News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by ninetyninenine on Sunday May 19, 2024 @01:59PM (#40408567)
AI is to the point where it can create it's own style. We talk about these styles as if it's some kind of sacred thing. What you don't realize is that we're past this point.

There's a latent space of different art within a certain style category, but there's the latent space of different categories itself. AI can already traverse the space between art in a single style category AND it can traverse the gradient space BETWEEN categories. It can even go beyond that.

AI has turned everything into a freaking best fit curve.

Copywrite is such a mundane question. It's just a fight against the inevitable truth. That human creativity are just points on that curve. Nothing more, nothing less.

I view this as a BAD thing. Copywrite is good, it's great. It's a law that implies what humans create has meaning. But we have to face the truth. That the output we produce is in actuality just one part of a high level pattern. That's all we are.

Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by croniev on Sunday May 19, 2024 @02:10PM (#40408671)
Human creativity turns into a point on that curve. One mission of art is to find a different dimension, out of the curves reach, until eventually it becomes more common and the curve can be fitted to it again. AI cannot think outside of the box because it cannot think at all, there is no meaning behind what it does.
Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by ninetyninenine on Sunday May 19, 2024 @02:14PM (#40408700)
>Human creativity turns into a point on that curve.

All human creativity are points ON the SAME Curve.

It doesn't matter what turns what into what into some point on the curve or finding a different "dimension"

If you come up with an algorithm that can traverse that curve you've found the algorithm for human creativity.

We are close, deadly close, to the end.

Especially given the fact that these AI algorithms literally treat the problem as a best fit curve from a mathematical perspective. Like the analogy I made is not even really an analogy, it's the reality of how these algorithms actually work.

Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by mistermann on Sunday May 19, 2024 @04:10PM (#40409432)
"We're at the tippity top of the mountain, but we're only halfway up".
Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by ninetyninenine on Sunday May 19, 2024 @04:48PM (#40409644)
We're at the foot of the mountain. We only just started.
Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by mistermann on Monday May 20, 2024 @10:24AM (#40415791)
Surveys of humans strongly demonstrate that they are rather impressed with their mountain climbing accomplishments thus far. The main shortcoming to humanity is only the actions of those other people.
Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by astrange on Sunday May 19, 2024 @05:38PM (#40409951)
> All human creativity are points ON the SAME Curve.

That's what they said about mathematical proofs.

> If you come up with an algorithm that can traverse that curve you've found the algorithm for human creativity.

And that's what they said about programs that take finite time to prove whether or not other programs halt.

Neither of those turned out to be true though. (In particular, because the curve you're talking about is infinitely large and so you cannot compute on it in finite time.)

Also, real world things cannot be reduced to their bit descriptions because they have metadata even if their descriptions are identical: https://ansuz.sooke.bc.ca/entry/23

Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by ninetyninenine on Sunday May 19, 2024 @06:51PM (#40410340)
>And that's what they said about programs that take finite time to prove whether or not other programs halt.

An actualization of human creativity exists. Your brain.

The existence of your brain as a physical thing indicates that human creativity can be actualized. It’s literal proof via existence.

It’s the complete opposite of what you describe. We have proof that it is 100 percent possible.

Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by astrange on Monday May 20, 2024 @10:43PM (#40423482)
Turing completeness arguments don't apply to brains because we have infinite storage space ;)

(it's in the environment around us and other people's brains.)

Obviously you can construct something with human level creativity, it just takes two people and nine months.

Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by saintfire on Sunday May 19, 2024 @02:07PM (#40408642)
Wish we could apply that logic to software. AI is in a magical universe where we all pretend copyright isn't a thing just because we don't like it.
Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by spywaregorilla on Sunday May 19, 2024 @02:14PM (#40408697)
Do you want a world where google can sue your open source project because it utilizes it's style of coding?
Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by pbhjpbhj on Sunday May 19, 2024 @03:45PM (#40409293)
Maybe? If they show you started with their code and abstracted your code from their's mechanistically, then it seems reasonable to say that you copied from their code.

If you, a person, read their code and imitated the style - assuming it to be definable as Google's style and not easily confused with the style of others (which would suggest it was not distinctive) - then yes, why not? You would have directly abstracted the essence of Google's work from them.

