The association with higher AI goals is merely a mixture of pure marketing and LLM company executives getting high on their own supply.
The point I am trying to make is that the benefits of AI-related tech is likely to be quite pervasive and we should be looking at what corporations are actually doing. Sort of what this poem says:
For while the tired waves, vainly breaking / Seem here no painful inch to gain, / Far back through creeks and inlets making, / Comes silent, flooding in, the main.
Oh sure, yes. For Nvidia.
Gold rush, shovels...
The potential of a sufficiently intelligent agent, probably something very close to a really good AGI, albeit still not an ASI, could be measured in billions of billions of mostly inmediate return of investment. LLMs are already well into the definition of hard AI, there are already strong signs it could be somehow "soft AGI".
If by chance, you're the first to reach ASI, all the bets are down, you just won everything on the table.
Hence, you have this technology, LLM, then most of the experts in the field (in the world blabla), say "if you throw more data into it, it becames more intelligent", then you "just" assemble an AI team, and start training bigger, better LLMs, ASAP, AFAP.
More or less this is the reasoning behind the investments, sans accounting the typical pyramidal schemes of investments in hyped new stuff.
Juicero, tulips....
> then you "just" assemble an AI team, and start training bigger, better LLMs, ASAP, AFAP.
There's a limit to LLMs and we may have reached it. Both physical: there is not enough capacity in the world to train bigger models. And data-related: once you've gobbled up most of internet, movies and visual arts, there's an upper limit on how much better these models can become.
We do not call Intelligence something related to consciousness. Being able to reason well suffices.
I do not really understand who you are accusing of a «good enough» stance: we have never defined "consciousness" as a goal (cats are already there and we do not seem to need further), we just want something that reasons. (And that reasons excellently well.)
The apparent fact that LLMs do not reason does is drily irrelevant to an implementation of AGI.
The original poster wrote that understanding consciousness would be required to «crack AGI» and no, we state, we want AGI as a superhuman reasoner and consciousness seems irrelevant.
Llms appear to reason because they captured language with reason already in it, rather than producing language because of reason.
And nobody here is saying that LLMs would reason: you are the one attacking that idea that was not proposed here.
What you replied to said that calculators do not need consciousness to perform calculations. Reasoning is a special form of calculation. We are contented with reasoning, and when it will be implemented there will be no need for further different things for the applications we intend.
You can do "reasoning" about a topic, the LLM can produce a very similar output to what you could, how do you name the output of the LLM?
Birds can fly, they do by a natural process. A plane also can fly, we do not "see" any difference between both things when we look at them flying in the air, far from the ground.
This is mostly it about LLM "doing reasoning" or not. Semantics. The output is same.
You could just name it otherwise, but it would be still the same output.
because someone decides to connect them either unintentionally, or intentionally for personal gain, or, more likely, for corporate purposes which seem "reasonable" or "profitable" at the time, but the unintended consequences were not thought through.
Look at that recent article linked to HN about how MSFT allowed a huge security flaw in AD for years in order to not "rock the boat" and gain a large government contract. AI will be no different.
Forever? The same AI techniques are already being applied to analyze and understand images and video information after that comes ability to control robot hands and interact with the world and work on that is also ongoing.
> Till the tie we understand consciousness, we will not crack AGI …
We did not fully understand how bird bodies work yet that did not stop development of machines that fly. Why is an understanding of consciousness necessary to “crack AGI”?
There is intelligence. The LLM current state-of-the-art technology produces output analog to natural intelligences.
This things are already intelligent.
Saying that LLMs aren't producing "intelligence" is like saying planes actually don't fly because they are not flapping their wings like birds.
If you run fast enough, you'll end flying at some point.
Maybe "intelligence" is just enough statistics and pattern prediction, till the point you just say "this thing is intelligent".
There isn't
> Maybe "intelligence" is just enough statistics and pattern prediction, till the point you just say "this thing is intelligent".
Even the most stupid people can usually ask questions and correct their answers. LLMs are incapable of that. They can regurgitate data and spew a lot of generated bullshit, some of which is correct. Doesn't make them intelligent.
Here's a prime example that appeared in my feed today: https://x.com/darthsidius1985/status/1802423010886058254 And all the things wrong with it: https://x.com/yvanspijk/status/1802468042858737972 and https://x.com/yvanspijk/status/1802468708193124571
Intelligent it is not
The way the current interface for most models works can result in this kind of output, the quality of the output - not even in the latests models - doesn't necessarily reflects the fidelity of the world model inside the LLM nor the level of insight it can have about a given topic ("what is the etymology of the word cat").
The current usual approach is "one shot", you've got one shot at the prompt, then return your output, no seconds thoughts allowed, no recursion at all. I think this could be a trade-off to get the cheapest most feasible good answer, mostly because the models get to output reasonably good answers most of the time. But then you get a percentage of hallucinations and made up stuff.
That kind of output could be - in a lab - fully absent actually. Did you you notice that the prompt interfaces never gives and empty or half-empty answer? "I don't know", "I don't know for sure", "I kinda know, but it's probably a bit shaky answer", or "I could answer this, but I'd need to google some additional data before", etc.
In a lab, with recursion enabled, the models could get the true answers probably most of the time, including the fabulous "I don't know".
but I think it wouldn't make much economic sense to make public a prompt interface like that.
I think it could also have a really heavy impact in the public opinion if they get to see a model that never makes a mistake, because it can answer "I don't know", so there you have another reason to do not make prompts that way.
We've had the models for a while and still no one has shown this mythical lab where this regurgitation machine reasons about things and makes no mistakes.
Moreover, since it already has so much knowledge stored, why does it still hallucinate even in specific cases where the answer is known, such as the case I linked?
It would be a good experiment to interact with the unfiltered, not-yet-RHLFed interfaces provided to the initial trainers (nigerian folks/gals?).
Or maybe the - lightly filtered - interfaces used privately in demos for CEOs.
Did evolution understand consciousness?
> So there is nothing to worry.
Is COVID conscious?
People are falling for marketing gimmicks.
These models will remain in the word vector similarity phase forever. Till the time we understand consciousness, we will not crack AGI and then it won't take brute forcing of large swaths of data, but tiny amounts.
So there is nothing to worry. These "apps" might be as popular as Excel, but will go no further.