News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:British Museum gems for sale on eBay – how a theft was ex... by darth_avocado on Monday May 27, 2024 @01:50PM (#40492987)
Very ironic considering one of their excuses on returning artifacts to countries of origin is “they wouldn’t be cared for and would be stolen”.
Re:British Museum gems for sale on eBay – how a theft was ex... by mensetmanusman on Monday May 27, 2024 @02:41PM (#40493391)
There is no one to return them to, everyone from the past is dead.
Re:British Museum gems for sale on eBay – how a theft was ex... by aprilthird2021 on Monday May 27, 2024 @02:57PM (#40493545)
I think since these are cultural artifacts, many times looted in war or conquest, there's an argument to be made they could be returned to the cultural institutions or museums of the place they were taken from.
Re:British Museum gems for sale on eBay – how a theft was ex... by mensetmanusman on Monday May 27, 2024 @10:33PM (#40496822)
What if the culture requesting it has artifacts of their own that they can’t give back, because they themselves genocided those cultures. No one is innocent.
Re:British Museum gems for sale on eBay – how a theft was ex... by aprilthird2021 on Sunday June 02, 2024 @02:21AM (#40551849)
It's not about innocence or guilt.

It's about, if you have a piece in your museum, and you know in its chain of ownership, it was looted from, say, France during, say, the German occupation in WWII. Even if all the parties involved are now dead, there's a case to be made to transfer the artifact from a German museum to a French museum.

And this argument holds some weight and can be extrapolated to many other scenarios.

In your case if items exist in the museum looted from a nation that no longer exists (and isn't like Czechoslovakia which was split up into currently existing nations) and the nations in that same land aren't culturally connected or caring to have the artifacts, fine. Nothing else can be done

Re:British Museum gems for sale on eBay – how a theft was ex... by wigster on Monday May 27, 2024 @02:46PM (#40493429)
my first girl friend is still alive.
Re:British Museum gems for sale on eBay – how a theft was ex... by pests on Monday May 27, 2024 @09:21PM (#40496463)
What about everyone from the present? You don't think they care about their own heritage?
Re:British Museum gems for sale on eBay – how a theft was ex... by jmprspret on Monday May 27, 2024 @10:15PM (#40496753)
Queen Lizzy is from the past. Stealing her crown jewels right after she died and putting it on display in my work office would be okay?
Re:British Museum gems for sale on eBay – how a theft was ex... by KingMob on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @11:05AM (#40501413)
I think you need a better example :) It's not like her ancestors didn't steal the wealth of the populace to make their shiny hats.
Re:British Museum gems for sale on eBay – how a theft was ex... by jmprspret on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @02:31AM (#40509112)
You're correct! I do need a better example :D
Re:British Museum gems for sale on eBay – how a theft was ex... by mensetmanusman on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @01:31PM (#40503196)
Stealing is not okay.
Re:British Museum gems for sale on eBay – how a theft was ex... by justanotheratom on Monday May 27, 2024 @02:24PM (#40493253)
yup, no sympathy for "British Museums".
Re:British Museum gems for sale on eBay – how a theft was ex... by twixfel on Monday May 27, 2024 @02:08PM (#40493105)
Same excuse every museum gives. The US is full of European art and artifacts.
Re:British Museum gems for sale on eBay – how a theft was ex... by throw5345346 on Monday May 27, 2024 @03:45PM (#40493948)
Small beer when it's also built in very large part on stolen land, eh? If giving stuff back is important (and I think it is), I'd love it if the knee-jerk thinkers of HN would start by looking at where they live and which tribe it was stolen from by force.
Re:British Museum gems for sale on eBay – how a theft was ex... by tasuki on Monday May 27, 2024 @05:12PM (#40494764)
Sure, but which land isn't stolen?
Re:British Museum gems for sale on eBay – how a theft was ex... by throw5345346 on Monday May 27, 2024 @06:00PM (#40495166)
In many cases, the USA knows the names and families of the people it stole land from. Knows their lineage. Even has photographs of some of them!

In historical terms it is a recent, deliberate, judicially-supported, documented theft. Not some undocumented invasion in hazy pre-history. Acts of Congress were passed to do it.

The British Museum (along with the V&A) has some stuff (well looked-after) that people want back. Currently the law literally prevents it being returned, and these organisations are in many cases trying to find ways to work around that law so that it is long-loaned back forever, until the law is changed. There's no simple intransigence; there is dialogue and politics.