They should be entitled to the copyright for at least 7 years, maybe up to at most 14!

Could you expand on what you mean by "its style of coding"?

Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by ninetyninenine on Sunday May 19, 2024 @06:52PM (#40410346)
I’ll have ai randomly generate unique styles of code and start copywriting it all.
Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by pbhjpbhj on Monday May 20, 2024 @01:43PM (#40418007)
Copyrights only apply when there is copying; independent production is allowed. As it's tort (mostly!), you only have to prove they copied on balance of probability (in jurisdictions I'm familiar with), but you still have to show they copied.

Fwiw, copyright is named for "rights", legally allowed/restricted activities. "Copywrite" is the verb meaning to write content for a publication, content being referred to as "copy" in this context.

Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by spywaregorilla on Sunday May 19, 2024 @07:14PM (#40410468)
Ok let's try a different argument.

You think the world would be a better place if Monet was able to sue Renoir out of the impressionist movement?

Or if Spielberg was able to sue director's trying to emulate the Spielberg oner?

Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by pbhjpbhj on Monday May 20, 2024 @01:50PM (#40418074)
Impressionism has scope. Most people can tell a [famous] Renoir from a Monet and would not think Renoir copied Monet (in general). The devil is in the detail, courts have too decide what is too close and what isn't, but it's very much 'I know it when I see it', I feel. Allowances to be made for distinctiveness.

I'm not a movie buff, I know a few films from Spielberg's oevre, but I've never seen anything that I thought was a copy of his style ... perhaps you have examples you feel are so close that 'a blind man on a horse' would see (sic) that they are copying Spielberg's style?

I like the change of tack though, would appreciate some more push back.

Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by spywaregorilla on Tuesday May 21, 2024 @02:35PM (#40432109)
I'd like to stick with Impressionism. Perhaps you think Renoir is distinct, and sure, he is. Now what about the hundreds of non-famous artists that are not Renoir and are instead just trying to make novel art in exactly the style of Monet? You think their original works are illegal? You think they are more illegal than an ai generated monet painting that uses a different color palette to be distinct?

I'm not very interested in debating this further because I think we just disagree. I'm glad this is not the way copyright law actually works.

Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by pbhjpbhj on Saturday May 25, 2024 @03:38PM (#40477297)
"Novel art" in exactly the style of Monet, is not entirely novel. I think it would be reasonable to allow Monet to have sole right to produce his style for 7 years or so, and then it enter the public domain. That rewards coming up with a new artistic style, which I feel is at least as valuable to reward as coming up with a new piece of artwork in an established style.

Again, my art history is weak, but when Picasso came up with his first cubist work, the cubism part of that work seems as valuable, and worthy of reward, as the actual instance of cubism that the work embodies?

There's a generally derivative style that follows the spirit of the age, and then there's a clearly copied style from a specific maker/creator/artist. It seems poor to protect the individual instance of an inspiring new style, but then not reward the creator of that style, not even with an acknowledgement.

FWIW, I'm not sold on either side of the argument. To me that's not how online discussion works. Also, I absolutely would not want copyright terms of the length we have to protect anything like this (nor anything really, they're obscenely long).

I would not of course want to inhibit the natural progression of styles, Monet's landscapes bore some similarity to JMW Turner, and a Chinese style called Lingnan, but this is a different thing to taking Monet's pallette used for water lilies, then painting a similar subject in the exact same style. If you do that immediately after Monet first presented his style for water lilies then I'd at minimum want you to say 'in the style of Monet' as a subtitle, and preferably have to pay him a little of your profit for the first few years.

Thanks for your interesting, thoughtful responses.

Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by ninetyninenine on Sunday May 19, 2024 @02:09PM (#40408662)
You missed the point.

You view it as a war against human rights. Copywrite.

I view it as a lost war. The war against human meaning.

We're living in a bubble. Where we pretend it all still matters and that AI will always be inferior to everything we do forever and for all eternity.

All bubbles will eventually pop.

Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by nonrandomstring on Sunday May 19, 2024 @02:38PM (#40408864)
> I view it as a lost war. The war against human meaning.

If "human meaning" goes, all else goes with it;

Social media, search, education, ambition, creation, innovation...

