One day you're going to encounter something that really moves you.
And then you'll realize it was procedurally generated, by an AI.
We're only about 1 - 2 years into AI. Think about the pace of progress.
This long tradition of stuff you speak of has only been a couple years at most. Draw the trend line. Extrapolate the inevitable consequence.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generative_art
Could also count elephant paintings and such.
Since, of course, they must eternally seek to reproduce capital to the detriment of everything else.
Comes off as naive and distracting to me.
My point was that since their entire purpose in life revolves around developing and refining technology for the reproduction of capital, it reveals their blindness to any deeper aspect of the human condition than what can be sold for a profit. When people post 3d versions of the Mona Lisa or a shitty remix of Monet's water lillies with breathless praise, it's because in their eyes the stylistic reproduction or reinterpetation of the literal shapes and colors on a flat screen is all there is to art, not merely because it demonstrates utility in replacing already exploited sectors of creative workers.
I don't think we disagree about any of this. I think that I'm just making a tangential point to the article in response to a dumb comment, while you are talking about the subject more directly. Otherwise I fail to see what you think is naive, if only because I've seen so many examples of this rot of understanding around the essence of artistic expression from the mouthpieces of silicone valley and our wider, increasingly corporatized, culture.
And I think that's grossly missing the point. The vast majority of people making art are just trying to make something look aesthetically nice within some sort of provided communication framework. And that's perfectly fine.
Frankly I think elevating artists to the pedestal of the illuminating the human condition is very damaging to their actual interests
But I hope at last some subset of human art strives to do more than that, and I think it's a bad thing that the incentive to increase revenue at the expense of quality has now expanded past being a tool to improve efficiency of laborious tasks and is now instead cutting costs via cutting artistic value.
Being trapped in a computer with no environmental interaction is obviously a big difference though.
> but maybe the people with decades of research in linguistics and neuroscience are right to be skeptical.
Like other kinds of academics, many of those people are cranks so they're not necessarily right. For instance, some of them are Chomsky.
(But it's their job to be wrong most of the time so of course this is expected.)
And it would probably be good to distinguish between "things that appear superficially intelligent" and "things that have genuine capacity for internal experience" while you're at it, since the popular perception on this forum seems to be to just declare that physicalism/materialism is obviously correct and explanatory and we can just brush the hard problem of conciousness under the rug. People are so eager to endow the statistical model that has been designed to produce responses that are statistically feasable in a given context (a very impressive feat of technology to be clear) as having internal experience.
Chomsky happens to be more right about LLMs than 90% of the popular discourse will ever be able to understand, which isn't that suprising considering the impact if this "crank's" earlier work.
But people have built explicit grammar knowledge into LLMs (it's in llama.cpp) and nobody seems to need it to make English text.
Of course the main reason Chomsky is a crank is that he's completely convinced he's right about politics despite his unbroken record of endorsing every mass murderer in the world as long as they're anti-American.
It's truly fascinating.
https://www.counterpunch.org/2021/09/10/noam-chomsky-and-the...
stop spreading lies that have been debunked for decades, not everyone share your inability to parse information from outside your ideological bubble
But what does this have to do with problem of consciousness or internal experiences? There's no reason why the latter cannot be a material process.
As for the linguists... people forget these days, but before the AI winter, there were many experiments trying to build an AI by modeling the language. And what they learned from it is that when you have enough compute and just throw it at a neural net, you get better results (there was even a joke about AI progress being inversely proportional to the number of linguists working on it). Which, to put it bluntly, means that our understanding of language is still very lacking, and quite likely to be fundamentally wrong some respects. I don't think those people are in a position to judge at that point; not until they figure out language enough to program something that can talk as well as GPT-4 does.
People who claim that it is obvious that neural networks and LLMs replicate the functioning of a brain, any brain - let alone human, are just wrong. They are wrong to assume that it is obvious that just making bigger LLMs will somehow generate a being with the capacity of internal experience, whatever that may mean. They are wrong when they act like they have solved the problem of understanding cognition by just forgetting to mention the hard problem of conciousness. They are even wrong to simply assert that neurons and neural networks are "to do" with cognition. Hallucinogens and brain damage affect subjective experience, and both of those things are involved with the vascular system of the brain. Would I be right to say the vascular system produce cognition? Why doesn't anyone argue in favor of that view since it is not too far off from the same reasoning?
Obviously, it's reasonable to assume that neurons are somehow involved with subjective experience, most serious neuroscientists and other researchers would hold that same assumption. But you need to EXPLAIN how, preferably with evidence. It is the burden of the one claiming they have finally figured it all out to present a convincing theory, or at least conjecture the path to get there. Loudly and smugly asserting that your assumption is correcter than the other people who have spent decades working on the problem doesn't make the problem dissolve, but it is especially irritating when the incentive of the loudest people doing so is in the pockets of the shareholders they are indebted to.
Just like how they think that these glorified typing assistants function identically to the human brain. I mean maybe they really do replicate the level of creativity and intelligence of the people who believe these things, but maybe the people with decades of research in linguistics and neuroscience are right to be skeptical.
Its kinda like when people talk about research mathematics like its all adding really big numbers together or calculating really tricky integrals.