109)
When collecting there's a selling price and a buying price. The difference can be -substantial-.

For example, stamps have a catalog. Literally a giant book, with all the stamps and variations, and the current value. (Ahem, buying value). Think if it as a giant "vendor neutral" price guide. [1]

Now obviously when you come to sell you mostly sell to a dealer. So you expect him to take some margin. He has to make a living. But the margin they expect will make your eyes water. (50% to 90% is common). Do test $100 stamp you have is say $10.

But eBay- sell direct. Sure you get more. But still a lot less than book value (partly because scams etc makes eBay risky for good stuff.) And it's it's lot of extra work. Useful for one or two pieces, less useful for 50. (And, of course, scams happen in both directions.)

That's if you know what you have. Selling someone else's collection on eBay when you don't know what you have is equally tricky.

In short, collections are expensive to acquire and hard to get rid of. The value in collecting is the joy of acquiring and having. Collections are (with rare exceptions) not a financial investment.

[1] my insight into stamps collecting died 20 years ago, so I'm guessing thus catalog is online now.

Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by Kaijo on Thursday June 27, 2024 @04:39AM (#40808554)
I'm a lifelong collector of a variety of (very) niche things, and have at times sold or tried to sell items from my collections, or whole collections at once. You're right about everything, I would only add that each category of thing is its own world in terms of liquidity and how certain you can be of obtaining a guide price. It also pays off to learn about the collector cultures and communities surrounding each type of thing, so you know what obscure periodical or special interest show, etc. to target when you are trying to sell. Never be in a rush, and the other thing that can make a difference is developing good product photography/videography skills.
Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by bombcar on Thursday June 27, 2024 @01:11PM (#40812716)
Sometimes the best thing you can do with a collection is bequeath it to someone in the hobby who's much younger.
Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by bruce511 on Thursday June 27, 2024 @02:19PM (#40813424)
Weeel.. maybe. The joy in collecting is the collecting. Getting it all at once kinda robs the fun..

But bequething them one or two significant pieces can get them started, and perhaps carries more meaning...

Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by brudgers on Thursday June 27, 2024 @02:13PM (#40813367)
Patient buyers are another characteristic of long tail markets on eBay.

The pool of stamp collectors etc. is small relative to say guitar players; there’s not an endless September; and buying from dealers is the “socially acceptable” way of starting.

So potential buyers on eBay tend to be experienced bargain shoppers when it comes to ordinary collectability. They will happily wait for the bragging rights price or at least the no way to lose money price.

Collecting is a hobby. Picking is a business.

Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by brudgers on Wednesday June 26, 2024 @11:57PM (#40807043)
[I’m not the person who said it.]

Sellers don’t control when a sale will happen in the ways buyers do. Once you decide to buy you can — assuming the item is already for sale.

That already for sale part is the difference. Sales have lead times. Even at fire sale prices the decision to sell precedes someone buying. It takes time for the right person to find your item.

Pricing and advertising and marketing can help. But they don’t force the timing of a sale.

Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by BobAliceInATree on Thursday June 27, 2024 @10:33AM (#40810966)
I appreciate the advice. My collection is catalogued with what I paid and current-ish fair market values. The future executor will know which handful ones are worth consigning individually and at what galleries, and the rest will likely be bulk sold.
Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by bruce511 on Thursday June 27, 2024 @12:03PM (#40812003)
That's the way to do it! Mind you paintings are bigger than stamps so it feels like you're cheating.... :)
Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by ikiris on Wednesday June 26, 2024 @06:54PM (#40805495)
Few is if they're lucky. More like 1.
Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by devilbunny on Wednesday June 26, 2024 @08:48PM (#40806201)
I have bought a lot of stuff at estate auctions. Yeah, a generic estate sale will not generate a lot of money, but if you have serious art (i.e., it would sell to more than a local audience), it can bring in quite a bit. I saw an Alan Bean (the astronaut) painting at one; ended up going for over $30k. And the estate gets all of that; the auction house charges a premium (in this case, 25%) paid by the buyer, but the official auction price is what the seller gets.
Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by intrasight on Wednesday June 26, 2024 @10:58PM (#40806784)
The liquidation value of the average middle-class house is $10k - according to my divorce attorney.
Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by fl7305 on Thursday June 27, 2024 @04:04AM (#40808403)
$10k sounds high to me if we're talking about home electronics, furniture, etc?

