> AND less easily mitigated lowers bone mass, weakens tendons, and weakens ligaments.
Does it do these things any more than losing the same amount of weight by other means in a similar time frame?
"Diet-induced weight loss reduces muscle mass without adversely affecting muscle strength" [1]. (Not sure about magnitudes.)
So to get back to your question, one could lose the weight in the best possible way by correcting their diet, eating less, doing HIIT, fasting, good supplements like creatine, stress reduction through breath work and meditation, and resistance training and end up in a very strong position.
Please anyone correct me on this.
(star) Anecdote about my friend: He went on Metformin for a few years, had lots of diarrhea, and lost about 30 pounds and is skinnier than me. At this point, he could really really get into a strong health position having had that shortcut. His eating habits even got a little better from wearing a glucose monitor. He's sick of the diarrhea which really keeps him from wanting to be out of the house for long, and is slowly looking for some intriguing physical activities. So I think these drugs can help people.
Yes, but actually doing that when you’re obese is extremely difficult and maintaining it is even harder than that. The best way I can describe how difficult, it’s like climbing Mt Everest and then discovering that you have to live up there. Lots of people do manage the climb, but staying up there is the real challenge and not a big percentage of people do. So, statements like yours while they’re technically true are ignorant of the biological and psycho-social dynamics of obesity, condescending (“why didn’t I think of just eating less!?”) and totally unhelpful.
From my own hiking experience, that the first few days my appetite is suppressed, and similar reports from others, anthropomorphizing the body a bit it says "well, if we're going to be moving around this much, I don't want to carry all this weight".
Just walk.
"Become a security guard" isn't sustainable advice for weight loss.
Source: I work at a healthcare company that does weight loss, among other things.
The obsession with emotional safety that is prevalent these days is probably killing people.
Maybe pull your head out of your ass long enough to realize that nobody wants to be fat under the immense societal pressure of random assholes telling them "you're going to die", and that poor self-control is actually a physical and mental issue.
This is like a tall person telling a short person "just reach higher! Ugh!".
Is your plan sustainable through injury, and on vacation, and after being laid off and through holiday temptations, and through deep emotional turmoil, and just insidious calorie increases over time, and a million other real world scenarios that throw people off the wagon who have lifelong deep seated eating problems? This is so difficult for so many not because the obvious things work for everyone but because they don’t for a majority of people. We’ve tried all the obvious things!
If you're laid off you have more time to walk. If you're not walking that much quit your job and reduce your outgoings so that you can get a job that helps you survive past 45 without type 2 diabetes. Walking is very calming if you have emotional turmoil.
You don't get to a BMI that was much greater than 40 without eating disorders. Walking helps calm that, too.
I think people who say they have tried walking are lying to themselves. They're like the women who go to the gym and lift 2 lb dumbbells.
Walk ten miles a day for a year before telling me you've tried it.
Walking 10 miles a day isn't feasible for disabled and many injured people nor people who don't have 3+ hours spare to walk that far. If the principle is "do lots of exercise that you can do" yes we know about that, we've tried it many times, and the habit to sustain that didn't stick for the million and one reasons that they fail. Thankfully there are doctors and pharmaceutical companies that can understand recidivism statistics and don't just assume that obese people are morons or "lazy" or whatever ignorant and arrogant opinion you're espousing.
However, there is some science now to suggest that the body has other means of lowering BMI and reducing fat burn when it thinks it's starving (IE - any time it's losing weight). So it could be that my body not being in a panic is also helping to lose weight. But I'd bet it's largely just less calories.
GLP-1 increasingly looks like a vitamin.
It is "essential to [humans] in small quantities for proper metabolic function" [1]. But what our body produces gets eliminated in minutes [2]. Not everyone needs supplementation and too much can be harmful. But a deficit results in ultimately-fatal chronic conditions.
Sure, which is why I say looks like, not may be. If calcitrol were eliminated like GLP-1, a drug that activated the VDR would be beneficial to those with a deficiency [1].
These are the common effects of weight-loss and they and other risks are why you should be under the care of a specialist in obesity and/or diabetes, a nutritionist, and a trainer.
These drugs aren't a free lunch and from my understanding can't be stopped without dramatic lifestyle changes or most of the weight comes right back. 20+ years of losing bone density and connective tissue mass is going to be catastrophic in old age for people who have to stay on it long term but really so is the obesity, diabetes, and heart disease. It's a tough moral quandary.
All the results are from lowering BMI, being fat is just this unhealthy.
See this disproportionality analysis from a nationwide population-based study of the French (full text, figure 2):
https://diabetesjournals.org/care/article/46/2/384/147888/GL...
1. Weekly vs daily administration, liraglutide and exenatide had to be injected daily which made the drug less attractive for patients and doctors vs metformin which is well known and a cheap pill.
