News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by cyberax on Friday May 31, 2024 @06:16PM (#40540902)
The proposal is:

> Ideally, the reactor would not need service until end-of-life (e.g. ~10 years). That way, it can be encased in concrete and buried.

This will blow up the level of radioactive waste that needs to be buried by about 1000x. Instead of a couple of kilos of long-lived isotopes after reprocessing, you'll need to bury THE WHOLE FREAKING REACTOR CORE.

Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by JumpCrisscross on Friday May 31, 2024 @06:29PM (#40540993)
> blow up the level of radioactive waste that needs to be buried by about 1000x. Instead of a couple of kilos of long-lived isotopes after reprocessing, you'll need to bury THE WHOLE FREAKING REACTOR CORE

Why the scare caps? The first word in SMR is “small.”

We currently wash out the industrial waste from processing and manufacturing our energy inputs and infrastructure. Also, nothing stops reprocessing those cores in the future. Next to a spent-fuel tank or tailings pool, a buried core seems preferable.

Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by cyberax on Friday May 31, 2024 @09:16PM (#40541997)
> Why the scare caps? The first word in SMR is “small.”

It's "small" only when compared to full-scale PWRs.

Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday June 01, 2024 @11:47AM (#40546695)
> It's "small" only when compared to full-scale PWRs

And mines and tailing pools, to say nothing of acres and acres of panels and wind farms.

Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by cyberax on Saturday June 01, 2024 @01:55PM (#40547751)
Ah, also don't forget that you'll have to store "spent reactors" in pools for a decade, to make sure they cool down sufficiently before burying them.

Sorry, but this idea is about as stupid as they come.

Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by TheDudeMan on Friday May 31, 2024 @09:08PM (#40541949)
It is buried while it runs. At end-of-life, you dig it up and properly dispose of it (whatever that process may be).
Re:Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, an... by cyberax on Friday May 31, 2024 @09:15PM (#40541991)
No, it won't be buried while it runs. The core can be buried, but it has to be in close proximity to steam generators and turbines.

And what "end of life"? Fuel will be exhausted in 3-5 years max. And I very much don't want disposable nuclear reactors. Modern PWRs are designed to last for 50 years and can probably last for 100.

TerraPower wanted to build "nuclear candle" reactors that can last for 50 years without refueling, but they had an inconvenient problem of requiring unobtanium for the reactor vessel walls (a material that can sustain 400-500 dpa, while the best steels can maybe push 150). "DPA" is "displacements per atom".