News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Product Roadmap by WheatMillington on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @09:43PM (#40293535)
Is Bluesky still relevant? They failed to capitalise on a moment, and it's hard to see another opportunity for them in the future.
Re:Product Roadmap by pfraze on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @11:32PM (#40294070)
Products take time to build; protocol takes a lot of time. That we were able to productionize in about 4 months — having previously been a team of 4 working on the protocol for 10 months — and not collapse under the load is a pretty decent.

We got up to around 15 engineers since then. We decided it wouldn’t increase our throughput enough to hire aggressively (org building alone is a major distraction) and decided it wiser to preserve our burn rate, which we did.

Inevitably we get compared to Threads, and that’s just how the market works, but they had 60 people on the team when they launched, and they did so by running off of Instagram’s infra and T&S. Watching them handle 100 million signups in their first week? That’s the rubric that the market is grading on today. So, that’s what that moment looked like for us. And again, I think we captured it well. We managed to build a really strong initial userbase with it. So the challenge for us now is to create new moments, which is what the product work is about.

Re:Product Roadmap by bschmidt1 on Wednesday May 08, 2024 @12:40AM (#40294385)
> pretty decent

Nice to see you're still patting yourself on the back lol I think you took wayyy too long to release your product and it's overall not an impressive looking social media app, certainly doesn't look like the work of

> 15 engineers

Re:Product Roadmap by ianwalter on Wednesday May 08, 2024 @03:19PM (#40301876)
As a software engineering leader I can appreciate the huge amount of work it took you all to get here. It may not be super flashy because you had to start from scratch and get to feature parity with existing platforms, but IMHO Bluesky has the best app and I'm excited about all of the stuff you will add in the future. I'm rooting for you!
Re:Product Roadmap by SkyMarshal on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @09:56PM (#40293619)
Well given Elon's continuing shenanigans at Twitter that moment is probably still ongoing, and the competition is still wide open.

I do think Bluesky may have chose the wrong launch strategy by using the old and tired invite-only method. But hard to say for sure. If they had fully opened to the public last year or the year before, they might have gotten a large influx of users, who would then complain that it doesn't have all the bells and whistles of Twitter, which had 10+ years to develop them. So who knows. At least with invites, they made sure to get people who really wanted to be there, even if it was a smaller crowd.

Re:Product Roadmap by roenxi on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @10:09PM (#40293684)
> I do think Bluesky may have chose the wrong launch strategy by using the old and tired invite-only method. But hard to say for sure.

Hard to say indeed. I'm not sure how a social network bootstrap method can get "old and tired" either - humans don't change how they socialise that quickly!

Facebook achieved remarkable things by starting in the Ivy League community then branching out, it really stands as a fascinating example of how curating the early community is critical in the bootstrapping process for a social network. I'm happy to bet that there is a 0.01 to 1% of the population who actually matters for getting groups of people to use something, and if a social network manages to find them then it will succeed, invites or not.

It could be that there is too much dross out there for free for all signups early on. To me it looks like a core community should be established first.

Re:Product Roadmap by SkyMarshal on Wednesday May 08, 2024 @12:37AM (#40294382)
> Hard to say indeed. I'm not sure how a social network bootstrap method can get "old and tired" either - humans don't change how they socialise that quickly!

But they do get wise to things like false scarcity of digital goods or artificial gatekeeping, and it puts them off. When a strategy is no longer novel or original, its loses its effect.

Yes that early core community can really set the tone for a long time, and may have been worth it. On the other hand, an even bigger risk to a social network is not getting enough community to cause positive feedback effects and organic hockey-stick user growth. Failure to launch. Especially with a glut of social media competitors crowding the landscape.

Re:Product Roadmap by bschmidt1 on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @10:38PM (#40293827)
They should have hired more builder types and great designers. IMO they had all the press on their side, riding the decentralization wave, and really were given an excellent opportunity, it's a shame.

Product took forever and when it finally came out it wasn't impressive. They should have staffed up some badass devs & designers who ship or even considered a top tier agency who would have made something truly stunning. Test the market at each step. Decentralization deserved better!

I think a good comparison is OpenAI (including the whole "are they open vs closed" part that Bluesky had to deal with). OpenAI has done an excellent job of: 1) Releasing good products on a good cadence 2) Keeping us waiting in suspense for the next big thing.

Decentralization has a very high excitement potential - I think Bluesky just dropped the ball. Didn't prioritize product.

