News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by TheDudeMan on Friday May 31, 2024 @03:48PM (#40539468)
"Too Expensive, Too Slow, and Too Risky"

Because they are still too big. They must be very small. Fuel efficiency is less important than creating economies of scale in manufacturing.

Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by lven on Friday May 31, 2024 @04:03PM (#40539607)
not when it's more expensive than diesel. Must find the balance.
Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by TheDudeMan on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:54PM (#40540721)
Nuclear fuel is about 20x cheaper than diesel (per unit energy).

https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/840500 (page 6, table VII)

Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by Arnt on Friday May 31, 2024 @04:23PM (#40539809)
Can a nuclear reactor be small enough that it doesn't need an expensive fence with 24/7 guards, and an expensive evaluation of the site for disaster risk?

I sort of suspect the answer to be no, but would like to hear arguments for yes.

Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by marcosdumay on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:16PM (#40540347)
You should be able to make a reactor with anything larger than a couple kg of material.

Maybe you can avoid a thorium reactor if that size from being a valuable target. I have little idea about the social risks of somebody using the material as poison, instead of explosive, but I suspect it's incredibly overblown currently. (Wannabe thieves are probably way more effective going after something else.)

But well, don't expect very small reactors to be efficient or cheap. They maybe could be cheap heat sources, but electricity generation and distribution are full of scale efficiencies.

Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by pfdietz on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:26PM (#40540442)
> You should be able to make a reactor with anything larger than a couple kg of material.

A reactor that small needs highly enriched fissionable material. Of course it would need guards, since it's a proliferation nightmare.

Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by throwup238 on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:28PM (#40540462)
The lower limit is a nuclear lightbulb with ~20kg of uranium fuel, but that’s a high pressure reactor chamber that would definitely need to be protected and it needs large centrifuges inline to separate the fuel back out from the gas.
Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by TheDudeMan on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:51PM (#40540692)
You don't need distribution for a small enough reactor -- you use the electricity on site.
Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by TheDudeMan on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:50PM (#40540686)
Ideally, the reactor would not need service until end-of-life (e.g. ~10 years). That way, it can be encased in concrete and buried.
Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by cyberax on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:52PM (#40540700)
Yeah, so basically, you want to spam the world with nuclear waste.
Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by JumpCrisscross on Friday May 31, 2024 @06:02PM (#40540783)
> spam the world with nuclear waste

You may be vastly underestimating the amount of toxic waste produced by our energy production processes, renewable or not. (Wind, as I understand it, being the least nasty.)

Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by cyberax on Friday May 31, 2024 @06:16PM (#40540902)
The proposal is:

> Ideally, the reactor would not need service until end-of-life (e.g. ~10 years). That way, it can be encased in concrete and buried.

This will blow up the level of radioactive waste that needs to be buried by about 1000x. Instead of a couple of kilos of long-lived isotopes after reprocessing, you'll need to bury THE WHOLE FREAKING REACTOR CORE.

Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by JumpCrisscross on Friday May 31, 2024 @06:29PM (#40540993)
> blow up the level of radioactive waste that needs to be buried by about 1000x. Instead of a couple of kilos of long-lived isotopes after reprocessing, you'll need to bury THE WHOLE FREAKING REACTOR CORE

Why the scare caps? The first word in SMR is “small.”

We currently wash out the industrial waste from processing and manufacturing our energy inputs and infrastructure. Also, nothing stops reprocessing those cores in the future. Next to a spent-fuel tank or tailings pool, a buried core seems preferable.

Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by cyberax on Friday May 31, 2024 @09:16PM (#40541997)
> Why the scare caps? The first word in SMR is “small.”

It's "small" only when compared to full-scale PWRs.

Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday June 01, 2024 @11:47AM (#40546695)
> It's "small" only when compared to full-scale PWRs

And mines and tailing pools, to say nothing of acres and acres of panels and wind farms.

Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by cyberax on Saturday June 01, 2024 @01:55PM (#40547751)
Ah, also don't forget that you'll have to store "spent reactors" in pools for a decade, to make sure they cool down sufficiently before burying them.

Sorry, but this idea is about as stupid as they come.

Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by TheDudeMan on Friday May 31, 2024 @09:08PM (#40541949)
It is buried while it runs. At end-of-life, you dig it up and properly dispose of it (whatever that process may be).
Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by cyberax on Friday May 31, 2024 @09:15PM (#40541991)
No, it won't be buried while it runs. The core can be buried, but it has to be in close proximity to steam generators and turbines.

And what "end of life"? Fuel will be exhausted in 3-5 years max. And I very much don't want disposable nuclear reactors. Modern PWRs are designed to last for 50 years and can probably last for 100.

TerraPower wanted to build "nuclear candle" reactors that can last for 50 years without refueling, but they had an inconvenient problem of requiring unobtanium for the reactor vessel walls (a material that can sustain 400-500 dpa, while the best steels can maybe push 150). "DPA" is "displacements per atom".

Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by littlestymaar on Friday May 31, 2024 @04:34PM (#40539936)
> doesn't need an expensive fence with 24/7 guards

You means, like most industrial plants anyway or even college campuses?

