News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by barrenko on Thursday June 20, 2024 @07:01AM (#40737229)
As mentioned, the shittiest part of the EU is that we don't ever get any insight. I wish we could launch some civil legal probe into EU institutions themselves, but that would probably end up being like staring at floating points of a tensor.
Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by Vinnl on Thursday June 20, 2024 @07:49AM (#40737580)
We don't get a lot of insight, but we do get some. For example, when it does come up for a vote in the Council, we'll know which countries voted in favour (something you can take into account in your next national elections).

Then the Parliament will have to agree as well, and we can see which parties there voted in favour, which you can take into account in the next European elections.

The Commission is toughest to hold accountable. The Commissioner pushing it (Ylva Johansson in this case) was nominated by a country's (Sweden, in this case) government, so Swedish voters could hold the parties in that government accountable in their next national election, I suppose, but that's a very weak signal.

Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by bux93 on Thursday June 20, 2024 @09:04AM (#40738317)
And you know, fund lobbyists. Shocking I know, but it's not just corporations who have lobbyists, NGOs too.
Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by toomuchtodo on Thursday June 20, 2024 @11:49AM (#40740073)
I've been donating forever to Signal, and at this point, I'm resigned that it won't reach WhatsApp parity. Just hire some lobbyists to keep encrypted communications legal as a human right.
Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by Renaud on Thursday June 20, 2024 @12:33PM (#40740556)
That wouldn’t help. The proposal “got around” weakening encryption without outright removing it.

They “just” wanted anything you sent to be scanned before it was sent encrypted.

Stupid and dangerous, the even have sections in the proposal that talk about encryption being important, but somehow less important than thinking about the children and putting a cop looking over the shoulder of every single citizen.

Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by moffkalast on Thursday June 20, 2024 @12:42PM (#40740639)
That's like saying only a good guy with a gun can stop a bad guy with a gun.

The solution is to remove guns/lobbyists, not attempting to beat them at their own game because you will absolutely lose.

Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by WaitWaitWha on Thursday June 20, 2024 @12:56PM (#40740790)
With your solution bureaucrats only have access to registered lobbyist to be eliminated. Bribery remains.
Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by int_19h on Thursday June 20, 2024 @04:36PM (#40743086)
It's only a solution if you actually have the means to do so.

If you do not, then the best you can do is to learn to play the game as best you can, so that at least you won't lose quite so badly.

Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by Log_out_ on Thursday June 20, 2024 @01:30PM (#40741126)
I wonder why NGO advice does not correlate with decision directions at all. Remember the CCC talks by NGO lobbists, usually culminating for everything they do in a"anyway that was what we advised, they however would vote/do/the thing we advised against". Had a huge speakerscorner going nowhere vibe and europes youth kicked that play pretend democracy in the nuts last election.
Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by cG_ on Friday June 21, 2024 @04:10AM (#40747279)
I've started donating to EDRi[1] for this reason.

[1] https://edri.org/about-us/who-we-are/

Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by throwAGIway on Thursday June 20, 2024 @10:10AM (#40738987)
What can I do about foreign politicians?
Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by DoughnutHole on Thursday June 20, 2024 @11:46AM (#40740039)
Your MEPs are likely part of a parliamentary group with foreign politicians and coordinate with them on policy.

If your commissioner and MEPs have been solidly opposed to a policy there might not be much you can do. But do you know that that’s a case? Many governments tend to blame unpopular proposals on the EU while the commissioner that they themselves chose vote in favour.

Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by toyg on Thursday June 20, 2024 @10:57AM (#40739457)
Push your own politicians to talk to them. Most serious EU Parliament groups are trans-national.

It's like asking what can you do about parliamentarians elected in other districts.

Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by Vinnl on Thursday June 20, 2024 @11:36AM (#40739919)
That's always problematic. The best shot you have is pressure your own politicians (at whatever level) to try to strongarm them.

For example, US policy has quite a lot of influence on me, but I can't vote for US politicians. Or Russian policy, for that matter.

Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by wasmitnetzen on Thursday June 20, 2024 @10:44AM (#40739309)
Ylva Johansson was proposed by the previous Swedish government though (a Social Democratic one), which (sort of) lost the last election. No idea why the current (right wing) government is keeping her in place.

In practise, that means she's supported by all except one of the relevant Swedish parties.

Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by toyg on Thursday June 20, 2024 @10:55AM (#40739439)
Commissioners are typically not replaced when a national government changes, which is a good thing from a stability perspective (countries can often have two or three different executives in a single year). In the end, a Commissioner is proposed by a country but is then meant to work in the interest of the entire Union, in what is largely an administrative role (Council and Parliament are the real political entities). They are supposed to be uncontroversial people, respected across the entire political spectrum, and typically will stay in post for the duration of their mandate unless embroiled in scandals.
Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by tsimionescu on Thursday June 20, 2024 @03:39PM (#40742466)
The Commission is far more powerful than the Council and Parliament, since it is the only body that can actually propose legislation to be voted on by the other two. If the commission doesn't want something done, that thing doesn't get done - including changing older laws.
Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by toyg on Thursday June 20, 2024 @03:56PM (#40742650)
No, I disagree. The Commission cannot pass anything on its own, the agenda is set by the Council and directives are effectively drafted by Parliament bodies (since MEPs have the ultimate say). The Commission largely routes things back and forth between other bodies but has very little power in practice, and is technically required to be fundamentally apolitical.

Until a few years ago, nominations for Commissioner jobs were mostly handed to long-serving but lower-level politicians. This has changed a bit in recent times, but not fundamentally so. One of the critiques of the current constitutional setup is precisely that the executive, in practice, can execute very little without constantly going back to the Council.

Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by sakjur on Thursday June 20, 2024 @11:43AM (#40740002)
The commissioner before her was Cecilia Malmström 2010-2019, a liberal party politician (right bloc) whose second term was wholly during a social democratic (left bloc) government because the nomination happened before the election.

Unfortunately, both Sweden’s most recent commissioners have been prominently advocating against encryption and for mass surveillance. I really hope our new commissioner for the 2024-2029 period ends up with a better track record on privacy advocacy.

Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by petre on Friday June 21, 2024 @02:23AM (#40746734)
Unless it's from the Greens/EFA or The Left there's little hope. And considering that the EPP and S&D still hold the majority of seats in the EP, less so.

https://howtheyvote.eu/votes/167712

Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by achtung82 on Friday June 21, 2024 @02:48AM (#40746863)
When voting about the law in the swedish parlament, both the left and green parties voted for chat control despite having campaigned against the law in the EU election.

Both claim it was a misstake, but ironically leaked chat messages seems to indicate that the green party MP Rasmus Ling did vote for it intentionally.

https://www.dn.se/sverige/interna-chattar-motbevisar-mps-utt... (swedish news article about it).

Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by agilob on Thursday June 20, 2024 @11:48AM (#40740066)
>when it does come up for a vote in the Council, we'll know which countries voted in favour

Isn't it kinda late to act?

Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by Vinnl on Thursday June 20, 2024 @02:34PM (#40741737)
That is something you could say about almost any legislation, and it's correct to some extent. That said, politicians do seem to try and predict what they'll be held accountable for, and pre-empt that. So it's not so much the voting afterwards that potentially influences the behaviour, but the threat of doing so. I also assume that this is why contacting your representatives is important - that is, essentially, making the threat.

I'll give you that it's not a terribly strong signal.

Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by tsimionescu on Thursday June 20, 2024 @03:35PM (#40742420)
We don't need this type of insight to act. For all its fualts, the EU does tend to have ample time between the time a law is drafted and made public, and the time it is voted on. And it's relatively clear who you need to try to influence in this period: your local government and/or president for EU Council proposals, your country's EU commissioner, and the government that proposed them for EU Commission proposals, and your MEPs for votes in Parliament, which is anyway the last line of defense.