Re:Product Roadmap by arcalinea on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @11:52PM (#40294156)
Bluesky CEO here. We were founded to build a protocol for Twitter, and likely would have died as a project within Twitter had I not spent half of 2021 negotiating for our independence. In 2022, I got funding and began building an independent protocol team that was still consulting with Twitter on how they might integrate an open protocol.

Elon buying Twitter was the factor that changed our plans and led us to build an app, as it became clear a path to adoption within Twitter would never pan out. We were not set up as a product team given the legacy of our origins, but did the best we could last spring, shipping an app to hundreds of thousands of users with just one app dev, pfraze. OpenAI has been around for nine years, and while what they've done is truly impressive, launching projects with a fully-staffed engineering team is very different from building a team as you grow a userbase.

Hindsight is 20/20 when it comes to market timing, but our goal from the start has been to deliver a decentralized social experience with good UX, and deliver on the previously theoretical concepts of algorithmic choice and community moderation in a global public square. Because of this, our product focus has been driven by showing what's possible on an open protocol, and only after doing things like custom feeds and third-party labelers have we circled back on some more basic features users have been requesting like DMs and video. We still believe decentralization, and the innovation it enables for social, has high potential, and are always looking at how we can better surface it in the app.

Re:Product Roadmap by ssahoo on Wednesday May 08, 2024 @12:31AM (#40294353)
@Jay - Thanks for jumping in. What was Dorsey's balance on BlueSky(AT) vs Nostr?
Re:Product Roadmap by bschmidt1 on Wednesday May 08, 2024 @12:06AM (#40294223)
Thanks for the reply. Some of your earlier tweets on protocols (in 2021/22) inspired me a lot and got me into decentralized content for a while. I consider you to be one of the major thought leaders in the space and I remember being very excited about Bluesky when I first heard about it - had that OpenAI appeal where I was excited for every update. I guess when it started getting compared to Mastodon all the time, and ActivityPub etc. - all the focus on the protocol and conventional social media made it boring. Now it seems like a Discord or Mastodon type competitor, part of it just social media itself declining. Would have liked to see something totally new with a stunning UI and marketing experience.
Re:Product Roadmap by SkyMarshal on Wednesday May 08, 2024 @12:49AM (#40294432)
Thanks for commenting, always nice to get a reality check from the actual founder, vs just armchair speculating in the ether. I really like what you guys are doing and am amazed you did it with just one app developer. I hope 2024 can be a year of ramping up the feedback->prioritize->implement->feedback loop as quickly as possible. As I said above, I think the space is still wide open, and I think you can win over a lot of users with a federated protocol + clean app UI/UX + sane and decent people like you leading the org and attracting a like-minded community. I wish you the best!
Re:Product Roadmap by bschmidt1 on Wednesday May 08, 2024 @12:59AM (#40294469)
> armchair speculating in the ether

I don't have to be the founder of their company to be qualified to speak on product design. I've designed and built stuff for DocuSign, Brave, Nike, and some others but my portfolio speaks for itself: https://dribbble.com/bennyschmidt

Your reply was basically useless - like a LinkedIn support comment. The last thing the Bluesky founders need.

They need to hire talented people who know how to build good products fast instead of patting themselves on the back year after year while offering nothing innovative or interesting to the world.

It's not an impossible future - they're in a hell of a lot better position than 99% of other people and are actually a very privileged bunch - but so far they can't design or build, and their product ideas aren't even that good.

Re:Product Roadmap by SkyMarshal on Wednesday May 08, 2024 @01:09AM (#40294532)
Lol, dude, I was mainly referring to myself armchair speculating in the ether, which is exactly what I was doing in my comment above that you replied to. Maybe I should have been more explicit about that, but pro-tip: Stop being so sensitive on the internet man, you don't have to justify yourself to every online rando, and given your accomplishments it's not even worth your time to. Peace bro.
Re:Product Roadmap by bschmidt1 on Wednesday May 08, 2024 @01:26AM (#40294632)
You're on a technology message board, there are going to be opinions - you might be the sensitive one.

If you think HN is bad try the others!

Re:Product Roadmap by pfraze on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @11:36PM (#40294090)
We couldn’t handle the server load and had to build a T&S team. The invites were the only thing that stopped us from collapsing.
Re:Product Roadmap by SkyMarshal on Wednesday May 08, 2024 @01:00AM (#40294478)
Gotcha good to know, thanks for commenting. I'll just repeat what I said to arca above, also to you: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40294432.