The British Empire did some amazing things, and many, many ugly things. You won't find a person in the UK who doesn't understand that now, and there are all sorts of reparation campaigns, restitution campaigns, history projects, etc. etc.; nationally we rub our own noses in it so often that there's a right-wing backlash.

So it's tedious in the extreme the way Americans keep prattling on about British museums as if there is only stonewalling, and as if there is no appropriation from native culture in its post-independence history. It's literally on paper.

Re:British Museum gems for sale on eBay – how a theft was ex... by twixfel on Monday May 27, 2024 @05:50PM (#40495090)
Well, the USA was completely stolen, every single square inch, and the natives genocided. Whereas the Basques for example, if they stole their land, did it in deep prehistory.
Re:British Museum gems for sale on eBay – how a theft was ex... by MaxHoppersGhost on Monday May 27, 2024 @05:58PM (#40495152)
The natives weren’t one political group of people. They were hundred or thousands of tribes. And at some point each tribe “stole” it from some other tribe and territory. Some tribes (example: the Iroquois) were genociding other tribes.
Re:British Museum gems for sale on eBay – how a theft was ex... by throw5345346 on Monday May 27, 2024 @06:02PM (#40495180)
You know this is the same form of justification that used to be used for squirrelling things away in western museums?
Re:British Museum gems for sale on eBay – how a theft was ex... by MaxHoppersGhost on Monday May 27, 2024 @06:17PM (#40495280)
Yes.
Re:British Museum gems for sale on eBay – how a theft was ex... by MaxHoppersGhost on Monday May 27, 2024 @05:53PM (#40495110)
All land is “stolen”. The tribes that were on the land when the Europeans rolled in had stolen it from some other tribe at some point too.

Feel free to donate your land back to the tribe it was “stolen from”.

Re:British Museum gems for sale on eBay – how a theft was ex... by yjftsjthsd-h on Monday May 27, 2024 @06:32PM (#40495394)
> If giving stuff back is important (and I think it is), I'd love it if the knee-jerk thinkers of HN would start by looking at where they live and which tribe it was stolen from by force and murder.

Okay. Where do you live, who was it stolen from, and what are you going to do about it?

Re:British Museum gems for sale on eBay – how a theft was ex... by throw5345346 on Monday May 27, 2024 @06:53PM (#40495545)
In the south east of England. It's not really clear it was stolen by anyone. The only people in even slightly recorded history to really steal it buggered off a few hundred years later because they missed olive oil and hated the climate. Everyone else pretty much just turned up to run it better, like slightly violent management consultants.

The point is that commenters arguing a museum should give stuff back from where they took it are often arguing from a country that has documentary records in its current legislative body that it faux-legalistically stole the very land it is on.

In many cases, the USA stole that land well after the British Museum (which is older than the USA) acquired some of its objects. It's astonishingly well-documented.

If the argument is that all land has changed hands at some point in history and that excuses the documented way the USA murdered people, used biological warfare, and walked them to their deaths off their own land, then I'm not sure what all the po-faced American social media fuss is about the Elgin Marbles.

(Personally I think the Marbles should go home)

Re:British Museum gems for sale on eBay – how a theft was ex... by alephnerd on Monday May 27, 2024 @02:23PM (#40493237)
American museums also seem to have a stronger financial muscle [0] as they tend to be overwhelmingly funded by self sustaining endowments and more open to monetization strategies like IP Licensing (eg. MoMA+Uniqlo's partnership)

[0] - https://www.sothebysinstitute.com/news-and-events/news/the-b...

Re:British Museum gems for sale on eBay – how a theft was ex... by aprilthird2021 on Monday May 27, 2024 @02:57PM (#40493553)
There's a difference between museums and galleries where pieces were purchased and have a good chain of ownership and pieces where the museum knows one of the owners in the chain looted the piece
Re:British Museum gems for sale on eBay – how a theft was ex... by bossyTeacher on Monday May 27, 2024 @02:28PM (#40493282)
The US is a former British colony so it makes sense for it have british artifacts
Re:British Museum gems for sale on eBay – how a theft was ex... by twixfel on Monday May 27, 2024 @05:46PM (#40495049)
European, not just British.
Re:British Museum gems for sale on eBay – how a theft was ex... by bossyTeacher on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @05:36AM (#40498987)
Brits had all sorts of European forces on their lands and each brought cultural artifacts with them