Do people have a lot of expensive jewelry that's included, or does it include vehicles?

Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by bombcar on Thursday June 27, 2024 @01:12PM (#40812731)
If we're talking the contents, you can get to $10k pretty easily, think appliances (a hundred or so each), laptops, stereo, etc.

If you held a garage sale today and let people go throughout your entire house, you could probably net $10k.

Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by devilbunny on Thursday June 27, 2024 @12:48PM (#40812481)
The ones I’m talking about are definitely not middle class.
Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by 9659 on Wednesday June 26, 2024 @06:10PM (#40805151)
Personal collections are for enjoyment, not investment.

I liquidated some of my fathers things for effectively nothing. That he spent decades acquiring.

Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by femto on Wednesday June 26, 2024 @10:16PM (#40806597)
That can be a good outcome if things go to someone who values them as much as the original owner.

My Dad had a collectable car. We sold it for a fair price to an enthusiast who drives it, looks after it and keeps in in a public museum when it's not being driven. That was a good outcome. Better than someone in the family hoarding it and letting it deteriorate.

The money was immaterial, main reason for asking a fair price was to discourage someone who didn't value the car from flipping it for a tidy profit. We were also lucky, in that a member of Dad's car club was prepared to vet buyers for us.

Disbanding a closed computer museum isn't a bad thing if the items go to others who will value and display them.

Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by klyrs on Thursday June 27, 2024 @01:21AM (#40807508)
A collectable car is one thing. A bevy of collectable figurines, another thing all together.
Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by dbish on Wednesday June 26, 2024 @06:45PM (#40805439)
In this case he didn’t have heirs and seems to have asked in his will to auction it off instead of endowing it.
Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by shiroiushi on Wednesday June 26, 2024 @08:34PM (#40806130)
Is there any value to a museum for that art?
Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by ChuckMcM on Thursday June 27, 2024 @12:44AM (#40807294)
My Dad collected antique cap guns. By the "collector's bible" its "worth" $40 - $50 grand. He got zero offers for it when it became clear he needed to liquidate some of his "stuff" to pay for health care. So yeah, I don't think my collection of "classic" computers will return anything to my heirs sadly.
Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by fl7305 on Thursday June 27, 2024 @04:02AM (#40808396)
Well, I see classic 1970s-80s computers that I'm interested in selling for hundreds or even thousands of dollars on eBay etc.

Gen-Xers who grew up with them are getting nostalgic, and many of them have a lot of disposable income and plenty of space to house them.

But it is a lot of work to get that kind of money for each individual machine. And I suspect it will be a passing fad. In some decades when the Gen-Xers start to log out, the younger generations will not sustain the same kind of market.

Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by rjsw on Thursday June 27, 2024 @05:55AM (#40808892)
I wonder if anyone is buying them at those prices though.

I collected a few machines when they were either being given away at work or nearly given away on eBay.

Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by formerly_proven on Thursday June 27, 2024 @06:19AM (#40808994)
Computer prices are a bathtub curve for interesting computers. Very expensive at the start, then they're worthless garbage for 10-40 years, then prices start to rise. If it's not interesting, then they just stay worthless.

Examples:

- Supercomputer parts

- SGI, HP 9000, Sun SPARC machines and parts

- More esoteric UNIX workstations

- PDPs

- VAXen (how many complete cabinet-style VAXen still exist?)

