Re:British Museum gems for sale on eBay – how a theft was ex...
by aprilthird2021 on Monday May 27, 2024 @02:57PM
(#40493545)
I think since these are cultural artifacts, many times looted in war or conquest, there's an argument to be made they could be returned to the cultural institutions or museums of the place they were taken from.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:British Museum gems for sale on eBay – how a theft was ex...
by mensetmanusman on Monday May 27, 2024 @10:33PM
(#40496822)
What if the culture requesting it has artifacts of their own that they can’t give back, because they themselves genocided those cultures. No one is innocent.
Re:British Museum gems for sale on eBay – how a theft was ex...
by aprilthird2021 on Sunday June 02, 2024 @02:21AM
(#40551849)
It's not about innocence or guilt.
It's about, if you have a piece in your museum, and you know in its chain of ownership, it was looted from, say, France during, say, the German occupation in WWII. Even if all the parties involved are now dead, there's a case to be made to transfer the artifact from a German museum to a French museum.
And this argument holds some weight and can be extrapolated to many other scenarios.
In your case if items exist in the museum looted from a nation that no longer exists (and isn't like Czechoslovakia which was split up into currently existing nations) and the nations in that same land aren't culturally connected or caring to have the artifacts, fine. Nothing else can be done