I think one of your biggest competitive advantages is just a sane decent core team, who attract similar people from their network. A sane and decent core community is a refreshing change from Twitter's increasingly crazy and distasteful one, and a federated protocol is inherently more trustworthy than centralized ones like Twitter or Threads. I hope the nexus of those two things helps you take off in 2024. Good luck!

Re:Product Roadmap by pixxel on Wednesday May 08, 2024 @02:39AM (#40295023)
> given Elon's continuing shenanigans at Twitter that moment is probably still ongoing, and the competition is still wide open

What shenanigans?

When he fired a whole load of staff there were cries of Twitter’s demise. The opposite has happened: many new features added (more than the previous 10+ years?) and site stability is solid. So how is the competition “wide open”. I use Mastodon (since 2017) but I’m not kidding myself about the small fringe userbase (I like it this way BTW).

And Dorsey has just binned bsky and championed Twitter.

A small contingent detest Musk so much that it obscures observable reality.

Re:Product Roadmap by foinker on Wednesday May 08, 2024 @08:38AM (#40297383)
I consider myself a Musk detester, and you're definitely right that all those calls for Twitter/X's death were wishful thinking at best. But I don't think that these supposed new features have anything to do with the continued use of the site (stability being solid is the baseline expectation so congrats I guess?) Lot's of people deleted their accounts forever in the past 2 years and were replaced with crypto shills, bots, and propagandists (it's all the same to Musk). Everyone else stayed because of inertia.

The site will continue to be one of the most popular in the world largely because people don't want to "redo Twitter" on a new website. It really doesn't matter what Musk does.

Re:Product Roadmap by pcloadletter_ on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @09:46PM (#40293561)
It's the only social network I'm really on right now. And AT protocol is pretty neat. I'm glad it's around and will keep using it until something else better comes along.
Re:Product Roadmap by ianwalter on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @09:56PM (#40293616)
I think so. Sure, platforms like Threads have the raw numbers and network effects, but Bluesky has an authentic community, a solid team (Dan Abramov from the React team joining was a surprise), and they are making the right product tradeoffs. I can definitely see them “coming out on top” as the spiritual successor to Twitter in a few years.
Re:Product Roadmap by neglesaks on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @10:51PM (#40293885)
Nostr has an authentic community too, not least due to that users can directly tip the developers for their work, as well as tip each other for the interesting content people post.
Re:Product Roadmap by threeseed on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @09:59PM (#40293631)
Dorsey left the Board and has seemed to be pretty critical of Bluesky.

Calling X and NoStr "freedom tech". Whatever that means.

Re:Product Roadmap by wmf on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @10:39PM (#40293831)
Jack Dorsey is mad that Bluesky doesn't use crypto.
Re:Product Roadmap by neglesaks on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @10:47PM (#40293861)
No, Dorsey has per his own words recognised that a corporation running a social app/network is what created the tragedy we call Twitter.
Re:Product Roadmap by Uehreka on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @11:00PM (#40293934)
So he’s switched to endorsing… Twitter?
Re:Product Roadmap by ejj28 on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @09:52PM (#40293594)
Seems to me like it's not. I rarely hear about it, I've never seen anyone link to a Bluesky post, and it has weird limitations due to it being on top of a new federated protocol (which I still don't understand the purpose of when the internet's already kinda settled on Mastodon/ActivityPub as the go-to for decentralized social media).

Even as they talk now about addressing the stuff that's missing from Bluesky like DMs and videos (which, no wonder it hasn't taken off when those features are absent), it still sounds like even when those features launch, they'll still be subpar. DMs not part of the AT protocol? Did they just not think of DMs when they designed the protocol? And only 90 second videos? Really? In my opinion, Bluesky isn't going to take off if this is the roadmap.

Re:Product Roadmap by bschmidt1 on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @10:50PM (#40293880)
> I've never seen anyone link to a Bluesky post

Since Twitter/X stopped making some posts public and make it so hard to view profiles you'd think Bluesky would be all over this.

We had a small earthquake not too long ago in SF and I had no Twitter to check - that instant live Internet community is just gone, and it's not just that. Everything used to come out so fast on Twitter, it was a really exciting place to be. It's of course totally ruined now and has been for years, but it was once an awesome thing.

Not sure why Bluesky isn't all over Hollywood and politics, in a presidential election year no less. They're just not doing this very well.

