News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by littlestymaar on Friday May 31, 2024 @04:38PM (#40539972)
The argument about cost in this paper is complete bullshit anyway, since they are talking about one-shot reactors, of course it's going to be expensive, the main argument about SMR is that you're able to create multiple ones and improve the process to drive cost low as the learning curves kicks in (and without needing the kind of All-in France did in the 80s when they built 58 regular-sized reactor in 20 years, leading to very good economies of scale).
Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by worik on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:08PM (#40540267)
> the main argument about SMR is that you're able to create multiple ones and improve the process to drive cost low as the learning curves kicks in

I was thinking that too. But they addressed that in the article

Why will this time be different, when nowhere in the world has any nuclear industry succeeded in lowering costs over the life of a programme?

The French, the article says, built 55 reactors, standardising the parts and processes but still could not control costs

Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by cyberax on Friday May 31, 2024 @06:03PM (#40540794)
> Why will this time be different, when nowhere in the world has any nuclear industry succeeded in lowering costs over the life of a programme?

Russia (Rosatom) did it with the exported reactors. China is on track as well, although their finances are not as transparent.

Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by littlestymaar on Saturday June 01, 2024 @03:08AM (#40543563)
> The French, the article says, built 58 (ftfy) reactors, standardizing the parts and processes but still could not control costs

This is crazy bad faith at play here! Between the start of the French nuclear program and the end, two major international accident (TMI and Chornobyl) occurred and lead to massive changes in safety regulations. Of course it's going to have an impact on costs!

Also, in the meantime there had been a huge return on operation experience, which allowed to design plants that became cheaper and more efficient to operate (load following is much easier on the second generation than on the first for instance) but obvious lead to changes in design, but that's still part of the learning curve.

Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by TheDudeMan on Sunday June 02, 2024 @10:08AM (#40554257)
55 is a tiny number in manufacturing.