- Apples

- Terminals (since almost all of these were tossed, these are surprisingly expensive even in bad condition)

Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by ghaff on Thursday June 27, 2024 @09:52AM (#40810547)
And probably need to be in pretty mint condition and find the right buyers. Nothing I have is mint and I wouldn't even try to sell it. The minicomputer boards are from a once major minicomputer maker but very few people have probably even heard of them today.
Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by kps on Friday June 28, 2024 @09:48AM (#40820575)
Yes, I have a number of things on the parent list (e.g. UNIX workstations, deskside and rackmount VAXen, terminals) and I can't give them away.
Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by fl7305 on Friday June 28, 2024 @01:34PM (#40822918)
Really? Looking at the asking prices on eBay, a VT100 terminal seems to go for many hundreds of dollars even in poor condition?

You wouldn't happen to have SUN 3 workstations?

Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by kps on Friday June 28, 2024 @02:51PM (#40823809)
VT100, maybe; not later less iconic terminals. (Personally, I think I still have a few V2xx and a Wyse or two.)

I may still have a Sun 3/60 pizza box (as well as a Sparc or two), and maybe even keyboard and cables (one of the common problems — I've had people excited about a ‘free’ SGI Indy but they come to their senses when they realize it's a blue paperweight without time, money, and luck finding the ancillaries). Fortunately I found takers for my (three!) deskside Sun 3/160s about a decade ago. But even for a single pizza box, shipping has become a killer for non-local transfers (I'm outside the US).

Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by rjsw on Saturday June 29, 2024 @10:25AM (#40830856)
I had not done an eBay search for "sold" items until now, some people seem to be paying high prices for Atari Falcon systems.

I have a SPARC Station 2, Ultra 1, Ultra 2 and a Macintosh Quadra 950 that all work and would maybe have resale value if I wanted to get rid of them.

Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by fl7305 on Thursday June 27, 2024 @08:30AM (#40809751)
Like the other poster wrote, it is time dependent.

The stuff that went into dumpsters in the 1990s can sell for thousands today on eBay. But in 30 years, they might be dumpster bound again.

I just double checked to make sure, and an Atari Falcon early 1990s 68030 CPU computer sells for around $3000 today.

Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by hnlmorg on Thursday June 27, 2024 @06:15AM (#40808971)
The problem is it’s only valuable to those who hold value to it because they grew up with it. Once those collectors get old and start dying off, the bottom falls out of the market because subsequent generations don’t have the same nostalgia. and thus those once valuable collectibles are then basically worthless.

I have first hand experience of this happening too. My dad collected a specific type of model railway. His collection used to be worth thousands but by the time I inherited it all the other collectors were also dead and neither myself nor my brother wanted to maintain the collection. So we sold it for practically nothing.

Dad would be turning in his grave if he knew but frankly, he was the only person who had sentimental value to that collection and we needed the space. It wasn’t even about the money for us, it was literally just multiple boxes of stuff we knew we wouldn’t ever use and didn’t want to keep indefinitely just to honour the memory of dad (we have far better ways to honour his memory).

This isn’t meant to sound insensitive because I loved my dad and still miss him a lot.

I have a large collection of retro gaming consoles and 8 and 16 bit computers. Plus hundreds of games on physical media. I love my collection just like my dad loved his trains. But I know my family will sell it for a pittance the moment I pass away. And I’m fine with that. I own it because it brings me pleasure. I didn’t buy it thinking my family should honour my legacy by hoarding it too.

Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by bdjsiqoocwk on Thursday June 27, 2024 @06:44AM (#40809095)
This is sad because it's true. Thank you for writing this.
Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by ghaff on Thursday June 27, 2024 @09:49AM (#40810516)
I enjoyed stamp collecting as a kid. I inherited a stamp album from a distant relative who I think was a clipper ship captain or something along those lines. Was probably worth some money once upon a time. I should look at it one of these days. I'm sure it (and my own collection) are worth nothing today.
Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by Basketb926 on Thursday June 27, 2024 @02:34PM (#40813555)
Easy thing to do with Unwanted Stamps is Donate to Oxfam Canada. Address to mail your donation to is at this link: https://www.oxfam.ca/take-action/support-oxfam/stamp-out-pov...
Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by BobAliceInATree on Thursday June 27, 2024 @10:29AM (#40810917)
Yeah, I'm really nostalgic for 90s era computer & gaming stuff — turns out, that stuff is pretty expensive right now cause all of us that grew up with it have the disposable income to re-buy it. 30-40 years from now when we're all dying & downsizing? I'm sure that market will crater.
Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by ilamont on Thursday June 27, 2024 @10:21AM (#40810837)
We've seen this play out before. This couple in Wisconsin stocked up on antique phones when the demand was hot in the 1980s, now they are in their 80s and they can't get rid of them:

https://madison.com/news/local/phoneco-wisconsin-telephones-...

Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by rekabis on Thursday June 27, 2024 @01:35PM (#40812962)
They should advertise up here in Canada. Functional rotary phones are selling like hotcakes for $50-80 a pop. Especially original non-standard (not-black) colours.
Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by georgeecollins on Friday June 28, 2024 @04:00PM (#40824650)
That's like collector cars that peak in value for the generation after they were made. If it was a poster on your wall growing up, you want it when you are old and wealthy. The generation after is less interested.
Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by cableshaft on Sunday June 30, 2024 @08:59AM (#40836917)
With cars specifically it doesn't help that they tend to be a lot less safe to drive the older they are (as health standards have increased a lot over the years), also they just become harder and harder to keep in good shape as the parts become rarer and rarer. Also they had terrible emissions and low gas mileage, so they suck for the environment.

Like I still think some 60s muscle cars look pretty cool, despite being born a couple decades later, but there's no way in hell I'd ever want to own one, for the above reasons. Instead I'll just drive them in video games.

Meanwhile I think it's cool to own a painting brought home from World War II, or a metal cup souvenir from the 1904 World's Fair in St. Louis.

Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by deafpolygon on Thursday June 27, 2024 @12:56AM (#40807381)
This is one of the reasons why I avoid "collecting" anything. (Another is space, maintenance, etc.)

There's just not much point, unless you absolutely love something. But many people collect with the end-game of making a profit, which is a mistake.

Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by imperfect_light on Thursday June 27, 2024 @02:42AM (#40807971)
> but likelihood that any of your potential heirs is also interested in it

That's not the issue, he set up the parts of his empire he cared about so they'd live on (Allen Institute for example) and instructed his sister to sell the rest. She could have gone against his instructions, but the point is he clearly he didn't care whether the Cinerama or the Living Computer Museum continued on. That's on him, not his heirs.

The fact that no other Seattle-adjacent computer billionaires like Gates, Bezos, Simonyi, Ballmer has offered to continue it just shows the generally low quality of people that have gotten rich from tech.

Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by ghaff on Thursday June 27, 2024 @09:57AM (#40810609)
Or the fact that they don't see maintaining a home for a bunch of old computers for people to look at is a priority given other museums and world needs.
Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by imperfect_light on Thursday June 27, 2024 @11:39AM (#40811664)
It's not like there's a shortage of money for art museums or natural history museums, but we do seem to be closing museums (this one and previously the Boston one) detailing the history of one of the biggest innovations in human history.

When you say "world needs" you mean sports teams and personal space travel? It's safe to say all of them have plenty of money to save this small museum and still fund their hobbies and causes.

Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by ghaff on Thursday June 27, 2024 @04:36PM (#40814810)
They depend on people actually willing to pay to support them. Both through donations and admissions.
Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by imperfect_light on Thursday June 27, 2024 @07:05PM (#40816135)
If the museum was open I'm sure it would have plenty of visitors and support. Can't visit a museum that isn't open.

But the fact is that most museums rely, in least in part, on grants and benefactors in addition to visitors.

Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by ghaff on Thursday June 27, 2024 @07:29PM (#40816314)
Except it apparently didn't have sufficient donors and benefactors.
Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by imperfect_light on Friday June 28, 2024 @04:32AM (#40818769)
What are you basing this assertion on? It was closed because of the pandemic. When that was over Allen had been dead for several years, his instructions had been to sell everything and give it to charity so that's what his sister has been doing. No one attempted to reopen with alternative benefactors or see if visitors would come.

I was there right before the pandemic and there were a decent number of visitors (given that it was a weekday afternoon).

Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by jl6 on Thursday June 27, 2024 @02:57AM (#40808057)
The issue with estate sales is that they are usually estate disposals. People inheriting their parents’ stuff are usually themselves grown adults with their own busy lives, and the average estate consists of immense amounts of clutter that the inheritor has approximately zero interest in. They’re grieving, they’re seeking closure. Not looking to spend years sifting through hundreds of thousands of items of household bric-à-brac looking to extract value. They want your house cleared so they can sell it and hopefully pay off a bit of their own mortgage.
Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by ZaoLahma on Thursday June 27, 2024 @05:02AM (#40808681)
This is all sadly too true, which is why I think we should do our best to declutter as we age. Ideally when our time comes, we should only have things of immediate use and value to us left, and pretty much none of "might be good to have one day".

I've seen instances where people couldn't get rid of things due to grief and decided to keep it all tucked away for several decades, leaving the decluttering to the following generation(s). Better then to be a bit proactive.

Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by smegger001 on Saturday June 29, 2024 @09:51PM (#40834586)
My grandmother long ago made up her will of who got what, and then when she was through with it she told all of her children and grand children to write in her notebook which items not already spoken for they wanted when she no longer needed them. When was ready to move into her assisted living facility she got out her will and notebook and distributed everything she wasn't taking there with her and got rid of the rest. Compared to my other grandparents where it was a giant fiasco and almost nothing documentedas to how it was to be distributed and accusations and mistrust it sowed amongst my father and his siblings, I can say for certain its far better to be organized.
Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by badgersnake on Thursday June 27, 2024 @06:49AM (#40809119)
I’m sure if somebody came along with a serious offer for the collection with the goal of exhibiting it somewhere else it would be accepted.
Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by ghaff on Thursday June 27, 2024 @09:45AM (#40810463)
Well, yes. But that assumes someone with the capital and interest in kicking off a probably money-losing museum. After all, another computer museum with some significant holdings also went out of business 20-30 years ago. Silicon Valley is not unique but computers and other industrial artifacts are just not what most people have in mind when they're looking for a museum to go to.
Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by alsetmusic on Thursday June 27, 2024 @10:31AM (#40810935)
Reminds me of the guy (Ken Fritz) who built a $1M listening room that his kids sold for (essentially) parts after he died.

> The total take for the million-dollar stereo system, including the speakers, the turntable, the dozens of other components from detached cones to the reel-to-reel decks? $156,800.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/style/interactive/2024/ken-fr...

I don't blame them at all. It was his passion, not theirs.

Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by Fatnino on Thursday June 27, 2024 @12:09PM (#40812064)
There was a private tank collection in Portola Valley. There was a way to arrange tours but it didn't have anything like regular hours. It was just a guy with lots of money spending it on buying and restoring tanks. Most of them could run under their own power. Stuff like a German Tiger parked facing an American Sherman and a Russian T34. 2 huge garage fulls of these things. And visitors were allowed to climb onto and into all the tanks. It's how I learned that British tanks are righthand drive.

Anyway, guy died, his heirs preferred money to tanks, and they all got sold off. At best they are on display somewhere on the east coast behind velvet rope where no one will touch or drive them again.

Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by fulladder on Sunday June 30, 2024 @11:09AM (#40837593)
I remember that guy, but can't think of his name now. A VC told me about the tanks back in the mid-2000s. Thanks for bringing to mind a good memory from back in the day.
Re:LHM to permanently close and sell DEC-10 at auction by cchi_co on Friday June 28, 2024 @09:23AM (#40820390)
Agree, the passion and effort one puts into a collection may not be shared by future generations