2. Greater magnitude of effect. Liraglutide had less impact at prescribed dosage for both lowering A1C and weight loss so in combo with (1) made it less attractive than semaglutide.
3. Magnitude of weight loss from (2) now so significant it easily beats all previously approved weight loss drugs with few side effects. So entire GLP-1 agonist class of drugs reexamined as direct weight loss treatments vs just a modest but very welcome side effect of diabetes treatment. And once weekly administration meant it would have much better patient compliance than a daily injection.
drugs don’t need to be used long-term to have a pretty good picture of the long-term tradeoffs, particularly when it’s something like cancer or obesity that has a clearly negative long-term outcome in the a sense of a successful intervention. Most interventions for obesity are ultimately not successful and to have one that is is a game changer, even if it has some minor side effects (and burden of proof cuts both ways - it’s not clear that they even exist etc, only that it would still be worth it if they did).
in the real world, things usually don’t turn out to have some stealth side effect that takes 30 years to manifest, and nobody is telling you to take them anyway, just to stop injecting yourself into private medical decisions around an approved, well-studied drug with a seemingly quite benign profile.
(why oh why do I suspect that semaglutide skepticism correlates heavily with the “respect my freedom to not wear a mask” crowd…)
> stealth side effect that takes 30 years to manifest
Heavy metal toxicity, cirrhosis, lung cancer, persistent infections that lead to cancer (HPV, Hep B, etc), silicosis, COPD, skin cancer, all sorts of diseases result from cumulative exposure.
> (why oh why do I suspect that semaglutide skepticism correlates heavily with the “respect my freedom to not wear a mask” crowd…)
Can you approach skepticism without ad hominem attacks?
Alcoholism, diabetes and obesity don't give you long enough to get these cancers. Even if we had evidence GLP-1 agonists massively increased the risk of these cancers, which we don't, despite them having been studied and prescribed for decades [1][2], the tradeoff makes sense for much of the population.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GLP-1_receptor_agonist#Approve...
To put that into perspective, annual cost of diabetes to America is $1,200 per capita ($1,300 adjusted for inflation [2]. 40% more than a month of Ozempic [3].
One twelfth of Americans have diabetes [4]. If the government could negotiate just a 10% bulk discount, the payback period on buying every American with diabetes Ozempic would be around a year. Even if everyone ceased treatment after that, even if you only did this for a couple years, we'd see a permanent boost in productivity and health across the American population.
[1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37909353/
[2] https://www.usinflationcalculator.com
[3] https://ro.co/weight-loss/ozempic-cost-without-insurance/
[4] https://www.niddk.nih.gov/health-information/health-statisti...
https://www.healthline.com/health-news/how-affordable-could-...
"Semaglutide is expected to become patent-free in the United States no earlier than December 2031" [1].
We could probably strike a volume deal for ~$200 for 5 years and then $75 (the upper end of your study’s estimate for manufacturing cost) for another 5.
My understanding is that they are patentening the drug+device and or the dosing, not the molecule. Looks like the FTC is clamping down on it.
Age doesn't cost society, morbidity does [1]. A society of long-lived healthy people is richer than one of the short-lived obese.
The only significant finding was "an increased risk of overall thyroid disorders (RR 1.28, 95% CI 1.03-1.60)."
The abstract of the paper itself concludes "However, due to the low incidence of these diseases, these findings need to be examined further." suggesting that the authors didn't even find their own work to be conclusive about the short/medium-term risks at the scale of widespread use, let alone the long-term risks that they weren't even analyzing.
Straw man. Nobody claimed these studies prove GLP-1 agonists are totally safe. Just that they don't show "severe unknown incidents like thyroid and pancreatic cancer" [1].
> suggesting that the authors didn't even find their own work to be conclusive about the short/medium-term risks at the scale of widespread use, let alone the long-term risks that they weren't even analyzing
Sure. That's a straightforward reading of the paper. Again, nobody argued these aren't thesre. Just that present data don't sustain it as a serious problem.
>However, no major safety concerns have arisen to date, although definitive conclusions for pancreatic cancer, thyroid cancer and DRP complications cannot be drawn at this point. When compared with the beneficial effects of these drugs on glucose metabolism, blood pressure, body weight and cardiovascular (and potentially even renal) endpoints, these agents have an overall beneficial risk/benefit-profile for treatment of patients with T2D.
Losing weight means losing the muscle “scaffolding” also.
Until I see proof that these drugs result in dramatically more muscle mass loss, I’m going to assume the argument is FUD.
Mindful that this also lowers muscle mass (can weight train and eat enough protein to compensate slightly)
AND less easily mitigated lowers bone mass, weakens tendons, and weakens ligaments.
It’s a great option if the patient is diabetic and their current lifestyle/condition has worse outcomes than the side effects listed, but we’re hearing from celebrities like this is a vitamin D pill