Why and how exactly this proposed law came to exist in its current form is much harder to figure out, but that's not necessary to fully understand in order to oppose it successfully.

Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by tchvil on Friday June 21, 2024 @12:19AM (#40746105)
Yes, one round late. But some past votes they did were decisive in my vote this year.

This is the site where we can see who voted what in the parlement: https://howtheyvote.eu/

Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by vkou on Friday June 21, 2024 @03:03AM (#40746943)
I mean, that's how representative democracy works. You elect someone, see if they are a complete prick on a hundred different issues, and then at some point they might come up for re-election.

Another way that representative democracy works is that for many issues, you get a lot of heads-up on what will be discussed, and can influence your representative accordingly.

This generally requires coordinating your resources and efforts with other people. Lobby, protest, rabble-rouse, bribe.

Half of politics is who shows up.

Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by navane on Friday June 21, 2024 @03:46AM (#40747153)
https://howtheyvote.eu/votes/167712

This is how they voted last time, voting against is voting for privacy

Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by Aerroon on Friday June 21, 2024 @04:27AM (#40747404)
>something you can take into account in your next national elections

There's nobody to vote for.

I looked at how Parliament voted on the AI act.

https://howtheyvote.eu/votes/166051

Basically everyone voted for it.

Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by Vinnl on Saturday June 22, 2024 @03:25PM (#40761455)
The sentence you quoted referred to national elections, i.e. pertaining to the Council vote.

You linked to the European Parliament vote, and that vote actually, if I recall correctly, was to prevent Chat Control (i.e. the harmful provisions).

Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by Aerroon on Saturday June 22, 2024 @10:02PM (#40764069)
National elections are dominated by the same parties that dominate European Parliamentary elections. It's the same voting system after all, except you have even less choice since there are fewer spots.

>and that vote actually, if I recall correctly, was to prevent Chat Control (i.e. the harmful provisions).

The one I linked is the AI act.

Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by doikor on Friday June 21, 2024 @04:32AM (#40747434)
One thing to remember is that the members of the commission are supposed to represent the interests of EU not the member state they are from.

Member countries are represented in the council by representative of their government and EU citizens in the parliament by MEPs they voted for.

Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by tpm on Thursday June 20, 2024 @07:43AM (#40737524)
That wouldn't help anyway because most important things happen between national governments and the people they nominate. The EU institutions would work very differently if they were directly formed and managed by the European parliament. Alas the national governments know very well why they won't ever allow that.
Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by fredgrott on Thursday June 20, 2024 @07:10AM (#40737292)
makes a nice plot for a Dr. Who episode.
Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by justinclift on Thursday June 20, 2024 @09:05AM (#40738335)
Didn't they can Dr Who finally?
Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by maleldil on Thursday June 20, 2024 @11:39AM (#40739949)
They did a soft reset, with Ncuti's new season being marked as the Season 1 of the 2023 version. It's still going strong, with this season being very strong, IMO.
Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by swarnie on Thursday June 20, 2024 @10:02AM (#40738907)
No its still going on as "The most BBC show ever made by the BBC"
Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by HeatrayEnjoyer on Thursday June 20, 2024 @10:24AM (#40739126)
Why would they end it?
Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by semanticist on Thursday June 20, 2024 @11:26AM (#40739800)
They did in the '80s, after a run longer than the current revival. Sometimes things come in and out of fashion.
Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by barbazoo on Thursday June 20, 2024 @11:40AM (#40739965)
> As mentioned, the shittiest part of the EU is that we don't ever get any insight.

You can get quite a bit of data, what are you looking for?

Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by Vinnl on Thursday June 20, 2024 @02:37PM (#40741775)
One thing would be interesting was to know who pushed for it to be withdrawn for now, and why.
Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by Propelloni on Friday June 21, 2024 @06:30AM (#40748069)
This is trying to be a democratic process. There is no single "hero" to worship, but a number of things to consider.