Re:Product Roadmap by SkyMarshal on Wednesday May 08, 2024 @01:16AM (#40294579)
> Not sure why Bluesky isn't all over Hollywood and politics

Ugh, that would turn it into just another online cesspool.

Re:Product Roadmap by bschmidt1 on Wednesday May 08, 2024 @01:23AM (#40294615)
At least people would use it.
Re:Product Roadmap by jacoblambda on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @11:29PM (#40294061)
> which I still don't understand the purpose of when the internet's already kinda settled on Mastodon/ActivityPub as the go-to for decentralized social media

The things bluesky wants to do well really just don't map well onto ActivityPub.

Things like:

- Custom feed providers - Custom indexers/firehoses - Labellers (i.e. content filtering/flagging services) - Proper, cross-instance moderation services - Separating identity from the instance

> DMs not part of the AT protocol?

Currently the AT protocol is basically all public. If you want DMs you need to work out an E2EE layer that can still tolerate moderation and a propagation system that doesn't leak details of who is messaging who. That's all very hard to do right. Even signal spent years trying to get this right and they have pretty centralized infrastructure. I'd rather no DMs at first with the expectation that they'll be done properly when they actually ship.

> And only 90 second videos? Really?

Mastodon sets a video limit of 99MB. If you wanted to match the quality of a 1080p 30fps youtube video for example, that 99MB would buy you about 82 seconds. So the 90 second limit really isn't that unreasonable. And if you want a longer form, external video embeds have been supported in the app since the beta.

Re:Product Roadmap by est on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @09:53PM (#40293600)
from my limited experience, it's a better choice than mstdn or nostr.

mstdn's weakness is the activitypub protocol, it has many limitations, but understandably because it's designed in good o' GNU Social days. On the other hand nostr had like gazillion of NIPs

ATProto fits the right spot, designed by the people who knows what they are doing, and addresses all the problems.

Re:Product Roadmap by omoikane on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @10:50PM (#40293882)
Anecdotally, some of the people I follow on Twitter have increased their usage of Bluesky, although their primary activity is still on Twitter.
Re:Product Roadmap by jiveturkey on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @09:46PM (#40293559)
> In the past year, Bluesky has grown from 40K users to 5.6M users.

It it were still relevant, they would have quoted DAU.

Re:Product Roadmap by conroy on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @09:53PM (#40293601)
You can see the latest stats here: https://bsky.jazco.dev/stats

Around 200,000 folks liked a post today.

Re:Product Roadmap by jiveturkey on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @11:44PM (#40294124)
amazing interactivity on those charts. anyone know what is the framework/toolkit for them? i'm not seeing any clues jump out at me in the DOM.
Re:Product Roadmap by jiveturkey on Wednesday May 08, 2024 @02:44PM (#40301558)
found it. apache echarts via echarts-for-react
Re:Product Roadmap by mrcwinn on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @09:49PM (#40293582)
I once helped run a website you probably never heard of and it had more than 5.6M registered users. :shruggydude:
Re:Product Roadmap by yazzku on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @09:48PM (#40293569)
My boy can smell the BS ten miles away.
Re:Product Roadmap by foolfoolz on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @09:49PM (#40293576)
honestly no, but it’s not just them. no “social network” is relevant on its own anymore. big content is cross posted everywhere. features are copied. differentiation between them is mostly lost

user bases will remain separate as not everyone reads every network. but a new app on its own isnt that compelling. even ones that specialize in a niche like be real will have trouble finding large scale relevancy

Re:Product Roadmap by neglesaks on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @10:53PM (#40293896)
Agree with this, which is why I find federated networks (fediverse and nostr) to be the most relevant into the future.
Re:Product Roadmap by arcalinea on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @11:56PM (#40294178)
Bluesky is federated through the AT Protocol, and a bridge between Bluesky and Mastodon started running recently. https://fed.brid.gy/

I've seen some Nostr users bridged as well

Re:Product Roadmap by selectodude on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @09:49PM (#40293577)
It's relevant to all the people that use it. Frankly the fact that it hasn't been overrun with DAUs is one of the benefits.
Re:Product Roadmap by neglesaks on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @11:00PM (#40293939)
The same can be said for Mastodon/fediverse and that has been languishing apart for the first six months between late 2022 to mid 2023.
Re:Product Roadmap by baby on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @09:51PM (#40293590)
I use threads
Re:Product Roadmap by add-sub-mul-div on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @10:02PM (#40293652)
It's Twitter minus the bullshit and minus the eternal September. I hope it stays that way.