And along with that goes Google, Microsoft, OpenAI, Apple, Meta, Amazon...

There's nothing that exists outside that "bubble" of human meaning,

Technology must preserve it, or technology dies.

Unless you are confirming what many have already said.. that digital technology has become death cult?

Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by ninetyninenine on Sunday May 19, 2024 @04:47PM (#40409633)
Human meaning won't go out the door.

It's just we will no longer be able to differentiate it from machine generated content.

Machine generated content will become more superior and more prolific such that it will cheapen human meaning.

You'll find people will begin clinging onto the last vestiges of human created things like real painted art or vintage sculptures like they do vinyl records and non-digital books: An exercise in irrationality in attempt to reverse a war already lost.

Perhaps that is what will save human meaning in the end. Self delusion. We will deliberately ignore superior and better content and tell ourselves that human works are and always will be the best. That's a little of what's happening in this thread already.

Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by int_19h on Monday May 20, 2024 @02:10AM (#40412760)
Human art and appreciation thereof is already by and large an exercise in irrationality, so I don't see why this is necessarily a qualitative change. If people want to imbue "human made" with a special meaning, that's really no different than thousands of other ways we pretend things into being every day.
Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by ninetyninenine on Monday May 20, 2024 @04:00AM (#40413310)
Yeah. The difference is at one point in time we didn't pretend, now we do. And therefore the lie we tell ourselves is more obvious. Many people will see through the lie.
Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by nonrandomstring on Monday May 20, 2024 @04:00AM (#40413313)
Indeed. It's entirely arbitrary.

I think, in using terms like "rational" the grandparent is confusing AI with science and presuming some kind of objectivity. One cannot make any sensible claim about what is "more superior" (the "more" is redundant by the way) since quality of art and meaning is not arranged on any cardinal scale. Humans get to define what is better, and that's the final judgement. And should they choose to define AI as "meaningless", then it's meaningless.

Now as to whether it will be "more prolific", that's a another matter. Cockroaches are already far more prolific than humans.

Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by int_19h on Monday May 20, 2024 @03:35PM (#40419309)
I think they are arguing that by already established criteria, AI art can easily exceed human art in quality. So we can of course rejig our criteria, but in doing so we cannot help but acknowledge that the original ones no longer cut it.
Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by astrange on Sunday May 19, 2024 @05:40PM (#40409963)
Whether or not there are copyright issues depends on the laws of specific countries. In general though it's a lot more legal than currently legal things like Google Image Search, because it's much more transformative than making thumbnails of other people's images is.

But if you don't want it to be legal then just pass a law saying it's not.

Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by monadINtop on Sunday May 19, 2024 @02:05PM (#40408624)
lol sometimes I wonder if the reason so many tech bros make so many grandiose statements about how AI has already trancended the bounds of human creativity is because they've never really had actual experience with art and literature and music growing up. They say things like this and then you go and look for an example of these incredible works of artificial art and it is the biggest pile of shit you have ever seen.

Just like how they think that these glorified typing assistants function identically to the human brain. I mean maybe they really do replicate the level of creativity and intelligence of the people who believe these things, but maybe the people with decades of research in linguistics and neuroscience are right to be skeptical.

Its kinda like when people talk about research mathematics like its all adding really big numbers together or calculating really tricky integrals.

Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by ninetyninenine on Sunday May 19, 2024 @02:12PM (#40408677)
Not yet but this is not too far off:

One day you're going to encounter something that really moves you.

And then you'll realize it was procedurally generated, by an AI.

We're only about 1 - 2 years into AI. Think about the pace of progress.

Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by astrange on Sunday May 19, 2024 @05:56PM (#40410050)
There's a long tradition of random art and if you like that, there's dril GPT and Magic card GPT that produced lots of good absurdity. Of course, there's a human curation pass after it to let it be called art.

https://x.com/drilbot_aww/status/1792077476338057292

Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by ninetyninenine on Sunday May 19, 2024 @06:48PM (#40410320)
We just started on this. Imagine what the next two decades will bring.

This long tradition of stuff you speak of has only been a couple years at most. Draw the trend line. Extrapolate the inevitable consequence.

Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by astrange on Sunday May 19, 2024 @07:52PM (#40410649)
A lot longer than that!

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generative_art

Could also count elephant paintings and such.

Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by spywaregorilla on Sunday May 19, 2024 @02:18PM (#40408727)
Your dignified belief in the supremacy of human ingenuity will be cold comfort to the young artists struggling to find employment
Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by monadINtop on Sunday May 19, 2024 @02:23PM (#40408760)
Yep, you're right. But idk why you phrased that like it's a rebuttal to my criticism. This is another failure of our economic system, for incentivising the owners of art production to churn out literal mindless slop to cut costs, instead of safe guarding artists and creators for the sake of their intrinsic value to society and humanity.

Since, of course, they must eternally seek to reproduce capital to the detriment of everything else.

Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by spywaregorilla on Sunday May 19, 2024 @03:25PM (#40409161)
Well your argument is admonishing tech bros as if they don't get it, but generally they do get it completely in this context. The goal here is not replacing great art. It's replacing art assets.

Comes off as naive and distracting to me.

Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by monadINtop on Sunday May 19, 2024 @04:56PM (#40409681)
The distinction is philosophical. Tech bros consider "art assests" or consumer oriented products as art. In their eyes its capibility as a tool for profit is a downstream effect.

My point was that since their entire purpose in life revolves around developing and refining technology for the reproduction of capital, it reveals their blindness to any deeper aspect of the human condition than what can be sold for a profit. When people post 3d versions of the Mona Lisa or a shitty remix of Monet's water lillies with breathless praise, it's because in their eyes the stylistic reproduction or reinterpetation of the literal shapes and colors on a flat screen is all there is to art, not merely because it demonstrates utility in replacing already exploited sectors of creative workers.

I don't think we disagree about any of this. I think that I'm just making a tangential point to the article in response to a dumb comment, while you are talking about the subject more directly. Otherwise I fail to see what you think is naive, if only because I've seen so many examples of this rot of understanding around the essence of artistic expression from the mouthpieces of silicone valley and our wider, increasingly corporatized, culture.

Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by spywaregorilla on Sunday May 19, 2024 @07:21PM (#40410505)
> My point was that since their entire purpose in life revolves around developing and refining technology for the reproduction of capital, it reveals their blindness to any deeper aspect of the human condition than what can be sold for a profit

And I think that's grossly missing the point. The vast majority of people making art are just trying to make something look aesthetically nice within some sort of provided communication framework. And that's perfectly fine.

Frankly I think elevating artists to the pedestal of the illuminating the human condition is very damaging to their actual interests

Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by monadINtop on Sunday May 19, 2024 @08:38PM (#40410916)
Is creating things of aesthetic quality not of value with respect to the human condition? Is not some subset of that aesthetic quality derivative of the intuition and intention of a human mind? Sure, if you want to build some tehchnology to make designing packaging for dog food more effecient go ahead, as long as it isn't the previous dog food packaging creators that are being made to absorb the economic cost of the new technology (which they are).

But I hope at last some subset of human art strives to do more than that, and I think it's a bad thing that the incentive to increase revenue at the expense of quality has now expanded past being a tool to improve efficiency of laborious tasks and is now instead cutting costs via cutting artistic value.

Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by astrange on Sunday May 19, 2024 @05:44PM (#40409985)
If you need intelligent things to act exactly like a human being I think you're going to look bad in the future where we have aliens or uplifted ravens and this looks racist/speciesist.

Being trapped in a computer with no environmental interaction is obviously a big difference though.

> but maybe the people with decades of research in linguistics and neuroscience are right to be skeptical.

Like other kinds of academics, many of those people are cranks so they're not necessarily right. For instance, some of them are Chomsky.

(But it's their job to be wrong most of the time so of course this is expected.)

Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by monadINtop on Sunday May 19, 2024 @06:59PM (#40410386)
No, you need intelligent things to be intelligent.

And it would probably be good to distinguish between "things that appear superficially intelligent" and "things that have genuine capacity for internal experience" while you're at it, since the popular perception on this forum seems to be to just declare that physicalism/materialism is obviously correct and explanatory and we can just brush the hard problem of conciousness under the rug. People are so eager to endow the statistical model that has been designed to produce responses that are statistically feasable in a given context (a very impressive feat of technology to be clear) as having internal experience.

