Some good answers already in the comments and I just want to point out that we need to stop lending so much credence to authority and titles and better recognize that it is perfectly possible to both hold a “prestigious,” even elected title like Rector or priest or President or judge or District Attorney and be a laughing stock at the same time
Unless there is an explicit suspicion, nobody is going to systematically check all your citations and papers. There are simply too many of these things to do that systematically, for every researcher, grad student or professor.
The universities don't have resources for something like that - that would mean hiring multiple people doing just work like that full time. And it still wouldn't uncover the slightly more sophisticated cases, such as the professor getting a "mandatory citation" on every paper produced by the students working in their lab.
How do you think can a professor publish 20-30 journal papers a year (that's both a very common number and still quite low) when getting a single paper written and shepherded through the review process takes months in the best case and could take even 2 years in the worst for the large journals?
Yes, all the work is done by the grad students and assistant profs - and the professor's name gets added to the list of authors as a sign of respect (in the best case) or because they were told to do that (in the worst one). This is an extremely common practice.
I have personally witnessed one guy build essentially an entire fake academic career like this, by pushing grad students to credit him for work he didn't do - and he almost got away with it. He didn't obtain a tenured position at a prestigious European university only because one of the professors in the tenure committee worked with him before and knew how did he obtain those (on paper) stellar research credentials - and vetoed it.
Moreover, most of the metrics like impact factor are just a number. You can't see what they have been calculated from. Research has always been built on individual integrity and honesty. And there will always be bad apples that abuse it.
The motivations and what is on stake (your career, job, grants, etc.) are so skewed that a lot of people feel pushed into cheating like this.
Just recently, Yann LeCun bragged on Twitter about publishing over 80 papers in two years.
I wondered who he thought he was impressing. Anyone who knows anything about science knows that at least the majority of those weren't his own work.
(No disrespect intended; YLC has done important work. But that tweet was not his best idea.)
How would you distinguish between a clique and a group of people who cite each other because they work on the same topic?
I think that instead of turning over every opportunity for a human job to robots that will fail and be captured, we should be giving people those jobs. The kind of flesh bodies that are afraid of being jailed for years at a time.
This is especially problematic as some researchers build entire careers out of gatekeeping preprint access to unique, single- source primary data that only they or their lab/ staff can collect- not because of their superior ability to analyze it but because theirs is the only facility with the appropriate ensemble of apparatus on site or close at hand, or because they are the latest in a close-knit (often nepotistic) chain of custodians presiding over a certain exclusive primary source, such as a nature reserve or archaeological site.
I just finished my PhD at a "top tier" university. Everyone plays the same exact tricks. My group all self-cited and our collaborators and back and forth.
So there's no such thing as "top tier" as far as the quality goes, there's only higher paid.
Sounds like a great project for someone, especially someone in academia, to lead.
Call it the C-index, after Corchado, and test it against his network
Cliques are not the problem, in many niche areas, you will have natural cliques. It is hard to distinguish that from forceful citations like this. And, this may not be a clique. I don't think this guy was citing back researchers he forced to cite him.
The publisher have no reason to get at this, they actually profit quite a bit from research fraud.
Which also is very common. It took a long, long while before Macchiarini's fraudulent articles were retracted, same with some of the foundational Alzheimer-placque-articles.
Citation counts are considered by promotion committees though. In this case, committee members are often from different fields and have less ability to judge the quality of the applicants' work for themselves.
None of the above matters in this particular case though—the problem is that Corchado was the only candidate on the ballot: "… taking advantage of the strange surprise resignation of the previous rector, and presenting himself as the only candidate. He received the support of 6.5% of the 33,000 university members who were called to vote, with half of the faculty voting blank as a sign of protest. "
This turned into a huge setback for Alzheimer's research specifically. Politicians and their ilk poured money into 'amyloid research' so to get money that's what you had to do, even though it was rather early on pretty well known among researchers that it wasn't a fruitful way forward.
Nobody cares how you get to such an index unless you commit fraud.
I think technically creating citing cartels is not breaking any research rules. Unethical but within the rules.
Not true, citation cartels are unethical research practices, there is no question about it.
There is also no "technically within the rules", because there are generally no specific rules.
Research rules essentially are "Don't do anything unethical", in a research ethics course you would then be given examples, like don't falsify data, dont misrepresented data, acknowledge previous work...
And while I believe the vast majority of academics follow the principles, because the rules are unspecified there is a gray zone (I believe that is a good thing we don't need to bog down scientific research by even more administration).
Perhaps this is obvious to others, but could you articulate the ethical principle that this violates?
The authors artifically inflate the impact of their research thus misrepresenting how important it is. It is widely viewed as misconduct e.g. see these guidelines from T&F (most other journals would have something similar) https://authorservices.taylorandfrancis.com/editorial-polici...
Ran unopposed, elected on 6.5% of the vote.
I've literally seen faculty 'drawing straws' as of who'll agree to be the sole candidate for a particular elected administrative position, because it's clear that one of them has to do it for the university to function, but no one wanted to.
Protesting would mean getting some random guy to also run and make him win
This move will never cease to annoy the fuck out of me. Unless the election is somehow invalidated or recalled by the number of blank votes, it is completely counter-productive.
I could understand if it was some clever hidden cartel where people sneak in extra references that seem plausible, spread out over many people and articles. But to juts have cite only this guys garbage papers?
Also the citation / H-index metric clearly need improvements. It should be trivial to do clique detection and downrank such citations.