An “expensive fence” and 24/7 security guard are still ridiculously cheap compared to the price of the thing itself.

Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by consumer451 on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:04PM (#40540218)
I believe that after 9/11, we required all new nuclear plants to be able to withstand the impact of a 737. So it's just a little more complicated.
Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by amluto on Friday May 31, 2024 @06:04PM (#40540798)
Off the top of my head, if I had to protect a shipping container sized object from a 737, I would bury it. Dig a hole maybe the size of a residential swimming pool, build some drainage and some concrete walls with enough space to allow the container to get back out, stick the container in, and backfill outside the walls. Put a lid on it and cover it with local soil. As a bonus: anyone trying to steal it would need an excavator of some sort.

Or build an underground parking lot, park the SMR in it, put a serious door in front, and use the space above it for something else.

Conventional construction underground, especially of something complex, is expensive. But much of the point of an SMR is that it’s built off site and then installed. Driving a container down a ramp or lowering one off a crane is straightforward.

Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by consumer451 on Friday May 31, 2024 @06:08PM (#40540829)
I was thinking underground as well, but don't forget about the waste storage area/infrastructure:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40540802

Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by bialpio on Friday May 31, 2024 @06:00PM (#40540769)
How much (little?) radioactive material would there have to be inside the SMR for an impact of a 737 into the neighborhood to be more devastating than the release of the radioactive material?
Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by consumer451 on Friday May 31, 2024 @06:04PM (#40540802)
Well, this doesn't answer your question, but there is also the issue of waste storage. In light water reactors, that's stored on-site for a long time. This research appears to indicate that with SMRs, this is actually a bigger issue.

> Small modular reactors (SMRs), proposed as the future of nuclear energy, have purported cost and safety advantages over existing gigawatt-scale light water reactors (LWRs). However, few studies have assessed the implications of SMRs for the back end of the nuclear fuel cycle. The low-, intermediate-, and high-level waste stream characterization presented here reveals that SMRs will produce more voluminous and chemically/physically reactive waste than LWRs, which will impact options for the management and disposal of this waste. Although the analysis focuses on only three of dozens of proposed SMR designs, the intrinsically higher neutron leakage associated with SMRs suggests that most designs are inferior to LWRs with respect to the generation, management, and final disposal of key radionuclides in nuclear waste.

https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2111833119

Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by AlexAndScripts on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:52PM (#40540701)
Perhaps it could be underground, either in an excavated area or a natural cave?
Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by worik on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:04PM (#40540214)
> like most industrial plants anyway or even college campuses?

Nuclear power stations are an extreme, not typical, example

Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by littlestymaar on Saturday June 01, 2024 @02:50AM (#40543479)
This is in fact purely a political decision: a nuclear power plant is in reality less prone to being attacked than a virology lab, and the consequences are way less severe [1], then why should we expect the former to have much more stringent security rules?

[1] unless you leave the nuclear reactor unattended in the hands of terrorists for days, they won't be able to extract any nuclear material (which would be the worse case scenario and only one comparable to terrorist stealing a vial of Ebola or Smallpox)

Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by anothernewdude on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:47PM (#40540659)
Small enough to be inserted into the human body to power a pacemaker.
Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by pfdietz on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:58PM (#40540747)
That's not a nuclear reactor.
Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by littlestymaar on Friday May 31, 2024 @04:38PM (#40539972)
The argument about cost in this paper is complete bullshit anyway, since they are talking about one-shot reactors, of course it's going to be expensive, the main argument about SMR is that you're able to create multiple ones and improve the process to drive cost low as the learning curves kicks in (and without needing the kind of All-in France did in the 80s when they built 58 regular-sized reactor in 20 years, leading to very good economies of scale).
Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by worik on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:08PM (#40540267)
> the main argument about SMR is that you're able to create multiple ones and improve the process to drive cost low as the learning curves kicks in

I was thinking that too. But they addressed that in the article

Why will this time be different, when nowhere in the world has any nuclear industry succeeded in lowering costs over the life of a programme?

The French, the article says, built 55 reactors, standardising the parts and processes but still could not control costs

Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by cyberax on Friday May 31, 2024 @06:03PM (#40540794)
> Why will this time be different, when nowhere in the world has any nuclear industry succeeded in lowering costs over the life of a programme?

Russia (Rosatom) did it with the exported reactors. China is on track as well, although their finances are not as transparent.

Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by littlestymaar on Saturday June 01, 2024 @03:08AM (#40543563)
> The French, the article says, built 58 (ftfy) reactors, standardizing the parts and processes but still could not control costs

This is crazy bad faith at play here! Between the start of the French nuclear program and the end, two major international accident (TMI and Chornobyl) occurred and lead to massive changes in safety regulations. Of course it's going to have an impact on costs!

Also, in the meantime there had been a huge return on operation experience, which allowed to design plants that became cheaper and more efficient to operate (load following is much easier on the second generation than on the first for instance) but obvious lead to changes in design, but that's still part of the learning curve.

Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by TheDudeMan on Sunday June 02, 2024 @10:08AM (#40554257)
55 is a tiny number in manufacturing.