Chomsky happens to be more right about LLMs than 90% of the popular discourse will ever be able to understand, which isn't that suprising considering the impact if this "crank's" earlier work.

Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by astrange on Sunday May 19, 2024 @08:28PM (#40410854)
Chomsky's critique of LLMs was somehow not even correct about his own theories (https://x.com/profraha/status/1634311282135318529). And of course has the usual problem of 1. claiming LLMs are random statistical models (they aren't, the sampler is) 2. claiming instead of generating correct text they only "seemingly" generate correct text and not explaining why this is any less impossible.

But people have built explicit grammar knowledge into LLMs (it's in llama.cpp) and nobody seems to need it to make English text.

Of course the main reason Chomsky is a crank is that he's completely convinced he's right about politics despite his unbroken record of endorsing every mass murderer in the world as long as they're anti-American.

Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by monadINtop on Sunday May 19, 2024 @08:41PM (#40410938)
Oh right ok like I guessed, you have a ideological problem with him and his entirely irrelevant activism offends you, and so discredit any of his actual technical analysis on the subject. Maybe you do have the same faculty of reasoning as a LLM.
Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by optimalsolver on Monday May 20, 2024 @05:48AM (#40413828)
I swear there's a personality type that simply can't resist injecting their politics into unrelated conversations.

It's truly fascinating.

Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by astrange on Monday May 20, 2024 @10:40PM (#40423468)
I don't think that the opinion "70s intellectuals' love of the genocidal Khmer Rouge is bad" is "my" politics. I think this is a commonly held opinion actually.
Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by monadINtop on Friday May 24, 2024 @10:08AM (#40466433)
https://www.jstor.org/stable/25006809

https://www.counterpunch.org/2021/09/10/noam-chomsky-and-the...

stop spreading lies that have been debunked for decades, not everyone share your inability to parse information from outside your ideological bubble

Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by int_19h on Monday May 20, 2024 @02:17AM (#40412814)
Materialism is rather obviously correct when it comes to consciousness just based on what we know brain damage does to humans.

But what does this have to do with problem of consciousness or internal experiences? There's no reason why the latter cannot be a material process.

As for the linguists... people forget these days, but before the AI winter, there were many experiments trying to build an AI by modeling the language. And what they learned from it is that when you have enough compute and just throw it at a neural net, you get better results (there was even a joke about AI progress being inversely proportional to the number of linguists working on it). Which, to put it bluntly, means that our understanding of language is still very lacking, and quite likely to be fundamentally wrong some respects. I don't think those people are in a position to judge at that point; not until they figure out language enough to program something that can talk as well as GPT-4 does.

Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by monadINtop on Monday May 20, 2024 @06:35PM (#40421295)
There is zero understanding of the cause of internal experience. We can't even strictly define what it is. My contention isn't that materialism doesn't appear to be a reasonable canditate for cognitive process, but that we still have no idea HOW any of that happens. We may never know.

People who claim that it is obvious that neural networks and LLMs replicate the functioning of a brain, any brain - let alone human, are just wrong. They are wrong to assume that it is obvious that just making bigger LLMs will somehow generate a being with the capacity of internal experience, whatever that may mean. They are wrong when they act like they have solved the problem of understanding cognition by just forgetting to mention the hard problem of conciousness. They are even wrong to simply assert that neurons and neural networks are "to do" with cognition. Hallucinogens and brain damage affect subjective experience, and both of those things are involved with the vascular system of the brain. Would I be right to say the vascular system produce cognition? Why doesn't anyone argue in favor of that view since it is not too far off from the same reasoning?

Obviously, it's reasonable to assume that neurons are somehow involved with subjective experience, most serious neuroscientists and other researchers would hold that same assumption. But you need to EXPLAIN how, preferably with evidence. It is the burden of the one claiming they have finally figured it all out to present a convincing theory, or at least conjecture the path to get there. Loudly and smugly asserting that your assumption is correcter than the other people who have spent decades working on the problem doesn't make the problem dissolve, but it is especially irritating when the incentive of the loudest people doing so is in the pockets of the shareholders they are indebted to.