Imagine a skilled worker taking a new job that pays better. What a nightmare scenario.
Let's say tomorrow that you find a better way to do search. It's going to crush google, and MS.
You hire a team, smart people the VC's throw money at you. Everyone is happy. Your growing and the next darling of tech.
Google comes in and offers to buy you out. You decline cause you know that they are blockbuster and your Netflix.
In retaliation google hires all your staff, and sends them to the roof to rest and vest.
Thats great for the dozen people who got a great deal from google. It's bad for the rest of the world.
If you know for certain that "they are BlockBuster, you are Netflix", then why are you not cutting them a deal to make it worth them staying?
This is absolutely about workers -- specifically, companies not wanting to pay workers anything close to what they are worth.
It’s a fair question. Workers absolutely deserve a fair cut of the pie in that scenario. Non-competes have been pretty ridiculous lately, and companies had to provide little to no justification.
But the incentives of workers might not be entirely aligned with the “Netflix” or even their coworkers. Blockbuster wouldn’t hire the whole team unless they had to: one or two people who understood the core algorithm is enough, and for 10x their old salary it would be hard to resist. That leaves the startup and everyone else who works there out in the cold.
The second thing is that people aren’t rational expected value maximizers. You can’t pay rent with equity, and a startup may not have the cash to compete on salary.
Finally, it’s possible that allowing the larger incumbent to hire all of a competitor’s employees is actually not in their best interest. After strangling/eliminating the competition, an incumbent has no further need for those employees it poached.
And even if the do, it isnt at the inflated pay rate.
The big incumbent crushed the little guy.
When apple uses its dominant position to tax everyone 30 percent apple benefits, and the market does not.
When apple uses its dominant position to pay your team 30 percent more and stifle the free market by driving competitors out of business. you benefit, Apple benefits more and the market does not.
Is apple being a giant market dominating force a good thing or a bad thing? Your getting the high salary does not reflect your value, or the market value of your skill. It reflects apples desire to put your former employer out of business.
An exit for Employee < 50 at a netflix-to be will be in the hundreds of millions.
Unfortunately, these things aren’t certain and are contingent on many things including those that have nothing to do with technology.
It’s unfortunate because people have a bias towards guaranteed present value (cash) over expected future value (equity) which gives incumbents a natural advantage.
That's the choice of your staff and the reality you have to deal with, isn't it? I'm sure you as worker would prefer to have such an option.
What percentage of the company did you share with your workers? What is their upside if you really are a blockbuster?
If the workers really had an upside, then they might stick with you.
Hiring all the staff at an inflated rate to put a competitor out of business is good for the staff that got hired.
Without competition the dominant player makes more, without other places to work dominant player pays less.
> It’s not for the greater good.
Your not getting paid because your valuable your getting paid out because its anti-competitive. Paying you more to bankrupt a competitor is no different than dumping product to put them out of business ... Secure your market position and then jack up the prices and lower the salary.
That world sucks.
You would need to ban them from working ENTIRELY, and no sane person would accept that.
Alternatively, you might realize that NDAs and IP ownership is still a thing, Google can't just copy/paste your code, and if these people are truly irreplaceable, they should either be your cofounders or founding engineers with a significant equity stake.
Not slaves.
But other than that I'm not sure I see a problem. If a company "can just poach all of [your team] wholesale" then they were probably being under-compensated to begin with and are better off at their new company. After all, the primary point of banning noncompetes is to protect employees from employers who use noncompetes to suppress their wages. The increased competition is a nice ancillary benefit, not the primary motivation.
Doesn't California already ban non competes? The industry has seemingly thrived there and I've never heard of it being a problem.
"California law protects employers from raiding by competitors. An employee or competitor may not take a large proportion of your employees with the intent of driving you out of business. You must prove the employee or competitor had bad intent. Evidence of intent includes emails, texts, and witness testimony about what the bad employee or competitor did or said when soliciting your employees."
From: https://www.hg.org/legal-articles/stealing-employees-in-cali....
Exemptions and carve out will be used for (and politically paid for, with the mind bending official bribery system the USA runs in politics) by the powerful to consolidate their power. Small firms have a lot of power over their employees.
Small firms have to give their employees a reason to work for them, money is part of the picture, and small companies have to be well capitalised to pay competitive salaries. But small companies need to be places people want to work.
Giving employees the power to contract an employee into not quitting is a recipe for very bad behaviour.
In my experience the best and the worst employers are small firms. We need more of the best and fewer of the worst, laws that incentivise being bad do not help
https://www.squirepattonboggs.com/-/media/files/insights/pub...
Raiding is something they frown on there. They go so far as to call it anticompetitive.
It's called a free market, pay up
People and small companies kicking that addiction will be painful, yes, but important to everyone having a healthier life.
"At will" employment explicitly allows raiding.
"If you liked it then you should have put a ring on it." (IOW otherwise use an employment contract.)
YOU need to be out there beating the drum for a major exception to this. With out laws to ban raiding (and we dont have those on the federal level) this is a bad policy. It means that google doesn't have to aquire-hire your team, they can just poach all of them wholesale.
> Second, we need to prioritize forceful remedies to foster competition
If history does show us something its that outside a pure monopoly (ATT) these business have a shelf life. Roll the clock back 60 years, US Steel had the same market share as apple. ATT was a thing (and as a monopoly got smacked). But no one talks about GE or IBM or RCA as major players in tech... and they were tech giants of their day.
I am all for restrictions on these sorts of enterprises. But the bigger major step we can take is taxing them appropriately, not letting them all get the pass they have. Shift the tax burden to the largest players and you make room at the bottom and solve a host of other issues.
As for the rest of these proposals, it sounds like a lot of bureaucracy. I feel like we need to revisit our history and re-read our Orwell desperately, were literally repeating the mistakes of the past.