News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by saintfire on Sunday May 19, 2024 @02:07PM (#40408642)
Wish we could apply that logic to software. AI is in a magical universe where we all pretend copyright isn't a thing just because we don't like it.
Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by spywaregorilla on Sunday May 19, 2024 @02:14PM (#40408697)
Do you want a world where google can sue your open source project because it utilizes it's style of coding?
Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by pbhjpbhj on Sunday May 19, 2024 @03:45PM (#40409293)
Maybe? If they show you started with their code and abstracted your code from their's mechanistically, then it seems reasonable to say that you copied from their code.

If you, a person, read their code and imitated the style - assuming it to be definable as Google's style and not easily confused with the style of others (which would suggest it was not distinctive) - then yes, why not? You would have directly abstracted the essence of Google's work from them.

They should be entitled to the copyright for at least 7 years, maybe up to at most 14!

Could you expand on what you mean by "its style of coding"?

Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by ninetyninenine on Sunday May 19, 2024 @06:52PM (#40410346)
I’ll have ai randomly generate unique styles of code and start copywriting it all.
Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by pbhjpbhj on Monday May 20, 2024 @01:43PM (#40418007)
Copyrights only apply when there is copying; independent production is allowed. As it's tort (mostly!), you only have to prove they copied on balance of probability (in jurisdictions I'm familiar with), but you still have to show they copied.

Fwiw, copyright is named for "rights", legally allowed/restricted activities. "Copywrite" is the verb meaning to write content for a publication, content being referred to as "copy" in this context.

Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by spywaregorilla on Sunday May 19, 2024 @07:14PM (#40410468)
Ok let's try a different argument.

You think the world would be a better place if Monet was able to sue Renoir out of the impressionist movement?

Or if Spielberg was able to sue director's trying to emulate the Spielberg oner?

Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by pbhjpbhj on Monday May 20, 2024 @01:50PM (#40418074)
Impressionism has scope. Most people can tell a [famous] Renoir from a Monet and would not think Renoir copied Monet (in general). The devil is in the detail, courts have too decide what is too close and what isn't, but it's very much 'I know it when I see it', I feel. Allowances to be made for distinctiveness.

I'm not a movie buff, I know a few films from Spielberg's oevre, but I've never seen anything that I thought was a copy of his style ... perhaps you have examples you feel are so close that 'a blind man on a horse' would see (sic) that they are copying Spielberg's style?

I like the change of tack though, would appreciate some more push back.

Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by spywaregorilla on Tuesday May 21, 2024 @02:35PM (#40432109)
I'd like to stick with Impressionism. Perhaps you think Renoir is distinct, and sure, he is. Now what about the hundreds of non-famous artists that are not Renoir and are instead just trying to make novel art in exactly the style of Monet? You think their original works are illegal? You think they are more illegal than an ai generated monet painting that uses a different color palette to be distinct?

I'm not very interested in debating this further because I think we just disagree. I'm glad this is not the way copyright law actually works.

Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by pbhjpbhj on Saturday May 25, 2024 @03:38PM (#40477297)
"Novel art" in exactly the style of Monet, is not entirely novel. I think it would be reasonable to allow Monet to have sole right to produce his style for 7 years or so, and then it enter the public domain. That rewards coming up with a new artistic style, which I feel is at least as valuable to reward as coming up with a new piece of artwork in an established style.

Again, my art history is weak, but when Picasso came up with his first cubist work, the cubism part of that work seems as valuable, and worthy of reward, as the actual instance of cubism that the work embodies?

There's a generally derivative style that follows the spirit of the age, and then there's a clearly copied style from a specific maker/creator/artist. It seems poor to protect the individual instance of an inspiring new style, but then not reward the creator of that style, not even with an acknowledgement.

FWIW, I'm not sold on either side of the argument. To me that's not how online discussion works. Also, I absolutely would not want copyright terms of the length we have to protect anything like this (nor anything really, they're obscenely long).

I would not of course want to inhibit the natural progression of styles, Monet's landscapes bore some similarity to JMW Turner, and a Chinese style called Lingnan, but this is a different thing to taking Monet's pallette used for water lilies, then painting a similar subject in the exact same style. If you do that immediately after Monet first presented his style for water lilies then I'd at minimum want you to say 'in the style of Monet' as a subtitle, and preferably have to pay him a little of your profit for the first few years.

Thanks for your interesting, thoughtful responses.

Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by ninetyninenine on Sunday May 19, 2024 @02:09PM (#40408662)
You missed the point.

You view it as a war against human rights. Copywrite.

I view it as a lost war. The war against human meaning.

We're living in a bubble. Where we pretend it all still matters and that AI will always be inferior to everything we do forever and for all eternity.

All bubbles will eventually pop.

Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by nonrandomstring on Sunday May 19, 2024 @02:38PM (#40408864)
> I view it as a lost war. The war against human meaning.

If "human meaning" goes, all else goes with it;

Social media, search, education, ambition, creation, innovation...

And along with that goes Google, Microsoft, OpenAI, Apple, Meta, Amazon...

There's nothing that exists outside that "bubble" of human meaning,

Technology must preserve it, or technology dies.

Unless you are confirming what many have already said.. that digital technology has become death cult?

Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by ninetyninenine on Sunday May 19, 2024 @04:47PM (#40409633)
Human meaning won't go out the door.

It's just we will no longer be able to differentiate it from machine generated content.

Machine generated content will become more superior and more prolific such that it will cheapen human meaning.

You'll find people will begin clinging onto the last vestiges of human created things like real painted art or vintage sculptures like they do vinyl records and non-digital books: An exercise in irrationality in attempt to reverse a war already lost.

Perhaps that is what will save human meaning in the end. Self delusion. We will deliberately ignore superior and better content and tell ourselves that human works are and always will be the best. That's a little of what's happening in this thread already.

Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by int_19h on Monday May 20, 2024 @02:10AM (#40412760)
Human art and appreciation thereof is already by and large an exercise in irrationality, so I don't see why this is necessarily a qualitative change. If people want to imbue "human made" with a special meaning, that's really no different than thousands of other ways we pretend things into being every day.
Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by ninetyninenine on Monday May 20, 2024 @04:00AM (#40413310)
Yeah. The difference is at one point in time we didn't pretend, now we do. And therefore the lie we tell ourselves is more obvious. Many people will see through the lie.
Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by nonrandomstring on Monday May 20, 2024 @04:00AM (#40413313)
Indeed. It's entirely arbitrary.

I think, in using terms like "rational" the grandparent is confusing AI with science and presuming some kind of objectivity. One cannot make any sensible claim about what is "more superior" (the "more" is redundant by the way) since quality of art and meaning is not arranged on any cardinal scale. Humans get to define what is better, and that's the final judgement. And should they choose to define AI as "meaningless", then it's meaningless.

Now as to whether it will be "more prolific", that's a another matter. Cockroaches are already far more prolific than humans.

Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by int_19h on Monday May 20, 2024 @03:35PM (#40419309)
I think they are arguing that by already established criteria, AI art can easily exceed human art in quality. So we can of course rejig our criteria, but in doing so we cannot help but acknowledge that the original ones no longer cut it.
Re:AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training by astrange on Sunday May 19, 2024 @05:40PM (#40409963)
Whether or not there are copyright issues depends on the laws of specific countries. In general though it's a lot more legal than currently legal things like Google Image Search, because it's much more transformative than making thumbnails of other people's images is.

But if you don't want it to be legal then just pass a law saying it's not.