The German Bundesregierung signalled a few days ago they would vote against Chatcontrol (IIRC, it is part of the Ampel coalitions founding contract to vote against surveillance enhancing measures on the EU level.) Nancy Faeser, Social Democrats, Germany's interior minister and usually not against surveillance, and Marco Buschmann, Liberal Democrats, Germany's justice minister, released statements that Chatcontrol is irreconcilable with liberal democratic states of law. The Greens were opposed anyhow and said so the last few weeks. So, unity of sorts.

France had said from the start they would vote against it (but apparently backtracking after the EU election) and with the two biggest countries in the EU against it now, the law had little chance to pass the informal council vote.

Add on top that around 30 MEPs from the Greens, Liberals and Social Democrats already wrote a letter stating that their fractions are opposed, thus ratification would have been unlikely. Add on top strong efforts by economic lobby groups, I guess the Belgian president of the council saw no reason to put the vote forward anymore.

Of course, all this could be wrong. I'm just puzzling things together I read over the last few days and weeks.

Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by Vinnl on Saturday June 22, 2024 @03:22PM (#40761427)
Yeah I think you're right, but it's a shame that we have to piece the puzzle together ourselves, and still don't have complete certainty. It's certainly a process where more transparency is possible, as a general point.
Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by EasyMark on Thursday June 20, 2024 @11:55AM (#40740157)
I think this is what happens when you get an appointed council making decisions rather than a democratically elected one. It's a bad idea because it lets the appointees and appointers to point fingers and dilute blame, which is another weapon the 1% can use to get policies in their best interest (often the opposite of those for the 99%) passed.
Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by sandworm101 on Thursday June 20, 2024 @12:03PM (#40740244)
>> which is another weapon the 1% can use to get policies in their best interest

Mass surveillance is one of the few areas where the 1% generally align with the other 99%. Rich or poor, we all use the same communication infrastructure. Rich people don't want their chats monitored either. People don't want this. Intelligence agencies want this. But ask the people working at those agencies, ask them as individuals, and they won't want this on their phones either.

Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by chongli on Thursday June 20, 2024 @12:23PM (#40740447)
Mass surveillance is one of the few areas where the 1% generally align with the other 99%

Ideally, yes. In practice, the 1% have resources the 99% don't which allow them to minimize their exposure to mass surveillance. Whether this means carving out exemptions for their own communications or conducting their meetings in person, in private, in other jurisdictions.

Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by quonn on Thursday June 20, 2024 @01:37PM (#40741191)
Who do you imagine the 1% to be? Probably I‘m the 1% in my country. I have no extraordinary power whatsoever. Maybe you mean the 0,1% or the 0,01%.
Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by chongli on Thursday June 20, 2024 @01:42PM (#40741237)
Yes, your family doctor is also likely part of the 1%. Unfortunately, the term 1% has shifted to basically mean "the people with most of the wealth and power in a country" which is a much smaller group of people, perhaps even less than 0.01%.

Quibbling over the mathematical inaccuracy of the term is tilting at windmills. You'd have better luck getting people to stop using the word "literally" to mean its opposite.

Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by Dylan16807 on Thursday June 20, 2024 @09:00PM (#40745142)
> the people with most of the wealth and power

The top 1% are pretty close to having most of the wealth in the US. They have about a third of it. Then 90-99 have about a third, 50-90 have about a third, and 0-50 have a rounding error.

The top 0.1% have about 15-20% of the wealth, which is very concentrated but not a very big fraction of the entire pie. Meaningful cutoffs are tricky to assign.

I don't know how to measure power. You could probably assign a lot of power to the top 0.01%, but in the US they have a single digit percentage of wealth.

Re:EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control by int_19h on Thursday June 20, 2024 @04:39PM (#40743108)
A better metric is "people who have N times the median wealth", since that accurately captures the power disparity that stems from access to more resources. The exact percentage will vary significantly depending on how unequal distribution of wealth is in any given society.